Analysis Of Aerobic Sisyphus And The Suburbanized Psyche

Improved Essays
Writing As Thinking
Rebecca Solnit's essay, “Aerobic Sisyphus and the Suburbanized Psyche” was a critical piece of work focused on walking and its decline through the age of industry and modern technology. I believe Solnit was wrong in the terms of her essay, which is mostly about walking, in many ways. She makes a few good points, like when she talks about the idea of technology removing us from our sense of physical socialness, and how we admire and feel about the natural world. She also makes strong points about the separation of home and work, the creation of suburbia and the difficulty of modern walking. Her ideas of disembodiment and how we today work, exercise, and interact with our world has changed so negatively from that of the past
…show more content…
It in some ways dispels the thought of disembodying myself, encourage exercise and participating in abstract thought or learning, but also at the same time fortifies her main concepts of the technology barrier, and how it has changed our lives and the world we perceive. It in many ways encourages me to retreat from the community I live in, but also brings me into an online community of my high school friends and the nice people I have met through the games I’ve played. I see my own body and mind as a source of recreation in many instances when working out or learning, but otherwise is just a calming and peaceful place for me to retreat to when feeling stressed, which happens to be a lot. This space known for its electronic and secluded ways is a place for my mind to grow, or relax from the struggles of everyday life, and help keep my fitness. It supports Solnit’s ideas of being cut off from social, physically community, and a kind of disembodiment in playing video games, but ultimately embodies me in the ideas of learning and peace of mind. It centers my thoughts and creates the ideal environment for me to grow as an individual. Solnit argues that these thing have become a block in our social nature, and turn us away from physical activity and meaningful exercise, but how I feel in this place contradicts those ideas by making me more social and encouraging fitness and potential walking for fitness, as well as exploring and taking care of the animals that I have assumed responsibility for. It critiques the ideas that it separated myself from others, or replaces work with the gym experience, and encourages outside, physical activity at some opportunities, too. However among these topics none seem to make myself any less social or active, but instead encourages some of these ideas in different ways. This space has been a good place of experience, comfort, work, and relaxation and despite Solnit’s argument

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    “Changing Our Tune on Exercise,” written by Jane E. Brody, is a persuasive blog in The New York Times. This blog, created on August 27, 2012, focuses on changing the cultural view of exercise and depicts exercise as a vital aspect for a healthy lifestyle, both mentally and physically. Brody dives deep into the importance of exercise through a bit of history on the anticipated results and myriad research that support a hopeful change in the outlook towards exercise. Jane E. Brody effectively persuades her audience to alter the outlook on exercise through credible evidence, logical reasoning, and emotional well-being.…

    • 1577 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The article “Head in the (Instagrammed) Clouds,” written by Isabel H. Evans, reminds us that life should not be controlled by technology. To introduce her idea, Evans talks about our necessity to get likes and shares on our posts and comments to make ourselves feel loved and warm. Next, Blackwell explained how we justify spending time plugged in because we either want to avoid doing something we don't like or we are trying to pass the time. Blackwell concludes by stating that we need to refocus our efforts on gaining accomplishments in real life that we can physically touch and see rather than attaining accomplishments through our…

    • 108 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The majority rely on man-made transportation systems such as elevators or escalators, until the area is crowded. Many do not enjoy active activities that require stable stamina or raised heartbeat, such as hiking or running a mile. It is only when we are at a state of tranquility or walking aimlessly when we appreciate the beauty of nature. Albeit laziness does play a significant role in the decline of walking, what was once done for recreation has dissipated due to lifestyle. People in this era are occupied with their careers and favor cars over walking to their destinations.…

    • 552 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The study of the good life put’s prominence on finding our own individual path to happiness, while at the same time, being able to be aware of our surroundings. Human beings are adaptive creatures, meaning we unconsciously “fit in” with the culture we abide in. However, at what point does the pursuit of one’s good life become an extension of societies suggestions? In Clive Thompson’s article “I 'm So Totally, Digitally Close to You”, he describes a modern society that has conformed to the hands of social media, and as a result has suppressed creativity and individuality. However, when we look at Sophocles Antigone, Creon and Antigone possess two separate mindsets on what they believe to be right, and essentially Creon’s stubbornness and the…

    • 1292 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The author Simmons states, “Doing nothing has a lot going for it”(33). Though Simmons believes choosing a lifestyle that is not mainly active is mentally healthy, it is invalid because having an active lifestyle can result in having more positive emotions. Not only is living an inactive lifestyle contribute to developing more negative emotions it can create unhealthy physical attributes. The authors Candice Hogan, Lahnna I. Catalino, Jutta Mata, and Barbara L. Fredrickson of “Beyond Emotional Benefits” notes that “[p]hysical activity is known to improve emotional experiences, and positive emotions have been shown to lead to important life outcomes” (354). This showcases physical activity being linked with individuals having a positive emotional mood.…

    • 1107 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Everyday people are failing to realize that physical activity helps to keep a healthy body through weight, bone strength, muscle/joint, and overall mental well-being. As technology increases the public grows lazier with transportation,…

    • 420 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Authenticity is defined to be genuine and of undisputed origin. Throughout Sherry Turkle essay “Alone Together” she talks about authenticity and how technology has taken the human ability to build authentic relationships. She also speaks about how prominent technology has become for the human species. Sherry Turkle’s argument is strengthened by Jean Twenge in her writing “Generation Me” where she speaks about the depression, anxiety and the different pressures that lead to the rise in numbers of the current generation with issues. The explanation given by Turkle shines a light on the different problems experienced by today’s generation and how technology lead to the deaths of many in Twenge’s writing.…

    • 1349 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many writers post articles about this new generation destroying department stores, diamonds, golf, and more. Jean M. Twenge’s article titled “Have Smartphones Destroyed a Generation?” appears to take on the same point of view. However, she focused on behaviors and emotional health. She avoided bashing the post-Millennial generation (referred to as iGen) and instead studied the effects of the smartphone. Twenge completed research to show that, while physically safer, the new generation of teenagers is suffering mentally.…

    • 1076 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article “ Is Facebook making us lonely?” Stephen Marche provides an eye-opening piece stating the long term effects that the internet and social media portrays on the human mind and body. He provides statistics and examples of how the internet can affect our health, however these health concerns may only be affecting you because you have let them. The author demonstrates that social media is giving users a scapegoat to avoid physical contact, which in the long run is creating further problems in loneliness and anxiety which already existed. Stephen Marche conveys the idea that the internet has provoked feelings of loneliness through aiding in creating digital connections without providing the physical aspect as well yet, the internet…

    • 706 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the essay “Walking and the Suburbanized Psyche” by Rebecca Solnit, she believes walking was so valuable in the past because “walking was a sort of sacrament and a routine recreation”. People would walk frequently and voluntarily for their own pleasure like by making a date for a walk. Solnit narrates how “urban innovations such as sidewalks and sewers were improving cities” however it had “not yet menaced by twentieth-century speedups”. Solnit calls this period the, “golden age of walking” that initiated in the eighteenth century and she fears that it has “expired some decades ago”, yet its significance is the “creation of places to walk and its valuation of recreational walking”. Unfortunately, the development of suburbanization which…

    • 964 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    She starts with a 2015 study by the Pew Research center, where they concluded most people feel like they hurt the last social event they were a part of due to using their phones. She next uses a survey conducted by The University of Michigan over the course of thirty years to reinforce her claim by revealing a decrease in the rate of empathy in the college environment. The author then uses Psychologist Yalda T.Uhls study of a device free camp to help introduce the topic of solitude. After a claim arguing that technology can’t be bad if you use alone. Turkle brings to attention that the time we spend alone is being outsourced to technology.…

    • 1244 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Essay on “Why Place Matters” In Wilfred M. McClay and Ted V. McAllister’s “Why Place Matters,” they discuss about “place” as an abstract concept that can also be very precise and meaningful. However, due to globalization and digital interactions, place no longer seem to matter in modern society. Individuals are substituting place and physical space with websites and online relations. As a result, people are disconnecting from our physical innate need for thereness. I agree with McClay and McAllister that the lack of physical place can risk losing our ability to associate with others, one’s identity, and public virtues.…

    • 953 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Walking In The Late 1800s

    • 1128 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Walking is a natural task that we must take part in everyday. Before cars were invented in the late 1800’s, our own two feet was the main source of transportation. Since cars and other uses of transportation have evolved, walking has slowly diminished over the years. For the most part, we have brought this problem on ourselves. With everyday construction of new neighborhoods, cities, highways, and roads, we are generating them to be less walker friendly.…

    • 1128 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “In this ideology, walking functions as an emblem of the simple man and as, when the walk is solitary and rural, a means of being in nature and outside of society”(Solnit, Pg. 18) Walking is always overlooked, and is only looked at as one way of many to get from point A to point B. I feel Solnit had a great point when she illustrates how important walking is in the world. Walking is a great way to connect to your environment. When you walk you are always connected with your environment. You are looking at different things, walking on different surfaces, touching different objects, and are breathing and smelling various substances. I feel you cannot have environmental art without including walking.…

    • 463 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Solitude and its Importance In today's society, community is a small part of happiness. The more friends someone has or the more liked they feel, the more they enjoy life. They are happier because they feel wanted and popular. This feeling often feeds ego, but it also makes people able to enjoy more things in life.…

    • 702 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays