An Honest Analysis Of Harappan Script Speculations Essay

1379 Words Dec 5th, 2016 6 Pages
An Honest Analysis of Harappan Script Speculations Since their discovery around 1920, the Harrapan seals of the Indus Valley Civilizations (circa. 2600–1900 B.C.) have been a topic of debate. Said seals contain pictures of unicorn-like cow creatures, human figures, and short bursts of symbols, seemingly crammed onto the seal as an afterthought . Scholars are unable to come to any sort of consensus on the issue and have resorted to publishing articles that focus more on why everyone else is wrong than attempting to decipher the strange artifacts. This is particularly true when it comes to the odd symbols. While it seems to be the natural order of things, the manner in which scholars approach decipherment of this mysterious script is counterintuitive and infantile. A simple, honest analysis of the artifacts is actually a simple matter. Though facts can only get you so far, an honest acknowledgement of the fallibility of speculation will solve the issue much quicker.
The Oxford dictionary defines script as “writing using a particular alphabet” . When assessing the Indus symbols under this definition, two definitive questions arise. Are the symbols using a particular alphabet or alphabet-like structure? And If so, what language does that structure represent? These two questions have paved the way for three major, controversial hypotheses. The first of which was presented by Steve Farmer et al. in the paper The Collapse of the Indus-Script Thesis: The Myth of a Literate Harappan…

Related Documents