An Examination of “Minimal Fact” Argument for the Resurrection of Christ as Proposed by Gary Habermas

4050 Words Oct 21st, 2012 17 Pages
CRAM Exclusive
Essay Sample
Michael Haggard Advanced Topics in Contemporary Apologetics - Course Number: AP 661 IS R2 03 Trinity Theological Seminary AN EXAMINATION OF “MINIMAL FACT” ARGUMENT FOR THE RESURRECTION OF CHRIST AS PROPOSED BY GARY HABERMAS Gary Robert Habermas is distinguished Professor of Apologetics and Philosophy as well as department chairman of Philosophy and Theology at Liberty University in Virginia.[1] He has devoted a large part of his career to the topic of the resurrection of Jesus Christ,

middle of document…

While they still have questions about other points of the report of the New Testament, the minimal facts remaining and without reasonable dispute are adequate in themselves to show that Jesus died and later appeared alive in body to his followers.[12] Such a view may also work on their doubts concerning those "troubling" passages as well, since they are mostly based on a denial of the miraculous as unreliable reporting.
In Habermas’ view, this approach is more effective than the use of the Bible alone, since the evidence is effective even for the skeptics who disbelieve the Scriptures.[13] He contends that this is not just a good method for hard cases, but rather that the strongest argument for the resurrection of Jesus is one which can be based on the minimal historical facts alone. In other words, if one utilizes only those facts which are agreed upon by all parties to be historical, even by skeptical scholars, there is still enough data to show that Jesus rose from the dead in body[14] and that data will be the most accurate, undeniable and convincing. Few scholars, even rather critical ones, doubt that the resurrection as reported by the earliest witness was imagined; in other words, it is agreed that they indeed had a visionary experience. However, this vision as an hallucination or spiritual vision fails any attempt to explain the data as recognized by scholars. The facts favor a visual, real,
CRAM Exclusive

Related Documents

  • The Resurrection of Christ Essay

    big rock just by himself (Keathley 2). The linen wrappings that were in the tomb were not disturbed but were layed neatly (Keathley 1). The Theft theory gives an explanation that Jesus’ disciples stole the body of Jesus at night, thus no resurrection happened. This theory may include other followers of Jesus instead of the disciples like the

    Words: 1732 - Pages: 7
  • A Critical Examination of Judith Thomsons Argument for Abortion

    pregnancy is first outlined in a thought experiment later on in Thomson's argument, of which I will discuss further. Thomson uses another thought experiment to convey her stance on abortion where rape is not the issue, but a fault in contraception is. She effectively assesses the notion of responsibility In the 'people seed' thought experiment, which although quite far-fetched at first, ultimately adds some legitimacy to her argument. The reader is asked by Thomson to envisage a scenario in which the

    Words: 2743 - Pages: 11
  • Gary Paulsen Essay

    Gary Paulsen has written more than one hundred and seventy five books and two hundred articles. Gary Paulsen always loves to tell everyone about everything that he has accomplished. In his book Guts, Paulsen describes heart racing and exciting tales about his many adventures. Two books have won him the Newberry Award. These two books are The River and The Winter Room. Gary Paulsen’s reasons for writing any particular book are many. 1 Paulsen often thinks of the younger generations

    Words: 671 - Pages: 3
  • Examine How the Teleological Argument for the Existence of God Has Developed

    The fact that these things can follow these laws and fulfil some purpose without having the ability to think suggests they have been directed by something else that possesses intelligence. For Aquinas, the only explanation was that the guiding intelligence was God. William Paley proposed his version of Natural theology in the early 1800s. He compared the universe to a watch. A watch has certain complex features, it consists of different parts with specific functions and they all work together to

    Words: 927 - Pages: 4
  • Gary Soto Essay

    them. In one of Gary Soto’s books, The Old Man and His Door, he writes on the first page about a song in Mexico that says: “La puerta. El Puerco. There’s no difference to el viejo” (2). He exclaims right after that a viejo is an old man, puerta is a door, and that a puerco is a pig. He wants all the readers to understand what certain things mean in his story, for the fact that readers do not get lost since throughout the story he uses both English and Spanish. Gary Soto does this so he

    Words: 1448 - Pages: 6
  • The Cosmological Argument and the Mystical Argument Essay

    some beliefs are justified and can justify others in the process, however are not based on other beliefs themselves. On a side note, premise two of Aquinas’ argument was derived from Aristotle’s argument of nature, in which “facts about nature are based on experience”, which leads to an explanation, followed by the conclusion that that fact must be about God. The third part of Prima Pars involves the concept of “Possibility and Necessity”, which goes as so: 1) Some things now exist a) But

    Words: 1124 - Pages: 5
  • The Gary Valvers Cartoon Essay

    He sets it up in a very usual scene where the President would give a speech. Gary gave concerned faces on the press and made them eagerly waiting there in the audience seats with their important questions again in the speech balloon about current events and their paper and pens ready to write. Valver then puts a big goofy, overly eager smile on the caricatured Presidents face, just like a kid in the candy shop, he is excited to share. Valver also writes, "My NCAA pick," in bright bold red letters

    Words: 917 - Pages: 4
  • God's Purpose Revealed: Reconciliation & Unity in the Body of Christ

    All that Christ Jesus is now resides in His ekklēsía. “For in Christ all the Deity lives in bodily form and in Christ you have been brought to fullness. The “fullness” (plērōma) of God dwelling within his ekklēsía is the methodology which God purposed to use in his ultimate plan of reconciliation. Jesus Christ “serves as the forerunner who establishes the pattern that those who are ‘in him’ will follow. Christ leads the way, setting the terms of new life for those who continue to live ‘in him’”

    Words: 2701 - Pages: 11
  • A Comparison of Winthrop and Edwards to the Apostles of Christ

    is obvious due to his confession, "I have gone under continual conflicts between the flesh and the spirit, and sometimes with Satan himself many falls I have had" (Heath 238). James struggles with the spirit when he rejects the death and resurrection of Jesus Christ. Nonetheless, both men test their characters and persevere through their trials. This is seen in their writings as they encourage their audiences who will inevitably struggle with the flesh and the spirit. James' encouraging words to the

    Words: 1957 - Pages: 8
  • Proposed Research Essay

    work for approximately 20 hours during the four week period. My primary focus will be on their interaction in meetings, although I will also observe (and perhaps enquires about) interactions during their other work. [Describe the context of the proposed research, making it clear how this context will allow you to accomplish your stated purposes] Scope: I will engage in participant-observation over a six-week period, from 8 April to 22 May for approximately four hours per week. I will typically

    Words: 1234 - Pages: 5