An Analysis Of Westmoreland's Request

Improved Essays
Westmoreland’s Request “Vietnam divided America more deeply and painfully than any event since the Civil War.” (Readings 9, To Avoid a Defeat, 231). The steady stream of American casualties suffered at the hands of the NVA made a difficult situation intolerable as American support for the war diminished with each soldier laid to rest. President Lyndon B. Johnson made a dire mistake in approving General Westmoreland’s request on to put combat boots on the ground in Vietnam, as the threat to American security had not been triggered to the point where it was worth the lives of American soldiers. The American military was severely underprepared for war, and the eventual withdrawal of troops would become a global embarrassment that continues …show more content…
“LBJ feared defeat in South Vietnam, but he craved success and glory at home.” (Readings 9, To Avoid a Defeat, 233). President Johnson wanted to win the Vietnam War to prove secure his place in history. Johnson was a very insecure leader whom many thought did not have the proper education or background to be President. Regarding Vietnam, Johnson believed, “If I don’t go in now and the show later I should have gone, then they’ll be all over me in Congress. They wont be talking about my civil rights bill, or education, or beautification. No sir, they’ll push Vietnam right up my ass every time. Vietnam. Vietnam. Vietnam. Right up my ass.” (Readings 9, To Achieve a Victory, 225). Clearly. Johnson was troubled driven by factors other than doing what was best for the American people. He wanted the respect necessary to push through his notion of the Great Society, and gambled with the lives of the 282,000 American soldiers lost in Vietnam. President Johnson should have known that the strategy was not working, but still he pushed beyond the point of reason in order to make a name for himself, which he could then use to advance the domestic policies he wanted to enact at home. Johnson’s arrogance led to his recklessness in pursuing victory in Vietnam. Undeterred by the French defeat at Dien Bien Phu and Vietnam, Johnson, “was less wary of the French experience than Taylor or Ball; he was …show more content…
Johnson was extremely reckless in approving General Westmoreland’s request for American troops in 1965. In so doing, he committed one of the greatest military blunders in American history. There was no clear path to a decisive and quick victory. This conflict would become, “a protracted war involving an open-ended commitment of U.S. forces, mounting U.S. casualties, no assurance of a satisfactory solution, and a serious danger of escalation at the end of the road.” (Readings 9, George Ball Dissents, 1965, 217). Johnson should never have agreed to send troops to Vietnam. Doing so only prolonged American presence in Vietnam, which led to massive casualties, caused an international embarrassment, and forever tarnished President Lyndon B. Johnson’s

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Alexandra Cox Johnson vs. Nixon Kennedy and Johnson started and expanded the war in Vietnam, making it the dominant issue of foreign policy. Johnson escalated the Soviet containment strategy in Vietnam with more ground troops. Johnson wanted to focus on internal affairs like health care but had to address the war he inherited in Vietnam and could not fulfill both domestic or foreign policy successfully. Nixon ended the war in Vietnam, his slogan while running for presidency was “Peace with honor” and he succeeded at it through political negotiations. Most of Nixon’s foreign policy was to prioritize détente with China and the Soviet Union so it helped increase political slack.…

    • 1350 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Vietnam War is one of the longest and most divisive wars in US history. U.S entry into the war was largely due to misperceptions about Vietnam by U.S policymakers, including US presidents. President Kennedy and President Johnson were both responsible for the escalation of US involvement in Vietnam. In this essay, I will discuss which US president, Kennedy or Johnson, was most responsible for US involvement in the Vietnam War. First, I will discuss why President Kennedy is responsible for US involvement in the Vietnam War.…

    • 712 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Johnson continued sending American troops over to defend South Vietnam, or “South Vietnam would be [at] lost” (A. Pollock, 1991). May, 1965 US Commander in Vietnam General ordered for 180,000 men, in prevention of South Vietnam falling into communists. In nine weeks, Johnson sent over 99,000 US troops to Da Nang. “We cannot be defeated by force arms. We will stand in Vietnam” (A. Pollock, 1991), due to South Vietnam falling, so did Johnson and “The Great…

    • 1150 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Vietnam War Dbq Analysis

    • 738 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Overall, the Vietnam war was a popular conflict that failed in terms of the defense of S, Vietnam against the communist N. Vietnam, and changed many American’s opinions about the nation’s role in the world and on their lives. The Vietnam War was yet another example of the escalation of the cold war, but his time, American intentions were completely misguided, and the damage done to society was huge. American involvement in Vietnam increased conflict and tension in the U.S. because of the overwhelming unpopularity of the government decisions causing great social unrest and unhappiness especially young people, political corruption in the Johnson and Nixon administrations, and economic mismanagement of the war effort vs. domestic programs. As…

    • 738 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Dbq Vietnam War

    • 1700 Words
    • 7 Pages

    It is argued that American involvement in the Vietnam War is not justifiable; they were engaged in the wrong war, at the wrong time in the wrong place. I consider this assessment to be fair and the arguments of Carl N. Degler, Jon Roper and Nigel Cawthrone and others will be discussed in support of this argument. This essay will also elaborate on why I understand this assessment to be fair together with reasons why the involvement of the Americans in the Vietnam War was unjustifiable. America’s motive for involvement was to halt and prevent the spread of communism and a containment strategy and foreign policy called the National Security Council Report 68, NSC-68 for short, was implemented to do so. Roper explains the introduction to a book…

    • 1700 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    This investigation will explore the question: to what extent did Nixon achieve the ‘Peace with Honor’ in the Vietnam war? The scope of my research will assess Nixon’s ‘Peace of Honor’ statement given to Vietnam in the early 1970s to see if Nixon kept his words or not to South Vietnam to have peace with North Vietnam after the Vietnam war. The method used to gather evidence of whether or not Nixon’s achieved the ‘Peace of Honor’ will be determined by the range of primary and secondary sources, compare and contrast of the evidences, as well as evaluating the origin and purpose of my sources for their values and limitations. Two sources- the New Republic Editorial ‘Peace with Honor’ and General text by John Traynor focused on modern United States…

    • 1765 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Dereliction of Duty, H. R. McMaster provides a detailed analysis of the key decisions that the Johnson administration made leading up to the Vietnam War. Using recently declassified material, including many tapes and papers from the Johnson Presidential Library, he highlights how and why those decision were made, thereby giving readers a fresh and unique view of how the United States turned Vietnam into an American war. McMaster, a military historian and former history instructor at the United States Military Academy, based this book on his dissertation he wrote while at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. At the time of writing this book, he was a major in the United States Army. McMaster had previously led combat troops…

    • 1028 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In Johnson’s “Speech on Vietnam” delivered on September 29th, 1965 at John Hopkins University, he continues Kennedy’s trend of imperialist rhetoric disguised as responsible foreign policy. To start, he argues that South Vietnam’s freedom is in danger of falling under “the deepening shadow of Communist China” ignoring the fact that communism in Vietnam is enacted by the Northern part of Vietnam, and not China (Johnson 1965). The majority of Johnson’s speech draws on imperialist rhetoric, dictating that America has a responsibility to support freedom in a global context, ignoring the very real effects of violence in order to achieve such a valiant claim. In response to the escalating brutalities, Johnson strategically speaks to it from abstract point of view, obscuring the audience’s understanding regarding the amounts of American bodies…

    • 1215 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    To insure we do not have a recurrence of the great depression we must start with an even greater society and that is exactly what Lyndon B. Johnson had created. Lyndon Johnson the 37th president of the United States did not go to school believing that one day he would run this country. Mr. Johnson came from a less fortunate family, who attended college to teach the less fortunate children of minorities, this did help his presidency because he could see where people other than the rich first class was coming from and acknowledged that they needed more help. President Johnson believed that a great society would be a society “Where progress is the servant of our needs,” (Johnson qtd. in Great).…

    • 1094 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Logevall claims that committing to war in Vietnam was a terrible mistake. Logevall begins by showing some sympathy to President Lyndon Johnson and other leaders at the time, as they believed that the strategies they had would work. He then goes on to state that “vocal proponents of taking the war to North Vietnam were strikingly few in number”4. He states this to show the overwhelming rejection of support to go to Vietnam by many American leaders of the time, other than Johnson. Logevall also suggests that even other countries were skeptical of being able to win in a long-term battle with the Viet Cong.…

    • 865 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    . By 1972, when President Richard Nixon was running for reelection, the United States had been embroiled in the Vietnam War for 17 years and deeply divided internally as a result. Re-election insecurity and positioned in a war that hurt our nation economically and emotionally, Nixon was aware of the stress put on him and high expectations he would have to live up to, however: “Nixon was among those who stopped bothering. Just as the initial support for the reforms waned, so Nixon’s enthusiasm disappeared. The war in Vietnam was proving to be far more intractable than he hoped and he was forced to devote more and more of his attention to the effort to end it” .…

    • 1119 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Truman had to make a tough choice during WWII and at the beginning of the Korean War. Lyndon B. Johnson had a difficult decision to make regarding Vietnam and what course of action we should take. Johnson had the difficult decision of deciding whether the United States would send ground troops to Vietnam in order to protect South Vietnam, which was an ally. Johnson believed that if he did send troops it would turn into another Korea. If he did not send troops it was only a matter of time before the North Vietnamese would take over South Vietnam.…

    • 837 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Patrick R. Hollman Billington English 11 8 May 2015 Nixon and Vietnam The presidency of Richard M. Nixon was fraught with turmoil; but despite the madness and chaos that were part of his presidential history, Nixon will go down as one of the most dedicated presidents of our country. At a time that America was in a state of disarray from being involved in three different wars since the beginning of the century, Nixon entered office with Vietnam fully engaged in warfare. His policy for the war was one that held promise; however Nixon’s ability to move forward with the policy became compromised by the politics. The Vietnam War had an impact on both the United States and the presidency of Richard M. Nixon.…

    • 1928 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    President Lyndon B. Johnson made the decision to send troops to Vietnam and to bomb the North to stop communism in Vietnam. That decisions is about the outcome of the Vietnam War that the United States was all in this war. Even though the citizen do not like that the U.S was in this war, it did not matter because President Johnson is all in.…

    • 467 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Following the assassination of Kennedy, Johnson had taken over and became even more invested in the war. He continued to send aid in the form of military troops and even made the statement that he would not be the president who would lose the Vietnam war (Moss, 2010). Following the Tet Offensive, Johnson decided to drop out of the running for Presidency. It was president Nixon who then followed and eventually was able to withdrawal troops from Vietnam giving him what he called “peace with honor” (DeVry, 2014). Although all of the presidents were very much different, they all had one thing in common, none of them wanted to admit defeat.…

    • 773 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays