Analysis Of Are Campus Activist Too Dogmatic By Victor Tan Chen

Improved Essays
In Victor Tan Chen article, on “Are Campus Activist Too Dogmatic”, many points were made, however was not followed by a valid argument. In his article, he discussed how college activist is a nuisance to society in a way that targets liberals. Chen never seems to emphasize in his article the reasons for the campus activists protest, yet includes the fact that their protest is highly severe. In other words, Chen’s article is almost dismissive to the whole point of the student protesters furthermore, describing their actions as being useless in its entirety even with them tackling issues like racism and sexism. It is a total disregard of your first amendment right, abridging the right to freedom of speech in this country in a logical …show more content…
Chen states that, campus activist “alienated the uninitiated with their join-us-or-else self-righteousness”, which is not true and he provides no factual evidence to support this claim. Chen then reverts to the 1960s, with the “New Left” cultural warriors who became influential in leading the country into a different path, one strongly against the American society and principles. By including these facts in his article, Chen is using logos to appeal to the audience and prove that the campus activist did not follow through with the new “egalitarian economic agenda and savvy political strategizing.” However, by him staying that her does not includes ways that they can stop deterring from the “New Left” and spark some actual change. Chen article, is filled of a list of things that these campus activists are doing wrong, with out seeing the true meaning behind it. Which almost leads you to the assumption of thinking that he wrote this article simple because he was annoyed with campus activist and thought their actions served no …show more content…
Whether it maybe campus activist or regular people protesting some issue there moral or religious beliefs are always going to have some part in it. Especially, now that information is so easily accessible, and people’s opinions are openly heard. Which is there right given to us by the U.S constitution signed by some of our founding fathers. Chen approach towards his audience/ readers should have been more developed and evidence based. His entire article sets a tone of harness and hatred towards campus activist. Therefore, caused his article to lack in effectiveness throughout in really trying to advocate his point for the readers to understand. Lastly, even though Chen’s article show some effect of logos, in all is lacked credibility which puts in to question the whole point of him writing the

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    This leaves little to no room for actual credibility to be added. There is an extreme appeal to pathos, but almost no appeal to logos. This is surprising coming from an author that is highly educated and has contributed much to the science community. Lastly, one of the biggest flaws of this piece comes into play at the conclusion. As Eisley tries to tie his writing back to his introduction, he chooses one of the weakest aspects, again citing a memory not many others can relate…

    • 547 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The subject for the article “The Age of Protest” by Thomas Friedman revolves around today’s act of protesting and how people are “becoming more morally aroused” from these various protests. Protests nowadays are very much involved with the society as a whole because “when you get that much agitation in a world, everyone with a smartphone is now a reporter, news photographer and documentary filmmaker.” Now that generally everyone has a smartphone, he is saying that anyone can take part in any issue of importance because they can stay involved with conflicts happening over any broad distance. Also since many people are aware of different protests happening, they experience a moral debate about it as well of the decisions made during the event.…

    • 151 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Rather he allows his audience to imply what he really is saying. He does attempt to give reasoning to persuade his audience but it is ineffective. An example of the logos’ ineffectiveness can be found in the connection/flow between paragraphs one and two. In paragraph one he states the deaths that happened in new haven, identifies his unfamiliarity with them and then states a probable reasoning that doesn’t contain the required credibility in this situation (Sinha, 2014). In paragraph 2, he provides statistics on deaths that happen during residency.…

    • 1046 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Logos correlates with logic, something that the authors showed through this piece. When writing an article on scientific research and studies, there can be no fabrication to it and the authors knew that. Through studies conducted by them and other researchers, it backed up the tone that the authors were trying to present. The tone was to inform and through the use of studies and a formal, yet sympathetic tone they achieved that goal. That is one literary device that was shown.…

    • 666 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Kevin J. O’Brien’s article, Rightful Resistance, the methods of rightful resistance are described as resisting by using legal and non-violent means, exploiting promises made by political elites, and exerting political pressure. The article argues that rightful resistance is the ideal way to protest against the political elites, and attempt to gain new rights. O’Brien begins his argument by first discussing popular resistance. He describes a sort of stereotypical view of popular resistance that includes uprisings of the poor against the elite. He uses this in contrast to rightful resistance, which is indeed a method the underprivileged may use, as it is non-violent.…

    • 1159 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Weak Tie Activism

    • 406 Words
    • 2 Pages

    To define the difference between “strong tie activism” and “weak tie activism,” “Small Change” is an essay written by Canadian journalist Malcolm Gladwell, which targets several breaches that modern social media activism possesses to this day. Gladwell commences his essay by describing how a protest occurred at a campus in the University of North Carolina after four college students were denied a cup of coffee because of their race, where several of the students’ friends gathered with them to protest. This protest is categorized as “high-risk activism” because many of the protestors had a personal connection with the students and they committed actions that put them in a risky situation. This is also known as strong ties. Gladwell then writes:…

    • 406 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hidden Assumption Essay

    • 798 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Compare and contrast the hidden assumptions, undefined terms, statements without research, and errors in logic The first article that I analyzed came from www.ottawacitizen.com titled “Dozens of oil pipeline protestors arrested on parliament hill.” Firstly, the hidden assumption falls in the title in which it assumes that it was a violent crowd with most people acting in a rowdy manner. It goes on to quote an ‘organizer’: “[It was] the largest act of youth-led climate civil disobedience in Canadian history.” However, it doesn’t specifically mention what organization it was that this statement came from.…

    • 798 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Kent State Massacre

    • 1829 Words
    • 8 Pages

    The United States takes pride in the amendments it has created to provide freedom for all citizens, but what if the government is more controlling than it leads the world on to believe? The right to peacefully assemble, freedom of speech and press is sacrificed for the government to manipulate the people and promote nationalism. A protest at Kent State puts the theory of right to peacefully assemble and freedom of speech into question. On May 4th of 1970 this college becomes a killing ground disperse with the bodies of college students, as choices made by the government provide another example of how nationalism is more important than life and freedom. The students protesting Richard Nixon’s decision of involvement in the Vietnam War were…

    • 1829 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    American’s First Amendment gives us many significant freedoms such as freedom of speech, freedom of religion, and freedom to assembly, Communist China doesn’t have any of these freedoms if it goes against the People’s Government. In Fan Shen’s book, Gang of One Memoirs of a Red Guard, he had no rights to believe or say anything different from what the government wants. Shen is born and grows in a Chinese Communist family in Red China, and he tries to escape the legal way because if he doesn’t it would cause problems for his family. It is difficult to know what it is like not having freedom of speech when we have grown up with it, Shen was not as lucky, he grew up in a world without the basic freedom that is given to us in the First Amendment;…

    • 1109 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The 1960’s were full of powerful movements in effort to end oppression, enact change, and encourage America to get involved. One of the groups fighting for equality and democratic participation were the Students for a Democratic Society, or SDS. The SDS wrote a political manifesto where they proposed a system to encourage participation called The Port Huron Statement, or PHS The Port Huron Statement was written by Tom Hayden and 58 other college students in the SDS, on June 15, 1962. The main purpose of the PHS was to express the dissatisfaction many college students in the 1960’s felt towards college administrators in regards to them telling them how to live their personal lives, to voice their opinions on how the current state of America…

    • 1595 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Over the years the ideas of the first amendment has changed, and it has become very controversial. The first amendment has become very controversial in the late 19th century and 20th century around college campuses monitoring how and what students say in today’s generation. In the article “Free Speech on Campus” by CQ Researchers readers are given the information about what the controversies concerning how far free speech extend are, how state and federal courts decided on various cases of free speech, traces of history of academic freedom of universities, and what the issues at stake in colleges hosting academic centers sponsored by authoritarian regimes. The controversies concerning how far speech extends according to the articles free…

    • 1003 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Asian American Movement was an era of radical change in which the urgency for Asian Americans to overcome oppression and negative perceptions of American society transcended their clichéd silence and indifference. However, such a(this) monumental movement was not achieved without the courageous efforts of activists who had ideologies that coincided but also contradicted each other that stemmed from their different backgrounds. Two advocates in particular who emphasized the need for social change were Amy Uyematsu in her new article “The Emergence of Yellow Power” and Warren Furutani in his interview with the Amerasia staff. Both activists, in their own contexts, explain the evolution of the Asian American Movement, highlighting its roots,…

    • 853 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article titled, “Kindly Inquisitors: The New Attacks on Free Thought,” Jonathan Rauch concludes that hate speech should not be censored on campus. Rauch believes that students have a right to academic freedom. He believes that students will not feel free to explore or question topics that may be taboo, if they are fearful of reprimand, limiting their ability to learn about the world during a crucial time in their education. First Rauch argues that gaining knowledge is painful and Knowledge cannot be separated from pain, even the most “scientific” criticism can be painful. For example, Physicist Ludwig Boltzmann committed suicide following criticism of his ideas.…

    • 713 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Logos formed another important part of making this article…

    • 908 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Malcolm Gladwell’s article “Small Change”, activism and its development into modern day society is targeted. Through the repetition of examples that happened in the real world, a sense of reality and importance is placed on the activism. As the article opens, it tells of four college students sitting in at the Woolworth’s and their protest that sparked the interest of many others. Iran’s Twitter war is brought up to repeat the activism in the article and introduce the actions in a more modern-day view. The people who go onto Facebook are called, “Facebook warriors,” in the article.…

    • 705 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays