Steinmetz And Schaefer Critical Analysis

Improved Essays
The articles by both Steinmetz and Schaefer and Carr emphasize the differences in which authors portray issues and shape their article in effort to effectively relay a message, a message that plays a role in the purpose, and consequently actions, of individuals based on their identification as an audience. Considering content, Carr concisely yet simply goes through the concept of the medium to relay an understandable idea to a general audience, while Steinmetz and Schaefer extensively go through the current uses and issues of the medium, conveying complex ideas to an audience knowledgeable about the Internet as a medium. Furthermore, reflecting on exigence and stakes, while Steinmetz and Schaefer aim to provide a beneficial resource to an experienced …show more content…
Carr presents the idea that because individuals rely on the Internet for all sources and thus are pulled into a one-dimensional world that provides filtered information, they remain susceptible to manipulation by higher powers (Carr 2). While Schaefer and Steinmetz agree, they furthermore state manipulation is also due to lack of awareness of the medium itself because the focus on content trumps the importance or even knowledge of how the medium alters its message (Schaefer and Steinmetz 505). This comparison between Schaefer and Steinmetz and Carr reveals that they both have the same overall exigence- to provide awareness of vulnerability of the medium. However, because their audience consists of researchers seeking to further their own knowledge of the Internet as a medium, Schaefer and Steinmetz specifically write their article so that their audience themselves can further investigate how higher powers and even the medium itself manipulates content and perhaps spread awareness. Further displaying their exigence as authors, Schaefer and Steinmetz state that although the increase of monitoring the Internet has increased citizen’s democratic rights and powers, it has inhibited those same rights and powers due to authorities using the same method to …show more content…
Both Schaefer and Steinmetz and Carr write about the same concept, however, in order to effectively convey their message and promote awareness about the susceptibility of the medium to manipulation, they shape their content in such a way that fits into the audience’s purpose, whether that be to further their own research or gain a basic understanding of the issue. The comparison between the two articles is essential as it emphasizes the need to recognize the audience’s background of knowledge so that the audience themselves can make actual use of the content and follow through with the author’s

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In the article “The Internet is a surveillance state”, which appeared on CNN.com on March 16, 2013, Bruce Schneier claims the government can see our every move on the internet. He goes on to state, “Whether we admit it to ourselves or not, whether we like it or not, we’re being tracked at all times.” (55). He uses specific and persuasive examples from his work experience to share his thoughts and beliefs on a subject that not everyone is aware of, but the ones who do are usually chilled by it. This paper will analyze Schneier’s article from his view as an American security technologist, cryptologist, and author of “Liars and authors:…

    • 801 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The author uses her knowledge of the topic to further her own argument against it, and to ultimately scare her readers. Whether they are the older generations who did not grow up with the internet, or the younger generations that are unaware of the effects of their browsing history. Andrews knows her target audience and how to tailor her words to them, similar to news agencies choosing what to report to each user based on their history. This “weblining” that she discusses in her essay, she is guilty of herself (334). She rattles off buzzwords that, to a layperson, sound quite intimidating.…

    • 758 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Tech-no Ever since Benjamin Franklin discovered electricity, people have both used and misused technology. The development of technology has brought along a thing called the internet, which has strong effects on the way people act and behave today. It gives people access to information through media, entertainment from video games, and communications through social networks that can be harmful to people of early ages. Many people today believe that the increase of violence in society is due to the many platforms that spread influential ideas that can affect people 's behaviors negatively.…

    • 1031 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the New York Times article, “ Stop Googling. Let’s Talk,” the author, Sherry Turkle, uses her chance to show parents and young adults how having access to internet all the time is hurting the world today. She informs the audience with specific statistics to show how technology is not only taking over how we find new information, but changing how we communicate. In addition, it shows that not only teenagers are being affected but adults also. Devices are not just changing what we do but changing who we are as people.…

    • 800 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Censorship in the media has been a controversial topic ever since the founding of the United States. From the Alien and Sedition Acts of 1798 that restrict the rights of immigrants, under the John Adams presidency, to the Edward Snowden and NSA scandal in 2013 that concerned government surveillance of its citizens and government transparency. These controversies have caused a public backlash against media censorship of any kind but there are aspects of media censorship that protect society rather than hurt it. Instead of hiding government secrets or preventing certain political ideas from being expressed, media censorship can be used to hide criminal’s and victim’s names as well to hide sensitive and graphic images or video from the public.…

    • 875 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In today's world we are introduced to new technology everyday, that is made to make our lives both easier and better. Although in the article, “Is Google Making Us Stupid?”, author Nicholas Carr provides the reader with his own thoughts on how he feels that the internet is taking over. Carr first explains that the internet has caused focusing issues forever everyone including himself. And continues to add that his life has become immersed in the internet, for he now struggles to stay connected to one task without feeling any temptations to use the easier to access internet. Like all successful writers Carr had to use rhetorical appeals to draw in an audience to read his article.…

    • 732 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Carr uses this technique because readers can relate to it, just he can relate to it as well. Carr reaches out to readers through ethos in a strong way by connecting to them as a human being and not just as a messenger. He shows that he experiences the Web and uses it to his advantage just like any other person. He too uses the Internet to read information faster instead of critically reviewing a long article. He does this by stating, “the Net is becoming a universal medium” not only for himself, but for everyone.…

    • 237 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Nicholas Carr Rhetoric

    • 1067 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In this article, the writer Nicholas Carr attempts to explain how is the information offered on the internet has reformed our method of intelligent. He uses several altered techniques to play on the reader’s emotions by using stories, studies, and his own reflection to try to convince the audience that the internet has been unfavorable to our intelligent and knowledge ways. For the most part of his argument is unproductive because of his organization, his choice of sources, and his tone. Carr started his article with a quote from 2001 called A Space Odyssey. He clarifies the quote, speaking about in what way the human is modernizing the PC, but then the equivalents that with how PCs have renewed his brain.…

    • 1067 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Nicholas Carr has brilliantly apply the used of the three rhetorical appeals to convince his reader that the internet is changing the way that an individual think, read and process information. Through the combination of ethos and pathos, Carr was able to shock his reader with the serious consequence that the internet can have on them with a goal that they will be more careful about the amount of time that they spend online. But in all honestly, did he successfully convince his reader?…

    • 673 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Presently, electronic media remains unavoidable (Tuning in to Electronic Media, 2011, p.1). We live in an interconnected world with society having a variety of means to communicate and stay connected to one another locally and globally. In addition, electronic media can reach people by the masses. For instance, electronic media notifies the public about world news, advises us of local news and events, provides entertainment, recommends products and even warns the population about potential dangers. Advertising, a major component of electronic media plays a huge role in the U.S economy (Advertising, 2011, p.129).…

    • 817 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Introduction The most powerful and prominent force in the world has without a doubt has been, the rapid advancement of technology following the industrial revolution. From the introduction of the steam engine by James Watt to the mass expansion of railway lines, technological advancement has increased productivity and globalization exponentially. By breakthroughs in communication, transportation, and information technology, the world in which we reside has become unrecognizable to what it was 200 years ago. This essay encompasses these three ways in which technological advancement has completely restructured and revamped the world of as we know it. Cementing itself as the most powerful force on the planet.…

    • 1516 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Lastly, he had to make the information relatable because no one wants to read a lengthy article they can 't relate to. From this article one should know that there are negative effects to overusing the Internet as opposed to just simply picking up a book. In all Nicholas Carr does an exceptional job at educating his audience on the effects of the Internet. Throughout his essay he easily engages the reader without coming off as overbearing, ambiguous, nor does he weaken his argument. As a whole this essay was great and should be highly recommended to all users of the Internet.…

    • 1167 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In a time when society is more egocentric than ever, people must resist or conform to a form of life that revolves strongly around knowing what everybody is doing all the time through social media platforms. Ms. Ham and Mr. Standage focus on how trends draw people out of their normal social interactions and into a world that seemingly revolves around themselves (We Shall Overshare, Mary Ham 280). Their focus upon the false sense of attention that people get from sharing about themselves shows how the audience in each article should be able to relate to this kind of situation. The world that people live in today is full of self-centered beings that seek only to grab attention for themselves and distancing themselves from their friends and family…

    • 1199 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Digital Democracy

    • 1113 Words
    • 4 Pages

    This reflects aspects of audience studies as users are performing “mass self-communication” as a result of their ability to share and contribute to political and social affairs, enlarging the scope of exposure to a particular issue (Castells 2012, p.6). In having the capacity to potentially exert influence through the arguably liberal, democratic and decentralized nature of the online environment by challenging dominant power structures in reality, networks can be understood to have a profound effect on contemporary politics (Castells 2012, p.2). However, in saying this, the question of who truly holds the power becomes evident, to which Castells argues that the political force derived from these networked societies should be considered a “counter-power” to the power that is rooted within the institutions of society (Castells 2012, p.5). In challenging these powers, social actors are able to demand for the representation of their values and interests, with Castells asserting that domination of institutionalized power systems will occur if “a majority of people think in ways that are contradictory to the values and norms…enforced by the state” (Castells 2012,…

    • 1113 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    “Some dismiss [communication studies] as “fluffy,” or easy” (Frierson, 2012). However, people seem to not understand that a communication studies program can prepare you for a variety of careers. Frierson (2012) states, “In fact, the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics lists more career opportunities for communications graduates than any other major, including computer science, engineering and mathematics.” “Communication Studies is a broad discipline that covers rhetorical theory from the ancient Greeks to the latest in digital media.…

    • 1144 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays