Femininity In Charlemagne's The Song Of Roland

Improved Essays
Men and beards, two terms that are used synonymously throughout much of history, either through Medieval literature or Contemporary literature. In the epic poem of Old French literature, The Song of Roland, there is much deeper importance behind hairy objects presented in scenes of war with the Saracens, emotional moments of characters, and Thierry’s appraisal in the trial of Ganelon’s fate. The anonymous poet has ascribed various heroic attributes to the men who possess beards: wisdom, experience, masculinity, and high social status. However, some may dispute that alongside these attributes there is irony that stems from the romantic background of the epic as the poet makes both Charlemagne and Thierry display instances of femininity through …show more content…
Although femininity may skew these attributes, we can trace a connection from the repetition of beards to the fur coat given to Thierry at the very end of the poem, and correlate beards, fur, and ultimately hair as indications of power and status. Furthermore, the poet expresses Charlemagne’s white beard to rationalize how bearded men represent the ideal image followers of Christendom.
We will first examine the actions of both Charlemagne and Thierry in different emotional scenes to reveal the hidden feminine aspects tied to the masculine symbolism of beards. Looking first at Line 3712, Charlemagne is asked about the whereabouts of the departed Roland, and stricken with emotion he “feels the weight and grief of this, tears fill his eyes, he weeps, pulls his white beard” (268: 3712-13). The masculine beard and its attributes, associated with a king who represents the ideal strong-hearted man, is fragile. Charlemagne
…show more content…
The messengers of the Saracens are in awe when white beard is first witnessed as they meet with Charlemagne and his council. Line 117 says, “His beard is white, his hair flowering white. That lordly body! The proud fierce look of him!” (8: 117-18). The description presented by the poet paints Charlemagne as angelic or holy-like individual in order to mesmerize outsiders with what men of Christian faith look like. The “flowering white” imagery of the beard is then traced when Baligant, the incredibly powerful emir of Babylon, is introduced “like a true knight: He has a beard that is white as a flower” (229: 3172-73). Charlemagne’s image with the white beard depicts him as the ideal Christian, similar to that of Jesus, who desires to spread the richness and wisdom of Christendom to outsiders. This connection between the “flowering” white beards of Charlemagne and Baligant suggests that the Saracen looks good enough to be a Christian. Therefore, from the facial hair similarity of white beards Charlemagne feels the opposing men are symmetric counterparts that are ancient, and alike in bravery, nobility, and

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    This symbol shows a boy going form a Jew to a Christian. This holds true since when the boy grows older and joins the monastery he finds more love for God’s work. In addition, Guibert talks about a noble Beauvais who once was not a religious man, but who found God and became a religious man in the monastery. Book two can be considered as a section of Guibert’s autobiography dedicated to praising God. He praises God all throughout his work, however book two center on the monastery, which is a place to praise…

    • 785 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The objectification of the female body is commonly done by men, who see women as something that is of use or owned by them. Although, this usually has negative implications Marie de France’s lai Guigemar objectifies the female body as a tool to expose the negative aspects of society. By objectifying the female characters her message is more easily understood and even satirizes, the patriarchal society. Marie explores the problems women face in society and how they are so much more than the box they are placed in.…

    • 1984 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Charles The Great Dbq

    • 431 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Charlemagne or Charles the Great is most famous ruler of the Middle Ages. He lived ca 742-814 and ruled over the Frankish kingdom which covered Belgium, France, Luxembourg, the Netherlands and a part of western Germany. He went on to conquer much of western Europe, all under a policy of friendship and cooperation with the Christian Church. He therefore greatly contributed to the expansion of the Christian Church’s power. He also introduced the basis of Feudalism and revived the political and cultural life of Europe after the fall of Western Rome.…

    • 431 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Geoffrey Chaucer and Marie de France have strikingly similar themes within the Breton Lai’s they have produced within their works. A Breton Lai is a narrative form of English and French Medieval literature that usually consist of tales of Courtly love, Chivalry, and often using supernatural elements within the story as well. Both Chaucer’s work of The Wife of Bath’s tale and Breton Lais produced by Marie de France such as Bisclavret and Lanval incorporate all of these elements and they will be examined and compared in this response. The Earliest Breton Lai’s were written by Marie de France and although we have no way of knowing whether or not Chaucer read Marie de France’s works, we can clearly see a connection between the two authors as shown in The Wife Of Bath’s Tale.…

    • 575 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    For some historians, it is difficult to come to terms with the overwhelming number of sources centered on the male gender. It would be foolish to discount the impact of women on society when they consist of half the population. Valerie L. Garver’s Women and Aristocratic Culture in the Carolingian World illuminated the feminine nature within the Frankish cosmos by showing off how women’s roles downplayed the idea of a masculine dominated social construct. Though she admitted to her argument involved much speculation due to the impossibility of separating ideals from reality, she used a “disciplined imagination” to embrace the limited sources that uncover elite women’s responsibilities and impact.…

    • 780 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Einhard composes Life of Charlemagne in 825 AD with the intention of commemorating King Charles’s well rounded devotion to his kingdom and his family, as he went beyond the expected duties of a King. Throughout the course of his life, Einhard had became very fond of the King and felt it his responsibility to preserve his knowledge of the King’s great deeds subsequent to the King’s death. Einhard provides a detailed piece of writing in which he eternalizes the deeds enacted by the King through which the King’s devotion, to both his kingdom and his family, is reflected. First, Einhard provides some detail about rulers who came before King Charles. In doing so, he provides the reader the opportunity to create a comparison in which King Charles…

    • 1128 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the twelfth century, a variety of different genres in poetry and storytelling started to form to celebrate the allied cultures of chivalry and courtliness. Entertainment that focused on courtliness had a very different style, subject matter, and authorship. Many of them of them were composed by women. An example would be Marie de France, author of the collection of lais and The Life of Saint Audrey. Marie de France wrote during the time that Henry II and Eleanor of Aquitaine were ruling.…

    • 1286 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The difference between vassal and lord shows the ranking of power, and the foundation for feudal relationships of medieval history. Idealised views of feudalism represent honorable agreements between a lord and his vassal or vassals in which they both offered their loyalties to one another in exchange for land and services that were usually military in nature. Instead the Agreement between Count William V of Aquitaine and Hugh IV of Lusignan translated by Paul Hyams of Cornell University, demonstrates the tumultuous relationships between vassal and lord for the struggle of having and maintain power and authority. This literary account shows the conflict that formed between Hugh and William. The text depicts the kinds of relationships that had…

    • 729 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Guanyin Vs Avalokitevara

    • 1116 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The lines in the traditional monk’s robes are not as deeply set, but the layers of the cloth creates a deeper shadow above the inner elbow area. The quality of the lines make it easier to see the overall composition of Guanyin as opposed to the faded look of Virgin and…

    • 1116 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Merchant’s Tale follows a genre of the narrative common to the medieval French literature known as a “fabliau.” According to Christina von Nolcken “these types of stories are often short, comic, and involve a person stealing another person’s wife.” The key plot of The Merchant’s Tale fits this, especially with the stock features of the lustful old man cuckolded by a young woman. Von Nolcken continues, “part of the comedy of a fabliau of this kind is the folly of the old man who thinks he can sexually please his young, good-looking wife, and have her truthful to him”. The tale focuses on January as he appears the victim of the unfaithful wife, but his inappropriate lust and foolishness would have caused no sympathy from Chaucer's medieval audience.…

    • 997 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    La Belle Dame Sans Merci and the Great Gatsby are two examples of a beautiful romance gone wrong- in both novels, someone ends up getting hurt. Both authors, although living in completely different time periods, are trying to convey the same message; that even though a relationship feels right, sometimes it couldn’t be more wrong. In La Belle Dame sans Merci, the knight-at-arms recalls the way his lover announcer her feelings for him. He says,”’And sure in a language strange…

    • 622 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Two lives of Charlemagne is a book that has the writings of two people that wrote about the life of Charlemagne. The first person was a man named Einhard who wrote a biography of Charlemagne’s life. The second was Notker the Stammerer who wrote about the deeds of Charlemagne. The writings from Einhard and Notker combine to make the book Two lives of Charlemagne. The text will focus on six ideals from the text.…

    • 741 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In comparison to Sir Gawain and the which is a celebration of medieval chivalry knight, Lanval by Marie de France is a critique of the medieval chivalry. Even though at timed Lanval shows acts that should be praised by the chivalry system, most of the story relies on mocking this system. In Lanval we see more of a mockery towards the chivalry system. One of the biggest factors that led me to conclude this was that this poem was written by a woman.…

    • 781 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Marie De France’s uncanny, whimsically lai “Lanval” satirically challenges and reverses the themes of love through stereotypical gender roles, which are unique and romanticized to traditions of the 12th century. Women for eternity have been rendered as beautiful, physical objects, who where inferior to men, and needed nothing more then a body. Marie De France depicted these same stereotypes in her writing but just in a reverse methodology. She criticizes the stereotypes of women with very opposing qualities while still displaying characters with feminism. This poem combines mercy and humility with a physical attraction which indicates the placement of power in the women characters.…

    • 1465 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    When one thinks back to the Early Middle Ages and the times of stories such as “Beowulf”, images of masculinity and bravery come to mind. Scenes of monster slaying and grand battles for honor and glory are easily accessible in many Old English verse, the men of these tales are strong, decisive and the poster children of the ideal male figure. With all of this testosterone coursing through the lines of the epic poems, it is strange to discover the presence of a feeling that doesn’t really go with the image of the tough man. This feeling exists between the men themselves, and when the feeling is explored, the reader can find examples of homosexual tendencies between the lords of the land and their men. The feeling isn’t really felt between men…

    • 2083 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays