An Analysis Of Dorothea Dix As A Leader Of Asylum Reform

Improved Essays
The nineteenth century was the era of reform. From politics to religion, it seemed like every aspect of nineteenth century American society was going through a rapid change of ideas and beliefs. One aspect of society in particular, the criminal justice system, had a series of specific reforms. These reforms ranged from the separation of prisoners; to the decrease of crimes punishable by death. Yet, there was no reform to aid in the improvement of the mentally insane in prisons. Unfortunately, it was not until 1841 that the mentally insane gained a champion, Dorothea Dix. The analysis of Dorothea Dix as a leader of asylum reform shows how women gained rhetorical experience, and how they effectively implemented it into their campaigns for reform. …show more content…
These campaigns allowed women to display their rhetorical skills. Women, like Dorothea Dix, found and honed their skills in a variety of ways. One way these women might have honed public speaking was through their passion for these causes. Dix for example found her passion when teaching Sunday school class in East Cambridge prison. Dix channeled her outrage of the inhumane treatment and turned it into passion, fueling her campaign for the separation of the mentally insane from regular prisoners.
Another way, women gained rhetorical skills was going out and gathering information. For instance, Dorothea knew to be effective in presenting her case to the government she was going to have to go into prisons and gather information herself. She traveled the Northeast going into prisons and examining the condition of inmates, and asking to speak to the most deprived souls. During these encounters with inmates, she realized that the mentally insane needed their own institution where they can try to become normal

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    There is much to be learned from analyzing Dorothea Lange’s photograph “Migrant Mother” and the article relating to it by Kevin Starr. The photograph shows a poor migrant family and how the conditions they have been living through have begun to wear them down. The article gives more personal information on the family, ones you wouldn’t have been able to get from the photo, like how the mother’s name was Florence Thompson and that, “...they had been living on frozen vegetables from surrounding fields, and birds that the children killed” (Starr 2). After the photo was released, many criticized Lange for focusing on the issue behind the photo and not the people in it since she hadn’t even asked for the name of the woman she photographed. After…

    • 314 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Beginning in the middle of the nineteenth century and continuing into the twenty century, women’s rights activists traveled the country in an effort to win women’s suffrage; this is known as the Women’s Rights Movement. Ending in 1920, the movement was deemed successful as the Constitution was amended and all women in the United States were granted suffrage. This life altering success can be attributed to the hard work and unwavering devotion of five women. In Jean H. Baker’s book, Sisters, The Lives of America’s Suffragists, Baker's main focus is centered around who the women truly were as individuals. By examining the lives of Lucy Stone, Susan B. Anthony, Cady Stanton, Frances Willard, and Alice Paul, the book reveals an unfamiliar side…

    • 822 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Photographer Dorothea Lange’s most famed photograph “Migrant Mother” is considered by many to be synonymous with the great depression era and the struggle faced by southwestern migrants looking for better opportunity in California. The image of a destitute mother, Florence Thompson, was spread across American newspaper and the image is credited with having “made Americans aware of the story of the dust bowl.” , alongside other similar individual accounts. Lange’s snapshot of Florence Thompson seems to have been captured in a candid moment, as if Lange had just happened upon Thompson and captured the image as it unfolded in front of her camera’s lens. “Migrant Mother” is actually the sixth shot in a series, Lange often instructed her subjects’…

    • 247 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Dorothea Dix was known a very opinionated and brave woman during her time. Even when woman in the 1800s were not supposed to have any say in the federal justice system. Dix made sure she found a way to get her word known to the government and make a change to the treatment of mentally ill patients in prisons. This paper will go over what steps Dix has to take to make those impactful changes to the prisons to allow the mentally ill, blind, deaf, and mute to have equal treatment to others. This writing will go over only few of the great moments during Dix’s life and discuss her contribution to society, how it impacted the nursing field, and how her contribution made a person influence.…

    • 127 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Dorothea Lange was a very prominent photographer during the Great Depression. Her most notable piece of photography was Migrant Mother. This particular art piece was intended to evoke emotion toward its viewers, due to the different aspects of this phot. The main emotion that the photographer tried to have in this photo was fear and struggle. The facial expression shown by the woman in this photo emits a very melancholy tone and the fact that she has her children burrowing their heads in desperation against her shoulders also contribute to the overall tone of this photo.…

    • 219 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    As the eighteenth century was ending, and the nineteenth century was beginning, the start of something no one expect was coming. The start of movements. The nineteenth century until the early twentieth century, were known for its movements across the world. It was a time when people wanted equality among one another, and they felt the only ways to truly succeed in achieving some of their goals was to create a stir. The Temperance Movement was a movement created a group of thirteen women.…

    • 1908 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Analysis Questions: “Rousseau and His Readers” 1. Rousseau sought to limit women’s activities to those in which they were naturally suited for. While Rousseau petitioned for women’s education, he felt strongly that the application of the knowledge learned must be specific to her role as a women. Unlike Mary Wollstonecraft, Jean-Jacques Rousseau sought to bar women from politics and keep them in the topics in which he saw fit. For instance, Rousseau believed men were more inclined to argue philosophy and deal with matters demanding precision, accuracy and science while women of wit were more suited for observation.…

    • 290 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Maternal Reformers

    • 1131 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In this reaction paper, I explain the role of maternal and how the maternal discipline is applied in women’s penal development projects. The paper represents the development of separate women 's prisons through maternal reformers. The paper explains the effect of American women 's corrective movement in Canada and how this prison system different from each other. Historically, the society was believed in the power of the penalty to change the criminal behavior and to restore the social order.…

    • 1131 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Migrant Mother: Dorothea Lange The Dust Bowl of the 1930’s left many migrant families destitute as they struggled to survive through a period of economic depression in the United States. Dorothea Lange captured the plight of one of these families in the photograph, titled Migrant Mother. While working for the Farm Security Administration (FSA), Lange took six photos, but this one in particular became the most popular image from the series.…

    • 961 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    During the age of the scientific revolution women faced continuous struggles with their representation in a heavily male dominated society. Even during the reign of Queen Elizabeth the I, women were seen as incompetent temptresses that deceived and distracted men to fulfill their own desires. Women writers of the time were required to place great thought and consideration into their works on any subject or risk being written off as foolish or shrewd. However, this led to another problem for women. The careful and clever arguments only managed to increase their reputation as deceivers of men, and worsen the reputation placed on them.…

    • 1192 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Topic Overview Mental health in the corrections system has been a persistent problem since the dawn of incarceration. For a long period, before we knew about mental health disorders, people suffering from these diseases often ended up in prisons. In the 1840’s, a woman named Dorothea Dix began to investigate the treatment of mentally ill in the prison system. She soon urged for the creation of institutions that would house and treat mentally ill, rather than condemn them to jail cells. Dix succeeded, and up until the 1950’s most mentally ill individuals were held in mental health institutions.…

    • 1443 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Most individuals assume that once an inmate is sentenced to time in prison, their violent actions would be depleted. However, multiple articles, news stories, and professional statistics prove otherwise. In fact, chaos appeared in the South Carolina prison riot, overpowering the force of state officials; leaving seven dead and seventeen injuries (Fausset). “ State officials Monday blamed the carnage on the turf war between gangs over territory, money and contraband items like cellphones” (Kinnard). There are countless factors contributing to the mentality of these individuals .…

    • 998 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Women In Prison History

    • 328 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The history of the prison system has evolved over the years compared to what it was many years ago. During 1900 century violence seemed to signal great advances against women’s oppression. Veenstra (2011) established that significant degrees of discrimination exist in many different aspects of Canadian society, especially against poor women, and even more pronounced, against minority female populations. The interventions from Elizabeth Fry in the early nineteenth century campaigning for women to be housed in separate prisons from men and have a safer facility. The prison system was developed by adapting a model that was designed for male prisoners.…

    • 328 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The topic of deinstitutionalization is a controversial issue in psychology. Deinstitutionalization refers to a process of relocating chronically mentally disabled populations from institutions to community-based treatment facilities. The idea of the deinstitutionalization reform was created to promote more effective and humane treatment for patients with mental illness via a shift from statewide institutions to more community-based treatment services. Deinstitutionalization first began in the 1950s with the closing and downsizing of multiple asylums, which was initiated by President John E. Kennedy in the United States. These asylums were labeled as “lunatic asylums” and were either shut down or altered.…

    • 1046 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    When looking at these two photos one can observe some obvious differences between the two of them. The first obvious difference between the two photographs is the idea that one is showing the struggling mom with her kids and the other photo is showing the race relations that existed in this country during this time period. The second difference between the two photos is that Dorothea Lange’s Migrant Mother was taken in 1936 where Margaret Bourke-White’s At the Time of the Louisville Flood was taken in 1937.…

    • 217 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays