An Analysis Of Donald Trump's Veil Of Ignorance

Improved Essays
7. Donald Trump has promised since day one of his bid to become president, that he would build a wall between the Mexican/American borders, and stop the flow of illegal immigrants once and for all. From a philosophical principle Trump is applying the teachings of Stuart Mills idea of the greater good, or utility, but also using the “Veil of Ignorance” among his supporters to get what he wants. Using Mills idea to of a greater good, Donald Trump is skewing it as a utility for the greater good of the United States. Trumps campaign slogan during the 2016 presidential election was “Make America Great Again”, one the aspects Trump attacked that made America not great. Was the presence of illegal aliens, mostly from Mexico who had border jumped …show more content…
The Veil of Ignorance, proposed by John Rawls, does not allow people to use their advantages, or suffer from their disadvantages. Everyone has to act impartially, out of fear they will be disadvantaged by the rules. From the mutual commitments the U. S. and its allies have made mutual commitments that Donald Trump has gone back on these commitments, pulling the United States out of them. Trump has cast his own Veil of Ignorance in not holding to these commitments, when the United States has been a part of them for years, is unethical. Trumps Veil of Ignorance can be based on the idea that he is more committed to solving the United States problems on the home front, and not on a global scale which will eventually come back to bite him. The Veil of Ignorance for Trump is that he isn’t willing to accept the outcome of his choices. In the past decade the world has entered into the idea of globalization, where the world is connected more than every before, not just through technology but also politically. Especially with Trump becoming the next President, whatever happens in Russia will in turn effect the United States under Donald Trump? Because of Trump unethically withdrawing from previous commitments, Trump is undoing years of work done by previous Presidents and not thinking of the long term problems that will happen because of his …show more content…
Aristotle’s idea on virtue, being that to be good one must be virtuous in all things. Not being a coward and not expecting a reward for what they do, because it is the right thing to do. As President of the United State, Donald Trump will need to believe what he is doing is good, not just for America, but good in general. Following on that, Immanuel Kant’s categorical imperative, that as President, Trump will have to act and make decisions. He cannot just wait for other things to happen. As president he must speak softly and be willing to use the big stick if need be, and let history be the judge of his actions. Through Mills philosophical concept of utility, Trump will need to think on the utility of the United States first, and the rest of the world second. Based on the philosophers we learned about in class, Trump would not follow the ideas of John Rawls. Being a politician and also being a leader, Trump won’t be able to be fair. In order for him to make a decision someone will have to win, and someone will have to

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In June 2015, while announcing his candidacy, our future president Donald J. Trump said “When Mexico sends its people, they’re not sending their best, they’re not sending you. They’re not sending you. They’re sending people that have lots of problems, and they’re bringing those problems with us. They’re bringing drugs. They’re bringing crime. They’re rapists. And some, I assume, are good people." Although he said the criminals are coming from Mexico, it made all immigrants upset because in this case he was not only aiming towards Mexican but to all Hispanics. Not all people who cross the border are criminals, most are just escaping poverty, trying to better themselves and their families. Immigrants are a huge part of the American community but people do not seem to acknowledge it. Former Governor of Michigan, John Engler said “It is important to note that immigrants or their children founded more than 40 percent of U.S. Fortune 500 companies — turning their American dreams into American jobs. That is just one reason why high-skilled immigrants are so critical to…

    • 1157 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Addressing the first principle, he wants to fortify the United States’ southern border by constructing a wall along the border, and wants the Mexican government to pay for the wall. Secondly, the laws that the American government makes regarding immigration need to upheld and no one is above the law. In order to do so, Trump calls for “tripling the Immigrant and Customs Enforcement officers, e-verifying the nation, mandatory return of all criminal aliens, the detainment of illegals caught crossing the border, the defunding of sanctuary cities, enhance penalties for those who overstay their visa, cooperate with local task gang task forces, and end birthright citizenship” (“Immigration Reform”). Lastly, Donald Trump wants to use legislation to put American workers first. Donald Trump’s policies are unaffected by interest groups, but public opinion of his immigration policy has potential to damage, but not destroy, his ability to win the Texas Primary. Donald Trump’s immigration policy, should he be elected, would result in economic and social problems. Additionally, Trump’s immigration policy affects those within and those without of his constituency, therefore he needs to bridle his shock value in order win the Texas Electoral College…

    • 1053 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    What did Donald Trump start his campaign on? Building a wall, making America great again, bringing wealth to by creating more separation between it and the rest of the world. In other words, Trump is wanting to turn America into a fortress. And like Nimrod before him, his life’s obsession has been building…

    • 1914 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The slogan that propelled Donald Trump into his influence across the nation, “make America great again,” shows that Trump sees America has fallen downhill and has hopes to improve it. Trump wants to see this country go back to the prosperous country it once was, but he does not know how to filter his words according to most, which makes him seem frightening. Despite Clinton’s accusation about the risk of Donald Trump, his clever use of scare tactics gives voters a sense of security because of his ideas concerning immigration and terrorism.…

    • 923 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Although the other candidates have tried to hinder Trump’s momentum, he has still dominated the Republican primaries. Being the driving force Trump is, a voter may wonder why he is so popular. His campaign slogan “Make America Great Again” displays exactly what Trump stands for (Make America Great Again!). His many comments on against Hispanics and other races surprisingly find support among his constituents. The building of a wall on the border of Mexico has been one of Trump’s biggest issues. He claims the funding of this wall will come directly from the Mexican government. He states, “Immigration is a privilege, not a right.” (Make America Great Again). With this ideology, he will cancel many Mexican visas to compel Mexico to fund his wall. Even though Trump uses words like “compel”, he is truly using scare tactics against the Hispanic people (Make America Great Again). Donald Trump’s whole campaign is based out of fear and discrimination, He has alienated almost every minority group, and even his own party does not support his bid to run in the primary election. It can be said that represents the worst parts of the United States. A president’s place is not to separate the people, but to join everyone together in unity. A president like Donald Trump would not be able to accomplish that…

    • 829 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Where Clinton depended on facts and personal testimonials, Trump had thrown in ad hominem fallacies and had avoided answering questioned posed towards him. For example, on the topic of abortion, Trump was asked if he would want the Supreme Court to overturn Roe v. Wade. Instead of answering the question, he had insisted that the issue would go back to the state level instead of establishing his position on the legality of abortion at the federal level. He had also deflected the question of immigration and his proposed legislation in establishing a wall by attacking Clinton and accusing her of voting for a wall as well. However, after fact checking this information, Trump’s definition of a wall was by any means, broad, seeing as how Clinton voted for legislation that created porous fences that allowed owners to access their land on both sides of the established…

    • 313 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Donald Trump is known far and wide as the man who wants to build a huge wall between America and Mexico to keep out immigrants. Trump believes that building a wall is going to make all the violence and issues of the country disappear but Clinton is smarter than that. Clinton wants to work on getting rid of violence all together and she understands that ones race doesn’t determine whether they are violent or not. Violence is a huge problem in this country that needs to be fixed but getting rid of a race isn’t going to fix it. When I first heard Trump say, “We have some bad hombres here, and we are going to get them out.” I was appalled. I was shocked that someone could be so ignorant and say something like that on national TV. Being a minority I couldn’t believe that someone with those ideas and beliefs could possibly become the next leader of our country. Coming to American I knew it as the place where everyone had equal opportunities and right but Trump is actively trying to destroy that. Millions of people dead, trillions of money spent and hundreds of years to get equal rights and opportunities for people means nothing to Donald Trump. He is like an uneducated spoiled little kid, he wants what he wants and if doesn’t get what he wants he will throw a “trumpertantrum”. When I have kids I don’t want them to hear our leader of the country say that just because they are not white it must mean they are…

    • 975 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In the opening pages of their book Mistakes Were Made authors Tavris and Aronson note that politicians conspicuously engage in the art of self-justification (3). Politicians rarely admit mistakes they have made in the past and instead opt to find ways to justify their actions. This often presents cases of dissonance whereby politicians seem to be out of touch with reality. One such case is the recent US attack on Syria. The campaign rhetoric of Mr. Trump during the last election period and even before that period presented a philosophy of America first where the US is expected to keep off affairs that do not directly benefit it. In fact, Mr. Trump vehemently and repeatedly aired views against any attack on Syria by then President Obama. The seemingly change in view by President Trump needs an analysis as it presents a dissonant situation that the President needs to self-justify to get over. The attack on Syria is an act that President Trump previously opposed in very strong terms and thus for him to now blame crossing of red lines is just a mere self-justification for clearly a dissonant act.…

    • 1840 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Have you wacthed this years presidental debates? If you have then you know of donald trump. Donald trump has ra5n for presidency for 2017. If you know that, then you most likely know his major selling point. Trump wishes to build a wall on the mexico-american border. He wishes to stop illegal immigrants from stealling americans jobs. However, since this has a low chance of coming to fruition, the next cannadate is most likey deportation. Deportation is when you send illegal immigrants back to their home country. However, this is a terrible way to deal with illegal immigrants.…

    • 651 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Trump markets himself as a businessman and not a politician; in his campaign announcement speech Trumps keeps referring to himself as the “right guy,” the guy who is going to make America great again. Trumps wants to instill and, more importantly, bring out the skepticism in the public; he claims that America has been brought to near ruin because of the incompetence of America’s current leaders. He attacks and belittles politicians as seen in his speech when, after discussing America’s debt to China,”How stupid are our leaders? How stupid are these politicians to allow this to happen?”(Trump, Donald. “Our Country Needs a Truly Great Leader”Trump Tower, New York City. June 16 2015. Speech) He isn’t throwing smoke without a purpose though, it is all to serve his purpose; the argument he makes is that he is not like the politicians who got America into it’s current debt, but he is the businessman who will get the Nation out of it, and all in the effort to make America great again. This claim, and others like it, are all meant to be the reason why the public should vote for him, and for the most part the arguments are successful. This is not to say that this argument is well constructed or infallible-- Trump spends a lot of time discussing what he will do and not a lot about what he has already done-- but it is a very effective appeal to the ethos. There aren’t numbers…

    • 1483 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Trump wants to get all illegal immigrants out of the country. But one may ask “How do you expect to get every single illegal to go back to their home country?” His only response to this could be is to build the 10-foot wall. Johnson said “A 10-foot wall just requires an 11-foot ladder.” this does say a lot because people will do anything to be in the United States. Trump wants people to come into our country, he wants to bring people in but all he wants is to be able to do it legally.…

    • 563 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    At this point, it is uncertain whether some of his speeches are actually heartfelt and he believes what he is saying 100%, or everything he has been doing for practically the past year has been a brilliant publicity stunt. According to The Guardian.com, Trump is openly proposing to round up all aliens in the country, mainly referring to Mexicans, and send them back to their homeland and afterwards create the next Great Wall of China on the U.S. border. What good would this plan be? Many of the immigrants he proposes to deport have been standing citizens of their communities for several years who no longer have any connections to their previous country. If Trump 's plan were to succeed, millions of families would be separated and the parents would have to make the excruciating decision whether to leave their child and separate their family, or take their child to a country they have never had a connection with and do not consider home. Also, in an article by USA Today.com, it states that Donald Trump tried to persistently persuade the American public that undocumented immigrants are threats to society by using Kathryn Steinle, a woman murdered by an undocumented immigrant, as an example. However, the article later goes on to explain that undocumented immigrants commit violent crimes at a far lower rate than native-born Americans. Speaking from…

    • 1635 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Decent Essays

    President Trump’s first official meeting with congressional leaders for the first time. In the article, “ Trump Repeats Lie About Popular Vote in Meeting With Lawmakers” by Michael D. Shear and Emmarie Huetteman, he states that millions of immigrants made him lose the popular vote majority. He has made plenty of these claims before on Twitter and also at the White House Reception. This shows evidence that Mr. Trump still overthinking and cares about the issue, even though he has become President. He is concerned that the public views his presidency, unsanctioned because of the conspiracy of how Russia helped him win the election against Mrs. Clinton. He won 304 electoral votes, but Hillary Clinton had around 3 million votes more than him in…

    • 510 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Donald Trump’s egotistical and nonchalant demeaner are just characteristics of who will be represent our country. He says whatever he wants whenever he wants without considering the consequences. It is said that by being blatantly truthful and saying what he really feels Trump is being “real” with everyone. To be a good president one must understand when, what, and how to speak. President Donald Trump has strong opinionated views on gun control, abortion, and the death penalty. President Trump has a very strong standpoint on these topics and believes in trying to make America great again. By controlling the population he believes can do just that. Leading an entire country is no easy task however it is no excuse for not exhausting all resources and approaches to make the best decisions.…

    • 919 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is good for politicians like Donald Trump to awaken voters with informative and riveting speeches. Furthermore, as stated before, illegal immigrants bring crime into the country, steal money from government programs, and take many jobs from Americans. Therefore, Illegal immigration are detrimental to the United States, and Americans should no longer share some of the same values as the founding fathers, for they did not think of the unintended consequences. If Americans changed their way of thinking, it would help the country heal and progress to a better…

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays