Amy Tan Two Kinds Analysis

Superior Essays
“Two Kinds”: The Role of the Chinese Parent in Todays Society.
Many people wonder how Chinese parents raise such successful kids. Much of these speculations into the mystery of Chinese parenting styles are very recent. Chinese parenting practices focus more on being demanding and strict to guide their children to do well. It is important to examine exactly how the parenting roles of the Chinese differ from those of western cultures. The story of “Two Kinds” by Amy Tan explores what happens when a mother from China brings her family over to America, to give her daughter the opportunity to live the American dream. This story shows a mix of stern Chinese parenting and modern day American culture; Chinese parenting is influenced by history and
…show more content…
H.P Wilkinson, author of The Family Life in Classical China, states that most of the Chinese have gained their fundamental social principals through The Rituals of Chow by Chow Kung and The Record of Rites. (Wilkinson 19) These works, along with many other classics, showcase writings from the origins of China about how the first people of china conducted themselves including family life. Another example that the Chinese drew from to structure there own families and ways of parenting were The Odes which are the oldest existing collection of Chinese poetry and songs; they comprised works from 12th to 7th century BCE. It served as a template for many Chinese families in early tradition. The problem with The Book of Odes is that the poems and songs are often interpreted in different ways, but the importance of The Odes and other historical works of China are that they gave developing China a traditional structure of doing …show more content…
In the past according to the book (Wilkinson 21) “Women were the theoretically of little importance. They were necessary for the reproduction of species, in most cases for the labor in the home.” In the past as with most society’s women didn’t have much responsibility outside of the home, this was also true for the Chinese culture, they usually served their husband, and son but over time the roles have changed and a balance between mother and father in Chinese households has been established. The term tiger mother came about after the story Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother was released by Amy Chua, a story that shows a clash of cultures between Chinese parenting methods and western society. Several reasons why this parenting style has become so popular in western societies are because many Chinese children are excelling in school and seem to be very disciplined. According to the American Psychological Association today the Chinese mother not only puts emphasis on academic achievement but they also see it as important to foster other traits they believe their children will need to thrive. (Chamberlin) The goal of the Chinese mother has expanded past beliefs of creating a model citizen they not only want to instill a child with morals, and esteem, but also help them survive in todays economy, by providing the best form of

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    In today’s society, most schools, both elementary and secondary, don’t discuss Asian or even Asian American History. African American, Native American and even European histories are all extensively covered in history classes. Many students have at least some knowledge of African American slavery, forced cultural assimilation of Native Americans, and the civil rights movement. From an early age, children are taught that the U.S. is a country created by immigrants; however, American history classes have shown a trend of teaching that excludes Asian Americans from the history of this country. At most, the topic of Asian American history is lightly touched, only introducing San Francisco Chinatowns or the large influx of Asian immigrants looking…

    • 1254 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Amy Tan's Two Kinds uncovers clashing qualities. The mother-little girl relationship goes through the entire story. Clashes happen attributable to disparate conclusions about distinguishing proof. As a Chinese settler in America, Jing-Mei's mom puts her American dream on the shoulder of her little girl. Be that as it may, as an American conceived youngster, Jing-Mei would not like to experience the desires of her mom.…

    • 1360 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In some extent, I disagree with Amy Chua’s view about “Chinese mother” and “Western mother” in the article why Chinese mothers are superior. Although, she thought that Chinese mothers are superior, in my opinion, her some description about Chinese mother and reasons that support her ideas are unconvincing, exaggerated even extreme. We cannot define Chinese mother as what she said in the essay. Her view of Chinese mother looks like the truth, but actually far from the fact.…

    • 909 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Is America’s academic “boat” being taken over by the Chinese? In the New York Times article, “Amy Chua is a Wimp”, by David Brooks, touches on whether Chinese parenting is better than American parenting, and criticizes one parent’s, Amy Chua, method of raising her own kids. In this piece, Brook uses effective literary strategies in order to turn us against Chua, but at the same time opens our eyes to the idea that she is no better than us Americans. He exploits Chua’s parenting flaws right from the beginning, and takes repeated stabs at the way she punishes her kids. Statistical data is included in the article to establish supporting evidence , and to make his writing credible.…

    • 824 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Amy Tan Two Kinds Essay

    • 753 Words
    • 4 Pages

    “ A Mother’s controlling habits” A mothers role is to love their child unconditionally and want the best for them. But their constant constructive criticism can turn a loving mother into a nagging one. In the short story "Two Kinds" by Amy Tan, Ni Kans mother is constantly pushing her to strive for the "American Dream. " Just like any mother would like to guide their child which is understandable, but for them to dictate their life is completely wrong. Ni Kans mother should have guided her to the right path instead of telling her how to live her life, Ni Kans mother should not have a say towards her future and here is a few reasons why is because this may lead a child to become rebellious and demonstrating hostile to others, dictating…

    • 753 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Parents in this generation strive to convey to their children that they can pursue any career of choice. American children have this upbringing more so than other ethnicities due to the ideology of the American Dream. For instance, Chinese parents have strict guidelines for their children to abide by, and in most cases, they expect their children to pursue the lives that they tell them to. In a healthy parent-child relationship, there is a balance between parental guidance and individuality. Problems between the child and parent can surface when the balance is geared more towards one side than the other.…

    • 918 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Civilizations are always experimenting with how to create a harmonious and balanced society, and in the process of doing this, they must dictate roles for all members of said society. In the Chinese kinship group, the father is the leader of the household, and the mother is the foundation of their family. The ways women contribute to their households, and the amount of independence they have, fluctuates and changes as time passes and dynasties rise and fall, but there are also consistencies in how society, as a whole, views them. These textual sources officially establish women in roles of obedience and submission, but many biographies illuminate the power women wielded through teaching their sons and daughters, as well as the respect they…

    • 1471 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In this day and age students are tested. They are tested in everything. Once a child enters school they are in for a lifetime of being tested. Many people believe these tests do not represent all types of intelligence, and that children have their own unique aptitudes. In “Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior” Amy Chua goes on to describe this as “Western” thinking.…

    • 1221 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In the short story “Two Kinds” by Amy Tan, the author creates a conflict between a Chinese mother and her daughter. The relationship between the mother who wanted her daughter to be prodigy, and her daughter who refused to be prodigy is presented (43). She uses dialogue, irony, similes and metaphors to illustrate and set her writing. Tan’s main message that stands out in the story is parents-to-kids relationship, in this case mother-to-daughter relationship.…

    • 1325 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The influence of culture dictates the way one acts and the activities one participates in. In “Rules of The Game”, by Amy Tan, MeiMei is brought up in a household based on principles of the Chinese American culture. MeiMei talks to her mom about what Chinese people do, and MeiMei’s mom reflects on the occupations that Chinese people partake in,“Chinese people do business, do medicine, do painting. Not lazy like American people.” (Tan, pg. 2)…

    • 244 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article, “Roar of the Tiger Mom,” Amy Chua explains the essential differences between Chinese and Western parents. Western mothers try to respect their kids individuality, motivating them to pursue their true passions while providing a nurturing and safe environment. On the other hand, Chinese mothers believe that the best way to protect children is by preparing them for the future and arming them with skills, and inner confidence. There are three differences between Western and Chinese parenting. First, Western parents concern about kids’ self-esteem while Chinese focus on strength.…

    • 463 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This different socioeconomic status decides the situation of children 's life, even in their future. According the textbook, "The style of parenting that is most successful can depend quite heavily on the norms of a particular culture, and what parents in a particular culture are taught regarding appropriate childrearing practices" (Feldman & Landry, 2014. P,173 ). In western societies, parents expect and encourage their children to thinking independently, to be brave and conscientious. In Chinese culture, parents want their children to achieve the social standard, which is get high score in school, to be a obedient child and follow their guidance in any aspect of life.…

    • 713 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Gish Jen 's story called “Who’s Irish?" is about an elderly Chinese woman living in America as she and her family struggle with issues concerning the correct way to raise a childand cultural differences between two families. The elder believes that her daughter, Natalie, isn’t living the way a Chinese woman should live because of her husband, John. The mother describes John as a depressed man who doesn’t help Natalie. So the mother is constantly arguing with her daughter about how she shouldn’t be the head of household. Another argument they have with each other is the way a child should be disciplined.…

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    What started out as a discontented story of a girl who denied her Chinese background concluded with the same woman fully acknowledging her own Chinese cultures, customs and heritage leading up to willingness and embracing of one’s ethnicity. By the use of diction, breaks-between-paragraphs technique, imagery, and organization; Amy Tan ties together the main ideas of each short story, bringing them all together to reveal the ultimate theme of…

    • 1354 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the poem, “Zhongzi, Please,” the reader is witness to the follies of young love. It states, “… Don’t break the willows planted there. It’s not that I care so much for them, but I dread my father and mother; Zhongzi may be in my thoughts, but what my mother and father said— that too may be held in dread” (1327). This part of the poem enables readers to get direct insight to relationships that occurred in ancient societies. This poem shows the reader that…

    • 1213 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays