American Sniper Critical Analysis

Improved Essays
American Sniper is definitely one of the most anticipated and controversial films of 2014. The movie is a biopic of the Navy Seal, Chris Kyle. His story is truly amazing and his account of what happened in the Iraq war gets the audience closer to real life battle than anything else. Clint Eastwood did an amazing job depicting the life of Chris Kyle and the stories that were inspired from the book the Kyle wrote. This movie has obviously stuck some sort of chord in the heart of America. In 2014, A lot of people were dying to watch this controversial, emotional, action packed film. The film received good feedback overall. American Sniper received a 7.3 on 10.0 scale on the rotten tomatoes website. With all of the good film reviews, these types …show more content…
One of these bad film reviews comes from the famous pop culture magazine company, “Rolling Stone.” This article comes from the website and tells of how bad the film is. This review is completely wrong and has many errors within it. The article is very opinion based. In the sum of all of this, the article is wrong and needs to be refuted.
The title of this review is called “American Sniper is almost too dumb to criticize.” The article is written from an author from the “Rolling Stone” magazine company. The author’s name is Matt Taibbi. Most of the articles that he writes are political. Matt begins the article speaking on Clint Eastwood movies in general and the simplicity in it. The format of Clint Eastwood movies is evident in American Sniper, according to Taibbi. He then goes off topic and makes a film comparison with the film, Forrest Gump. Taibbi says, “the mere act of trying to make a typically Hollywoodian one-note fairy tale set in the middle of the insane moral morass that is/was the Iraq occupation is both dumber and more
…show more content…
It is simply not fair to criticize a movie based on whether the movie involves politics or not. . Matt Taibbi seems to be a political reporter for the Rolling Stone. All of the articles that he has written have been related to politics somehow. This particular article is the most far fetched from politics than any other of his articles, but still relates it back to politics. Matt Taibbi seems to write this article from a political side and not an entertainment side. The movie was not made to challenge the political well being of leaders during that time. It was meant to honor Chris Kyle and his story. Matt seems to want the movie to be just like a Michael Moore film. Matt Taibbi claims that it is dumb to make a fairy tale type movie in the middle of the Iraq occupation of the war. Matt never really explains why it is dumb though and he leaves the reader to decipher the thesis of his claim. It was not up to Chris Kyle to make the decisions the political leaders did. Yes, it was a mistake occupy Iraq during the war. Chris Kyle simply did what he was supposed to do in the war. He went and served four tours of duty in the war. He didn’t have a choice. Politics and the decisions of political leaders should not mean that the movie was bad. Keep in mind, the movie is a human story, not a political story. Most of the claims in this article can honestly be refuted with the same argument. Which is that the

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    Robert Gordon, a SALON writer, disagrees fiercely, stating that “taking a conflict” such as the Iraq War, where there are intense, unavoidable political connotations and then centering the film on a single man then eliminates the context from the story, which Gordon believes “is a political act in itself.” Both sides argue well on the meaning and political meaning, or lack of it, in the film. Yet personally the view is that American Sniper is a film that intentionally or otherwise argues on the righteousness of the United States military’s actions during the Iraq War. Chris Kyle, despite how humanized he is in the film with his scenes…

    • 1509 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ben Carson. It is commonly known that political news sources claim to post unbiased information, but often do not do so. CNN is a liberal-sided news media network, and often will support leftist views. This is especially true with the media surrounding Dr. Ben Carson. As two primary source examples, “A Tale of Two Carsons” and “Carson Claimed West Point Scholarship but Never Applied,” both provide unflattering photographs of Ben Carson from a lower angle and bright spot lights that seem to pull out his natural flaws (Cheney 1) (Glover and Reston 1).…

    • 1254 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    During the movie, Marty, the senior partner for the law firm, withheld his intentions of merging the firm with another and in the process of doing so, took on the case of defending U-North, which he knew lied to their customers. In both movies, the characters could have chosen to be truthful to their colleagues from the beginning, instead of taking a path of dishonesties. Next, there is situation of Nixon’s abuse of power. He instructed troops to invade a country that he new did not have anything to do with the far and caused the lives so many people. This was clearly a decision that was not given enough thought and how it would affect others.…

    • 742 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Especially when comparing it to other war films. The plot of the movie is always one of the most important parts. American Sniper fared well over the entire film. From the beginning, with the Islamic call to prayer, which probably hit home for many Iraq War veterans, to the active war scenes, to the struggles with his wife and post-war, and finally to Chris Kyle’s murder. Every aspect of the movie kept you locked in with suspense on what was going to happen next.…

    • 835 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Catch 22 Satire

    • 620 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The controversy combined with the rising anti-authoritarian generation resulted in a nation prime to go against the grain. Additionally, since no other novel had ever satirized a major war, Catch-22 was published at the perfect time. Inflaming society’s controversy, Catch-22’s satirizing about a past war caused the rebellious generation to protest against the involvement in Vietnam (Aldridge 1). However, Heller does not use the war as his basis for the satire, he uses the authoritative corruption and general natures of war (Neary 3). Therefore, readers at the time were forced to reflect on how the United States’ involvement in Vietnam was actually beneficial.…

    • 620 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The assassination of Lincoln was a tragic day for all Americans and the authors interpreted the book in a very exciting way to find out what happened next after the Confederate War and his death. The authors counted down the days till Lincoln 's death during his presidency after he accomplished the war or after he got through a rough time. Killing Lincoln should be a well recommended book. The book would be recommended to high school or college students to read. It strikes interest of the Lincoln assassination and is very well written also…

    • 1313 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Pathos In American Sniper

    • 1182 Words
    • 5 Pages

    This film only consists of Chris Kyle’s life from starting basic training to getting honorably discharged and being back home with his family. The only information we got in this film was that Chris Kyle was assigned to capture leaders of al-Qaeda, nothing else. There was not on mention of Suddam Hussein or George Bush meaning that this movie isn’t trying to focus on the political part. Every other war film tries to focus on the political aspect of it, but this film “doesn 't deal with whether we should have been there or what we were doing there". Many war films consist of the war itself and what is going on with it rather than doing what American Sniper does.…

    • 1182 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    White House Reaction

    • 970 Words
    • 4 Pages

    These people do not make decisions on cost/benefit for the group as a whole, but rather for themselves alone. This does not help make rational decision making and will hurt the country, like what happened with Rumsfeld and Cheney. This documentary started out as an informative movie focused on what happened in Iraq, but it really was a movie about the issues America has with knowing when to stop forcing their hand in the international system. The Iraq war would have gone much smoother if we knew when we were going too far into the affairs overseas. The documentary shows both the benefits and drawbacks of the mentality of realism in society as a…

    • 970 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Sure, “it’s just a movie!” It’s just a movie, which is just a form of media that is consumed by the public and shaped by interpretation and then rooted into the belief system of society. Enthusiasts of American Sniper will adamantly reject the idea that the film has any underlying political message, and implying that it’s anything similar to a propaganda is probably the quickest way to get yourself jumped by rednecks. Clint Eastwood himself asserted that his work “certainly has nothing to do with any [political] parties or anything” (Lussier). But for a movie that’s not about politics, it sure does have a lot of politics in it; when I asked viewers of American Sniper to rank how strong of a political message they thought it contained on a scale of 0-10, the average score was 7.14, and there was no significant difference in the results between respondents who identified as conservative and respondents who identified as liberal. I also asked participants to rank how justified they believed the U.S. government was in invading Iraq, and, interestingly enough, respondents who answered that they had watched American Sniper gave an average rating 2.5 points higher than respondents who answered they hadn’t watched the film.…

    • 1585 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Essay On American Sniper

    • 1020 Words
    • 5 Pages

    American Sniper: or American Propaganda? The film American Sniper has been criticized by numerous reviewers and celebrities as depicting Chris Kyle as "a killing machine with a heart of gold." and "racist who took pleasure in dehumanizing and killing brown people." (Rolling Stone, Matt Taibbi) but Clint Eastwood’s response was "The biggest anti-war statement any film" can make is to show "the fact of what [war] does to the family and the people who have to go back into civilian life like Chris Kyle did." The movie itself did exceptionally well at the box office as well the majority of the viewers had positive remarks regarding the film.…

    • 1020 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays