Alice Rothchild's Voices Across The Divide

Improved Essays
In every conflict, there are multiple perspectives that come together to make the whole story. These narratives are rarely equally represented in media and pop culture, but that does not make any perspective less important or valid than another. In reality, the integration of these narratives comes closest to showing the ‘truth’ of situations. Voices Across the Divide, a documentary directed by Alice Rothchild, seeks to give a voice to the Palestinian people, whose narratives are so often underrepresented in the media. It features interviews with Palestinians as well as Dr. Rothchild’s own personal narrative to show different aspects of the Palestinain perspective, as well as to urge its viewers to question the formation and content of their …show more content…
However, hearing the voices of those displaced by or disturbed by the conflicts themselves was especially powerful. Watching and listening to these people share their life stories felt more personal than many other pieces we have read this year; we could watch these people break down in tears, and begin to understand that this conflict does not exist in a bubble, and has a substantial impact on many people. Palestinian voices often go unheard, especially in American media. Due to the U.S’s alliance with Israel and Israel’s significant technological advantage over Palestine, most of the media coverage is from the perspective of Israelis, leaving the Palestinian people silenced. By directly interviewing those involved in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, Dr. Rothchild made their stories personal for everyone watching. Watching someone tell about their experiences with tears streaming down their face makes their stories hard to deny, and created a sense of connection and honesty between the audience and the interviewees. Dr. Rothchild stated that one of her objectives of this documentary was to give those forced into silence a voice, and by including footage of her interviews with those directly affected by the conflicts, she did so effectively and

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The Apology: Letters From a Terrorist, written by Laura Blumenfeld, details the her pursuit of Omar Khatib, the man who shot her father. Laura, thirteen years after her father was shot by Omar, writes of her encounter with the Khatib family as well as establishing a correspondence with Omar, who at the time was in prison, via an exchange of letters. Laura primarily uses juxtaposition, as well as pathos, to identify, and at times even to argue for or rationalize, the differing perspectives in the essay’s center conflict. Using this act of violence as the catalyst for her reflection on the Middle East, Laura interweaves historical information about the disputes between the Israelis and Palestinians while writing about her encounter with Omar.…

    • 894 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I Am Eleven Documentary

    • 534 Words
    • 3 Pages

    “I am eleven” and “3 Wishes” are 2 amazing pieces of work both of which are documentaries that talk about children how they feel towards an array of different questions. Although they do so many things differently. So how do they compare? Well “I am eleven” is a filmed documentary on eleven-year-olds all around the world.…

    • 534 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Edward Said discusses in “States” about his hardships being a Palestinian who is often forced to move around the Middle East due to discrimination. Because of Said’s race he can no longer visit places of his youth nor does he have full rights in many other countries. His family and other Palestinians are continually looking for a place they can be long since Israeli invasions and civil wars. Said states, “Identity — who we are, where we come from, what we are — is difficult to maintain in exile. Most other people take their identity for granted (Said 8).”…

    • 1469 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In the 1800’s there was a power struggle for ethnic and gender equality for people of African descent. Enslaved Africans or slaves taken from Africa and African Americans sought out to gain the same natural rights: life, liberty, and property which were given to people of European descent. After slavery was banned throughout the United States Africans gained the freedom and rights of a European “man”, such as voting and right to property, but what about intellectually? What rights were Africans given in education after the abolishment of slavery? The thought or idea that African Americans could make a change in society was out of the social norms or standards that society set into place beginning in the late 1700’s.…

    • 1879 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Avner Gvaryahu Analysis

    • 566 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The conflict, in the first part of the podcast, is about a group of Israeli ex military service members talking about their experiences, because of the empathy towards the Palestinian families, the Israeli government sees this a a form of treason. The second conflict is about a professor in a Palestinian professor, who had to flee his country because he spoke about trying to empathize and having peace with the Israeli people. In the first story, Avner Gvaryahu was a former paratrooper for the Israeli military. He was raised in a religious household, went to a religious high school. At first he saw his actions as what he was supposed to do.…

    • 566 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Finally, Chapter 6 defines Bresheeth’s analysis of the cinematic dominant cinematic narrative of the Pro-Zionist cause, which historically has ignored the plight of Palestinians in the context of the 1948 exodus. In some cases, the film “A Take of Two Towns: Saffuriyya” (1948) and other films serve as form of memory that defines the cinematic portrayal of the Palestinian people in this regional context. This is, yet, another “mode” of memory that is analyzed in relation to the depiction of refugee status during the 1948 exodus of the Palestinian people from…

    • 1191 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Looking For Palestine, a book by Najla Said, explores themes of race/ethnicity, economic status, and patriotism while telling the story of a young Arab girl struggling with identity. Najla Said is the daughter of a Palestinian father and a Lebanese mother. Growing up in New York City’s Upper East Side, a fairly wealthy environment, her disorganized thoughts gradually plague her throughout adolescence and young adulthood, as she struggles to understand which cultural group she feels most connected to. Despite her drastic familial cultural differences, as a child, she often felt drawn toward her father, and subsequently her father’s Palestinian heritage.…

    • 264 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    For possibly decades now, there has been fighting in the middle east and I am not sure it will ever stop. One particular story of fighting stuck out to me, however. A man named Emad Burnat filmed activist protest of Israel taking land from his small Palestinian village. The documentary he created is called Five Broken Cameras. He is a peasant farmer who lives off of the land he owned.…

    • 1228 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Khadra’s depictions of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict shed light on a brutally, longstanding contention between two cultures with no end in sight. The disharmony within this sector of the world has been an international battle of choosing sides and allies, but more importantly it has been the cause of violent slaughter for thousands. This fictional literary piece can be used as a vehicle to bring its audience into a state of understanding the Israeli-Palestinian conflict for what it truly is. Because this conflict over land is between two opposing cultures, backed by two opposing religions, a resolution seems to be far fetched. Khadra allows the reader to understand the history between the two parties, better revealing why these two cultures resort to fighting one…

    • 1137 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Elie’s story is unique in the sense that despite knowing of the anti-semitic events that were occurring, the people of Sighet worried little. His story provides more depth to the common knowledge of the Holocaust. Without his recorded memories of what happened, the world may never of known about these people that were taken so late into the war, and their perspective. His desire to spread his memories and inform others helps to ensure that great tragedies, such as genocide, will be prevented. Elie’s memory, coupled with his motivational drive to educate the world of the genocide, has led to a more accurate understanding of the Holocaust that will not be forgotten.…

    • 1118 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Female Documentary Analysis

    • 2617 Words
    • 11 Pages

    Female Documentary Directors in Israeli Women documentary filmmakers in Israeli may be different than others directors however they tell us a story with her camera in her views. The readings of Like Windows in the Wall: Four Documentaries by Israeli Women by Janet Burstein, Women, Border, and Camera: Israeli feminine Framing of War by Anat Zanger, and lastly, Ethics and Responsibility: The Feminization of the New Israeli Documentary by Yael Munk, has different types of telling story of women documentary directors. The directors had face while making the film and what were her views as a woman directors. Some of women went into the war to shoot a scene when the men were fighting in the war however the men were not happy. However, these authors…

    • 2617 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    As I was watching it, it evoked a lot of unpleasant emotional feeling such as sadness, anger, sympathy, pain, and powerlessness. My eyes were full of tears throughout the documentary as Susan describing how Alan was living his life and how it influences her and her family. Watching the documentary evoked those feeling because a lot could have been done to improve Alan’s conditions, but because of the lack of knowledge great deal of wrong were done that could have been prevented. The guilt that Mitzi (the mother) carried her whole life that she was responsible for her son condition, and Alan condition would have been so much improved if he would have got better care and one-on-one attention from the beginning. Watching the film, I also felt extremely powerless as today we understand the problem and know how to address it, for the most part, but in some places of the world there are still people who are experiencing the same situation as Mitzi, Bill, and Susan.…

    • 1336 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Alice Walker's Women

    • 99 Words
    • 1 Pages

    The tone of Alice Walker's poem; “Women,” is determination you can tell because she is trying to portray that through the words she chooses such as when she says "... Headragged generals ..." it means the generals were not in the best of shape and yet, they transpired to do what needed to be done; and it is also stated when it says, "How they knew what we Must know Without knowing a page Of it Themselves. "this means that they went through a lot to get them what they knew that they needed, an education, without having one…

    • 99 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Chosen “The Chosen” is a novel by Chaim Potok following the friendship of two Jewish boys who grew up in Brooklyn nearing the end of World War II. Chaim Potok introduces many relationships throughout the book, this includes David Malter and Reb Saunders. Throughout the story, we begin recognizing the differences between the two fathers as well as the similarities. Reb Saunders raised Danny Saunders in silence, meaning that Reb does not speak to his own son unless they are studying the Talmud. Danny and Reb had not had an ordinary conversation with Danny since he was four years old because Reb Saunders wants to teach Danny “What it is to have a soul” (Potok, 265).…

    • 456 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Ethnic Cleansings

    • 1189 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The farmers are under a nonstop risk of being beaten, shot at, having their water contaminated, their land torched and their trees uprooted (Karkar, 2007). Israel is responsible for the eradication, torture and ethnic cleansing of Palestinian people, along with an uncountable amount of war crimes (Said, 1979). Israel controls Palestine’s drinking water, education, access to the sea (Al Mezan, 2013), has taken thousands of political prisoners (Adameer, 2014), and is involved in systematic torture (Falk, 2013). Yet, it still manages to gather sympathy, support, financial assistance and political partnership with the wealthiest western countries in the world. America is giving Israel three billion dollars a year until 2018 (Obama, 2014).…

    • 1189 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays