Hamilton Vs Thomas Jefferson Essay

Superior Essays
During the early, immature years of our nation’s history, the interests of north and south, rich and poor, and industry and agriculture were dealt with as compromises, upsetting both sides until two deeply different visions for the country arose. Treasury Secretary Alexander Hamilton believed that our new country’s federal government should be more powerful. However, Hamilton 's views faced strong opposition by many, such as Secretary of State Thomas Jefferson and House Representative James Madison. He believed it more wise to provide more power to individual states. The two emerging parties deemed themselves with names that reflected their most treasured values. The Federalists attached themselves to the flourishing campaign in favor …show more content…
Alexander Hamilton, a Federalist, thinks James Madison and Thomas Jefferson, Democratic-Republicans, are dangerous to our new nation. Hamilton states in Document 2, “In respect to our foreign politics, the views of these gentlemen are … unsound, and dangerous. They have a womanish attachment to France, and a womanish resentment against Great Britain”. Hamilton thinks Democratic-Republicans are too attached and “in love” with France and they are too bitter and spiteful to Great Britain to actually get anything done. Jefferson thinks differently, he thinks Federalists (Hamilton) are only about themselves and other wealthy people. Jefferson said in Document 1 that “Hamilton was not only a monarchist, but [in support] of a monarchy [based upon] corruption”. Federalists favor strong central government, which Democratic-Republicans often viewed as something that would turn into monarchy and we 'd have another King George all over again. Jefferson also stated in Document 5 that he thinks the Federalists are Aristocrats and monocrats. He thinks the Federalists are stuck up, and only in favor of themselves and other wealthy people. That they do not care about the poorer people in this country. Because of the differing views, it lead to a split in political …show more content…
The Federalists and the Democratic-Republicans both spoke badly of one another. The Sedition Act was passed partially because of this. If something was published in the newspapers that was negative in any way directed towards the government, those people were prosecuted. Congressman John Allen, of Connecticut, was tired of the all the slander and hatred in the papers, so he agreed with this law. Stating in Document 6, “If ever there was a nation which required a law of this kind, it is this”. Congressman Allen agrees with the Sedition Act because he 's tired of all the lies and mean things being said about the government. He sides with the Federalists, that could be due to the fact that he is wealthy and higher up in the government. Democratic-Republicans were at the brunt of this act. They were the ones who were being prosecuted for publishing newspapers with the slander. George Hay, a member of Virginia State Legislature, points out in Document 7 that the Sedition Act was actually a violation of the Constitution. He states, “The freedom of the press … means the total exemption of the press from any kind of legislative control, and consequently the Sedition Bill … is an

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Salutations, old cheerio friend. I like your entrepreneur. Now, you need to go achieve and accomplish your fine and extravagant sly endeavors. Salutations, old cheerio…

    • 1672 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The American Revolution was fought to escape the hand of an overpowering monarch. Many Democratic - Republicans were afraid of a powerful federal government because they did not want to be at the mercy of a monarchy again. Jefferson deemed the country too large for a single government, and also believed that a single government would lead to corruption. In general, the federal government was oppressive in his opinion, and it gained power at the expense of the people. Jefferson wanted states to be independent within themselves, but united when dealing with foreign affairs.…

    • 1205 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Fdr New Deal Essay

    • 1139 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Republicans claim “that Roosevelt was behaving like a dictator” and they thought he “was making the government too powerful”. They also believed “FDR was destroying the American way of life”, claiming his Social Security Act “would make Americans lazy and dependent on government help”. The New Deal was “taking high taxes from the wealthy Americans” and this angered the Republicans because they believe that they “were wealthy because they had worked hard” for their money. The businessmen were “angry at trade unions, at the idea of minimum wages, and a group of wealthy businessmen formed the Liberty League to oppose the New Deal”. The Liberty League was “founded to defend the Constitution and defend the rights and liberties guaranteed by that Constitution” (Who attacked the New Deal).…

    • 1139 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This political party held views that power of the Federal government should be limited. Although they did not necessarily condone the violent methods that the rioters used, they believed that the government’s actions were a clear overstep of power. Additionally, the Republicans believed that the Rebellion was a sign that Americans were becoming more aware of the government’s misdeeds, calling most people of the time period “lethargic” to what was happening around them (Hewitt and Lawson). The party also worried about the government’s use of militias and that if the Rebellion had continued the president would have deemed a “standing army necessary for enforcing the laws” (Hewitt and Lawson). (The Pittsburg Resolution, 1794)This was problematic to the Republicans since they had opposed British policies of taxation and quartering and now their new government was behaving similarly.…

    • 1278 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Jeffersonians were very pro French while the Federalist had been very pro British. The Federalist hated when the embargo of 1807 was passed because it greatly hurt relations with Britain and also the economy and the trade with them. The Federalist had like England because trade h to pay off the war debts and without it this plan could not be continued. The embargo was one of the largest uses of presidential authority. Even though Jefferson had claimed to be for small government he was willing to go above this if it meant protecting the country.…

    • 1006 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    When George Washington selected these two gentlemen as cabinet members, he saw the diverse beliefs among the two officers and thought that by electing them, there would be a more diverse opinion for decisions he had to make. His selections ended up causing a breakdown in the Constitution because of how each viewed it. Hamilton, who was a business man and believed that the future of America lay in the hands of the wealthy, interpreted the Constitution loosely, trying to expand the power of his wealthy supporters and businesses. Jefferson, who saw future America as middle class workers and farmers, looked at the Constitution strictly because he saw the power balance hidden among the words of the Constitution. These ideas which are part of the revolution, obviously did not line up well with the Constitution because it couldn’t meet the ideals of both people and the creator of the document didn’t expect a two party system to happen.…

    • 1105 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    These ideas formed the Federalist Party, originating in the early 1790s. Hamilton 's views for America were ambitious and power-hungry, and from his fears and hopes, for his country, the Federalist Party was born. One fear of Hamilton 's was the people. He believed that the masses were “turbulent and changing.” (MP 163) In saying this, he is implying that he doesn’t trust the people and instead power should be entrusted to the wealthy elite, not only because they were more educated but above all because they were the ones most able to handle national debt. To explain, America had foreign debt as well as national debt to pay off.…

    • 890 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As leaders in their parties, Hamilton and Jefferson only served to encourage the partisan divisions. The two members of Washington’s cabinet had different views on government. From as early as the Constitutional Convention, Hamilton was clearly a Federalist and Jefferson was clearly an Anti-Federalist. These philosophical differences between the two only served as a catalyst for their disputes during Washington’s presidency. Fearing that Hamilton’s economic plans would cause tyranny similar to the British rule, Jefferson created the Democratic-Republican Party to oppose Hamilton’s Federalist Party.…

    • 520 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The largest issue Americans had with British rule was the creation of unfair taxation, without political representation. Americans felt like they were being looted for their money and King George was a tyrant monarch. To change their poitical discourse Americans rebelled and revolted in the name of gainng their own freedom. This clearly shows that Americans have a tradition and inherent…

    • 1431 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Jefferson’s revolutionary viewpoints soon shaped the beginnings of a profound split in American politics. On one side… Alexander Hamilton… On the other side, centered on Thomas Jefferson…” (The First American Party System: Events, Issues, and Positions). Eventually, Jefferson and Hamilton argued over Hamilton’s financial plans, creating conflicts between Jeffersonians and Hamiltonians. The Jeffersonians were the ones who supported Jefferson and favored a powerful, yet not too powerful central government and a limit on presidency. The Hamiltonians were the people who agreed with Hamilton’s ideas and favored a powerful central government and a strong president.…

    • 870 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays