Agamemnon Vs Achilles

Improved Essays
Achilles is wrong to reject the embassy because what he wants in return is unreasonable, he lets his injured pride cloud his judgment, and he disregards and endangers the lives of others around him.
By rejecting the embassy, Achilles wants infeasible things in compensation: a complete humbling of Agamemnon and sense of superiority over him. Both Achilles and Agamemnon can be seen as superior in their own rights: Achilles with his physical prowess in battle and Agamemnon with his political authority. Thus, Achilles’ demand to somehow strip away Agamemnon’s authority is illogical. He cannot simply dethrone Agamemnon and remove him as a leader of troops as it would totally disrupt the existing order. Achilles’ own sense of superiority clashes
…show more content…
When Agamemnon claims Briseis for himself, Achilles is rightfully upset, but he takes this offense to unreasonable proportions. Achilles fails to see that Agamemnon had done this as an act of retaliation. In publicly exposing Agamemnon in front of the troops, Achilles wronged him. Thus, in an attempt to regain some semblance of authority, Agamemnon chooses to take Achilles’ war bride in return (83). After this, Achilles feels shamed and decides to withdraw from the fight completely, denouncing his loyalty to Agamemnon (87). In doing so, Achilles wants to escape the perpetrator of his humiliation. However, he fails to realize that his reasoning his hypocritical. Achilles seems to think of himself as the sole victim of humiliation, when in reality, he had done the same to Agamemnon. When Agamemnon attempts to reconcile with Achilles, even offering to return Briseis, Achilles still remains angry. He still refuses to associate with Agamemnon and refuses to accept any sort of material compensation. When rebuffing Agamemnon’s act of charity, hedecides to sail home, effectively turning his back on the war …show more content…
He is their greatest warrior, and was undefeated in his battles throughout the nine years they were at war (cite?). With Achilles, the Trojans did not dare to cross the Greeks’ walls, but in his absence, they have started to overtake them (cite). To have him withdraw is a crushing blow for them, and the Trojans take full advantage of this, turning the tides of the war to their favor (cite). Achilles had willingly participated in the war, so suddenly dropping out lets those past nine years of bloodshed be for naught. In his anger, he even wishes for the very comrades he fought alongside with to die. Achilles’ inaction even causes his dear friend Patroclus to beg him to lend his armor. Patroclus knows Achilles will not fight and is driven to do anything to improve the dire situation (cite). As a result, he is killed and Achilles must live with the guilt of letting his beloved friend die whilst he had done

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Hubris In Greek Mythology

    • 788 Words
    • 4 Pages

    seen in the examples of Odysseus vs. Prometheus, Achilles vs. Hector, and Arachne vs. Athena. The first myth to be examined that prominently displays hubris is that of Odysseus. On his way back from the Trojan War, he and his men end up on an island inhabited by cyclopes. He enters the cave of Prometheus, a cyclops…

    • 788 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    the author is Homer. Theme: The central idea of the epic is Rage. In the beginning of the work the character, Achilles, is said to be the reason why many Greeks died during war. In the epic poem, it says that Achilles allowed his rage to control his thinking, which resulted in him removing himself from the war between the Greeks and the Trojans. Continuing throughout the work Achilles continued to allow his anger to control his actions and emotions, which in turn, effected many of his soldiers…

    • 1143 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    of men and leaves even more in grief. Another theme remains apparent halfway through the tale: friendships become deeply rooted ties between warriors. The Iliad reads “Achilles plunges into violent grief; the messenger who brings him the news even fears the hero will kill himself”. At the news of his best friend’s death, Achilles threatens to kill himself for their bond had become so incredibly deep. A third theme uncovered in The Iliad has endured for centuries; war brings glory and honor, but to…

    • 1064 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays