Shelby Steel On Affirmative Action Analysis

Superior Essays
Shelby steels view’s on affirmative action aligns with the neo-conservative view. He recaps on the theory explaining that affirmative action and other entitlement programs stem from the presence of white liberal guilt. He recognizes this as the guilt which roots from the ill- intentions and actions of their ancestors which motivates them to sponsor and advocate for these government assistance programs. White liberals believe that by installing a program, which is intended to elevate the black community in an already developed society, they have indirectly cleared their guilty consciences. Steels states, “In a very real sense, entitlement programs for blacks serve the personal interests of whites as well.” (Steels. 151) He further analysis …show more content…
Instead solely basing the accomplishments off of their merit, they believe that their position is attainment through public policy. In Steels opinion, liberal victimization and preferential treatment is a detrimental aspect of the black society. Though he feels this way, he is not against all liberal government assistance programs. He advocates for policies which aid the inner-city residents in bettering their own lives and promotes programs that eliminate the horrific conservative view of bootstrapping. He acknowledges and attempts to disintegrate the barriers within the black community. Steels’ ideological view on affirmative action correlates to theories of other neo-conservatives, specifically, Cornel West.

Cornell West addresses the notion of affirmative action through the study of both the Liberal and conservative ideologies. He begins by stating his individual view of both approaches alluding to the idea that both parties failed to realized and understand the true meaning of these programs. He states that, “The liberal notion that more governmental programs can solve racial problems and political problems.”(West. 2) He argues this to be extremely
…show more content…
West focuses on the reasons for creating governmental programs through the eyes of the black community while Steele’s chooses to explain the reasons of creating these programs through the white liberal perspective. Steel’s ideological theories as to why these entitlement programs were initially created, only includes the presence of white guilt, failing to include the elevation rooting from the Civil Rights movements and the Black power ideology. Although they have separate approaches, they both come to a meeting point within their theories on affirmative action. Both philosophers attain the idea that affirmative action is simply a program which takes away from black success corrupting their psychological mindset, and hindering the black community from reaching their full potential by them heavily depending on

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Dubois. Dubois advocated separation of blacks from whites would lead to African American economic cooperation among themselves, pride and self-confidence, and a self-defense mechanism to challenge whites, self-segregate. Dubois’ challenge was to create black autonomy over conquering the whites ruling. (Rucker, pg.38) Dubois strengths lied in his challenging the authority to change legislation. He constantly challenged the legality of the laws and wanted blacks to work together to fight the laws.…

    • 1026 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    “the black man in American has to lift up his own sense of values, (X, 301).” In the early period, he thought the black people were oppressed by white people and society should help African American to achieve their equal position. However, he lately thought the right of the black people should depend on themselves without other’s help. They could develop their own industries and company in order to promote their social position. At the same time, he also reconsidered the problem of all white people are evils. “the white man is not inherently evil, but America’s racist influence him to act evilly, (X, 406),” he said.…

    • 2074 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Washington advocated for equality for African Americans by being more conservative, as opposed to aggressive during protests. He believed that violence would be ineffective for African Americans; it would only make matters worse for them. He expressed his thoughts on the issue during his 1895 speech called the “Atlanta Compromise.” In this speech, Washington stated that African Americans should accept social segregation and as long as whites allow them economic progress, educational opportunity and justice in the courts (Coffman, Anita and Rose, Vanessa). In response to Washington’s famous speech, author W.E.B Du Bois challenged Washington’s ideas in his book The Souls of Black Folk, saying “Mr. Washington’s programme practically accepts the alleged inferiority of the Negro races.” He believed that protests were necessary for a change in equality, instead of “blending in” with white people.…

    • 798 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Affirmative Action Debate

    • 1724 Words
    • 7 Pages

    In the debate over Affirmative Action, Liberals take their stand as an advocate for affirmative action. They believe that America needs to atone for the history of racism, cruelties and social discrimination towards African-Americans and other minorities. This is achieved through the preferential, or favoring, treatment of minorities. Conservatives do not believe in affirmative action. They believe that people should receive benefits based on ability rather than race.…

    • 1724 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    While some may claim that it was a defense of states’ rights, it was a hypocritical defense of states’ rights to crush a group’s individual rights, some of which, like the Second Amendment, had existed long before the Civil War. The code relied on deceptive language to disguise this violation of rights. Apprenticeship, for instance, painted white persons as saviors, helping needy African American children, while in reality it reasserted white supremacy. The code, because it was written by white Democrats with political power, fails to account for the opinions of African Americans, and of the Southern whites who supported emancipation. It ignores the struggles of African Americans to overcome socio-political hurdles by obtaining an education in schools and colleges run by African Americans, by establishing communities and community leaders in churches, and even by aligning with Populists and other Democrats to influence politics, even if these parties didn’t always align with black interests.…

    • 968 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    White Guilt J.C. Watts, a former U.S. Representative, states “I 'm not one that believes that affirmative action should be based on one 's skin color or one 's gender, I think it should be done based on one 's need…” This idea that affirmative action, a societal way of helping those in need, should not be based on ethnicity is supported by esteemed author Shelby Steele. Shelby Steele, the author of “The Age of White Guilt and the Disappearance of the Black Individual”, claims that Blacks have self-victimized their own group and that Whites are plagued with “White Guilt” –the idea that someone has to prove that they are not a racist. The discussion of racial disparity in American society is a hot topic, but Steele is able to quench the flames…

    • 1359 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Affirmative Action: The Price of Preference In “The Price of Preference”, Shelby Steele takes a stance opposing affirmative action and focuses his discussion primarily on the effects that it has on African-Americans. Steele reasons that while affirmative action was created with good intentions, he argues that black people have more to lose from it than they gain. Steele believes that affirmative action strayed from its initial goal of anti-discrimination enforcement and instead escalated into a form of social engineering through preferential treatment. Essentially, the main issue presented by affirmative action is the manner in which it attempts to bypass the development of formerly oppressed groups to the stage where they are fully able to…

    • 984 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Racial Inequality is Everyone’s Problem “Only by being conscious of race can you be truly conscious of yourself and your world, and only by working to overcome racial injustice can you ensure that you are not complicit in it” (3). Jack Turner, a professor of political science at the University of Washington, makes a convincing point about the importance of understanding the way that race inevitably determines people’s social and economic standing in society and how it then benefits or disadvantages those people (2). He argues for a form of democratic individualism that acknowledges the way race molds and restricts individual opportunity in the United States and urges the American people to act against racial injustice (2). For Turner, white…

    • 1421 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    DuBois promotes assimilation and meritocracy. The African Americans should assimilate into the white majority society, and should play into their meritocracy. I understand where DuBois comes from when he speaks of how Washington only wants African Americans to survive through submission. While he says that Washington asks that black people give up political power and education, which I don’t think is right. I believe that DuBois asks the Black man to give into the White standard, which can be just as harmful to their growth as a group of people.…

    • 1616 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The book explained the effects of racism on African Americans and how they view themselves (Du Bois, Intellectual Influences & Core Ideas, 11-16-16). Du Bois wanted to show people what it was to be African American in America. Du Bois believe segration did more than deny African Americans but deny them fair access to jobs, education and…

    • 1327 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays