Advantages And Disadvantages Of Open Immigration

Improved Essays
Capitalism is a system of economics in which the country’s trades and industries are owned by privately for profit, instead of owned by the state. Milton Friedman, an American Economist is known for his support of a capitalist economy that emphasizes a Laissez-faire approach. Friedman’s Q&A video, “What is America”, discusses how less government intervention would be beneficial in our Capitalist society. Joseph Stiglitz, an American Economist, narrates the second video as he advocates for more government and shares the advantages and disadvantages of having a capitalist economy.
One of the first issues that Friedman addresses in the video is the topic of open immigration. Friedman believed that in today's society you could not have open immigration
…show more content…
welfare programs. As long as this country continues to distribute money through its welfare programs, open immigration will not be economically possible. With our national debt at its highest, the U.S. would not be able to financially support a continuous flow of new immigrants if the country decided to open its borders. Friedman’s idea to slowly eliminate welfare programs and use a negative income tax would provide a healthier solution to helping the countries low-income households. By gradually eliminating welfare, the country would be able to weed out some citizens who abuse the system and take advantage of the government. The negative tax system prevents low-income individuals from paying taxes and actually provides them with supplemental pay from the government. I am in complete agreement with Friedman’s thoughts on the welfare system and open borders; therefore I find his logic to be …show more content…
Friedman acknowledged that all American citizens, at one point, immigrated to America for a better life for themselves and for their families. By gaining citizenship, they had access to better opportunities, are paid higher wages in comparison to new immigrants, and gained more skills. Friedman states that we should not deny immigrants the opportunity to immigrate to America for a better life. By immigrating, they have access to jobs that may pay lower wages but ultimately give these people a better life then they would have had in their homeland. Friedman opposes “equal pay for equal work laws”. He believes that by denying these immigrants the choice to work for lower wages, we are denying them the only weapon they have, which is to work for a lower wage than an American.
I agree with Friedman’s statement on immigration and equal pay. I believe that immigrants come to America for more opportunities and are able to find work because they are willing to work for lower wages. Due to their inexperience and lower skills, this is their only advantage over many Americans. Logically it is a win/win for both the immigrants that are able to find jobs and for consumers who like to pay lower prices for their goods. Friedman’s logic is

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In the article, Bordering on Insanity by Michael Mandel, the author is advocating for an open borders policy that would make it less difficult for people to travel and enter into a country. The policy would also increase trade and the amount of occupational skill in the country. Some objections made against this policy stated in the article, is that a higher number of immigrants coming into the country would decrease our wages. One serious point made in this article is that the issue with this policy is cultural and not economic because the influx of culture on one region can become overwhelming. Some of the arguments the author presented were based on LOGOS, arguments that are based off of logical reasoning.…

    • 451 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    S. 744 Case Study

    • 1282 Words
    • 6 Pages

    This would address the aforementioned strict boundary between H-1B visas and citizenship by giving them an opportunity to use the skills and experience that they gained while on the visa program to apply for citizenship, and given the Merit Based immigration reform’s emphasis on U.S. experience H-1B visa holders would stand a good chance of successfully apply for permanent residency. The rigidity of the H-1B visa allocation system would be addressed by increasing the number of visas allocated as well as tying that number to economic data, allowing it to fluctuate with the market’s current demand. Therefore, through a combination of H-1B visa reform and Merit Based immigration, the U.S. would be able to better retain the valuable skills and experience of H-1B workers while simultaneously taking advantage of the unique cultural knowledge and skills of economic immigrants…

    • 1282 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article “The National Death Wish” stated,“An exhaustive U.S. study by National Academy of Sciences found that immigration didn’t drive down most wages, but it had ‘very small’ and temporary effect on native-born workers without high school diploma”; however, in an article, “Yes, Immigration Hurts American Workers”, implies, “Typical high school dropout earns about $25,000 annually... immigrants admitted in the past two decades lacking a high school diploma have increased the size of the low-skilled workforce by roughly 25 percent. As a result, the earnings of this particularly vulnerable group dropped by between $800 and $1,500 each year”. Immigrants may have created more jobs for the lower class, but initially immigrants are the only one’s willing to take those jobs, but it leaves uneducated Americans income to decrease. As it connects back to low income housing, they can not keep up or afford the payments In the same article, “Yes, Immigration Hurts American Workers”, “Immigrants receive government assistance at higher rates than natives.…

    • 1109 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Conservatism Dbq Analysis

    • 1410 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In a book by economist Milton Friedman titled Capitalism and Freedom he expresses how ineffective the “great ‘reforms’” had been in achieving their objectives, “A housing program intended to improve the housing conditions of the poor, to reduce juvenile delinquency, and to contribute to the removal of urban slums, has worsened the housing conditions of the poor, contributed to juvenile delinquency, and spread urban blight”(Document 2). Friedman is essentially saying that the liberal reforms made by the government were ineffective and did not work, but does later on express a solution that did work: “The United States has continued to progress; its citizens have become better fed, better clothed, better housed, and better transported; class and social distinctions have narrowed; minority groups have become less disadvantaged. . . . All this has been the product of the initiative and drive of individuals co-operating through the free market” (Document 2). Friedman feels that what actually improved society was the free-market, not government reforms, and this belief that the government cannot enact social reform and change and only the free-market and private sector can is a major tenet of the new conservative viewpoint. Friedman shared his belief of government ineffectiveness, especially in social reform, with many people and that made them…

    • 1410 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Conservatism Dbq

    • 900 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Friedman states that government intervention has made social and economic situations worse for Americans. But, all the recent successes of America are claimed to be attributed to the individualistic nature of the free-market economy. For this reason, Friedman proposes an already successful solution to the disappointing liberal actions of the American government to be more conservative. From a different end of the social hierarchy, a letter written to Nelson Rockefeller (Republican governor of New York) on February 6, 1971 (Doc 3) describes the negative effects of the government’s implications of “welfare cheats” and taxes. This “law-abiding citizen” uses her letter to request a necessary use of government intervention in fixing the damage in the poorer parts of New York.…

    • 900 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Immigrant Entrepreneurs

    • 1009 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Throughout the world, there are vast amounts of skilled workers who desire to pursue their ultimate dreams. In order to earn the job they have wanted all their life, many try to come to America. This is problematic due to the fact that Americans believe that immigrants will steal the jobs from the nation’s people. Shayan Zadeh fights this opinion as he explains a personal story of how he accomplished his dream. In his opinion piece, “Bring on More Immigrant Entrepreneurs”, he responds to the claim anout immigrants draining the economy.…

    • 1009 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In regards to wage and employment effects caused by immigration, four readings immediately come to mind: Immigration Equation by Roger Lowenstein; The Impact of the Mariel Boatlift on the Miami Labor Market by David Card; Dual Labor Markets: A Theory of Labor Market Segmentation by Michael Reich, David Gordon, and Richard Edwards; and Immigration, Inequality, and Policy Alternatives by Gregory DeFreitas On the one hand, The Immigration Equation is a summation of “Heaven’s Door: Immigration Policy and the American Economy” by George Borjas. It explained the purpose of Borjas’ work; he wanted not to make policy, but to derive the truth. In other words, George Borjas did not want to conjure up immigration policies but desired to study the implications and socioeconomic effects that immigrants have on the economy. For example, Lowenstein examines the affects of two Senate bills geared towards deporting illegal immigrants.…

    • 522 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Zadeh On Immigration

    • 202 Words
    • 1 Pages

    Personally, I can’t help but agree with Zadeh’s liberal views on immigration. His research and astounding data instantly softened my heart to the reality that the United States of America, could in fact be a much better place if only more immigrants were able to obtain their Visas. Zadeh quickly diminishes my fear and the fear that most Americans tend to have rooted in the back of their minds. The overwhelming fear that immigrants would take jobs from Americans and split the economy in half. When really, Zadeh illustrates that granting legal status to illegal immigrants would create over 121,000 jobs per year.…

    • 202 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the Immigration Debate Readings the first four sets reflect on the immigration restriction and anti-immigrant views. While the last four sets reflect on the pro-immigrant and anti-restriction views. Looking closely to the sixth set, Making a New Prosperous America, the readings show a strong pro-immigrant views, in which foreign immigrant has helped the American industry and strengthen the economy. In the first reading titled “Chinese Immigration in its Social and Economical Aspect” the author, George F. Seward, openly questions the public views against Chinese immigrants in the U.S. and specifically the Chinese immigrants in California.…

    • 495 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Carens and Beltran cover many strong points as to why working towards open borders is the best course of action for the United States. Through supporting evidence and dismantling of opposing arguments, these authors justify my argument for increased immigration. However, Carens covers more information that proves his claim to be stronger than Beltran. Currently in the United States our immigration policies make it difficult to move from foreign countries.…

    • 831 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Pro Immigration Speech

    • 459 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Speech Good afternoon Mr/Madam chairman, ladies and gentlemen, the topic of our debate is how Us immigration should be altered to benefit immigrants. We the affirmative team believe this statement is correct. Today as the first affirmative speaker i will be speaking to you about how immigration to the Us increases diversity and expands the culture of the country, how immigration helps fill low paying jobs, and how some of the most intelligent and ambitious individuals who are unsatisfied with their own countries come to America, and how immigration improves the overall image of America, and how the Government can use the situation to promote peace and acceptance. My first point is how immigration to the Us increases diversity and expands the culture of the country.…

    • 459 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    With the exception of Medicaid, the welfare programs examined in this report are paid for almost entirely by the federal government. Even in the case of Medicaid, 58% of its costs were born by Washington D.C. About 88% of tax revenue paid to the federal government comes from income taxes and payroll taxes. Social Security is a positive idea in theory; however, it was not created to aid poor people who are citizens of other countries. If this plan to allow illegal immigrants have access to Social Security is successful, it is estimated to cost $345 billion to the American taxpayer over the next two decades.…

    • 1755 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One of the most controversial topics in the United States, among government parties and citizens alike, is the issue of immigration. In a country composed of 316,128,839 citizens, 41,348,066 of those citizens are foreign-born (FAIR). While this number is less than ten percent of the entire population, it is believed that there are around 12 million more people living in the U.S undocumented. In other words, they are illegal aliens. The people who come to America, whether legally or illegally, come seeking job opportunities and the ability to support their family.…

    • 1022 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Immigration In Texas

    • 1735 Words
    • 7 Pages

    As of 2012, the children of illegal immigrants account for 13.1% of all high school students in the state of Texas (Strauss, 2014). This number may not seem very big, but when you look at the funding coming from the state; there is an issue that arises. The education that these children are receiving is costing United States taxpayers $51.3 billion a year (Ruark, 2015). Projections that have been made for the next 15 years have shown that the increase in the number of students in all high schools will be due to the children of immigrants. If the parents were legal citizens, the states and government would not be having to pay for their child’s education.…

    • 1735 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Immigration has always been a huge debate in every country. Especially in America, where we have been sending immigrants through a rigorous test in order to enter. The real question is if this creates the best outcome for all. This plan will in fact create the best situation for all, by creating self-sufficient towns that will require jobs and residents. It will create jobs, abolish poverty and welfare, and create economic competition.…

    • 864 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays