Advantages And Disadvantages Of Child Soldiers

Superior Essays
Routines are a part of the human nature. We wake up, get dressed, and carry on our day with whatever we have planned. What if your routine consisted of grabbing a glock or an Arquebus and aiming at another human being and pulling the trigger? Wake up, fight, kill, survive, sleep. That routine is something child soldiers undergo every day of their lives. Kill or be killed, they say. The disputation of child soldiers has been going on for years and years. On one side of the debate, people insist the children were under drugs and alcohol persuasion and at that age they are vulnerable and livid with fear. The opposite side alleges with the idea that yes, they are children, but what about when they grow up? Others can use their background as advantages …show more content…
¨Many children volunteer to become soldiers in wartime out of patriotism or a desire to avenge the death of their families…. Many children occupy command positions in their armed group/military and are responsible for planning or ordering the commission of war crimes and human rights abuse.” The other side defends the family suggestion but they use it in a different standpoint. You have no control where you grow up, who is your family, so why should you be punished for doing what you think is right? Going back to Khadr's case, the article The Child Soldier on Trial in Guantanamo informs, “The No. 1 reason that khadr was dangerous; his father[a senior ranking al Qaeda leader] ….Khadr’s father took him to visit al Qaeda leaders when he was 10 and to a military training camp when he was 15.” (pg. 3 para. 4) Being raised in that environment played an important role in the way he acts now. That point although twists its way back to highlight my earlier topic; growing up in this world after living there at that age. “International Criminal Court (ICC) Article 26 prevents the court from prosecuting anyone under the age of 18, but not because it believes children should be exempt from prosecution for international crimes, ‘but rather that the decision on whether to prosecute should be left to States[countries]…. [The] exclusion of children from the ICC jurisdiction avoided the argument between States[countries] on the minimum age for international crimes.” (Should Child Soldiers be Prosecuted for their Crimes? Pg. 1, para. 4) Under the age of 18, the kids can not be prosecuted because the States are in charge. USing that example, people who want to save these children say that we could make the punishment more severe than anywhere else because we are taking them from their own place and bringing them

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    They are blamed for the crimes they committed to others, but it should be taken into account how they were also the victims of these shameful events. They were succumbed to do these things with the thought that they were doing the right thing. The article states, ““Child soldiers should not be prosecuted on account of what they have done but should rather be rehabilitated and given a second chance to re enter society as a human beings”(IRIN). This is significant because it shows tells the idea of how child soldiers were not treated as human beings but rather as objects that the army uses at their own expense without a care in the world. Perhaps if we were to take a look into their world we would understand the frustrations of being a child soldier and not being able to help yourself or others. Not to mention the extreme emphasis on the expanded usage of child soldiers around the world has given people much to think about. This is because many realize that they are mostly victims and that they should be pardoned rather than scrutinized for things that they were victims. A first hand source of these child soldiers tragedies states, ““At the end of the day, these children are victims of older soldiers, forced into war out of personal circumstances or peer pressure. Some are seeking revenge after seeing their families slaughtered. Once they're given an AK-47 and drugs, their innocence is lost, replaced by a killer instinct”(Koinange). This explains how children were put to the test to become the people they are today. Only because they were victims of much older child soldiers who had been through the same things. Child soldiers were the victims of these horrific events and were also victims of their own homes who were not able to protect them from the armies that had taken these children from their…

    • 1735 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Alert Child Soldiers

    • 1127 Words
    • 5 Pages

    These children did not have a choice if they wanted to stop killing they were abducted and forced. “Rebel group who had abducted her at the age of nine” (Okiror). This shows that children did not deserve to be abducted, and we as people should help them by not locking them up.These kids were taking and abducted, and their whole identity was changed. “Taking children away, abducting them, stripping them of their childhood to put them in the line of fire where they could die” (Hadid). This shows that these kids were changed into people they were not and they deserve a better life, and their past violence be forgiven. To conclude child soldiers were abducted and deserve…

    • 1127 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Can anyone possibly imagine a child in war causing havoc while carrying loaded weapons? Many child soldiers are being stolen from their families and being forced to fight and then being punished for their crimes committed in the wars. Unfortunately, there are tons of children forced to fight in the wars today. The topic child soldiers has become a huge controversy across the world today because of whether or not child soldiers deserve amnesty. The reason why it has become so controversial is because many people question if it is truly the child's fault that he or she committed the war crimes. Some people think that the child is not responsible for their crimes because they are being forced to commit them and they believe that child soldiers…

    • 1523 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I have developed this opinion after conducting research on this topic. I have discovered that child soldiers are often forced into fighting through false promises. They are also forced into fighting through drugs and alcohol. The drugs, often cocaine mixed with gun powder, brainwash the children to the point where they would rather not escape from the horror unravelling around them. I personally believe anyone who has to submit to such horrors and atrocities should not be prosecuted for the crimes they committed. Furthermore, I consider child soldiers different from ordinary child criminals. Child soldiers, as I have mentioned earlier, are abducted and then forced into murdering innocent human beings. They have no choice if they don’t fight they're killed if they fight they kill. Child criminals, on the other hand, are not forced into killing innocent civilians; they do it through a motive, often weak ones, such as killing someone for their money. In 1998, Lionel Tate, a 12-year-old boy, was convicted of murdering a 6-year-old girl he was babysitting. Unlike child soldiers, Lionel Tate was not forced into murdering. I do think children such as Lionel should be prosecuted, whereas child soldiers who are forcibly recruited shouldn’t be. I believe they should be taken to rehabilitation centres in order for them to be reintegrated into…

    • 822 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Children are a cheap and plentiful resource for military commanders in need of a steady troop supply to war zones. Their underdeveloped ability to assess danger means they are often willing to take risks and difficult assignments that adults or older teenagers will refuse. Children are more impressionable than adults, and depending on their age and background, their value systems and consciences are not yet fully developed.(steel) So, since they are so little they will be easy to manipulate their minds so they will kill anybody they tell them to. They are also torn from their families and they get broken down from war, “It’s much more than that. It is also a geostrategic and development issue. Child soldiers are usually depicted as victims. That’s accurate: Exploited, torn from their families, deprived of their education, and forced into battle, child soldiers are truly casualties of war.” (gates)They are then taken as a broken down child and ordered to do kill and them not knowing what they are doing, they…

    • 871 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    If you were a kid that was taken away from your family, brutally forced to join an army, finally made it out alive, and then you were prosecuted for all of the crimes you committed. That would be very harsh and unfair. Children that suffer through pain, lack of food and water, and see terrible things while they are in the midst of war. It would almost be cruel if kids make it out alive and make it back to somewhere safe, but then are hit with the devastation that they are going to be prosecuted for committing crimes that they were forced to commit. Take a minute or two to put yourself in a child soldier’s shoes and imagine what it would be like, and that might make you think twice before you say that they should be…

    • 863 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Now there are wars all over the middle east and in the wars there have been an increase in child soldiers. Many people believe that these children are unchangeable do too the conditions they were raised in. While they want somebody to take the blame they forget these children have had less time to…

    • 718 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Child Soldiers Is Wrong

    • 842 Words
    • 4 Pages

    To illustrate this point, take Beah, a child recently put into the media for explaining his life as a child soldier. Beah explained he was captured from his home and put into a squad along with boys 7-11 years old. He was told to kill or be killed. He said he couldn’t shoot at first, but as he watched his friends get murdered, he began. Beah said to the Senate "all I did was take drugs, fight and kill or be killed." as a child, his life consisted of murder and drugs, yet we still prosecute him for fighting for his life. The story of Dominic Ongwen also shows this point, a man prosecuted for actions he committed as a child while being forced to serve in a child soldier army. He is currently being prosecuted by the I.C.C. as an adult for actions that occured when he was a child. His story is one of many prosecuted for crimes they committed as children, a reason why many believe child soldiers should be granted amnesty.…

    • 842 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Child Soldiers Wrong

    • 537 Words
    • 3 Pages

    They can also come into to the country under certain circumstances. The children are given drugs and sent into battles. Their commanders tell them to go into to battle and kill everyone ( O’Neill 1). In some cases children are kidnapped out of their beds and they are taken from schools. Then they are brainwashed ( O’Neill 1). Another example is a 12 year old girl, Awil, has an fully automatic loaded rifle (Gettleman 1). Did you know that the guns could be bigger than the children ( O’Neill 1). The commanders say the children are “easy to deceive” and they listen to orders ( O'Neill 1). According to O’Neill, Angela (12yrs.) had to shoot one of her best friends ( O’Neill 1). She had no choice because she “had no choice” (O’Neill 1). These adults are teaching these innocent children horrible ways of life. It is possible that these children could have weapons and they could hurt fellow citizens. As Americans we should be willing to take chances and be the better people. To ensure safety these children will be monitored, go to rehab and before all of this they have to take a test to see if they can enter the country. These former soldiers should have to do community service as there punishment. They need to learn be an active and supporting member in the community. If they don't pass the test then they can apply at a later…

    • 537 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There are a lot of children that have been taken away from their families and were put to commit crimes that are very dangerous children. In the article of child soldiers prosecution it states, “ children are often forced into fighting and having little choice over whether they enlist.” This means that children have no choice about being in the military. In the article it states, “ The recruiters of child soldiers also use drugs and alcohol to make children more compliant and enable them to commit crimes they wouldn’t not ordinarily commit.” This means that I guess children take drugs and alcohol to commit crimes that you probably wouldn’t expect them…

    • 518 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Not everyone is familiar with the issue of child soldiers. This is a problem that the U.S. and other countries want to put under control. Many kids after war are physically and very emotionally scarred. Children are being abducted by Joseph Kony and forces them to fight. There has been lots of controversy on if children that have been in war, should be punished or if they should be given amnesty.…

    • 650 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Child soldiers a children who go into war with their country and many are in Africa's most dangerous places. Most child soldiers don't know what to do because they're either too young or don’t know anything about war or guns. Here we will see where most child soldiers are at and were in the world they are or what is happening now or before they joined. I support That they should not go on trial because its not really their fault, because they might of being forced or did not have someone to live with and was brought into the child soldiers army. And Most of the Children were forced to join or they would get killed, also they might of grown up with someone who was in the army of child soldiers and wanted to keep going with child soldiers.…

    • 570 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Child Soldiers War

    • 276 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Child soldiers are a extremely common things for many countries in civil wars such as Iraq, Afghanistan Central African Republic, Democratic Republic of Congo, Iraq, Mali, Myanmar, Somalia, South Sudan, Sudan, Syria, Yemen, Colombia, Nigeria and Philippines( Yates,Child soldiers). Child soldiers are mainly in lower Asia and northern Africa. The child soldiers would not only be forced to kill for the army group they were also forced to take drugs that would make them easier to control and make them better soldiers. This puts the children in these countries in extreme danger of being forced into the army group and if they refused they would be killed but if they accept they may be forced to kill their families and then forced to take drugs so they are not in their right mind.…

    • 276 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Countries around the World are using kids as soldiers to do the dirty work. They use children because children can’t be put in many of the jails after being caught with drugs or weapons. Some child soldiers enjoy the feeling of killing people for their country. More than half of the child soldiers are forced into war but some are also volunteering. Anyway, they are still killing and doing adult things. No matter the situation child soldiers need to pay for their actions.…

    • 564 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As a child did you ever take the luxuries in your life for granted? The ability to feel safe, with a family that supports you. Well, many kids in other countries don’t have that feeling. They have been recruited into war, and trained to kill. But, many of the kids didn’t have a choice to join or not. These child soldiers do have the ability to change when they get out of the war. Now some may argue that they’re criminals, and should be treated the same as any other adult soldier. But, they should be allowed to go through rehabilitation, and not be considered as a criminal, because they do feel remorse about killing, they’re forced to fight in the war, and they’re brainwashed into thinking killing is right.…

    • 776 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays