Philip Zimbardo Situational Theory

Great Essays
In 1971, a social psychologist by the name of Phillip Zimbardo conducted the Stanford Prison Study. Zimbardo researched the Abu Ghraib Prison problem took place in Iraq in 2003 and was made aware to the United States citizens in 2004. In fact, “the driving force behind this book was the need to better understand the how and why of the physical and psychological abuses perpetrated on the prisoners by American Military at the Abu Ghraib Prison in Iraq.” (Zimbardo 2007, p. 18) Zimbardo expressed that he believes we’re all capable of evil and uses several examples to back up his situational theory. He attempts to explain why people make the choice to partake in “evil” acts by using examples such as the rapes in Rwanda and China. The approach …show more content…
Since these students had no record of ever committing a crime, I can only assume that their action came from what they may have read or seen on TV. Also, if a person has never experience an authoritative role, they may become power hungry when they get a taste of what it’s like to be in control. The volunteers conformed to the stereotype formed from the knowledge they obtained about the prison system prior to joining this experiment. This is true for the guards as well as the prisoners alike. The prisoners entered this experiment knowing what could happen to a prison if he were to step of line. These presumptions about what prison is supposed to be had a tremendous impact on the volunteer’s actions during the experiment. The Milgram experiment conducted by Stanley Milgram comes to mind when I think about impact that a uniform and assumed position have on people. Milgram’s experiment researched “blind obedience of authority.”(Zimbardo 2007, 197) These individuals were told by a man in a “white lab coat” that they were administering painful and eventually deadly shocks to other individuals for incorrect answers. Since he seemed to have some type of authority due to his attire, participants went alone with what they believed to be real shocks. With each incorrect answer followed a shock with a voltage higher than the last. They later found that …show more content…
Upon viewing the photographic evidence, he admitted that he “was in shock but not surprised” because similar incidents had taken place in the experiment he help 3 decades prior. (Zimbardo 2007, p.19) In fact, Zimbardo stated that “the driving force behind this book was the need to better understand the how and why of the physical and psychological abuses perpetrated on prisoners by the American Military Police at the Abu Ghraib Prison in Iraq.” It was shocking for me to know that members of the military, those we hold to an extremely high regard, could partake in such acts. It is even more shocking that the government and news stations withheld some of the more explicit information and photographs because of the “greater damage it would have done to the credibility and moral image of the military and Bush administration.” (Zimbardo 2007,

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Then I would fight back and lead the prisoners to the warden’s/superintendent’s office where we would then ask for a change of how the prison was being carried out. This again is because of the balance, if one respects the guards they will respect you and leave you alone most of the time. However, if there was a sadist in the group then the balance is upset and it si time for an uprising. If the experiment was made to measure just the psychological effects of becoming a guard or a prisoner, I would say the experiment was relatively successful. However, we never really get to see for sure if things would’ve stayed this way in the long run, or if things would change throughout a guard’s or prisoner’s…

    • 479 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The book “Ordinary Men” describes the Police Batallion, a subset of the Order Police, who directly participated in the massacre of Jewish civilians in Poland of 1942. The author of “Ordinary Men”, Christopher Browning analyzes the testimonies made by the members of the Batallion in the 1960s, and tries to understand how any sane man was capable of performing the horrible deeds committed by these ordinary men. Browning takes a psychological standpoint in analyzing the motivation behind these killings, and generates multiple theories as to how a common man, previously a law-abiding citizen, can morph into a killer in such a short time. Browning assesses these theories, and tries to see if there’s any validity in them. When one is learning about the Holocaust, there is one question the general public always has: why did they do it?…

    • 1338 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Like Lord of the Flies, the experiment presented set rules and morals that stated how an individual should act towards one another, causing not only the guards, but the prisoners to fall into internal decadence. Through the sickening experience, the power the “guards” had most definitely got into their heads. “The Stanford Prison Experiment degenerated very quickly and the evil and inhuman side of human nature became apparent very quickly.” Also proven in the experiment is that the environment played a huge factor with the result of the guards beginning to harass the prisoners and play a more savage…

    • 1304 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In 1971, an experiment took place in Stanford, California. It was named the Stanford Prison Experiment, lasting what was meant to be two weeks, but due to the brutality of the trial, lasted a mere 6 days. Its purpose was to conduct a study on humanity and show just how evil a human can get when given a position of power. To summarize the experiment, a random 18 men were chosen, all innocent, good people who’d never committed a crime. They were divided into two groups erratically: 9 being “prisoners” and 9 being “guards.”…

    • 1004 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    In 1971, Philip Zimbardo made a huge impact on the field of Psychology. He changed the world of social psychology by taking it from a field focused on behavior being dispositional and transitioned it into a focus on social psychology in the terms of viewing behavior as situational. Gordon Allport, Fritz Heider, Harold Kelley and Bernard Weiner all helped set the stage for personality psychology and social psychology. Each of these individuals touched on the idea of behavior being dispositional until Solomon Asch, Stanley Milgram and Philip Zimbardo introduced the idea that situations influence our actions. Dispositional behavior means that behavior is presented by an internal factor within us (e.g. the environment or culture we grow up in).…

    • 2169 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Of the 75 people who answered the ad, 24 were selected after answering a battery of questions regarding their family, personal and mental health history. The 24 selected were judged to be the “most stable…most mature, and least involved in anti-social behaviors” (Haney et al., 1973). These subjects were informed they would be randomly selected to play the role of ‘guard’ or ‘prisoner’ and that ‘prisoners’ should expect to be under close surveillance throughout the experiment, as well as lose some of their civil rights during their ‘imprisonment’. ‘Guards’ believed the purpose of the experiment was to study the behavior of prisoners. They were given a pseudo orientation during which they were informed of their work and administrative duties as ‘guards’.…

    • 963 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    The study consisted of a group of male college students. The group was randomly divided, some men designated as guards and others as prisoners. In the experiment, real arrests and prison conditions were simulated. “Prisoners” were confined to cells. They wore degrading prison uniforms.…

    • 1635 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Dehumanization Human beings love to search for the meaning behind everything because once meaning is found, then justification and rationalization can be given. Genocide is a very complex term, but the act of genocide itself is unfathomable. People always want a reason for why presidents or dictators allow genocide to happen, and the only option that can make everything clear is that human evil must have developed. Although human evil provides an explanation, there is something true about human evil.…

    • 1068 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Prison Brutality

    • 508 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The basic purpose of this experiment was to see if the brutality reported among guards in prison was because of the situation and roles they were given or if it had to do more with their type of personality, and to see if prisoners lacked respect for law and order because of the situation they were in with the guards or if it had to do with personality as well. Mr. Zimbardo and his team chose a few men who answered to the newspaper AD and had them answer a questionnaire about their family background, physical and mental health history and all the study subjects were considered to be normal healthy men. By the toss of a coin flip they were then given roles to be prisoners and guards. If they did not act aggressive that would confirm that it…

    • 508 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    They wore a uniform that would give anyone the impression that it was not a good idea to cause trouble. Once the experiment began, they were given very little instruction as to what they should be doing, or how they should react towards the inmates. Their only rule was that there was to be no physical punishment. At first, everything was calm, almost too calm. Too calm in fact that the head of the project, Phil Zimbardo, was beginning to become frustrated with the calmed nature of the situation.…

    • 885 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mind Tyrant Analysis

    • 1333 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In the “Stanford Prison Study,” students were affected by institutional forces of the prison system. Even though all students were of healthy, normal and stable mental capacities, they took to the roles “inmate” and “guard” without prejudice. The inmates became disturbed, but more surprising is how the guards became violent and brutal, inflicting physical force and harassment. Outside the experiment, students wouldn’t have forced an individual to do something against their will.…

    • 1333 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Zimbardo’s Stanford prison experiment revealed how social roles can influence our behavior. The subjects were randomly assigned to play the role of “prisoner” or “guard.” The attitudes and morals of the prison guards changed due to their role as prison guards. They mistreated the prisoners and made them feel less than a…

    • 608 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Critical evaluation of “Rethinking the psychology of tyranny: The BBC prison study” This essay will try to illustrate what are the strengths and the weaknesses of Reicher and Haslam’s experiment and whether the strengths outweigh the weaknesses. Indeed, both researchers came together to understand how individuals can accept, in a group environment, behaviours that are tyrannical whether the individual is the one who inflicts it or undergoes it (Reicher & Haslam, 2006). This experiment, base its research on Zimbardo’s prison experiment. However, it is not a replicate of The Stanford prison experiment (SPE) for different matters. Firstly, Reicher and Haslam aim at creating an experiment that is ethical, with reliable data and that extends the…

    • 1086 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This experiment went wrong and led to mental problems. These problems became so extreme that the experiment was discontinued after 6 days instead of 2 weeks. The Stanford Prison Experiment called into question the idea of Good vs Evil. The experiment showed how situational journey can cause an individual to “compromise” their beliefs. This change in behavior lead to psychological conflict among the “guards” and “prisoners.”…

    • 869 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Stanford Prison Experiment conducted by Phillip Zimbardo (1972) gave us notable understandings into human behaviour, even though considered an unethical study. In the scandalous experiment, a group of participants completed a study in a mock prison environment. Some of the participants took on the role of prisoner, and others acted as the guards. The guards behaved in an inhumane and demeaning way towards the participants acting as prisoners. They were not given full details e.g. on what to expect and how to behave.…

    • 931 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays