Compare And Contrast A Rose For Emily By William Faulkner

Improved Essays
Written or Verbal
Written in 1930, William Faulkner’s twisted short story “A Rose for Emily” is still being discussed eighty-five years later. Having been made into a major motion picture in 1982, the cryptic story’s legend lives on into a new age of discussion. Miss Emily Grierson made a name for herself in the small southern town, and both forms of media convey the deep twists of her life in one way or another. The movie and book contain similarities like the odor problem and the townspeople’s views on Emily, as well as differences in the introductions and also the role her father plays.
Whether she knew it or not, from a young age Miss Emily was the center of the town gossip. That is the price she must pay having been born into the Grierson
…show more content…
Introductions are supposed to set the stage for what you are about to watch or read. The two different introductions to “A Rose for Emily” resulted in questioning as to why the movie director 's stray from the famous story line written by Faulkner and which was more effective? When the story opens up with, “When Miss Emily Grierson died, our whole town went to her funeral: the men through a sort of respectful affection for a fallen monument, and the women mostly out of curiosity to see the inside of her house, which no one save an old manservant- a combined gardener and cook- had seen in at least ten years,” the reader is automatically informed that someone important has died and it sets the stage for the personalities of the townspeople (Faulkner I). People of the town as a whole were curious, jealous and wary of the Grierson family; the women keying on the material things while the men showed respect, but all were suspicious. On the contrary, the film opens up in an examination room with the medical examiner’s and coroner declaring Miss Emily dead and stating how she died. The film does not convey important details that were provided in the story, therefore making the story’s introduction stronger than the films. Though Miss Emily’s father was not mentioned until his death in Faulkner’s story, Mr. Grierson makes an appearance in the film. The viewer is given an understanding of his possessive and superior personality whereas in the story, nothing is made clear. The importance of this is huge as it later contributes to an understanding of the attitudes and accusations made of the Grierson’s ego. Another scene that was lacking in description in the novel was the reactions of the relatives of Emily when they find the dead body that had been locked away. The story does not elaborate beyond, “For a long while we just stood there,

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Cassandra Clare once pointed out the importance of reading and comparing literature when she said, “Only the very weak-minded refuse to be influenced by literature and poetry.” The similarities between “The Story of an Hour” by Kate Chopin and “Richard Cory” by Edwin Arlington Robinson are striking, and they deserve thorough examination. In “The Story of an Hour,” Mrs. Mallard thought that her husband died, but when she found out that he was actually still alive, she died of shock. In “Richard Cory,” an entire town of people looked up to a man named Richard Cory who seemingly had everything, but Richard Cory was deeply unhappy and ended up killing himself. The same theme statement could encompass both pieces. “The Story of an Hour” and “Richard…

    • 1450 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Emily Grierson was a well known figure in the town who never paid her taxes. After her father died, and she was still unmarried, she became something of a shut in. When she emerged and met a fine man, the town thought they had married, until that fine man disappeared. The town pitied Miss Emily, but in a weird way respected the old broad. They were shocked when they found the body in her bedroom, but it made sense in an odd way.…

    • 792 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This is when Emily went to the store and bought some arsenic and a men’s toiletry set also with some men’s clothing (5). The townspeople began to think they were wed, but shortly they noticed that the sidewalks were done (5). This is when Homer disappeared for a long time. The next few years pasted, and Miss Emily died (5). The house was left untouched for a long time then her cousins came and wanted to find out what was in the locked room (6).…

    • 762 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Watching the short film and reading the story are completely different in their sequence of events, both have some similarities but mostly different. The story being the more confusing one because it starts explaining the ending to beginning as for the movie it shows you beginning to end which obviously makes it easier to understand the order. In both the story and the short film there are some similarities. Beginning with the short film, you see the end, Emily is dead at the morgue being drained, and the story goes on to how it all started, Emily and her father known as the Grierson family placed themselves too highly, and Emily’s father thought no young man is good enough for his daughter. As for the story, in the beginning we also know Emily has died and the writer begins…

    • 729 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The townspeople feelings for Miss Emily did not fade away even though they discovered Homer’s body being found. They attended her funeral in numbers. Faulkner insists “The held the funeral on the second day, with the town coming to look at Miss Emily beneath a mass of bought flowers, with the crayon face of her father musing profoundly above the bier and the ladies sibilant and macabre, and the very old men...some in their brushed Confederate…

    • 997 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The setting of “A Rose for Emily” is told from the townspeople, starts off with Ms. Emily 's funeral. Nobody has been with Emily for long time expecting her funeral. The townspeople had a special relationship with Emily since they stopped billing her taxes. But the new government in the town wasn’t happy with that so they tried to get her pay taxes. Everybody felt pitied for Emily father’s death.…

    • 1305 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    With these statements Faulkner shows that Miss Emily Grierson has been unable to change with the times like everyone else. Miss Emily’s home has also become outdated and out of place. The story mentions how all the other homes in this once prominent part of town are gone and have been replaced by garages and cotton gins. The narrator of the story calls the Grierson house “an eyesore among eyesores” (Faulkner). The first major event Miss Emily must deal with is the death of her father.…

    • 1350 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Emily passed the town began to develop and grow. The old black man finally died with no family to show for his funeral. Respectfully the town came together and buried him right next to his friend Ms. Emily. The mayor felt a big weight off him when Ms. Emily passed being that she was an elder to him and man other officials, the morals and values were never going to allow them to dis respect her no matter what. People were comfortable with saying it was bittersweet that Ms. Emily passed away.…

    • 952 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the beginning when the mayor at the time ask her to pay her taxes but she refused (731). Then she declined to tell the druggist what she was going to use the arsenic for; although it was against the law (734). Many times Emily Grierson 's acquaintances would ask her to get the smell controlled, but she acted as if they had not mentioned anything (732). Because she often ignored the law, she was the center of attention. When Emily Grierson died, the whole town wanted to know what her house looked and little small details about her.…

    • 776 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “A Rose for Emily” by William Faulkner is a short story that is divided into five sections. In section I, the entire town is at Miss Emily’s funeral, which is held at her home. The mayor, Colonel Sartoris has suspended Emily’s tax responsibilities to the town after her father’s death. But, the new generation of the town isn’t happy with this arrangement. However, they try to get her to pay the tax, but she refuses to pay the taxes.…

    • 1093 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays