Rhetorical Analysis Of Why Organic Food Might Be Worth The High Price

Improved Essays
A Rhetorical Analysis “Why Organic Food Might Be Worth the High Price”

In a February fourth, 2016 edition of Time Magazine in an article entitled “Why Organic Food Might Be Worth the High Price” Mandy Oaklander argues that certified organic fruits, vegetables, meats, dairy and other certified organic food goods, may actually be worth the higher prices. Oaklander states that certified organic is around 47% more expensive, according to Consumer Reports. Opposing views of certified organic goods have often claimed that the higher prices do not merit the worth of such goods. Oaklander states that a new review study from Nature Plants has researched all aspects of certified organic farming and compared the information with more traditional farming
…show more content…
Such as how it is providing jobs, its profitability, the positive environmental aspects of the reclaimed land, the energy savings, its benefits on pollination, and how it can be used in helping to end world hunger. She uses the following quotes from Reganold “When you look at ecosystem services, organic agriculture really shines,” he says. “The value they bring in areas like biodiversity, pollination, soil quality—if you were to put an economic value on those, and some researchers have, then it more than makes up for the higher price or price premium of organic food.” (Oaklander) She goes on to add information from a 2015 meta-analysis about the economics of certified organic farming, published in the journal PNAS where she quotes “…even determined that organic farming is more profitable than conventional, earning farmers 22% to 35% more money. They determined that the certified organic price premium (which was around 30% in the study) only had to be about 5% for certified organic profits to break even with conventional.” (Oaklander) She also adds that it is in fact the healthier option, stating new Nature Plants study information such as “The latest study points out that of the 15 or so scientific reviews focusing on nutrition, 12 studies have found evidence that certified organic is more nutritious than conventional by having more vitamin C, antioxidants and omega-3 fatty acids. Other studies indicate that children who eat organic foods have lower levels of pesticide metabolites in their bodies than those who eat conventional.” (Oaklander) By using these buzz friendly and timely attributes she keeps the article relevant to today’s readers. Today’s readers are quite concerned with general health, nutrition, and lowering the toxins in their bodies. They are also really interested in environmental issues like reclaiming the land, pollination and

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In this case, All Best Foods Inc. can employ experts to help local farmers switch to organic farming methods and keep the costs low. If they are able to convince a quarter of the farmers to switch to organic farming methods, then they will be able to produce their organic frozen vegetable line. All of the research and data shows that it is economically viable, so the hypothesis for All Best Foods Inc. is…

    • 832 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The author explains that there has been much progress made in advancing the movement, creating better food, ecological, and social conditions. However Obach also points out current issues like big-organic and conveys the idea there is more progress to be made. In order for organic to displace conventional systems, activists will need to continue their battle at all levels, from educating consumers, to making policy…

    • 772 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The final book that really spiked with my interest and stayed with me was Michael Pollan’s “The Omnivore's Dilemma: A Natural History of Four Meals.” In this book, we followed Mr. Pollan as he explained the food that we eat in three parts, two of which we read. In Part 1 of the book I realized that our government has set us up to buy processed food in order to feed into the large companies that continue to control this nation’s economy. Consequently, as it does not care about our citizen individual health, it is my perception that if more people knew this, and if they understood that by buying more organic products, it would cause the demand to go up and the prices down, then they would.…

    • 698 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Is Junk Food Really Cheaper?”: A Rhetorical Analysis. The purpose of the article “Is Junk Food Really Cheaper?” by Mark Bittman, is to persuade us that it costs just as much to eat out as it does to cook.…

    • 526 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the modern world today, many people cook and eat organic foods. They do this because they believe that it is better for them, despite the higher price. Robert Paarlberg noticed this when he was writing his article, “Attention Whole Food Shoppers”. While writing this article, he brought up the fact that while this entire process helps local farmers and fight climate change, the global issue of hunger is not solved.…

    • 815 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A major topic of concern today can be found in the world’s struggle with hunger and the malnourishment of millions of people. In attempt to address this matter, many countries have turned to genetically modified foods, causing many people to debate on whether or not they could be the answer to world hunger. Unfortunately, the countries not participating in the genetically modified foods movement are the main ones in need of food and nourishment. One author, Robert Paarlberg, attempts to describe the great need and positivity of allowing these modern growing methods in his article, “Attention Whole Foods Shoppers.” Through the use of convincing facts, rhetorical devices, proposals, and addressing opposing views, Paarlberg effectively argues…

    • 1079 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Statin’s claim was that organic food farms were as efficient as industrial agriculture; however, food farms were more competent and solicitous. The rhetorical appeal that could seen mainly throughout the video was Logos, because of the usage of reasoning and facts to support his claim. Evidence used to support this was when Statin argued that having cows out in grass fields allows for easier harvests and fertilization. It also gave the cows a source of natural food, as they are herbivores. Another piece of evidence that supports the presence of this rhetorical appeal was Statin arguing that the chickens from his farm had 130 CFUs compared to the store bought chickens which clocked in at around 3600 CFUs.…

    • 118 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    COMS 100B – Examination One Lianne Woo Question One: Goals, Themes, and Requested Actions: Although salad may be seen as a healthy alternative, Tamar Haspel’s aim in “Why salad is overrated” is to report that lettuce is more harmful than beneficial, in ways that are unhealthy and wasteful. Haspel informs the audience that the resources needed to process the vegetables cost more than the vegetables itself; she also explains why lettuce is overvalued, giving details to the nutrition density, calorie count, and shipment of the vegetable. She wants the audience to agree that lettuce causes more problems than benefits, and implies that she wants the audience to notify others to change their diet from iceberg lettuce, and similar vegetables, to something…

    • 1921 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Instead of using pesticides, and having most government farms and food programs' crops grown in monocultures, farmers should be encouraged by the government to let animals graze on the land and also plant crops, eliminating the need for other chemicals, and to grow a diversity of crops. Therefore moving into a system where cultivating polyculture crops are more common. During his argument, Pollan points out to the huge monocultures of the midwestern, the fencerow-to-fencerow planting policies of Nixon’s Secretary of Agriculture, the reeking feedlots, and the chemical fertilizer industry, Earl Butz, all as disastrous pieces of our quantity-over-quality, and cheap calories. Unsurprisingly, the way we eat and grow food is very connected to how healthy we are, which is why I believe Pollan is on the right track towards making a healthier choice on the way our food is cultivated and…

    • 578 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Documentary Food Inc

    • 1452 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The Documentary Food Inc. examines the current issues with the food industry in American. It shows how we have changed from a need-based form of production and consumption to a want and desire production and consumption base, where the large industry leaders produce as much as possible for as little cost possible. The documentary suggested that the move towards an industrial food system started with McDonalds, and the move that got rid of their waitresses and invented the drive through. This cut costs as every work position was specialized for one purpose. This became a model for every fast food restaurant that followed, leading to the mass demand for standardized food products that led to a concentration of food production into massive farms…

    • 1452 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Strolling through Stop and Shop, customers always seem to lay their eyes on the organic aisle for a split second, and think "What really labels this aisle as organic? Why would I ever want to be healthy?" Some, nonetheless, walk through the aisle, picking up these overpriced products that claim to allegedly be free of artificial flavors and genetically modified chemicals; products that claim to be unlike those found in the other ten aisles of the supermarket. The article "What are you Buying When You Buy Organic," by Steven Shapin depicts the corporate food industry, specifically Earthbound Farms and how the discussion of organic produce is more of a profitable matter, than what matters most, the health of an individual. Organic food is dictionary…

    • 834 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Stain of Sustainability Sustainability is discussed in “Attention Whole Food Shoppers” by Robert Paarlberg and “Sustainability by Christian R Weisser. Christian R Weisser speaks more about the idea of what sustainability is and how is important for society to be aware of it. Robert Paarlberg explains in his article the way the Earth is more and less sustainable because of everyone 's actions around the world. Both articles touch on the ideas that there are people out there helping change Earth for the better, and want to make earth sustainable for the future. The authors both explain how there are also harmful situations happening that hardly balance out the help from others trying to make a difference.…

    • 845 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    While there are room for improvements in her writing, Spriggs authoritative tone, logical rebuttals, and appropriately addressed counter arguments prove to make her essay an effective piece for persuading those who may have not followed her same belief system. Furthermore, with the organization of her writing, it's easy for readers to follow her argument from beginning to end, summarizing information and discovering a clear point as to what she wants her audience to think and do. Although some people may still have doubts on the benefits of buying local after reading Spriggs essay, the current push in America towards a greener, more sustainable way of living will eventually prevail. Consequently, this will cause the current way of large-scale monoculture farming to fall out of favor to the healthier, more sustainable way of local…

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This can be a true for many consumers who migrated towards the organic trend who felt it is morally inhumane to be eating corporate food when you have the option to eat “free range chickens” or “non-GMO fruits”. Furthermore, Shapin stated that organic farms can minimize its negative environmental impact by citing that Earthbound Farm “annually obviate the use of more than a quarter of a million pounds of toxic chemical pesticides and almost 8.5 million pounds of synthetic fertilizers, which saves 1.4 million gallons of the petroleum needed to produce those chemicals.” (429-430) Shapin aims to educate the readers on what it truly means to be…

    • 617 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    He asserts “the fact that better food — measured by taste or nutritional quality (which often correspond) — costs more, because it has been grown or raised less intensively and with more care. ”(Pollan 23). According to The Rationalization and Persistence of Organic Food beliefs in the Face of Contrary Evidence by Olson, Erik L, the authors disprove Pollan’s claim through a content analysis of 710 reader responses for a Stanford study, which objective was to examine the ‘pro-organic’ and ‘organic-skeptic’ reader comments and determine the personal impact of organic food consumption, as well as the environmental impact of organic food production. The exposure of a Stanford University meta-analysis, which concludes that organically produced foods do not offer any significant nutritional advantages, as opposed to, conventionally produced food completely refutes Pollen’s claim. The study proves that just because a food has the label “organic” on it does not mean it is significantly “healthier”.…

    • 1362 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays