The Price Of Forgiveness By Sharmeen Obaid-Chinoy Analysis

Improved Essays
Many girl, who are muslims, have no freedom to choose who they want to marry. When a girl does not obey her parents is shows disrespect, and ruins the family’s respect. Many of the girls are being punished for their actions, and some of them are murdered.“A Girl in the River: The Price of Forgiveness”, is a documentary, produced by Sharmeen Obaid-Chinoy, talks about a story of a women named Saba. She is a 19 year old women, who dishonors her family, due to marrying a man. The marriage was not approved by father or mother, meaning it was an unapproved marriage. Therefore, resembling a dishonoring to the family, because it showed that the child had no respect towards the father or mother. She was punished by her father and uncle, in which, they …show more content…
Father gives his opinion, he believes that what he did was the right thing to do, because she had dishonored the family. He mentions a lot about having the right to punish her because he takes care of her. Mother and sister also agree with father 's opinion, about her being punished for dishonoring the family, due to her action. As a result, the neighborhood does not have respect for them anymore. Mother in law, Qaiser mother, believes that Saba is happy with her life, which included, being around with her in laws, and husband. Furthermore, Saba and Qaiser show emotions towards each other intimacy. She mentions that she loves her husband, and that both live happily with each other 's companion. “ We were very happy. Qaiser and I talked over the phone and even met a few times.” Qaiser also alludes that “[His] lover for her is very strong. [He’d] die without her.” Finally the criminal investigator, lawyer, and doctor, also gave an emotional feeling towards her situation. Her lawyer, Asad Jamal, believe that she should receive justice towards her case, and that it should have been treated as a case of murder. The doctor who helped her, mentions how her injury was disturbing, and the story she had told him was dejected . “What that poor girl experienced was another level.” Ali Akbar, a criminal investigator, gave his emotion about …show more content…
In the documentary, it explains that “More than 1,000 women are murdered in Pakistan each year by male relatives who believe the victims have dishonored their families.” Saba’s Lawyer, explain that the court justice in Pakistan, forgives people who committed murder if the family forgives them. He explains that families will forgive the father, because they believe that the women should be punished for their mistakes. Father, as well mentions that, “Islam does not permit the girl to go out of the house.” He used this as a logic reason, to support himself, because he thought his daughter should not have run away with some

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Since people are not fond of her, they have started attacking her family, most importantly, her son. Along with Melania, Hester is not accepted by the people around her because of the scarlet letter she wears and because of her daughter Pearl, who is a living symbol of her sin. In the novel, The Scarlet Letter by Nathaniel…

    • 953 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    How these parents live their life after killing their children. It 's just heartbreaking to hear these kinds of the stories. In the online article "Shafilea Ahmed 's Father 'had Briefcase Full of Gold Bars so He Could Flee Justice at Any Moment" discusses how her parents killed her. Shafilea Ahmed was from Pakistan and raised in England and was forced marry someone, but she rejected. For "honor" her parents murdered their daughter.…

    • 759 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Her grandkids do not respect her because it seems that they learn the negative things from her. Also she is elegant because she mentions that if she gets in a car accident she wants to be notice that she is a lady. She would characterize herself as a good Christian. She tells her family that she does the things the right way and that they are doing the things the wrong way. The grandmother is a selfish, rude, racist, and she thinks that everything should be done her way.…

    • 867 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A quote from the television show American Horror Story does a great job a putting this feeling into words and it says “They say when a parent dies, a child feels his own mortality, but when a child dies, it 's immortality that a parent loses”. It is the parent of the child that is supposed to go first and not the child and when that happens great sorrow surrounds the parent. Richard murdered Steve in cold blood and the punishment should be equal to the crime. The old saying an eye for an eye may apply to this situation. So instead of being able to walk freely and haunt the parents of the victim, Richard should be serving life in prison or maybe even the death penalty for this crime At this point the ethics of the legal system has failed in caring out the right…

    • 708 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    My father told me that he was so thankful to God because he had married my mother. He said that your mother is a great woman; they have a lot of common things in their personality, As he said “which make my life with your mother easier and with no trouble. My father said your mother sometimes gets nervous and thinks about everything deeply which makes her uncomfortable in her day. The biggest issue that my father keep telling my mother is that she will not go out to work. My father did not say she will not go to work without having persuasive reasons to her.…

    • 910 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Why? The dark guilt in all men, unreckoned and without a name” (223). He had guilt in his family because he felt that he was not good enough. He felt that he did not know who he was, and did not feel accepted in the world. Also, He was upset emotionally because he never had children.…

    • 1472 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Some women that are frequently abused decide to commit suicide, thinking that it’s the best solution to end their suffering and misery. Unfortunately, that’s not the best solution. There are many NGO’s (none governmental organizations) out there that would help them. KAFA (enough), an NGO that focuses on gender based violence and that’s seeking to eliminate violence against women, estimates that one woman dies each month in Lebanon. According to Qiblawi (2014) “women facing abuse in Lebanon from their husbands and the Lebanese judiciary aren’t handling these cases properly and doesn’t respect women’s rights.” Several cases that happened in Lebanon that include Christelle Abu Shakra that was poisoned by her husband on valentine’s day and Rouqaya Mounzer, who was also shot in the chest by her husband.…

    • 1546 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Wrights did something wrong that doesn 't run through a persons mind on a daily basis. Wrights believed that she was feeling lonely once she married her husband so she believed to kill him because of her feelings. The main idea of Wrights perception in “A Jury of Her Peers” is she is aware of wanting to kill her husband. In the article, “Trends in Crime: Does Perception Match Reality?” Savi stated, “Many factors contribute to our perceptions of crime. News stories, types of crime committed, location of crime—these elements and others help to shape the way we perceive the safety of our communities.” The quote explains the characters perception because it was proven that the form of perception can be a crime.…

    • 1128 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Dick is very fond and attached to his parents such as they are to him while Perry is completely detached to his family. However, the outcome is the same for both. Dick and Perry get capture, which causes much trouble for their families. An example of this case would be with Perry’s sister where she says’’ I wanted to help him. I hoped I might have changed a few of his ideas.…

    • 884 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The deceit from Goneril and Regan are no help to anyone, including themselves. They both turn their backs on their family and betray their father’s trust. Both are willing to hurt and/or kill anyone to get power, all with disregard to family. Their cruelty is unacceptable and it shows that they care very little for their father and only care about getting more power. Lear feels like he has no home because his two eldest daughters have exiled him from their homes.…

    • 1285 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics