A Comparison Of Brutus In William Shakespeare's Julius Caesar

Improved Essays
In the book Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare, the speech that Antony gives at Caesar’s funeral is more effective than that of Brutus’, due to the differences Brutus and Antony have on what they believe will be most effective in persuading the plebeians to support them. They have different views on gravitas, and how it will serve them in persuading the plebeians. There are also differences in how they speak to them, including the use of verbal irony and sarcasm, or their straightforwardness. In addition, Antony relies on pathos to make his point, while Brutus uses logos. Due to the way Antony defends his side of the argument, the plebeians side with him, and later end up killing Brutus and the rest of the conspirators. During the funeral …show more content…
While Brutus is straightforward and blunt on his view of the situation, Antony uses verbal irony and sarcasm to make his point. For example, at first, all the Romans believe that Brutus and the other conspirators are honorable men. Antony, who is not allowed to speak poorly of them, brings up times and points to make them seem less so, and brings up points to show times when they were wrong, these men who, according to Antony, “you all know are honorable men” (JC III, II, 136). This is considered verbal irony, because although he calls the conspirators honorable men, he believes the opposite. However, Brutus speaks in a very straightforward manner, meaning every word he says. He is doing what he thinks is right, and is honorable in the fact that he tells what he believes to be the truth when at Caesar’s funeral, telling the plebeians “I slew my best lover for the good of Rome” (JC III, II, 47-48) If Brutus were to speak the plebeians in a more empathetic way, they might be more understanding of his reasoning, and side with him instead of Antony. Brutus is blunt when speaking to the plebeians, while Antony is sarcastic, one of the reasons Antony’s speech is more effective than that of …show more content…
When they speak at the funeral, Brutus uses facts to back his reasoning, and tries to explain to the plebeians that what killing Caesar was the right choice to make. He tells them this information in a way so that they do not think that he killed Caesar for his personal gain. He tells them, “there is joy for his fortune, honor for his valor, and death for his ambition.” (JC III, II, 106-107) trying to make a logical point that Caesar was too ambitious, and that he killed him for the good of Rome. On the other hand, Antony uses pathos in his speech, targeting the plebeians emotions to pin them against the conspirators. Antony during his speech, tells them “ My heart is in the coffin there with Caesar” (JC III, II, 116). Antony’s speech gains the hearts of the romans, ultimately causing them to go against the conspirators. During his speech he focuses on emotions, while Brutus focuses on facts and reasoning, this being the main reason behind Antony’s winning of the plebeians favor during his speech at Caesar’s

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Antony states “Was this ambition? / Yet Brutus says [Caesar] was ambitious, /And, sure, he is an honorable man” but he lets the people of Rome ponder the evidence that the noble Brutus is wrong (JC.3.2.96-98). Through the repetition of “…Brutus is an honorable man,” Shakespeare juxtaposes the true actions of Brutus (JC.3.2.93). Antony brings attention to the unethical assassination by focusing on Brutus’s apparent “honorable[ness]”. This rhetorical device forces the Romans to consider Brutus’s character and leads to them understanding the hypocrisy of his decision to kill his best friend.…

    • 886 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    By saying this, the phrase almost comes off as a question. Antony is saying since Brutus is an honorable man, does that make the rest of the men honorable as well? It's almost as if he is making the people question themselves if they can trust Brutus and the conspirators or not. Antony also brings up the repetition of the word “honorable” while talking about being raged about the actions of the conspirators, “I should do Brutus wrong, and Cassius wrong, Who, you all know, are honorable men: I will not do them wrong; I rather choose To wrong the dead, to wrong myself and you, Than I will wrong such honorable men” (3.2). Throughout this part of his funeral speech, Antony is now throwing the word honorable around like it is a word that is used on anyone.…

    • 1153 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In William Shakespeare's play Julius Caesar Mark Antony’s speech is more persuasive than the one Brutus gives because he uses better tactics and more powerful rhetoric. In his speech Brutus uses gravitas and ethos which in the end backfires because it makes his speech less relatable and portrays him as better than the plebeians. Mark Antony gives his speech after Brutus and he uses this to his advantage by using verbal irony and more specially sarcasm. Mark Antony uses pathos and exaggeration to create powerful rhetoric and to connect with the human emotions of the plebeians. In his funeral speech Mark Antony uses tactics that better relate to human nature and better connect with the plebeians rather than Brutus who tries to appeal to logic…

    • 1113 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In his speech, Brutus attracts the audience, and asks them to hear his reasons for killing his old friend Caesar. Brutus claims that when he killed Caesar, he had good intentions for doing so. He states, “Not that I loved Caesar less, but that I loved Rome more,” (III.ii.22). Brutus is declaring that he murdered Caesar for the good of Rome, in order to protect the wellbeing’s of others. Hence, he slayed one of his good friends in order to stop him from becoming a tyrant of Rome and saving the Republic, therefore showing he is admirable.…

    • 809 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Brutus uses many rhetorical questions that not only keeps the audience engaged, but also makes the audience think about the consequences if Caesar was still around. An example of Brutus’s use of rhetorical questions is found in lines eight to ten which states, “Had you rather Caesar living, and die all slaves, than that Caesar were dead, to live all freemen?” This rhetorical question persuades the audience that if Caesar was still around, they would live a much worse life, which convinces the audience that the death of Caesar was for the good of Rome. Mark Antony’s use of rhetorical questions, however, is used to convey the meaning of ambition, which gets sarcastic over the duration of his oration. In both lines eighteen and twenty-five, Brutus asks the audience about the word ambition, stating, “Did this in Caesar seem ambitious?” and “Was this ambition?” Over time, the readers loose the central focus of Mark’s speech, which was Caesar’s death was unnecessary. More so, Mark’s sarcastic questions and attacks towards Brutus, shrouds the true meaning of his oration.…

    • 1138 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    They force themselves to believe that this is true, in order to have an excuse and to wash away the guilt in which they feel after the killing of Caesar. Brutus continuously talks about how the killing of Caesar was for the good of Rome and that it was “not that [he] loved Caesar less, but that [he] loved Rome more” (Act 3, Scene 2, 22). Brutus feels as though what he did was for the good of Rome and that if Caesar had became leader, than life itself would have changed dramatically in a very negative way. To the people of Rome it seems as though Brutus in an honorable man, who will sacrifice himself for the good of society. Brutus being able to take the blame for the murder in order to keep Rome from falling apart seems to be a true act of honor.…

    • 1061 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This shows that Brutus was too trusting and gullible and he thought the people wanted him to make the decision to kill Caesar. Being that trustworthy of the people is a tragic flaw and is a perfect example. Being trustworthy of everyone is a tragic flaw but thinking everything you do is honorable is even worse. Antony says, “But Brutus says he was ambitious; And Brutus is an honourable man” (1.2.8). In this quote antony is saying that Brutus says he honorable and did nothing wrong in the killing of Caesar.…

    • 1034 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In William Shakespeare's play the Tragedy of Julius Caesar, two speeches are given to the people of Rome about Caesar’s death. Brutus and Antony both try to sway the minds of the Romans towards their views. Brutus tried to make the people of Rome believe he killed Caesar for a noble cause. Antony tried to persuade the people that the conspirators committed an act of brutality toward Caesar and were traitors. The effectiveness and ineffectiveness of both Antonys and Brutus’s speech to the people are conveyed through the tone and literary and rhetorical devices throughout the speeches.…

    • 723 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Brutus is a trusted man in Rome, so many Plebeians just accepted his word as fact because he was an “honourable man”. However, Brutus’s reputation could not carry his message alone to convince the Plebeians the murder of Caesar was justified. The content of his speech was not sub-par. Brutus is a man of reason and rhetoric and accordingly his speech was full of reason and rhetoric. The Plebeians, the working man is not as susceptible to reason and rhetoric as bright minds and thinkers.…

    • 1217 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Do grace to Caesar’s corpse, and grace his speech…”(III,ii,50-52). Here Brutus is convincing the people to listen to Antony talk about Caesar for his funeral. This is a costly mistake because Brutus just convinced the crowd that his actions were justified and that he killed Caesar for the greater good. The people now dislike Caesar and are…

    • 1002 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays