A Case Against College Linda Lee Analysis

Improved Essays
Years ago college in our world was not as popular as it is now. More and more young people are going to college after high school and will be the first in their family to do so. In her article “A Case Against College” Linda Lee brings up that college is not necessary. She points out all the negative aspects of college and none of the positive. She fails to grasp the reality that college is important and that its importance should not be downplayed. People should not take this article to heart. They should not take into account the statistics she states. People should disagree with this article because Linda Lee tries to mislead her audience with selective statistics, she uses her son for most of her examples, and her information is not creditable. …show more content…
One should also notice that she used very few of these statistics. The statistics she used were also very specific. “Even so, only 27 percent of Americans have a bachelor’s degree or higher. That leaves an awful lot who succeed without college” (Lee 10). Linda Lee uses a statistic here that only applies to students who have a bachelor’s degree or higher. She neglects to mention people who have graduated with an Associate’s degree. Linda Lee stated, “Is he getting a $1,000 a week’s worth of education?” In this question she asks she misleads people into assuming that all colleges are that expensive. Not all colleges cost that much. There are community colleges and non-private colleges that do not cost as much. A person who reads this article should make sure that he or she is not mislead by her selective …show more content…
Linda Lee stated, “Even so, only 27 percent of Americans have a bachelor’s degree or higher. That leaves an awful lot who succeed without college” (10). Linda failed to mention here the percentage of people that received an associate’s degree, which is lower than a bachelor 's degree,but is still a college education. “A number of his friends are [graduates], and those who were savvy enough to go into computers at an Ivy League school walked into $50,000-a-year jobs. But that’s not everyone. An awful lot became teachers making half that. And some still don’t know what they want to do” (Lee 11). Linda fails to mention how many teachers make $25,000 a year, if any make that. According to USNews, The median annual salary for high school teachers was $55,360 in 2013. The best-paid 10 percent in the field made approximately $86,720, while the bottom 10 percent made $37,230. Here it shows that no teacher makes less than $30,000. This shows that Linda is not a very credible source and that people should not take this article

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    “Misconception No. 2: College graduates are finding it harder to get good jobs with liberal arts degrees” (228). Ungar reports “A 2009 survey for the Association of American Colleges and Universities actually found that more than three-quarters of our nation 's’ employers recommend that collegebound students pursue a “liberal education”” (628). According to the chart on Unemployment Rates by Degree and Experience Level, 17.8 percent of recent high school diploma holders are unemployed. This percentage then lowers to 11.8 for all high school diploma holders.…

    • 1036 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Workers who majored in fine arts or graphic design barely earn more than the average high school graduate makes. Meanwhile, engineering professions account for seven out of the ten top earning undergraduate careers (Bennet and Wilezol 96-99). Choosing the right career oftentimes even makes more of a financial difference than going to a four year college. For example, Jonathan Rothwell reports “As of 2011, one out of every 10 U.S. jobs are sub-bachelor’s STEM jobs [sic]. With an average salary of $53,000…” (Rothwell).…

    • 1439 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sawhill. They also believe that not all college degrees are equal and that they are ranked by institution, major, and field of study. According to the business insider, 70 percent of billionaires attended college. I don’t think billionaires would be classified as middle class. Of those 70 percent that have attended college only 33 percent went to elite schools and the other 42 percent went to graduate school or just an ordinary college.…

    • 756 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Essay On Cycle Of Poverty

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Wodtke and Harding have shown that low income students have a lower high school graduation rate (87%) compared to affluent students (95%). For the 87% of low income students who graduated from high school, only 51% of students actually enroll in college. Up to this point, 44.4% of students have managed to make it so far. Finally, once college graduation comes around 20% of those students enrolled in college graduate. This comes to a grand total of 9% finishing college.…

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    That leaves an awful lot who succeed without college, or at least without a degree.”(Lee) Does she forget about the eight to ten percent of Americans who are unemployed? That immediately reduces the total amount of successful people with a degree to only sixty-three percent. Several million people in the United States make little to nothing in minimum wage jobs, which would reduce the percentage even lower. A college degree yields substantial economic returns. By the early 21st century, college graduates received earnings about 90% higher than their high school graduate counterparts, a premium that has increased dramatically over the last quarter century (Torche).…

    • 731 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Enrolling in a community college gives the full on university experience for thousands of dollars less. According to College Atlas, Money is the number one reason high school graduates don’t end up furthering their education. Financial aid isn’t always available to those who need it most, so naturally those students may decide to give up on college all together. Community colleges offer scholarships and financial aid just as universities do. However, the difference between community colleges and four-year universities are the initial costs.…

    • 1070 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Addison, however, don’t provide her own real-life story and experience the most she says is “Upon entry to my first community college I had but one O’level to my name” (256). Addison doesn’t provide enough details to her college experience to make a strong impact on her own article. Hrabowski story of Walter Sondheim is a very inspirational story that helps his articles argument unlike Addison’s. Freeman Hrabowski Colleges Prepare People for Life and Liz Addison Two Years Are Better than Four are good articles but it’s clear that Hrabowski overall gives a much more impactful article with better real-life situation examples, college success rate information, and a better emphasis/understanding on higher education effect on…

    • 717 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In fact, there are many decent jobs that do not require a bachelor 's degree. About fifty percent of the employment field consists of middle-skill jobs, which can be managed by the with a high school graduates when given some related training; not necessarily a bachelor 's degree (Billitteri). Some of those jobs include "web developers, receptionists, automobile repairers, and paralegal assistants" (Kensing). Accordingly, a significant number of the college graduates end up being employed to these middle-skill jobs which does not have any relation to their degree ("College Education"). This is because the economy is unable to produce enough occupations that will provide them the "college-level wage" that they deserve (Billitteri).…

    • 808 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is also said in the chapter that only 35% of students who did graduate from high school enrolled in college within a year with less that 13% obtaining a postsecondary degree of any kind after six years. These statistics show that students are not being properly educated during their K-12 education which really hurts them in their future. With few available jobs in Milwaukee a college degree is more important than ever if a person wants to be able to make a living. Therefore, people should try to focus on improving K-12 education as well as making college more accessible to everyone. Without a proper K-12 education students can not be expected to perform well throughout college and it can cause many students to have financial insecurities in their…

    • 736 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Discrimination In Colleges

    • 1343 Words
    • 6 Pages

    “On average, college educated African-American women annually earn $19,054 less than college educated white men. Also, on average, a woman with a Master’s degree makes $4,765 less than a man with an undergraduate degree.” There is no reason for someone who has the same credentials to be making less, especially if it 's just because of their race or sex. Especially if the disparity between the incomes are thousands of dollars. It says that on average that they make thousands less, which means that some people even make less which makes the disparity the amount between poverty of not and whether they can comfortably provide for their family or not. (civil rights.org, americans a fair chance).…

    • 1343 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays