• Shuffle
    Toggle On
    Toggle Off
  • Alphabetize
    Toggle On
    Toggle Off
  • Front First
    Toggle On
    Toggle Off
  • Both Sides
    Toggle On
    Toggle Off
  • Read
    Toggle On
    Toggle Off
Reading...
Front

Card Range To Study

through

image

Play button

image

Play button

image

Progress

1/358

Click to flip

Use LEFT and RIGHT arrow keys to navigate between flashcards;

Use UP and DOWN arrow keys to flip the card;

H to show hint;

A reads text to speech;

358 Cards in this Set

  • Front
  • Back
TORTS FALSE IMPRISONMENT (FI)
To establish a prima facie case for FI, the following elements must be proved: 1) an act or omission to act on the part of the defendant that CONFINES or RESTRAINS the plaintiff to a BOUNDED area; 2) INTENT on the part of the defendant to confine or restrain the plaintiff to a bounded area; and 3) CAUSATION.
TORTS LEGAL REMEDIES in Tort
Damages: D is ordered to pay money to P (compensatory, nominal, punitive). Damages are based on the harm to the P. REQUIREMENTS: 1) CAUSATION (Actual Cause) 2) FORESEEABILITY (Proximate Cause) 3) CERTAINTY (Damages cannot be too speculative) 4) UNAVOIDABILITY (P must take reasonable steps to mitigate damages).
TORTS NEGLIGENCE
The elements of a prima facie case for negligence include: 1) a DUTY on the part of the D to CONFORM TO A SPECIFIC STANDARD OF CONDUCT for protection of P against an unreasonable risk of injury; 2) a BREACH of that duty by D; 3) the breach is the ACTUAL AND PROXIMATE CAUSE of P's injury; and 4) DAMAGE.
EVIDENCE RELEVANCE
Evidence is RELEVANT if it tends to make the existence of any fact or consequence to the outcome of the action more probable than it would be without the evidence. All relevant evidence is admissible if it is offered in an unobjectionable form and manner.
TORTS Negligence: DUTY OF CARE
A duty of care is owed to all foreseeable plaintiffs. The extent of the duty is determined by the applicable standard of care. Therefore, when confronted with a negligence question, always ask: 1) was the P foreseeable? 2) If so, what is the applicable standard of care?
WILLS & TRUSTS What is Undue influence - prima facia case?
Testator has a weakness such that he is able to have his free will subjugated. 1) SUSCEPTIBILITY: Any weakness or predisposition 2) OPPORTUNITY: wrongdoer has access to testator 3) ACTIVE PARTICIPATION: or disposition to exert influence 4) UNNATURAL RESULT: i.e. wrongdoer taking devise were that person would ordinarily take nothing. Effect: only that part of the will affected by undue influence is invalid.
CRIMES Specific Intent Crimes
SOLICITATION: intent to have the person solicited commit the crime. ATTEMPT: Intent to complete the crime. CONSPIRACY: Intent to have the crime completed. 1ST DEGREE MURDER: premeditated intent to kill (defined by statute). ASSAULT: Intent to commit a battery. LARCENY/ROBBERY: Intent to permanently deprive another of his interest in the property taken. BURGLARY: Intent at the time of entry to commit a felony therein. FORGERY: Intent to defraud. FALSE PRETENSES: Intent to defraud. EMBEZZLEMENT: Intent to defraud.
CRIMES 4TH AM
The 4th Am provides that people should be free in their persons from UNREASONABLE searches and seizures.
TORTS Negligence: BREACH OF DUTY
Where D's conduct falls short of that level required by the applicable standard of care owed to the P, she has breached her duty. Whether the duty of care is breached in an individual case is a question for the trier of fact. The main problem relates to proof of the breach . P may use one of the following theories: 1. Custom or usage 2. Violation of Statute 3. Res Ipsa Loquitur (RIL)
CONTRACTS Applicable Law: UCC v. Common Law
UCC applies to sales of goods (moveable, tangible objects) while common law applies to all other types of contracts.
REMEDIES Restitutionary Remedies
These remedies are based on the theory that the D should not be UNJUSTY ENRICHED. Restitutionary remedies are based on the BENEFIT to the D, and the amount is calculated based on the value of the benefit. TYPES: LEGAL: a) Restitutionary Damages b) Replevin c) Ejectment EQUITABLE: d) Constructive Trusts e) Equitable Liens
PROPERTY WASTE
Life tenant MAINTAINS the estate--this expresses both the maximum and the minimum that the life tenant can do on the land. Three types of waste: 1. Voluntary waste 2. Permissive waste 3. Ameliorative waste
CRIMES SEARCH
A search is defined as a governmental intrusion into an area where a person has a REASONABLE and JUSTIFIABLE expectation of privacy.
BUSINESS ASSOCIATIONS Liability of Corporations for actions by a Promoter
The Corporation becomes liable on a promoter's pre-incorporation K when the corporation ADOPTS the K by: a) EXPRESS board of directors resolution; or b) IMPLIED adoption through knowledge of the K and acceptance of its benefits. The Promoter remains liable on pre-incorporation Ks until there has been a NOVATION (i.e., an agreement between the promoter, the corporation, and the other contracting party that the corporation will replace the promoter under the K).
CRIMES ACCOMPLICE LIABILITY: Parties -- Principal
A principal is one who, with the requisite mental state, ACTUALLY ENGAGES IN THE ACT OR OMISSION that causes the criminal result.
CON LAW What are the 4 Justiciability Requirements (required at all levels)?
(1) P must have standing; (2) Case must be ripe for review; (3) Case must not be moot AND (4) It must NOT be a political Q
WILLS & TRUSTS What is incorporation by reference?
Non-integrated writing given testamentary effect if incorporation by reference met. Requires: 1) Doc or writing 2) In EXISTENCE at execution 3) Clearly IDENTIFIED in the will 4) Testator INTENDED to incorporate the doc. NOTE: If 1-3 are met, 4 can be implied.
PROPERTY FUTURE INTERESTS
The INTEREST exists now but possession will not take place--if at all--until some time in the future. Future interests retained by GRANTOR: 1. REVERSION 2. POSSIBILITY OF REVERTER 3. RIGHT OF RE-ENTRY Future interests given to GRANTEE: 1. REMAINDER 2. EXECUTORY INTEREST
WILLS & TRUSTS What are facts of independent significance?
Identity of recipient beneficiary or what gift is intended may be given meaning by facts of significance INDEPENDENT FROM WILL - i.e., to my church. Or to all my employees at time of my death. 1) Must be a fact WOULD HAVE EXISTED even without the will. 2) Can be an event or fact before or after will is drafted Basically allows outside parole evidence to prove what stuff is; facts of independent significance allow us to fill in the blanks to T's will with parol evidence that is trustworthy.
CRIMES ACCOMPLICE LIABILITY: Parties -- Accomplice
An accomplice is one who, with the intent that the crime be committed, aids, counsels, or encourages the principal before or during the commission of the crime.
TORTS NEGLIGENCE PER SE
Negligence per se (aka "statutory negligence") is the legal doctrine whereby an act is considered negligent because it violates a statute (or regulation). In order to prove negligence per se, the plaintiff must show that: 1) the defendant violated the statute, 2) the statute is a safety statute, 3) the act caused the kind of harm the statute was designed to prevent, 4) the plaintiff was a member of the statute's protected class. In some jurisdictions, negligence per se creates merely a presumption of negligence.
PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY DUTY OF LOYALTY: Duty to Avoid Conflicts of Interests
“An attorney may not represent a client if the representation of the client may be materially limited by the lawyer's responsibilities to another client, or to a third person, or by the lawyer's own interests, unless:" (both must be present) i) the lawyer reasonably believes that the representation will not be adversely affected; and ii) the client consents. • must be informed consent • almost always now, consent must be in writing.
CIV PRO In Personam Jxn: Statutory Limitations
Each state may prescribe its own statutory bases for personal jxn, but must still satisfy constitutional requirements. Most states grant courts in personam jxn in 4 situations: (i) where the D is PRESENT in the forum state and is personally served with process; (ii) where the D is DOMICILED in the forum state; (iii) where the D CONSENTS to jxn; and (iv) where the D has committed acts bringing him within the forum state's LONG ARM STATUTES.
CRIMES ACCOMPLICE LIABILITY: Accessory After the Fact
An accessory after the fact is one who receives, relieves, comforts, or assists another, knowing that he has committed a felony, in order to HELP THE FELON ESCAPE ARREST, TRIAL, OR CONVICTION.
CRIMES ARREST
An arrest occurs when the police take a person into custody against her will for purposes of criminal prosecution or interrogation. An arrest must be based on probable cause (PC).
WILLS & TRUSTS What are the requirements of a holographic will? What happens if it is undated?
1) Must be signed by testator. Sig can be anywhere in will. 2) MATERIAL PROVISIONS must be in testator's own handwriting. (gifts made and the beneficiaries) NOTES: a) Testamentary can be preprinted. . .i) if there are issues extrinsic evidence as to intent is allowed. b) Series of letters may be will under integration. c) Date not required. . .i) If conflicts - Dated wins unless undated can be established as after . .ii) If both undated, then unresolved inconsistent is thrown out . .iii) If Testator may have been incapacitated during time will was drafted then invalid.
TORTS Comparative Negligence
A substantial MAJORITY of states now permit a contributory negligent P to recover a percentage of his damages under some type of comparative negligence system. In every case where contributory negligence is shown, the trier of fact weighs P's negligence against that of D and reduces P's damages accordingly.
CONTRACTS K Formation In order to form a valid K, the following elements must be present:
OFFER ACCEPTANCE CONSIDERATION
What is a codicil? What is the major concern regarding one?
Testamentary instrument executed with required formalities of the code, which modifies, amends, or revokes a will. A codicil REPUBLISHES A WILL. Important for: 1) Pour over wills; 2) Incorporation by reference: AND 3) Pretermission (for birth, marriage or domestic partnership) NOTE: codicil itself is a testamentary instrument thus pretermission analysis from date of codicil. (Discuss both on Bar)
TORTS BATTERY
Defendant commits a HARMFUL or OFFENSIVE contact; AND The contact is with the plaintiff’s PERSON. Requires INTENT and CAUSATION.
TORTS Respondeat Superior / Vicarious Liability
Issue: whether the principal will be vicariously liable for torts committed by agent. Two-part test: Principal will be liable for torts committed by agent if: (1) there must be a principal-agent relationship; and (2) the tort must occur within the scope of that relationship.
TORTS ASSAULT
D must place the plaintiff in REASONABLE APPREHENSION; That apprehension must be of IMMEDIATE HARMFUL OR OFFENSIVE CONTACT to plaintiff's person. Requires INTENT and CAUSATION.
PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY DUTY OF LOYALTY: Conflict of Interest: Business Deals with Clients (MR 1.8(a))
When an atty is both a party to the transaction and representing the other party to the transaction it is always suspect. Only if all of the following requirements are met will it be ok: 1) The terms of the transaction must be FAIR and reasonable; and 2) the terms must be DISCLOSED in writing in a manner the client can reasonably understand; and 3) the client is advised in writing to seek the OPINION of another lawyer, and give him the chance to do so; and 4) the client must CONSENT in writing. Mnemonic: "First Discuss Over Coffee."
TORTS Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress (IIED)
∆ must engage in outrageous conduct; AND π must suffer severe emotional distress. Also requires INTENT (or recklessness) and CAUSATION. NOTE: For this intentional tort only, reckless conduct on the part of the ∆ will be adequate. Does not need actual intent.
CRIMES SOLICITATION
Solicitation consists of inciting, counseling, advising, inducing, urging, or commanding another to commit a felony with the specific INTENT THAT THE PERSON SOLICITED COMMIT THE CRIME.
TORTS TRESPASS TO LAND
Physical invasion of π’s real property. Requires INTENT and CAUSATION. o ∆ can enter on foot on in a vehicle. o Π need not know that ∆ crossed the boundary line; intent is satisfied simply by the ∆ stepping foot on the land. o Trespass can also be by throwing a tangible object onto the property (includes airspace and soil).
PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY DUTY OF LOYALTY: Conflict of Interest
A lawyer must not allow her personal interests, the interests of another client, or the interests of a third person to interfere with her loyalty to the client. RULE: If an interest of you, another client, or a third party MATERIALLY LIMITS OR IS ADVERSE to loyal representation, you have a conflict of interest. ***Flag and discuss ACTUAL and POTENTIAL conflicts.
TORTS TRESPASS TO CHATTELS
An act by Defendant that INTERFERES with PLAINTIFF'S RIGHT OF POSSESSION in a chattel. Requires INTENT, CAUSATION, and DAMAGES. o ∆ can damage the personal property item (bend, break, scratch, etc.) o Take it away. Owner has an exclusive right of possession, so if you take it away, it constitutes interference. What tort has been committed? o It depends on the degree of interference: if the interference is small, minor, or slight, then it is a TRESPASS TO CHATTELS. o By contrast, the big harm would be CONVERSION. Recovery: FMV of property for CONVERSION; Cost of repair for TRESPASS TO CHATTELS.
REMEDIES Permanent Injunction Mnemonic
"I'll Put Five Bucks Down" I -- Inadequate legal remedy P -- Property Right / Protectible Interest F -- Feasibility of Enforcement B -- Balancing of Hardships D -- Defenses
CIV PRO PERSONAL JXN: Minimum Contacts
International Shoe requires that the D have "such minimum contacts" with the forum that the exercise of jxn would be fair and reasonable. Look to 2 factors: purposeful availment and foreseeability. There must be a relevant tie between ∆ and the forum state.
TORTS SELF-DEFENSE
When a person REASONABLY BELIEVES that she is being (or is about to be) attacked, she may use such force as is reasonably necessary to protect against injury. DEGREE OF FORCE: must be a degree of force REASONABLY necessary to respond to the threat (rule of proportionality). Self-defense is usually not available to the initial aggressor. A reasonable MISTAKE as tot he existence of the danger is allowed.
PROPERTY JOINT TENANCY (JT)
The 4 UNITIES must be persent at the outset in order to create a JT (T-TIP Test): 1. Unity of TIME. All JT interests must have vested at the same time. 2. Unity of TITLE. The grant to all JTs must be the same instrument (e.g., one deed). 3. Unity of INTEREST. All JTs must take the same kind and the same amount of interest. 4. Unity of POSSESSION. All JTs must have identical rights of possession. General RULE: To create a JT, the language of conveyance must clearly reflect the grantor's INTENT to create a JT. Under the Majority Rule today, certain magic words must be used: --"as joint tenants, with right of survivorship" or "in joint tenancy with right of survivorship." The JT carries a RIGHT OF SURVIVORSHIP. The surviving tenants take automatically on the death of a JT.
REMEDIES Remedies for Personal Property
DESTROYED PROPERTY: --Compensatory Damages DAMAGED PROPERTY: --Compensatory Damages DISPOSSESSION (most common): --Compensatory Damages --Restitutionary Damages --Replevin --Mandatory Injunction --Constructive trusts/Equitable liens --Self-help (reasonable force to recapture)
CRIMES CONSPIRACY
1) An AGREEMENT BETWEEN 2 OR MORE persons; 2) An INTENT TO ENTER INTO AN AGREEMENT; and 3) An INTENT TO ACHIEVE THE OBJECTIVE of the agreement. Today, a MAJ of the states require an OVERT ACT in furtherance of the conspiracy, but mere preparation will usually suffice.
REMEDIES Remedies for Real Property
SIMPLE TRESPASS: --Nominal Damages --Restitutionary Damages --Injunction (avoiding multiplicity of actions DESTRUCTION/DAMAGE TO REALTY --Compensatory Damages --Injunction DISPOSSESSION: --Compensatory Damages --Restitutionary Damages --Ejectment --Constructive trusts/Equitable liens ENCROACHMENT (common): --Compensatory Damages --Injunction **No restitution NUISANCE (common): --Compensatory Damages --Injunction **No restitution
CONTRACTS OFFER
An offer is a manifestation of an INTENT TO CONTRACT (words or conduct showing commitment). An offer must also have DEFINITE AND CERTAIN TERMS and be COMMUNICATED to the offeree. An offer must create a REASONABLE EXPECTATION in the offeree that the offeror is willing to enter into a K on the basis of the offered terms.
TORTS DEFAMATION
ELEMENTS: (i) DEFAMATORY LANGUAGE; (ii) "OF OR CONCERNING" the plaintiff; (iii) PUBLICATION thereof by ∆ to a third person; and (iv) DAMAGE to π's reputation.
REMEDIES Remedies for Personal Injury Torts
COMPENSATORY DAMAGES: a) Economic Losses/Special Damages (certainty rules apply) b) Non-Economic Losses/General Damages (e.g., pain and suffering -- certainty rules do not apply) c) Lump Sum Payment: Discounted to present value. Inflation not taken into account under traditional view. INJUNCTION (only against prospective intentional tortious conduct).
PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY Duty of Competence (MR 1.1; CA 3-110)
In representing a client, a lawyer must act competently and with the legal knowledge, skill, thoroughness, and preparation that are reasonably necessary for the representation. Elements: o Legal knowledge and skill (In emergency situations, a lawyer may seek assistance, but the assistance should not exceed what is reasonably necessary to meet the emergency) o Thoroughness and preparation o Maintaining competence – continuing legal education (Be up to date with the laws). A lawyer may accept representation where the requisite level of competence can be achieved by reasonable preparation.
REMEDIES Remedies for Fraud
1) Damages 2) Constructive Trusts/Equitable Liens **Always consider whether (i) punitive damages should be awarded AND (ii) if it also could be analyzed as a Ks case.
BUSINESS ASSOCIATIONS Corporate Formation
Corporate formation is "A PAIN": 1) AUTHORIZED SHARES -- the maximum # of shares a corp is authorized to issue. 2) PURPOSE 3) AGENT and address of registered office (registered agent is the corporation's official legal representative). 4) INCORPORATORS (name and address of each) 5) NAME OF CORPORATION -- the name must contain some indicia of corporate stautus.
BUSINESS ASSOCIATIONS The Principal-Agent Relationship In Tort
The Principal-Agent relationship requires: (A) ASSENT -- an informal agreement between the principal and the agent; (B) BENEFIT -- the agent's conduct must be for the principal's benefit. (C) CONTROL -- Principal must have the right to control the agent by having the power to supervise the manner of the agent's performance.
REMEDIES Specific Performance in K
6 part checklist: 1) K is valid / certain & definite terms 2) K conditions of P must be satisfied (P must be able to show her K conditions have been fulfilled--already performed, ready and able to perform, or excused from performing). 3) Inadequate legal remedy alternative; 4 reasons: --Damages are speculative --D is insolvent --multiple suits are necessary --the thing bargained for is UNIQUE 4) Mutuality of Remedy 5) Feasibility of Enforcement 6) Defenses
PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY Duty of Diligence (MR 1.3)
(Duty to pay attention to your client): You have a duty to diligently, promptly, and ZEALOUSLY pursue your case to completion. Diligence is the timeliness aspect of competence. Lawyers are obligated to be diligent in their client’s behalf and are required to be in persistent pursuit of the client’s matter. Once a lawyer takes on a client’s matter, the lawyer must: (i) act on the client’s behalf with reasonable diligence and promptness; (ii) act with dedication and zeal, taking whatever lawful and ethical steps are available to vindicate the client’s cause; (iii) pursue the matter to completion; and (iv) either terminate the relationship or act with the required diligence if there is any doubt as to whether a lawyer-client relationship exists.
TORTS Privacy Tort: INVASION OF PRIVACY
Invasion of π’s physical seclusion in a way that would be highly offensive to the average person. • Warning: π has to be in a place where there is a reasonable expectation of privacy in order for the tort to be committed. • EX: Eavesdropping of your conversation while you are at a restaurant – no expectation of privacy.
EVIDENCE EXAMINATION OF WITNESS: Improper Questions
Misleading Compound Argumentative Conclusionary Assuming Facts Not in Evidence Harassing or embarrassing Calls for a Narrative Answer Calls for Speculation Lack of Coundation Nonresponsive Answer
TORTS Privacy Tort: FALSE LIGHT
The widespread dissemination of a material falsehood about the plaintiff that would be highly offensive to a reasonable person. • Essentially the tort of “gossip” • To proceed in false light, π must prove falsity. Damages are not limited to economic damages, which is why someone may assert it as a second claim to defamation. If it is a matter of public concern, π must show ∆ acted with actual MALICE. ***PRIVILEGES for defamation apply to false light and disclosure. • Ex: Misrepresenting a π’s political or religious beliefs. • Fault not required; reasonable belief is not a defense.
CIV PRO PERSONAL JXN: Purposeful Availment
D's contact with the forum must result from her purposeful availment with that forum. Contacts cannot be accidental. D must reach out to the forum in some way, such as to make $$ there or to use the roads there. The court must find that through these contacts the D PURPOSEFULLY AVAILED himself "of the privilege of conducting activities within the forum state, thus invoking the benefits and protections of its laws." ASK: Has the ∆ purposefully availed himself of the benefits of the State; aiming his behavior at the state? • Look to shipping goods, whether the ∆ makes money from the transactions, etc. • An interactive website CAN be purposeful availment.
WILLS & TRUSTS What is the rule of Lapse?
If beneficiary doesn't survive the testator, the gift lapses and returns the residuary of the estate.
TORTS Privacy Tort: DISCLOSURE
Widespread dissemination of confidential information about the π that is highly offensive to a reasonable person. EXCEPTIONS: • If it is newsworthy information, the media can publish it. • The duel-life fact pattern: stripping to pay law school tuition hypo. ***PRIVILEGES for defamation apply to false light and disclosure.
WILLS & TRUSTS What is CA Anti-lapse statute?
Anti-lapse statute applies where devisee is: 1) Kindred of testator or of testators spouse and devisee predeceases testator 2) Leaving issue. NOTE: The anti-lapse statute applies to both wills and revocable trusts. But the devisee CANNOT be the SPOUSE or domestic partner
PROPERTY DUTIES OF THE TENANT
1. DUTY TO PAY RENT 2. DUTY TO MAINTAIN PREMISES If the lease is silent, the T is still subject to the CL duty not to commit waste. If the lease includes a covenant to repair, an express covenant makes the tenant the absolute insurer of the property. The MAJORITY view is that once the tenant covenants to repair, he is liable for EVERYTHING--including ordinary wear and tear. BUT, if the premises are destroyed without the tenant's fault, the tenant will be under no duty to rebuild the structure. 3. DUTY not to use the premises for ILLEGAL PURPOSES 4. DUTY NOT TO ABANDON THE PREMISES
TORTS ECONOMIC TORTS
• FRAUD – misrepresentation of a material fact, coupled with scienter (∆ made the statement and knew π would rely on it) with the intent to induce the π to act or refrain from acting, that caused the π to rely on that statement, and that π’s reliance was justifiable; and π must suffer actual loss. • NEGLIGENT MISREPRESENTATION –carelessly misrepresenting a fact in a business relationship where someone relies on your expertise • INDUCING BREACH OF CONTRACT -- Persuading someone to walk away from a binding contractual deal. • MALICIOUS PROSECUTION – instituting a lawsuit without any probable cause, for an improper purpose. • ABUSE OF PROCESS – Using a judicial proceeding or judicial process for an illicit purpose.
REMEDIES Specific Performance Mnemonic
"Cha Cha Is My Favorite Dance" C -- Contract is Valid C -- Conditions of P satisfied I -- Inadequate legal remedy M -- Mutuality of remedy F -- Feasibility of enforcement D -- Defenses
CRIMES ATTEMPT
A criminal attempt is an act that, although done with the intention of committing a crime, falls short of completing the crime. Attempt requires: (1) A specific intent to commit the crime; and (2) An overt act in furtherance of that intent.
TORTS CONVERSION
(i) An act by D that INTERFERES WITH P'S RIGHT OF POSSESSION in a chattel; (ii) The interference is SO SERIOUS that it warrants requiring D to pay the chattel's full value; (iii) INTENT and (iv) CAUSATION. Acts of conversion include wrongful acquisition (theft), wrongful transfer, wrongful detention, and substantially changing, severely damaging, or misusing a chattel. The longer the withholding of the property, the more likely it is to be a conversion. P may recover DAMAGES (FMV at the time of conversion) or POSSESSION (replevin).
PROPERTY DUTIES OF THE LANDLORD
1. DUTY TO DELIVER POSSESSION OF THE LEASED PREMISES 2. IMPLIED WARRANTY OF HABITABILITY At CL, there was NO DUTY to deliver the leased premises in habitable condition. Today, there exists an implied warranty of habitability, but ONLY FOR RESIDENTIAL PROPERTIES. 3. IMPLIED COVENANT OF QUIET ENJOYMENT
BUSINESS ASSOCIATIONS CORPORATE FORMATION: Ultra Vires Acts
Activities beyond the scope of a stated business purpose are considered to be "ultra vires." At CL, ultra vires acts were void and unenforceable. But under the RMBCA, ultra vires acts are generally ENFORCEABLE, and the ultra vires nature of an act may be raised in only 3 situations: 1) A SHAREHOLDER may sue the corp to enjoin the proposed ultra vires act; 2) THE CORPORATION may sue an officer or director for damages for approving an ultra vires act; and 3) THE STATE may bring an action to dissolve a corporation for committing an ultra vires act.
PROPERTY Tenant's Remedies for Breach of Implied Warranty of Habitability
1) Tenant can move out AND end the lease (w/ no further lease obligation). OR 2) Tenant can stay on the property AND sue for damages. 3) A growing number of states also allow the T to make reasonable repairs and deduct this cost from future rent payments ("repair and deduct")
PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY Confidentiality MR 1.6
“A lawyer shall not reveal information relating to the representation of a client unless the client gives INFORMED CONSENT, the disclosure is IMPLIEDLY AUTHORIZED in order to carry out the representation or the disclosure is permitted [by an exception]:” Basically, no revealing client information without the client’s consent, unless: • To prevent death or bodily harm • To prevent the client from committing a crime or fraud (But not in CA) • To prevent substantial injury to another’s property (But not in CA) • To secure legal advice about compliance with the rules • To establish a claim or defense on behalf of the lawyer in a controversy between the lawyer and the client, or • To comply with other law or court order
REMEDIES Rescission and Reformation Mnemonics
RESCISSION: "Good Dog" G -- Grounds for Rescission D -- Defenses REFORMATION: "Very Good Dog" V -- Valid K G -- Grounds for Reformation D -- Defenses
PROPERTY Implied Covenant of Quiet Enjoyment
Every lease includes the LL's implied promise not to interfere with the tenant's QUIET ENJOYMENT of the leased premises. This implied promise is included in EVERY lease--residential, commercial, or otherwise. The LL may breach this implied promise in 3 ways: 1) TOTAL EVICTION 2) PARTIAL EVICTION 3) CONSTRUCTIVE EVICTION
TORTS STRICT LIABILITY: Prima Facie Case
For SL, the following elements must be shown: (i) the nature of the defendant's activity imposes an ABSOLUTE DUTY TO MAKE SAFE; (ii) the dangerous aspect of the activity was the ACTUAL and PROXIMATE CAUSE of the plaintiff's injury; and (iii) the plaintiff suffered DAMAGE to person or property.
REMEDIES TORT Remedies
LEGAL REMEDIES 1. Damages RESTITUTIONARY REMEDIES (Legal Restitutionary Remedies) 2. Restitutionary Damages 3. Replevin 4. Ejectment (Equitable Restitutionary Remedies) 5. Constructive Trusts 6. Equitable Liens EQUITABLE REMEDIES 7. Injunctive Relief
TORTS PRODUCTS LIABILITY
Products liability refers to the liability of a supplier of a defective product to someone injured by the product. There are 5 theories of liability that P may use: (i) intent; (ii) negligence; (iii) strict liability; (iv) implied warranties or merchantability and fitness for a particular purpose; and (v) representation theories (express warranty and misrepresentation).
TORTS The Principal-Agent Relationship: SCOPE
The principal is liable for its agent's acts within the SCOPE of agency. FACTORS: 1) Was the conduct "of the kind" the agent was hired to perform? 2) Did the tort occur "on the job"? Frolic vs. Detour 3) Did the agent intend to benefit the principal?
TORTS PRODUCTS LIABILITY: Elements
To find liability under ANY products liability theory, P must show: (i) a DEFECT; and (ii) existence of the defect WHEN THE PRODUCT LEFT D's CONTROL.
REMEDIES CONTRACT Remedies
LEGAL REMEDIES 1. Damages RESTITUTIONARY REMEDIES (Legal Restitutionary Remedies) 2. Restitutionary Damages 3. Replevin 4. Ejectment (Equitable Restitutionary Remedies) 5. Constructive Trusts 6. Equitable Liens EQUITABLE REMEDIES 7. Specific Performance* 8. Rescission* 9. Reformation* *Different from Tort remedies
CIV PRO PERSONAL JXN: Stream of Commerce
Asahi: four justices found that placing an item in the stream of commerce, with the knowledge that it would end up in a particular forum, constituted purposeful availment. Four other justices found that there would also have to be a showing that the D took some additional step to avail itself of the forum.
BUSINESS ASSOCIATIONS Liability of Principle for Ks Entered by Agents
Issue: whether the principal is liable for Ks entered into by its agent. TEST: Principal is liable for Ks entered into by its agent if the principal AUTHORIZED the agent to enter the K. There are 4 types of authority: 1) ACTUAL EXPRESS Authority 2) ACTUAL IMPLIED Authority 3) APPARENT Authority 4) RATIFICATION
BUSINESS ASSOCIATIONS PIERCING THE CORPORATE VEIL
As a general rule, shareholder is not liable for the debts of a corporation. Except: the court will pierce the corporate veil to avoid fraud or unfairness. Courts will pierce the corporate veil for: ALTER EGO (failure to observe sufficient corporate formalities); or UNDER-CAPITALIZATION (failure to maintain sufficient funds to cover foreseeable liabilities). Remember: Courts are generally more willing to PCV for a tort victim than for a K claimant.
BUSINESS ASSOCIATIONS DUTIES of Agent to Principal
In return for reasonable compensation and reimbursement of expenses, agents owe principals: 1) Duty of CARE; 2) Duty to OBEY instructions that are reasonable; and 3) Duty of LOYALTY. The agent may NEVER do any of the following: (i) engage in SELF-DEALING (agent cannot receive a benefit to the detriment of the principal); (ii) USURP the principal's opportunity; or (iii) make SECRET PROFITS at the principal's expense without disclosure.
CONTRACTS ACCEPTANCE
An acceptance must manifest an intent to contract to the terms of the offer and be communicated to the offeror. The offeree exercises the power given her by the offeror to create a contract.
EVIDENCE HEARSAY
Hearsay is "a statement, other than one made by the declarant while testifying at the trial or hearing, offered in evidence to prove the truth of the matter asserted." If a statement is hearsay, and no exception is applicable, the evidence must be excluded upon appropriate objection to its admission.
CRIMES FOTPT: Basic RULE
Basic Rule: In addition to excluding all evidence which has been illegally obtained, any additional evidence acquired either directly or indirectly from the illegal arrest, search, or seizure must also be excluded as tainted "fruit of the poisonous tree." (Wong Sun v. US.)
CIV PRO PERSONAL JXN: Fairness
International Shoe also requires that the exercise of jxn not offend "traditional notions of fair play and substantial justice." FACTORS: --Relatedness of claim to contact -claim arising from activity in the state -systematic and continuous activity in the State --Convenience --Forum State's Interest (in providing redress for its citizens) --Other factors: (i) the P's interest in obtaining convenient and effective relief; (ii) the interstate judicial system's interest in obtaining the most efficient resolution of controversies; and (iii) the shared interest of the states in furthering fundamental substantive social policies.
CRIMES Warrantless Search
Warrantless search is presumptively unreasonable under the 4th Am. unless a SW exception may apply. Exceptions: 1) SITA 2) Auto Exception 3) Inventory/Impound Search (Inevitable Discovery) 4) "Pat Search" of Car
EVIDENCE Statements that are NON-HEARSAY under the FRE
FRE 801(d) provides that certain statements, when relevant, are not hearsay: 1) Prior Statements by a Witness 2) Admissions by Party-Opponent
CONTRACTS Acceptance: The Mailbox Rule
Acceptance by mail or similar menas creates a K at the MOMENT OF DISPATCH provided that the mail is properly addressed and stamped, UNLESS: (i) The OFFER STIPULATES that acceptance is not effective until received; or (ii) An OPTION K is involved (--> an acceptance under an option K is effective only upon RECEIPT). NOTE: because in most jxns a revocation is effective only upon receipt, under the mailbox rule if the offeree dispatches an acceptance BEFORE HE RECEIVES A REVOCATION sent by the offeror, a K is formed.
CON LAW PRIVACY is a FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT - what are the 9 privacy categories that are protected by SDP & the 1 he highlighted as not being protected?
(1) RT to marry (2) RT to procreate (3) RT to custody of one's children. (4) RT to keep the family together (housing) (5) RT to control the upbringing of one's children (6) RT to purchase & use contraceptives (7) RT to abortion (undue burden test) (8) RT to engage in private consensual homosexual activity (9) RT to refuse medical treatment BUT NO RT to physician - assisted suicide
CONTRACTS CONSIDERATION
Consideration is a BARGAINED FOR EXCHANGE whereby there is a DETRIMENT AND BENEFIT flowing from each party to the other. LONG RULE: Two elements are necessary to constitute consideration: (i) there must be a BARGAINED FOR EXCHANGE between the parties; and (ii) that which is bargained for must be considered of LEGAL VALUE or, put differently, it must constitute a benefit to the promisor OR a detriment to the promisee. Detriment is determined by whether an exchange contains legal value.
COMMUNITY PROPERTY QUASI-COMMUNITY PROPERTY (QCP)
Property that would have been community property if the parties had been CA domiciliaries at the time of acquisition.
COMMUNITY PROPERTY QUASI-MARITAL PROPERTY (QMP)
Applies to putative spouses. Putative spouses are spouses who think that they are legally married (and actually tried to get legally married) but for whatever reason they actually are not.
CRIMES INSANITY: M'Naughten
D is entitled to an acquittal if the proof establishes that: a) a DISEASE of the mind b) CAUSED A DEFECT of reason c) such that the defendant LACKED THE ABILITY AT THE TIME of his actions to either: (1) know the WRONGFULNESS of his actions; or (2) understand the NATURE AND QUALITY of his actions.
PROPERTY 4 Requirements to Enforce a RESTRICTIVE COVENANT
1) INTENT -- The parties must intend that the restriction run with the land. 2) NOTICE -- The person must have either actual, constructive or inquiry notice. 3) TOUCH AND CONCERN -- (RULE) If the performance of the covenant makes that land more valuable or more useful, the covenant touches and concerns the land. NOTE: covenants not to compete DO touch and concern the land. 4) PRIVITY -- Horizontal and Vertical.
CONTRACTS DEFENSES to Consideration
1. Absence of Mutual Assent 2. Absence of Consideration 3. Public Policy Defenses -- Illegality 4. Lack of Capacity 5. Defenses to Enforcement (i) Statute of Frauds (ii) Unconscionability
PROPERTY Determining PRIVITY in a RESTRICTIVE COVENANT
BURDEN: Successor-in-Interest is the DEFENDANT--requires both: a) VERTICAL PRIVITY -- refers to those who subsequently obtain the property subject to the covenant. They must take the FULL ESTATE. b) HORIZONTAL PRIVITY -- refers to the original parties to the peromise. They must share some interest in the land independent of the covenant. To establish horizontal privity, there must be a conveyance of the property between the original properties. BENEFIT: Successor-in-Interest is PLAINTIFF: a) VERTICAL PRIVITY -- On the benefit side, the general rule is that the holder of any succeeding possessory estate may enforce the benefit of the promise as a covenant at law. 2) NO horizontal privity is required to enforce the benefit of a restrictive covenant.
WILLS & TRUSTS Dependent Relative Revocation (RULE)
1) If testator revokes her will, or a portion thereof, 2) in the MISTAKEN belief that a substantially identical will or codicil effectuates her intent, 3) then, by operation of law, 4) the revocation of the first will be deemed conditional, dependent, and relative to the second effectuating testator's intent. 5) If the second does not effectuate testator's intent, the first (by pure legal fiction) was never revoked.
CRIMES EXCLUSIONARY RULE
The exclusionary rule prohibits the introduction, at criminal trial, of evidence obtained in violation of a D's 4th, 5th, or 6th Amendment rights.
PROPERTY EQUITABLE SERVITUDES: 3 Requirements to Obtain an INJUNCTION to Enforce the Burden of the Promise
1) INTENT that the restriction be enforceable by successors-in-interest; 2) The restriction must TOUCH and CONCERN the land; 3) NOTICE to the subsequent purchaser (actual, constructive, or inquiry). NO PRIVITY of any kind is required to enforce the promise in equity as an equitable servitude.
WILLS & TRUSTS W&T Essay CHECKLIST
WILLS: 1. Execution of wills 2. Revocation of wills 3. Components of wills (integration, republication by codicil, incorporation by reference, acts of independent significance) 4. Interpretation of wills 5. Intestate succession 6. Rights of surviving spouse and children (pretermitted) 7. Bars to succession (homicide, elder abuse, no contest clause) TRUSTS: 1. Creation of a valid trust (7 elements) 2. Types of Trusts (discretionary, mandatory, spendthrift, honorary, secret, semi-secret, revocable, totten, charitable) 3. Modification and termination of trusts 4. Trust administration and Trustees Duties
COMMUNITY PROPERTY SEPARATE PROPERTY (SP)
All property owned by a person before marriage All property acquired by gift, devise, bequest, or descent All property acquired by rent, issues, and profits of SP
WILLS & TRUSTS Creation of a Valid Trust (7 elements)
1. Settlor/trustor 2. Delivery 3. Trustee 4. Intent 5. Trust Property (Res) 6. Beneficiaries 7. Valid Trust Purpose (cannot violate law or public policy)
PROPERTY EQUITABLE SERVITUDES: Requirements to Establish a Mutual Right of Enforcement
1. An INTENT to impose a SERVITUDE (a restriction on use) on ALL land in the subdivision; 2. NOTICE (actual, constructive, or inquiry); DEFENSES: 1. Unclean hands 2. Acquiescence 3. Laches 4. Estoppel
WILLS & TRUSTS Trustees Duties
1) FIDUCIARY DUTY 2) DUTY OF CARE (Trustee must exercise degree of care, skill and caution of a reasonable person in managing her own property) DUTIES RELATING TO CARE OF TRUST PROPERTY: a) duty to collect and protect trust property b) duty to earmark property c) duty not to delegate investment decisions d) duty not to commingle trust funds e) duty to maintain marketability of trust property f) duty to keep trust property productive g) duty to diversify investments h) duty not to speculate i) duty to account do trust beneficiaries. 3) DUTY OF LOYALTY: a) Self-dealing b) Conflict of interest
PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY Candor Toward the Tribunal MR 3.3
(a) a lawyer shall not knowingly: (1) Make false statements, or fail to correct them (2) Fail to disclose legal authority (3) Offer evidence that the lawyer knows to be false
PROPERTY ADVERSE POSSESSION
Six Requirements: H-E-L-U-V-A 1. HOSTILE (X is on the land with no right to be there) 2. EXCLUSIVE (X must be excluding others from possessing the property) 3. LASTING (The possession must last for the statutory period; CL is 20 yrs) 4. UNINTERRUPTED USE (continuous use that an ordinary owner would make) 5. VISIBLE (open + notorious) 6. ACTUAL [POSSESSION] (X must actually possess the land to obtain title. --The true owner DOES NOT have to know what's going on. --The adverse possessor (X) DOES NOT have to think he owns it (GF/bad faith is irrelevant).
COMMUNITY PROPERTY CP Presumption
Property acquired during marriage is presumptively CP. Think possession vs. acquisition.
Directors' Liability: DUTY TO MANAGE
Directors have a DUTY TO MANAGE the corporation. Directors may delegate management functions to a committee of one or more directors that recommends action to the board.
PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY Advertising
A lawyer is allowed to advertise their services through written, recorded, or electronic communication, subject to limitations: • Lawyer CANNOT make false or misleading communication about the lawyer or lawyer’s services. “False or misleading” = 1) If it contains a material misrepresentation of fact or law, OR 2) Omits a fact necessary to make the statement considered as a whole not materially misleading EVERY written, recorded, or electronic communication MUST include the words “Advertising Material” on the outside envelope (if any), AND at the beginning and ending of any recorded or electronic communication, UNLESS they fit either of the previous exceptions (lawyer, past relationship. Lawyer MAY advertise online IF lawyer is licensed to practice in the state where the ad is initially placed. MUST specify jurisdiction where lawyer can practice.
CIV PRO DIVERSITY OF CITIZENSHIP JXN
Section 1332: Diversity of Citizenship; Amount in Controversy: (a) The district courts shall have original jurisdiction of all civil actions where the matter in controversy exceeds the sum or value of $75,000, exclusive of interest and costs, and is between— (1) citizens of different States; (2) citizens of a State and citizens or subjects of a foreign state; (3) citizens of different States and in which citizens or subjects of a foreign state are additional parties; and (4) a foreign state, defined in section 1603 (a) of this title, as plaintiff and citizens of a State or of different States. [aliens are deemed to be a citizen of the state in which such alien is domiciled] (b) [...] (c) For the purposes of this section and section 1441 of this title— (1) a corporation shall be deemed to be a citizen of any State by which it has been incorporated and of the State where it has its principal place of business... [and] (2) the legal representative of the estate of a decedent shall be deemed to be a citizen only of the same State as the decedent, and the legal representative of an infant or incompetent shall be deemed to be a citizen only of the same State as the infant or incompetent. (d) [...] (e) The word “States”, as used in this section, includes the Territories, the District of Columbia, and the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico.
CRIMES 6th Am RIGHT TO COUNSEL
The 6th Am provides that in all criminal prosecutions, the D has a right to the assistance of counsel. It applies at all CRITICAL STAGES of a criminal prosecution after formal proceedings have begun. The right is violated when the police deliberately elicit an incriminating statement from a D without first obtaining a waiver of the D's right to have counsel present. The 6th Am right has been limited to cases where ADVERSARY JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS have begun (e.g., formal charges have been filed). Thus, the right DOES NOT APPLY TO PRE-CHARGE CUSTODIAL INTERROGATIONS.
PROPERTY PRESENT and FUTURE COVENANTS
PRESENT: 1. Covenant of Seisin 2. Covenant of Right to Convey 3. Covenant Against Encumbrances FUTURE: 1. Covenant of Quiet Enjoyment 2. Covenant of Warranty 3. Covenant of Further Assurances--The "Mop-Up" Covenant BREACH of a Covenant of Title: Where there is a breach of warranty, plaintiff's damages will be limited to the amount of purchase price received by the warrantor plus any incidental damages.
BUSINESS ASSOCIATIONS Directors' Liability: BUSINESS JUDGMENT RULE (BJR)
In managing the corporation, the directors are protected from liability by the BJR. The BJR is a presumption that the directors manage the corporation in good faith and int he best interests of the corporation and its shareholders. As such, directors will not be liable for INNOCENT MISTAKES of business judgment.
CRIMES ENTRAPMENT
Entrapment occurs if the intent to commit the crime originated not with the D, but rather with the creative activities of law enforcement officers. The defense of entrapment consists of 2 elements: 1) the CRIMINAL DESIGN must have ORIGINATED WITH LAW ENFORCEMENT officers; and 2) the D must NOT have been PREDISPOSED to commit the crime prior to the initial contact by the government. If D offers evidence to show these two elements, then the gov't must show predisposition beyond a reasonable doubt.
COMMUNITY PROPERTY Basic CP Essay INTRO Paragraph 1
"California is a community property state. All property acquired during the course of a marriage is presumed to be community property. All property acquired before marriage or after permanent separation is presumed to be separate property. In addition, any property acquired by gift, bequest, devise or descent is presumed to be separate property."
CRIMES BATTERY
Battery is an unlawful application of force to the person of another resulting in either bodily injury or an offensive touching. Need not be intentional; force need not be applied directly. Consent is a defense only to simple battery (e.g., medical operation).
CRIMES 5TH AM (MIRANDA)
The 5th Am provides that no person shall be compelled to be a witness against himself. Interpreted to mean that a person shall not be compelled to give self-incriminating testimony
BUSINESS ASSOCIATIONS Directors' Liability: FIDUCIARY DUTY
Despite protection presumed from the business judgment rule, directors are FIDUCIARIES who owe duties of CARE and LOYALTY.
CRIMES ASSAULT
An assault is either: (i) an ATTEMPT TO COMMIT A BATTERY; or (ii) the INTENTIONAL CREATION--other than by mere words--of a REASONABLE APPREHENSION in the mind of the victim of imminent bodily harm.
CRIMES MIRANDA: When Required
Anyone in police CUSTODY and accused of a crime, no matter how minor a crime, must be given Miranda warnings PRIOR TO INTERROGATION by the police.
CON LAW What is the 3 part test for determining whether something qualifies as OBSCENE?
MUST meet ALL of these requirements: (1) The material must appeal to the prurient interest (= shameful or morbid interest in sex) (2) Material must be patently offensive under the law prohibiting obscenity (ANY law must delineate which depictions would qualify as patently offensive) (3) Taken as a whole, the material must lack serious redeeming artistic, literary, political or scientific value (= value determined by a NATIONAL standard & NOT a local value)
BUSINESS ASSOCIATIONS Directors' Liability: DUTY OF CARE
RULE: A director owes the corporation a duty of care. She must act with the care that a PRUDENT person would use with regard to her own business, unless the Articles have limited director liability for a breach of the duty of care. EXAM ANSWER: Directors have a duty to manage. They are protected by the BJR, but they are fiduciaries who have duties of care and loyalty. Directors must act with prudence unless the articles have limited liability or a duty of care.
COMMUNITY PROPERTY Basic CP Essay INTRO Paragraph 2
"In order to determine the character of any asset, courts will trace back to the source of funds used to acquire the asset. A mere change in form of an asset does not change its characterization. With these basic principles in mind, we can now turn to the specific items of property involved in this instance."
CRIMES MURDER
Murder is the unlawful killing of another human being with malice aforethought. Malice aforethought may be express or implied.
BUSINESS ASSOCIATIONS Directors' Liability: DUTY OF LOYALTY
RULE: A director owes the corporation a duty of loyalty. A director may not receive an UNFAIR benefit to the detriment of the corporation or its shareholders, UNLESS there has been material DISCLOSURE and INDEPENDENT RATIFICATION. Types: A. SELF-DEALING B. USURPING CORPORATE OPPORTUNITIES C. RATIFICATION EXAM ANSWER: Directors have a duty to manage. They are protected by the BJR, but they are fiduciaries who have duties of care and loyalty. Directors may not receive an unfair benefit unless there has been disclosure, plus independent ratification.
EVIDENCE HEARSAY EXCEPTIONS -- Residual "Catch All" Exception
The FRE provides a general catch-all exception of hearsay statements not covered by specific exceptions. There are 3 requirements: 1) "TRUSTWORTHINESS" -- Statement must have "circumstantial guarantees of trustworthiness'" that are equivalent to those of statements admitted under other hearsay exceptions. 2) "NECESSITY" -- The statement must be offered on a MATERIAL FACT, and must be MORE PROBATIVE as to that fact than any other evidence which the proponent can reasonably produce so that the "INTERESTS OF JUSTICE" will be served by its admission. 3) NOTICE TO ADVERSARY -- the proponent must give notice in advance of trial to the adverse party as to the nature of the statement so that the adversary has an opportunity to prepare to meet it.
CRIMES MURDER: Malice Aforethought
In the absence of facts excusing the homicide or reducing it to VM, malice aforethought exists if the D has any of the following states of mind: (i) Intent to kill (express malice); (ii) Intent to inflict GBI; (iii) Reckless indifference to an unjustifiably high risk to human life ("abandoned and malignant heart"); or (iv) Intent to commit a felony (FMR) In the case of (i), (iii), or (iv), the malice is IMPLIED.
COMMUNITY PROPERTY Distribution of CP at DIVORCE
"The basic rule at divorce is to divide each community asset equally in kind. Thus, each spouse is given one-half of each community asset."
CRIMES VOLUNTARY MANSLAUGHTER (VM)
VM is an intentional killing distinguishable from murder by the existence of adequate provocation, i.e., a killing in the heat of passion. ELEMENTS: a) the provocation must have been one that would arouse SUDDEN AND INTENSE PASSION in the mind of an ORDINARY PERSON such as to cause him to lose his self-control; b) the D must have IN FACT BEEN PROVOKED; c) there MUST NOT HAVE BEEN A SUFFICIENT TIME to cool; and d) the defendant IN FACT did not cool off between the provocation and the killing.
COMMUNITY PROPERTY Distribution of CP at DEATH
If the spouse dies with a will, the spouse is entitled to dispose of all of his or her separate property and one-half of the community property. If the spouse dies withotu a will, the community property is awarded entirely to the surviving spouse. Between 1/3 and all of the decedent's separate property will be awarded to the surviving spouse depending on whether there are issue or parents surviving.
COMMUNITY PROPERTY QCP: At DEATH and DIVORCE
"At DEATH, the surviving spouse has a 1/2 interest in the QCP titled in the decedent's name. The decedent does not have an interest in the QCP titled in the survivor's name." "At DIVORCE, QCP is treated exactly like CP."
CRIMES INVOLUNTARY MANSLAUGHTER (IVM)
There are two types of IVM: 1) Criminal Negligence 2) "Unlawful Act" Manslaughter
CONTRACTS BREACH
When a party fails to perform materially by the terms of the K he is in breach. The nonbreaching party may seek damages.
CON LAW What are the boundaries of congressional action under the Commerce Clause after Lopez? (3 rules)
1. Congress may regulate the CHANNELS of interstate commerce 2. Congress may regulate the INSTRUMENTALITIES of interstate commerce, and persons or things in interstate commerce; OR 3. Congress may regulate ECONOMIC ACTIVITIES that have a SUBSTANTIAL EFFECT on interstate commerce In area of non-economic activity, a substantial effect cannot be based on cumulative impact – Morrison (VAWA) Wickard v. Filburn – cumulative impact of economic activity, even if it’s for individual use, falls under the Commerce Clause
CRIMES FALSE IMPRISONMENT (FI)
The CL misdemeanor of FI consisted of: (i) unlawful (ii) confinement of a person (iii) without his valid consent.
COMMUNITY PROPERTY Treatment of QCP at DEATH
For every asset of QCP, there is an acquiring spouse and a non-acquiring spouse, and QCP is treated like the acquiring spouse's SP during marriage. When one spouse dies, he does not have any rights to the surviving spouse's SP. Thus, when a non-acquiring spouse dies, he has no rights to the acquiring spouse's QCP.
PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY PR Essay Checklist Mnemonic
"Clients Love Fierce Counsel: Courts Feel Differently." DUTIES OWED TO CLIENTS: --Confidentiality --Loyalty --Financial Responsibility --Competence --(and other reasonable things) DUTIES TO ENTITIES OTHER THAN YOUR CLIENT: --Candor/Truthfulness --Fairness --Dignity/Decorum --(and other reasonable things)
CRIMES KIDNAPPING
At CL, the misdemeanor of kidnapping was the forcible abduction or stealing away of a person from his own country and sending him to another. Modern statutes and the MPC extends far beyond this definition. Kidnapping is defined as confinement of a person that involved either: (a) some movement (i.e., asportation) of the victim; or (b) concealment of the victim in a "secret" place.
PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY CONFIDENTIALITY: General Rule
You can't reveal anything RELATED TO THE REPRESENTATION of a client without her consent. The rationale is to maximize candor and trust, allowing the adversarial system to work.
CIV PRO ERIE DOCTRINE
A federal court, in the exercise of its diversity jxn, is required to apply the SUBSTANTIVE LAW OF THE STATE in which it is sitting, including that state's conflict of law rules. However, the federal courts apply FEDERAL PROCEDURAL LAW in diversity cases. First, ask if there is a federal law directive on point (if so, use that). If there is no federal directive on point, ask whether the issue is substantive or procedural. --Substantive --> fed judge must follow state law in a diversity case --Procedural --> fed judge may ignore state law.
CONTRACTS Article 2: WARRANTIES
Ks for the sale of goods automatically include a warranty of title (in most cases). They may also include certain implied warranties and express warranties. WARRANTY OF TITLE & WARRANTY AGAINST INFRINGEMENT: Any seller of goods warrants that the title transferred is good (free of liens or encumbrances). This arises automatically and need not be mentioned in the K. A merchant seller regularly dealing in goods of that kind automatically warrants that the goods are delivered free of any patent, trademark, copyright, or similar claims. But a buyer who furnishes specifications for the goods to the seller must hold the seller harmless against such claims. IMPLIED WARRANTY OF MERCHANTABILITY IMPLIED WARRANTY OF FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE EXPRESS WARRANTIES
CRIMES RAPE
Rape is the unlawful carnal knowledge of a woman by a man, not her husband, without her effective consent. Requires only penetration of the female sex organ by the male sex organ. Today, most states have abolished the marriage exception. Must be without the victim's effective consent.
CIV PRO FEDERAL QUESTION JXN (Section 1331)
The district courts shall have original jxn of all civil actions ARISING UNDER THE CONSTITUTION, LAWS OR TREATIES OF THE UNITED STATES... --fed Q must appear as part of the P's cause of action as set out in a well-pleaded complaint.
CIV PRO VENUE -- In General
Venue in civil actions in the federal courts is proper in: (i) a judicial district where ANY D RESIDES, if all Ds reside in the same state; (ii) a judicial district in which a substantial par to f the events or omissions giving rise to the claim occurred, or a substantial part of property that is the subject of the action is situated; or (iii) if there is no district anywhere in the US which satisfies (i) or (ii), (a) for actions based SOLELY ON DIVERSITY, a judicial district in which any D is subject to personal jxn at the time the action is commenced; or (b) for actions NOT BASED SOLELY ON DIVERSITY, a judicial district in which any D may be found.
CRIMES LARCENY
(Basic CL property offense) Larceny consists of: (i) A taking (caption); (ii) and carrying away (asportation); (iii) of tangible personal property; (iv) of another (v) by trespass; (vi) with intent to permanently (or for a reasonable time) deprive the person of his interest in the property. (e.g., intent to borrow not larceny).
PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY Duty of CANDOR to the court and FAIRNESS to your adversary
A lawyer is prohibited from engaging in conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceit, or misrepresentation. You must refuse to make a false statement of material fact, or offer evidence you know is false to a tribunal, or fail to correct a false statement of material fact or law that you previously made or presented to the tribunal.
CIV PRO CA Long-Arm Statute (§ 410.10)
“A court of this state may exercise jurisdiction on any basis not inconsistent with the Constitution of this state or of the United States.” o CA Statutory analysis: Easy to meet, because the statute reaches the constitutional limit.
CRIMES EMBEZZLEMENT
Embezzlement, variously defined in different jxns, generally requires: (i) the fraudulent; (ii) conversion; (iii) of property; (iv) of another; (v) by a person in lawful possession of that property. Embezzlement did not exist at CL; Modern statutes distinguish between grand embezzlement (a felony) and petit embezzlement (a misdemeanor).
CON LAW What is the Privileges & Immunities clause of Article IV?
No state may deprive citizens of other states of the Privileges & Immunities that it affords its own citizens. An anti-discrimination provision - limits ability of a state to discriminate against out-of-staters. Only FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS (those involving important commercial activities, like the pursuit of livelihood) and CIVIL LIBERTIES are protected.
PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY Duty to state the law truthfully
An attorney who knowingly makes a false statement of law to the court is subject to discipline. An attorney has an obligation to be candid about the law and to cite to adverse authority if it is from a controlling jurisdiction and directly on point.
CRIMES FALSE PRETENSES
False pretenses generally consists of: (i) obtaining title; (ii) to the property of another; (iii) by an intentional (or knowing) false statement of past or existing fact; (iv) with the intent to defraud the other. False pretenses did not exist at CL; Modern statutes distinguish between grand false pretenses (a felony) and petit false pretenses (a misdemeanor). Distinguishable from "Larceny by Trick" by WHAT is obtained. If only possession --> larceny by trick. If title is obtained --> false pretenses.
CIV PRO PERSONAL JXN: Foreseeability
It must be foreseeable that the ∆ could get sued in this forum. • Does the ∆ know or should know that its products could reach the forum state?
PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY PR Essay CHECKLIST
I. ATTORNEY'S DUTY TO THE CLIENT: a) The duty of LOYALTY b) The duty of CONFIDENTIALITY c) The duty of COMPETENCE d) The duty of FINANCIAL INTEGRITY (i.e., fees, client property) II. ATTORNEY'S DUTY TO 3RD PARTIES: a) The duty to OPPOSING PARTIES in litigation b) The duty to ACCEPT REPRESENTATION c) The special duty of PROSECUTORS III. ATTORNEY'S DUTY TO THE COURT: a) The duty of CANDOR b) The duty of HONESTY c) The duty to WITNESSES and JURORS IV. ATTORNEY'S DUTY TO THE PROFESSION: a) The duty to avoid UNAUTHORIZED PRACTICE OF LAW b) The duty to avoid false or misleading ADVERTISEMENTS c) The duty to not improperly SOLICIT clients
CRIMES ROBBERY
Robbery is a felony in all jxns and consists of: (i) a taking; (ii) of personal property of another; (iii) from the other's person or presence; (iv) by force or intimidation; (v) with the intent to permanently deprive him of it.
CON LAW When does a state law violate the DORMANT COMMERCE CLAUSE? Exceptions?
If a law burdens interstate commerce, it violates dormant commerce clause UNLESS that law is necessary to achieve an important government purpose. Helping in-staters at out-of-staters expense is NEVER an important government purpose State has to show the law is necessary: has to show there is no less discriminatory way to achieve the objective. EXCEPTION 1: Congressional approval EXCEPTION 2: the market participant exception. (A state or local government may prefer its own citizens in receiving benefits from government programs or in dealing w/ government-owned businesses)
PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY CONFLICT OF INTEREST: Actual Conflict
When two clients’ interests are in present and actual conflict, the attorney cannot continue to represent both parties.
CRIMES BURGLARY (CL)
CL burglary is: (i) a breaking; (ii) and entering; (iii) of the dwelling; (iv) of another; (v) at nighttime; (vi) with the intent of committing a felony therein.
PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY CONFLICT OF INTEREST: Potential Conflict
A lawyer may represent two clients in a civil litigation if their interests are only potentially in conflict, provided the lawyer reasonably believes that he can represent both clients effectively and obtains the consent of both clients after consultation.
CONTRACTS Ks Essay Checklist
"Armadillos From Texas Play Rap, Eating Tacos." A -- Applicable Law F -- Formation of Ks T -- Terms of the K P -- Performance R -- Remedies for Unexcused Nonperformance E -- Excuse of Nonperformance T -- Third-Party Problems
CIV PRO PERSONAL JXN: Relatedness
Relatedness between the contact and the π’s claim. Quality of D’s contact with the forum. Ask: Does the π’s claim arise from the ∆’s contact with the forum? --Where the claim is related to the ∆’s contact with the forum, it is called specific jurisdiction. --If the claim does not arise from the ∆’s contact with the forum, then jurisdiction is ONLY OK if the court has general personal jurisdiction. To have this, ∆ must have CONTINUOUS AND SYSTEMATIC TIES with the forum state. --Examples of systematic ties: domicile, incorporation, major facilities there, etc.
CRIMES ARSON
At CL, arson consists of: (i) the malicious; (ii) burning; (iii) of the dwelling; (iv) of another. Burning = blackening or charring of structure; mere blackening by smoke or discoloration by heat is not sufficient. Modernly, expanded to include things like exposions. Malice required.
CIV PRO PERSONAL JXN: Convenience
Convenience: ∆ may complain that the forum makes it tough to litigate because it is far from the ∆’s home and it may be tough to get ∆’s witnesses and evidence to the forum. Standard: the forum is OK unless it puts ∆ at a SEVERE DISADVANTAGE IN THE LITIGATION • Relative wealth of the parties is not relevant.
CIV PRO PERSONAL JXN: State's Interest
State's interest is often to provide a forum for its citizens. Ex: The forum state might have an interest in providing a courtroom for its people who are harmed by allegedly careless out-of-state manufacturers.
CRIMES FELONY MURDER RULE (FMR)
A killing during the course of a felony--even an accidental one--is murder. Malice is implied from the intent to commit the underlying felony. Under the CL, the felonies included are BARRK To convict a D of FM, the prosecution must prove that he committed the underlying felony. So, if he has a substantive defense to the underlying felony, he has a defense to FM. CAUSATION required. D's conduct must he the cause-in-fact of the result; i.e., the result would not have occurred BUT FOR the D's conduct. Year and a day rule (CL) Remember, Intervening acts break the chain of causation.
CON LAW What is the SUPREMACY CLAUSE?
Constitution, and laws and treaties made pursuant to it, are the supreme law of the land. (eg, Federal law WINS every time)
CIV PRO PERSONAL JXN: Summary of Constitutional Test
“My Parents Frequently Forgot to Read Children’s Stories” • Minimum Contacts o Purposeful Availment o Foreseeability • Fair Play & Substantial Justice o Relatedness of contact and claim o Convenience o State’s Interest
CIV PRO The CLASS ACTION
Representative(s) sues on behalf of class members. Must initially demonstrate ALL of these: (1) NUMEROSITY: too many class members for practicable joinder; (2) COMMONALITY: There are some question of law or fact in common to class; (3) TYPICALITY: Rep's claims/defenses typical of those of the class; and (4) REPRESENTATIVE IS ADEQUATE: Rep will fairly and adequately represent class.
CON LAW RATIONAL BASIS TEST
RATIONALLY RELATED to a LEGITIMATE government interest. (actual purpose need not be legitimate; must only be conceivable). Gov. usually wins. The law us usually valid unless it is ARBITRARY or IRRATIONAL. Challenger has the burden of proof.
CON LAW INTERMEDIATE SCRUTINY
SUBSTANTIALLY related to an IMPORTANT government interest. --Court looks to government's ACTUAL purpose. --Burden is on the government.
CON LAW STRICT SCRUTINY
Must be NECESSARY to achieve a COMPELLING government purpose. You must find that NO less restrictive alternative could be used to achieve the government purpose. --Court looks to government's ACTUAL purpose. --Burden is on the government.
CON LAW FREEDOM OF ASSOCIATION
Laws that prohibit or punish group membership must meet strict scrutiny. To punish membership in a group it must be proven that the person: (i) actively affiliated with the group; (ii) knowing of its illegal activities; and (iii) with the specific intent of furthering those illegal activities.
CON LAW EPC: Proving a Discriminatory Classification
For strict or intermediate scrutiny to be applied, there must be INTENT on the part of the government to discriminate. Intent may be shown by: (i) A law that is DISCRIMINATORY ON ITS FACE; (ii) A DISCRIMINATORY APPLICATION of a facially neutral law; or (iii) A DISCRIMINATORY MOTIVE behind the law. NOTE: The third is the most difficult to prove. A discriminatory EFFECT alone is not enough. The legislature's discriminatory motive must be shown (e.g., by evidence of a history of discrimination).
CON LAW Restrictions on Speech in Limited Public Forums and Non-Public Forums
Speech and assembly can be more broadly regulated in limited public forums (e.g., military bases and schools when classes are in session) and nonpublic forums. The Gov't can regulate speech in such a forum to reserve the forum for its intended use. Regulations are valid if they are: (i) VIEWPOINT NEUTRAL; and (ii) REASONABLY RELATED TO A LEGITIMATE government purpose (rational basis).
BUSINESS ASSOCIATIONS Rule 10b-5 Elements
1) FRAUDULENT CONDUCT: a) SCIENTER -- an intent to deceive; b) DECEPTION -- an intent to defraud by: (i) Lying (misrepresentation of a material fact or failure to disclose a material fact in breach of a fiduciary duty to disclose) or (ii) Insider Trading (misappropriator, tipper, or tippee) 3) In connection with the ACTUAL purchase or sale of securities; 4) the fraudulent conduct involved the use of some means of INTERSTATE COMMERCE (something as simple as the use of the telephone or mail will suffice); 5) with RELIANCE and 6) LOSS CAUSATION.
CON LAW Speech: Validity for Prior Restraints
To be valid, a system for prior restraint must provide the following procedural safeguards: (i) The standards must be NARROWLY DRAWN, REASONABLE, AND DEFINITE; (ii) Injunction must PROMPTLY be sought; and (iii) There must be PROMPT AND FINAL DETERMINATION of the validity of the restraint. Prior restraints are very rarely allowed. The government has the heavy burden of justifying the prior restraint by showing that some SPECIAL SOCIAL HARM will otherwise result.
BUSINESS ASSOCIATIONS RULE 16(b)
16(b) applies to BIG CORPORATIONS: Reporting corporation (1) listed on a national exchange or (2) with at least 500 shareholders AND $10m in assets); and Applies to BIG SHOT DEFENDANTS (Officer, director, or more than 10% shareholder. Provides that a ∆ (officer, directer, or more than 10% shareholder) may NEVER buy or sell stock within a single 6 month period (short-swing trading). Fraud is not required. All "profits" from such "short-swing trading" are recoverable by the corporation. If, within 6 months before or after any sale, there was a purchase at a lower price than the sale price, there is a profit.
CON LAW The ESTABLISHMENT CLAUSE: The "LEMON Test"
The Establishment Clause prohibits laws respecting the establishment of religion. If government action includes a preference for one religious sect over antother, it is INVALID unless it meets STRICT SCRUTINY. If government action does NOT involve sect preference, it is VALID under the Establishment Clause if: (SEX) 1) There must be a SECULAR purpose for the law; 2) The EFFECT must be neither to advance nor inhibit religion; and 3) There must not be EXCESSIVE entanglement with religion.
BUSINESS ASSOCIATIONS Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 (SOX)
SOX provides for the creation of the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board to register public accounting firms that prepare audit reports for companies registered under the 1934 Act. The Board establishes rules for auditing, quality control, ethics, and independence relating to preparation of audit reports. Covers reporting corporations either (1) listed on a national exchange or (2) with at least 500 shareholders AND $10m in assets). CEO and CFO must CERTIFY that based on the officer's KNOWLEDGE, reports filed with the SEC do not contain falsehoods. Gen. Rule: No knowingly false filings and no benefits during falsehoods or blackout periods. Can be punishable by up to 25 years imprisonment.
TORTS FALSE IMPRISONMENT (FI)
To establish a prima facie case for FI, the following elements must be proved: 1) an act or omission to act on the part of the defendant that CONFINES or RESTRAINS the plaintiff to a BOUNDED area; 2) INTENT on the part of the defendant to confine or restrain the plaintiff to a bounded area; and 3) CAUSATION.
TORTS LEGAL REMEDIES in Tort
Damages: D is ordered to pay money to P (compensatory, nominal, punitive). Damages are based on the harm to the P. REQUIREMENTS: 1) CAUSATION (Actual Cause) 2) FORESEEABILITY (Proximate Cause) 3) CERTAINTY (Damages cannot be too speculative) 4) UNAVOIDABILITY (P must take reasonable steps to mitigate damages).
TORTS NEGLIGENCE
The elements of a prima facie case for negligence include: 1) a DUTY on the part of the D to CONFORM TO A SPECIFIC STANDARD OF CONDUCT for protection of P against an unreasonable risk of injury; 2) a BREACH of that duty by D; 3) the breach is the ACTUAL AND PROXIMATE CAUSE of P's injury; and 4) DAMAGE.
EVIDENCE RELEVANCE
Evidence is RELEVANT if it tends to make the existence of any fact or consequence to the outcome of the action more probable than it would be without the evidence. All relevant evidence is admissible if it is offered in an unobjectionable form and manner.
TORTS Negligence: DUTY OF CARE
A duty of care is owed to all foreseeable plaintiffs. The extent of the duty is determined by the applicable standard of care. Therefore, when confronted with a negligence question, always ask: 1) was the P foreseeable? 2) If so, what is the applicable standard of care?
WILLS & TRUSTS What is Undue influence - prima facia case?
Testator has a weakness such that he is able to have his free will subjugated. 1) SUSCEPTIBILITY: Any weakness or predisposition 2) OPPORTUNITY: wrongdoer has access to testator 3) ACTIVE PARTICIPATION: or disposition to exert influence 4) UNNATURAL RESULT: i.e. wrongdoer taking devise were that person would ordinarily take nothing. Effect: only that part of the will affected by undue influence is invalid.
CRIMES Specific Intent Crimes
SOLICITATION: intent to have the person solicited commit the crime. ATTEMPT: Intent to complete the crime. CONSPIRACY: Intent to have the crime completed. 1ST DEGREE MURDER: premeditated intent to kill (defined by statute). ASSAULT: Intent to commit a battery. LARCENY/ROBBERY: Intent to permanently deprive another of his interest in the property taken. BURGLARY: Intent at the time of entry to commit a felony therein. FORGERY: Intent to defraud. FALSE PRETENSES: Intent to defraud. EMBEZZLEMENT: Intent to defraud.
CRIMES 4TH AM
The 4th Am provides that people should be free in their persons from UNREASONABLE searches and seizures.
TORTS Negligence: BREACH OF DUTY
Where D's conduct falls short of that level required by the applicable standard of care owed to the P, she has breached her duty. Whether the duty of care is breached in an individual case is a question for the trier of fact. The main problem relates to proof of the breach . P may use one of the following theories: 1. Custom or usage 2. Violation of Statute 3. Res Ipsa Loquitur (RIL)
CONTRACTS Applicable Law: UCC v. Common Law
UCC applies to sales of goods (moveable, tangible objects) while common law applies to all other types of contracts.
REMEDIES Restitutionary Remedies
These remedies are based on the theory that the D should not be UNJUSTY ENRICHED. Restitutionary remedies are based on the BENEFIT to the D, and the amount is calculated based on the value of the benefit. TYPES: LEGAL: a) Restitutionary Damages b) Replevin c) Ejectment EQUITABLE: d) Constructive Trusts e) Equitable Liens
PROPERTY WASTE
Life tenant MAINTAINS the estate--this expresses both the maximum and the minimum that the life tenant can do on the land. Three types of waste: 1. Voluntary waste 2. Permissive waste 3. Ameliorative waste
CRIMES SEARCH
A search is defined as a governmental intrusion into an area where a person has a REASONABLE and JUSTIFIABLE expectation of privacy.
BUSINESS ASSOCIATIONS Liability of Corporations for actions by a Promoter
The Corporation becomes liable on a promoter's pre-incorporation K when the corporation ADOPTS the K by: a) EXPRESS board of directors resolution; or b) IMPLIED adoption through knowledge of the K and acceptance of its benefits. The Promoter remains liable on pre-incorporation Ks until there has been a NOVATION (i.e., an agreement between the promoter, the corporation, and the other contracting party that the corporation will replace the promoter under the K).
CRIMES ACCOMPLICE LIABILITY: Parties -- Principal
A principal is one who, with the requisite mental state, ACTUALLY ENGAGES IN THE ACT OR OMISSION that causes the criminal result.
CON LAW What are the 4 Justiciability Requirements (required at all levels)?
(1) P must have standing; (2) Case must be ripe for review; (3) Case must not be moot AND (4) It must NOT be a political Q
WILLS & TRUSTS What is incorporation by reference?
Non-integrated writing given testamentary effect if incorporation by reference met. Requires: 1) Doc or writing 2) In EXISTENCE at execution 3) Clearly IDENTIFIED in the will 4) Testator INTENDED to incorporate the doc. NOTE: If 1-3 are met, 4 can be implied.
PROPERTY FUTURE INTERESTS
The INTEREST exists now but possession will not take place--if at all--until some time in the future. Future interests retained by GRANTOR: 1. REVERSION 2. POSSIBILITY OF REVERTER 3. RIGHT OF RE-ENTRY Future interests given to GRANTEE: 1. REMAINDER 2. EXECUTORY INTEREST
WILLS & TRUSTS What are facts of independent significance?
Identity of recipient beneficiary or what gift is intended may be given meaning by facts of significance INDEPENDENT FROM WILL - i.e., to my church. Or to all my employees at time of my death. 1) Must be a fact WOULD HAVE EXISTED even without the will. 2) Can be an event or fact before or after will is drafted Basically allows outside parole evidence to prove what stuff is; facts of independent significance allow us to fill in the blanks to T's will with parol evidence that is trustworthy.
CRIMES ACCOMPLICE LIABILITY: Parties -- Accomplice
An accomplice is one who, with the intent that the crime be committed, aids, counsels, or encourages the principal before or during the commission of the crime.
TORTS NEGLIGENCE PER SE
Negligence per se (aka "statutory negligence") is the legal doctrine whereby an act is considered negligent because it violates a statute (or regulation). In order to prove negligence per se, the plaintiff must show that: 1) the defendant violated the statute, 2) the statute is a safety statute, 3) the act caused the kind of harm the statute was designed to prevent, 4) the plaintiff was a member of the statute's protected class. In some jurisdictions, negligence per se creates merely a presumption of negligence.
PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY DUTY OF LOYALTY: Duty to Avoid Conflicts of Interests
“An attorney may not represent a client if the representation of the client may be materially limited by the lawyer's responsibilities to another client, or to a third person, or by the lawyer's own interests, unless:" (both must be present) i) the lawyer reasonably believes that the representation will not be adversely affected; and ii) the client consents. • must be informed consent • almost always now, consent must be in writing.
CIV PRO In Personam Jxn: Statutory Limitations
Each state may prescribe its own statutory bases for personal jxn, but must still satisfy constitutional requirements. Most states grant courts in personam jxn in 4 situations: (i) where the D is PRESENT in the forum state and is personally served with process; (ii) where the D is DOMICILED in the forum state; (iii) where the D CONSENTS to jxn; and (iv) where the D has committed acts bringing him within the forum state's LONG ARM STATUTES.
CRIMES ACCOMPLICE LIABILITY: Accessory After the Fact
An accessory after the fact is one who receives, relieves, comforts, or assists another, knowing that he has committed a felony, in order to HELP THE FELON ESCAPE ARREST, TRIAL, OR CONVICTION.
CRIMES ARREST
An arrest occurs when the police take a person into custody against her will for purposes of criminal prosecution or interrogation. An arrest must be based on probable cause (PC).
WILLS & TRUSTS What are the requirements of a holographic will? What happens if it is undated?
1) Must be signed by testator. Sig can be anywhere in will. 2) MATERIAL PROVISIONS must be in testator's own handwriting. (gifts made and the beneficiaries) NOTES: a) Testamentary can be preprinted. . .i) if there are issues extrinsic evidence as to intent is allowed. b) Series of letters may be will under integration. c) Date not required. . .i) If conflicts - Dated wins unless undated can be established as after . .ii) If both undated, then unresolved inconsistent is thrown out . .iii) If Testator may have been incapacitated during time will was drafted then invalid.
TORTS Comparative Negligence
A substantial MAJORITY of states now permit a contributory negligent P to recover a percentage of his damages under some type of comparative negligence system. In every case where contributory negligence is shown, the trier of fact weighs P's negligence against that of D and reduces P's damages accordingly.
CONTRACTS K Formation In order to form a valid K, the following elements must be present:
OFFER ACCEPTANCE CONSIDERATION
What is a codicil? What is the major concern regarding one?
Testamentary instrument executed with required formalities of the code, which modifies, amends, or revokes a will. A codicil REPUBLISHES A WILL. Important for: 1) Pour over wills; 2) Incorporation by reference: AND 3) Pretermission (for birth, marriage or domestic partnership) NOTE: codicil itself is a testamentary instrument thus pretermission analysis from date of codicil. (Discuss both on Bar)
TORTS BATTERY
Defendant commits a HARMFUL or OFFENSIVE contact; AND The contact is with the plaintiff’s PERSON. Requires INTENT and CAUSATION.
TORTS Respondeat Superior / Vicarious Liability
Issue: whether the principal will be vicariously liable for torts committed by agent. Two-part test: Principal will be liable for torts committed by agent if: (1) there must be a principal-agent relationship; and (2) the tort must occur within the scope of that relationship.
TORTS ASSAULT
D must place the plaintiff in REASONABLE APPREHENSION; That apprehension must be of IMMEDIATE HARMFUL OR OFFENSIVE CONTACT to plaintiff's person. Requires INTENT and CAUSATION.
PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY DUTY OF LOYALTY: Conflict of Interest: Business Deals with Clients (MR 1.8(a))
When an atty is both a party to the transaction and representing the other party to the transaction it is always suspect. Only if all of the following requirements are met will it be ok: 1) The terms of the transaction must be FAIR and reasonable; and 2) the terms must be DISCLOSED in writing in a manner the client can reasonably understand; and 3) the client is advised in writing to seek the OPINION of another lawyer, and give him the chance to do so; and 4) the client must CONSENT in writing. Mnemonic: "First Discuss Over Coffee."
TORTS Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress (IIED)
∆ must engage in outrageous conduct; AND π must suffer severe emotional distress. Also requires INTENT (or recklessness) and CAUSATION. NOTE: For this intentional tort only, reckless conduct on the part of the ∆ will be adequate. Does not need actual intent.
CRIMES SOLICITATION
Solicitation consists of inciting, counseling, advising, inducing, urging, or commanding another to commit a felony with the specific INTENT THAT THE PERSON SOLICITED COMMIT THE CRIME.
TORTS TRESPASS TO LAND
Physical invasion of π’s real property. Requires INTENT and CAUSATION. o ∆ can enter on foot on in a vehicle. o Π need not know that ∆ crossed the boundary line; intent is satisfied simply by the ∆ stepping foot on the land. o Trespass can also be by throwing a tangible object onto the property (includes airspace and soil).
PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY DUTY OF LOYALTY: Conflict of Interest
A lawyer must not allow her personal interests, the interests of another client, or the interests of a third person to interfere with her loyalty to the client. RULE: If an interest of you, another client, or a third party MATERIALLY LIMITS OR IS ADVERSE to loyal representation, you have a conflict of interest. ***Flag and discuss ACTUAL and POTENTIAL conflicts.
TORTS TRESPASS TO CHATTELS
An act by Defendant that INTERFERES with PLAINTIFF'S RIGHT OF POSSESSION in a chattel. Requires INTENT, CAUSATION, and DAMAGES. o ∆ can damage the personal property item (bend, break, scratch, etc.) o Take it away. Owner has an exclusive right of possession, so if you take it away, it constitutes interference. What tort has been committed? o It depends on the degree of interference: if the interference is small, minor, or slight, then it is a TRESPASS TO CHATTELS. o By contrast, the big harm would be CONVERSION. Recovery: FMV of property for CONVERSION; Cost of repair for TRESPASS TO CHATTELS.
REMEDIES Permanent Injunction Mnemonic
"I'll Put Five Bucks Down" I -- Inadequate legal remedy P -- Property Right / Protectible Interest F -- Feasibility of Enforcement B -- Balancing of Hardships D -- Defenses
CIV PRO PERSONAL JXN: Minimum Contacts
International Shoe requires that the D have "such minimum contacts" with the forum that the exercise of jxn would be fair and reasonable. Look to 2 factors: purposeful availment and foreseeability. There must be a relevant tie between ∆ and the forum state.
TORTS SELF-DEFENSE
When a person REASONABLY BELIEVES that she is being (or is about to be) attacked, she may use such force as is reasonably necessary to protect against injury. DEGREE OF FORCE: must be a degree of force REASONABLY necessary to respond to the threat (rule of proportionality). Self-defense is usually not available to the initial aggressor. A reasonable MISTAKE as tot he existence of the danger is allowed.
PROPERTY JOINT TENANCY (JT)
The 4 UNITIES must be persent at the outset in order to create a JT (T-TIP Test): 1. Unity of TIME. All JT interests must have vested at the same time. 2. Unity of TITLE. The grant to all JTs must be the same instrument (e.g., one deed). 3. Unity of INTEREST. All JTs must take the same kind and the same amount of interest. 4. Unity of POSSESSION. All JTs must have identical rights of possession. General RULE: To create a JT, the language of conveyance must clearly reflect the grantor's INTENT to create a JT. Under the Majority Rule today, certain magic words must be used: --"as joint tenants, with right of survivorship" or "in joint tenancy with right of survivorship." The JT carries a RIGHT OF SURVIVORSHIP. The surviving tenants take automatically on the death of a JT.
REMEDIES Remedies for Personal Property
DESTROYED PROPERTY: --Compensatory Damages DAMAGED PROPERTY: --Compensatory Damages DISPOSSESSION (most common): --Compensatory Damages --Restitutionary Damages --Replevin --Mandatory Injunction --Constructive trusts/Equitable liens --Self-help (reasonable force to recapture)
CRIMES CONSPIRACY
1) An AGREEMENT BETWEEN 2 OR MORE persons; 2) An INTENT TO ENTER INTO AN AGREEMENT; and 3) An INTENT TO ACHIEVE THE OBJECTIVE of the agreement. Today, a MAJ of the states require an OVERT ACT in furtherance of the conspiracy, but mere preparation will usually suffice.
REMEDIES Remedies for Real Property
SIMPLE TRESPASS: --Nominal Damages --Restitutionary Damages --Injunction (avoiding multiplicity of actions DESTRUCTION/DAMAGE TO REALTY --Compensatory Damages --Injunction DISPOSSESSION: --Compensatory Damages --Restitutionary Damages --Ejectment --Constructive trusts/Equitable liens ENCROACHMENT (common): --Compensatory Damages --Injunction **No restitution NUISANCE (common): --Compensatory Damages --Injunction **No restitution
CONTRACTS OFFER
An offer is a manifestation of an INTENT TO CONTRACT (words or conduct showing commitment). An offer must also have DEFINITE AND CERTAIN TERMS and be COMMUNICATED to the offeree. An offer must create a REASONABLE EXPECTATION in the offeree that the offeror is willing to enter into a K on the basis of the offered terms.
TORTS DEFAMATION
ELEMENTS: (i) DEFAMATORY LANGUAGE; (ii) "OF OR CONCERNING" the plaintiff; (iii) PUBLICATION thereof by ∆ to a third person; and (iv) DAMAGE to π's reputation.
REMEDIES Remedies for Personal Injury Torts
COMPENSATORY DAMAGES: a) Economic Losses/Special Damages (certainty rules apply) b) Non-Economic Losses/General Damages (e.g., pain and suffering -- certainty rules do not apply) c) Lump Sum Payment: Discounted to present value. Inflation not taken into account under traditional view. INJUNCTION (only against prospective intentional tortious conduct).
PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY Duty of Competence (MR 1.1; CA 3-110)
In representing a client, a lawyer must act competently and with the legal knowledge, skill, thoroughness, and preparation that are reasonably necessary for the representation. Elements: o Legal knowledge and skill (In emergency situations, a lawyer may seek assistance, but the assistance should not exceed what is reasonably necessary to meet the emergency) o Thoroughness and preparation o Maintaining competence – continuing legal education (Be up to date with the laws). A lawyer may accept representation where the requisite level of competence can be achieved by reasonable preparation.
REMEDIES Remedies for Fraud
1) Damages 2) Constructive Trusts/Equitable Liens **Always consider whether (i) punitive damages should be awarded AND (ii) if it also could be analyzed as a Ks case.
BUSINESS ASSOCIATIONS Corporate Formation
Corporate formation is "A PAIN": 1) AUTHORIZED SHARES -- the maximum # of shares a corp is authorized to issue. 2) PURPOSE 3) AGENT and address of registered office (registered agent is the corporation's official legal representative). 4) INCORPORATORS (name and address of each) 5) NAME OF CORPORATION -- the name must contain some indicia of corporate stautus.
BUSINESS ASSOCIATIONS The Principal-Agent Relationship In Tort
The Principal-Agent relationship requires: (A) ASSENT -- an informal agreement between the principal and the agent; (B) BENEFIT -- the agent's conduct must be for the principal's benefit. (C) CONTROL -- Principal must have the right to control the agent by having the power to supervise the manner of the agent's performance.
REMEDIES Specific Performance in K
6 part checklist: 1) K is valid / certain & definite terms 2) K conditions of P must be satisfied (P must be able to show her K conditions have been fulfilled--already performed, ready and able to perform, or excused from performing). 3) Inadequate legal remedy alternative; 4 reasons: --Damages are speculative --D is insolvent --multiple suits are necessary --the thing bargained for is UNIQUE 4) Mutuality of Remedy 5) Feasibility of Enforcement 6) Defenses
PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY Duty of Diligence (MR 1.3)
(Duty to pay attention to your client): You have a duty to diligently, promptly, and ZEALOUSLY pursue your case to completion. Diligence is the timeliness aspect of competence. Lawyers are obligated to be diligent in their client’s behalf and are required to be in persistent pursuit of the client’s matter. Once a lawyer takes on a client’s matter, the lawyer must: (i) act on the client’s behalf with reasonable diligence and promptness; (ii) act with dedication and zeal, taking whatever lawful and ethical steps are available to vindicate the client’s cause; (iii) pursue the matter to completion; and (iv) either terminate the relationship or act with the required diligence if there is any doubt as to whether a lawyer-client relationship exists.
TORTS Privacy Tort: INVASION OF PRIVACY
Invasion of π’s physical seclusion in a way that would be highly offensive to the average person. • Warning: π has to be in a place where there is a reasonable expectation of privacy in order for the tort to be committed. • EX: Eavesdropping of your conversation while you are at a restaurant – no expectation of privacy.
EVIDENCE EXAMINATION OF WITNESS: Improper Questions
Misleading Compound Argumentative Conclusionary Assuming Facts Not in Evidence Harassing or embarrassing Calls for a Narrative Answer Calls for Speculation Lack of Coundation Nonresponsive Answer
TORTS Privacy Tort: FALSE LIGHT
The widespread dissemination of a material falsehood about the plaintiff that would be highly offensive to a reasonable person. • Essentially the tort of “gossip” • To proceed in false light, π must prove falsity. Damages are not limited to economic damages, which is why someone may assert it as a second claim to defamation. If it is a matter of public concern, π must show ∆ acted with actual MALICE. ***PRIVILEGES for defamation apply to false light and disclosure. • Ex: Misrepresenting a π’s political or religious beliefs. • Fault not required; reasonable belief is not a defense.
CIV PRO PERSONAL JXN: Purposeful Availment
D's contact with the forum must result from her purposeful availment with that forum. Contacts cannot be accidental. D must reach out to the forum in some way, such as to make $$ there or to use the roads there. The court must find that through these contacts the D PURPOSEFULLY AVAILED himself "of the privilege of conducting activities within the forum state, thus invoking the benefits and protections of its laws." ASK: Has the ∆ purposefully availed himself of the benefits of the State; aiming his behavior at the state? • Look to shipping goods, whether the ∆ makes money from the transactions, etc. • An interactive website CAN be purposeful availment.
WILLS & TRUSTS What is the rule of Lapse?
If beneficiary doesn't survive the testator, the gift lapses and returns the residuary of the estate.
TORTS Privacy Tort: DISCLOSURE
Widespread dissemination of confidential information about the π that is highly offensive to a reasonable person. EXCEPTIONS: • If it is newsworthy information, the media can publish it. • The duel-life fact pattern: stripping to pay law school tuition hypo. ***PRIVILEGES for defamation apply to false light and disclosure.
WILLS & TRUSTS What is CA Anti-lapse statute?
Anti-lapse statute applies where devisee is: 1) Kindred of testator or of testators spouse and devisee predeceases testator 2) Leaving issue. NOTE: The anti-lapse statute applies to both wills and revocable trusts. But the devisee CANNOT be the SPOUSE or domestic partner
PROPERTY DUTIES OF THE TENANT
1. DUTY TO PAY RENT 2. DUTY TO MAINTAIN PREMISES If the lease is silent, the T is still subject to the CL duty not to commit waste. If the lease includes a covenant to repair, an express covenant makes the tenant the absolute insurer of the property. The MAJORITY view is that once the tenant covenants to repair, he is liable for EVERYTHING--including ordinary wear and tear. BUT, if the premises are destroyed without the tenant's fault, the tenant will be under no duty to rebuild the structure. 3. DUTY not to use the premises for ILLEGAL PURPOSES 4. DUTY NOT TO ABANDON THE PREMISES
TORTS ECONOMIC TORTS
• FRAUD – misrepresentation of a material fact, coupled with scienter (∆ made the statement and knew π would rely on it) with the intent to induce the π to act or refrain from acting, that caused the π to rely on that statement, and that π’s reliance was justifiable; and π must suffer actual loss. • NEGLIGENT MISREPRESENTATION –carelessly misrepresenting a fact in a business relationship where someone relies on your expertise • INDUCING BREACH OF CONTRACT -- Persuading someone to walk away from a binding contractual deal. • MALICIOUS PROSECUTION – instituting a lawsuit without any probable cause, for an improper purpose. • ABUSE OF PROCESS – Using a judicial proceeding or judicial process for an illicit purpose.
REMEDIES Specific Performance Mnemonic
"Cha Cha Is My Favorite Dance" C -- Contract is Valid C -- Conditions of P satisfied I -- Inadequate legal remedy M -- Mutuality of remedy F -- Feasibility of enforcement D -- Defenses
CRIMES ATTEMPT
A criminal attempt is an act that, although done with the intention of committing a crime, falls short of completing the crime. Attempt requires: (1) A specific intent to commit the crime; and (2) An overt act in furtherance of that intent.
TORTS CONVERSION
(i) An act by D that INTERFERES WITH P'S RIGHT OF POSSESSION in a chattel; (ii) The interference is SO SERIOUS that it warrants requiring D to pay the chattel's full value; (iii) INTENT and (iv) CAUSATION. Acts of conversion include wrongful acquisition (theft), wrongful transfer, wrongful detention, and substantially changing, severely damaging, or misusing a chattel. The longer the withholding of the property, the more likely it is to be a conversion. P may recover DAMAGES (FMV at the time of conversion) or POSSESSION (replevin).
PROPERTY DUTIES OF THE LANDLORD
1. DUTY TO DELIVER POSSESSION OF THE LEASED PREMISES 2. IMPLIED WARRANTY OF HABITABILITY At CL, there was NO DUTY to deliver the leased premises in habitable condition. Today, there exists an implied warranty of habitability, but ONLY FOR RESIDENTIAL PROPERTIES. 3. IMPLIED COVENANT OF QUIET ENJOYMENT
BUSINESS ASSOCIATIONS CORPORATE FORMATION: Ultra Vires Acts
Activities beyond the scope of a stated business purpose are considered to be "ultra vires." At CL, ultra vires acts were void and unenforceable. But under the RMBCA, ultra vires acts are generally ENFORCEABLE, and the ultra vires nature of an act may be raised in only 3 situations: 1) A SHAREHOLDER may sue the corp to enjoin the proposed ultra vires act; 2) THE CORPORATION may sue an officer or director for damages for approving an ultra vires act; and 3) THE STATE may bring an action to dissolve a corporation for committing an ultra vires act.
PROPERTY Tenant's Remedies for Breach of Implied Warranty of Habitability
1) Tenant can move out AND end the lease (w/ no further lease obligation). OR 2) Tenant can stay on the property AND sue for damages. 3) A growing number of states also allow the T to make reasonable repairs and deduct this cost from future rent payments ("repair and deduct")
PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY Confidentiality MR 1.6
“A lawyer shall not reveal information relating to the representation of a client unless the client gives INFORMED CONSENT, the disclosure is IMPLIEDLY AUTHORIZED in order to carry out the representation or the disclosure is permitted [by an exception]:” Basically, no revealing client information without the client’s consent, unless: • To prevent death or bodily harm • To prevent the client from committing a crime or fraud (But not in CA) • To prevent substantial injury to another’s property (But not in CA) • To secure legal advice about compliance with the rules • To establish a claim or defense on behalf of the lawyer in a controversy between the lawyer and the client, or • To comply with other law or court order
REMEDIES Rescission and Reformation Mnemonics
RESCISSION: "Good Dog" G -- Grounds for Rescission D -- Defenses REFORMATION: "Very Good Dog" V -- Valid K G -- Grounds for Reformation D -- Defenses
PROPERTY Implied Covenant of Quiet Enjoyment
Every lease includes the LL's implied promise not to interfere with the tenant's QUIET ENJOYMENT of the leased premises. This implied promise is included in EVERY lease--residential, commercial, or otherwise. The LL may breach this implied promise in 3 ways: 1) TOTAL EVICTION 2) PARTIAL EVICTION 3) CONSTRUCTIVE EVICTION
TORTS STRICT LIABILITY: Prima Facie Case
For SL, the following elements must be shown: (i) the nature of the defendant's activity imposes an ABSOLUTE DUTY TO MAKE SAFE; (ii) the dangerous aspect of the activity was the ACTUAL and PROXIMATE CAUSE of the plaintiff's injury; and (iii) the plaintiff suffered DAMAGE to person or property.
REMEDIES TORT Remedies
LEGAL REMEDIES 1. Damages RESTITUTIONARY REMEDIES (Legal Restitutionary Remedies) 2. Restitutionary Damages 3. Replevin 4. Ejectment (Equitable Restitutionary Remedies) 5. Constructive Trusts 6. Equitable Liens EQUITABLE REMEDIES 7. Injunctive Relief
TORTS PRODUCTS LIABILITY
Products liability refers to the liability of a supplier of a defective product to someone injured by the product. There are 5 theories of liability that P may use: (i) intent; (ii) negligence; (iii) strict liability; (iv) implied warranties or merchantability and fitness for a particular purpose; and (v) representation theories (express warranty and misrepresentation).
TORTS The Principal-Agent Relationship: SCOPE
The principal is liable for its agent's acts within the SCOPE of agency. FACTORS: 1) Was the conduct "of the kind" the agent was hired to perform? 2) Did the tort occur "on the job"? Frolic vs. Detour 3) Did the agent intend to benefit the principal?
TORTS PRODUCTS LIABILITY: Elements
To find liability under ANY products liability theory, P must show: (i) a DEFECT; and (ii) existence of the defect WHEN THE PRODUCT LEFT D's CONTROL.
REMEDIES CONTRACT Remedies
LEGAL REMEDIES 1. Damages RESTITUTIONARY REMEDIES (Legal Restitutionary Remedies) 2. Restitutionary Damages 3. Replevin 4. Ejectment (Equitable Restitutionary Remedies) 5. Constructive Trusts 6. Equitable Liens EQUITABLE REMEDIES 7. Specific Performance* 8. Rescission* 9. Reformation* *Different from Tort remedies
CIV PRO PERSONAL JXN: Stream of Commerce
Asahi: four justices found that placing an item in the stream of commerce, with the knowledge that it would end up in a particular forum, constituted purposeful availment. Four other justices found that there would also have to be a showing that the D took some additional step to avail itself of the forum.
BUSINESS ASSOCIATIONS Liability of Principle for Ks Entered by Agents
Issue: whether the principal is liable for Ks entered into by its agent. TEST: Principal is liable for Ks entered into by its agent if the principal AUTHORIZED the agent to enter the K. There are 4 types of authority: 1) ACTUAL EXPRESS Authority 2) ACTUAL IMPLIED Authority 3) APPARENT Authority 4) RATIFICATION
BUSINESS ASSOCIATIONS PIERCING THE CORPORATE VEIL
As a general rule, shareholder is not liable for the debts of a corporation. Except: the court will pierce the corporate veil to avoid fraud or unfairness. Courts will pierce the corporate veil for: ALTER EGO (failure to observe sufficient corporate formalities); or UNDER-CAPITALIZATION (failure to maintain sufficient funds to cover foreseeable liabilities). Remember: Courts are generally more willing to PCV for a tort victim than for a K claimant.
BUSINESS ASSOCIATIONS DUTIES of Agent to Principal
In return for reasonable compensation and reimbursement of expenses, agents owe principals: 1) Duty of CARE; 2) Duty to OBEY instructions that are reasonable; and 3) Duty of LOYALTY. The agent may NEVER do any of the following: (i) engage in SELF-DEALING (agent cannot receive a benefit to the detriment of the principal); (ii) USURP the principal's opportunity; or (iii) make SECRET PROFITS at the principal's expense without disclosure.
CONTRACTS ACCEPTANCE
An acceptance must manifest an intent to contract to the terms of the offer and be communicated to the offeror. The offeree exercises the power given her by the offeror to create a contract.
EVIDENCE HEARSAY
Hearsay is "a statement, other than one made by the declarant while testifying at the trial or hearing, offered in evidence to prove the truth of the matter asserted." If a statement is hearsay, and no exception is applicable, the evidence must be excluded upon appropriate objection to its admission.
CRIMES FOTPT: Basic RULE
Basic Rule: In addition to excluding all evidence which has been illegally obtained, any additional evidence acquired either directly or indirectly from the illegal arrest, search, or seizure must also be excluded as tainted "fruit of the poisonous tree." (Wong Sun v. US.)
CIV PRO PERSONAL JXN: Fairness
International Shoe also requires that the exercise of jxn not offend "traditional notions of fair play and substantial justice." FACTORS: --Relatedness of claim to contact -claim arising from activity in the state -systematic and continuous activity in the State --Convenience --Forum State's Interest (in providing redress for its citizens) --Other factors: (i) the P's interest in obtaining convenient and effective relief; (ii) the interstate judicial system's interest in obtaining the most efficient resolution of controversies; and (iii) the shared interest of the states in furthering fundamental substantive social policies.
CRIMES Warrantless Search
Warrantless search is presumptively unreasonable under the 4th Am. unless a SW exception may apply. Exceptions: 1) SITA 2) Auto Exception 3) Inventory/Impound Search (Inevitable Discovery) 4) "Pat Search" of Car
EVIDENCE Statements that are NON-HEARSAY under the FRE
FRE 801(d) provides that certain statements, when relevant, are not hearsay: 1) Prior Statements by a Witness 2) Admissions by Party-Opponent
CONTRACTS Acceptance: The Mailbox Rule
Acceptance by mail or similar menas creates a K at the MOMENT OF DISPATCH provided that the mail is properly addressed and stamped, UNLESS: (i) The OFFER STIPULATES that acceptance is not effective until received; or (ii) An OPTION K is involved (--> an acceptance under an option K is effective only upon RECEIPT). NOTE: because in most jxns a revocation is effective only upon receipt, under the mailbox rule if the offeree dispatches an acceptance BEFORE HE RECEIVES A REVOCATION sent by the offeror, a K is formed.
CON LAW PRIVACY is a FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT - what are the 9 privacy categories that are protected by SDP & the 1 he highlighted as not being protected?
(1) RT to marry (2) RT to procreate (3) RT to custody of one's children. (4) RT to keep the family together (housing) (5) RT to control the upbringing of one's children (6) RT to purchase & use contraceptives (7) RT to abortion (undue burden test) (8) RT to engage in private consensual homosexual activity (9) RT to refuse medical treatment BUT NO RT to physician - assisted suicide
CONTRACTS CONSIDERATION
Consideration is a BARGAINED FOR EXCHANGE whereby there is a DETRIMENT AND BENEFIT flowing from each party to the other. LONG RULE: Two elements are necessary to constitute consideration: (i) there must be a BARGAINED FOR EXCHANGE between the parties; and (ii) that which is bargained for must be considered of LEGAL VALUE or, put differently, it must constitute a benefit to the promisor OR a detriment to the promisee. Detriment is determined by whether an exchange contains legal value.
COMMUNITY PROPERTY QUASI-COMMUNITY PROPERTY (QCP)
Property that would have been community property if the parties had been CA domiciliaries at the time of acquisition.
COMMUNITY PROPERTY QUASI-MARITAL PROPERTY (QMP)
Applies to putative spouses. Putative spouses are spouses who think that they are legally married (and actually tried to get legally married) but for whatever reason they actually are not.
CRIMES INSANITY: M'Naughten
D is entitled to an acquittal if the proof establishes that: a) a DISEASE of the mind b) CAUSED A DEFECT of reason c) such that the defendant LACKED THE ABILITY AT THE TIME of his actions to either: (1) know the WRONGFULNESS of his actions; or (2) understand the NATURE AND QUALITY of his actions.
PROPERTY 4 Requirements to Enforce a RESTRICTIVE COVENANT
1) INTENT -- The parties must intend that the restriction run with the land. 2) NOTICE -- The person must have either actual, constructive or inquiry notice. 3) TOUCH AND CONCERN -- (RULE) If the performance of the covenant makes that land more valuable or more useful, the covenant touches and concerns the land. NOTE: covenants not to compete DO touch and concern the land. 4) PRIVITY -- Horizontal and Vertical.
CONTRACTS DEFENSES to Consideration
1. Absence of Mutual Assent 2. Absence of Consideration 3. Public Policy Defenses -- Illegality 4. Lack of Capacity 5. Defenses to Enforcement (i) Statute of Frauds (ii) Unconscionability
PROPERTY Determining PRIVITY in a RESTRICTIVE COVENANT
BURDEN: Successor-in-Interest is the DEFENDANT--requires both: a) VERTICAL PRIVITY -- refers to those who subsequently obtain the property subject to the covenant. They must take the FULL ESTATE. b) HORIZONTAL PRIVITY -- refers to the original parties to the peromise. They must share some interest in the land independent of the covenant. To establish horizontal privity, there must be a conveyance of the property between the original properties. BENEFIT: Successor-in-Interest is PLAINTIFF: a) VERTICAL PRIVITY -- On the benefit side, the general rule is that the holder of any succeeding possessory estate may enforce the benefit of the promise as a covenant at law. 2) NO horizontal privity is required to enforce the benefit of a restrictive covenant.
WILLS & TRUSTS Dependent Relative Revocation (RULE)
1) If testator revokes her will, or a portion thereof, 2) in the MISTAKEN belief that a substantially identical will or codicil effectuates her intent, 3) then, by operation of law, 4) the revocation of the first will be deemed conditional, dependent, and relative to the second effectuating testator's intent. 5) If the second does not effectuate testator's intent, the first (by pure legal fiction) was never revoked.
CRIMES EXCLUSIONARY RULE
The exclusionary rule prohibits the introduction, at criminal trial, of evidence obtained in violation of a D's 4th, 5th, or 6th Amendment rights.
PROPERTY EQUITABLE SERVITUDES: 3 Requirements to Obtain an INJUNCTION to Enforce the Burden of the Promise
1) INTENT that the restriction be enforceable by successors-in-interest; 2) The restriction must TOUCH and CONCERN the land; 3) NOTICE to the subsequent purchaser (actual, constructive, or inquiry). NO PRIVITY of any kind is required to enforce the promise in equity as an equitable servitude.
WILLS & TRUSTS W&T Essay CHECKLIST
WILLS: 1. Execution of wills 2. Revocation of wills 3. Components of wills (integration, republication by codicil, incorporation by reference, acts of independent significance) 4. Interpretation of wills 5. Intestate succession 6. Rights of surviving spouse and children (pretermitted) 7. Bars to succession (homicide, elder abuse, no contest clause) TRUSTS: 1. Creation of a valid trust (7 elements) 2. Types of Trusts (discretionary, mandatory, spendthrift, honorary, secret, semi-secret, revocable, totten, charitable) 3. Modification and termination of trusts 4. Trust administration and Trustees Duties
COMMUNITY PROPERTY SEPARATE PROPERTY (SP)
All property owned by a person before marriage All property acquired by gift, devise, bequest, or descent All property acquired by rent, issues, and profits of SP
WILLS & TRUSTS Creation of a Valid Trust (7 elements)
1. Settlor/trustor 2. Delivery 3. Trustee 4. Intent 5. Trust Property (Res) 6. Beneficiaries 7. Valid Trust Purpose (cannot violate law or public policy)
PROPERTY EQUITABLE SERVITUDES: Requirements to Establish a Mutual Right of Enforcement
1. An INTENT to impose a SERVITUDE (a restriction on use) on ALL land in the subdivision; 2. NOTICE (actual, constructive, or inquiry); DEFENSES: 1. Unclean hands 2. Acquiescence 3. Laches 4. Estoppel
WILLS & TRUSTS Trustees Duties
1) FIDUCIARY DUTY 2) DUTY OF CARE (Trustee must exercise degree of care, skill and caution of a reasonable person in managing her own property) DUTIES RELATING TO CARE OF TRUST PROPERTY: a) duty to collect and protect trust property b) duty to earmark property c) duty not to delegate investment decisions d) duty not to commingle trust funds e) duty to maintain marketability of trust property f) duty to keep trust property productive g) duty to diversify investments h) duty not to speculate i) duty to account do trust beneficiaries. 3) DUTY OF LOYALTY: a) Self-dealing b) Conflict of interest
PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY Candor Toward the Tribunal MR 3.3
(a) a lawyer shall not knowingly: (1) Make false statements, or fail to correct them (2) Fail to disclose legal authority (3) Offer evidence that the lawyer knows to be false
PROPERTY ADVERSE POSSESSION
Six Requirements: H-E-L-U-V-A 1. HOSTILE (X is on the land with no right to be there) 2. EXCLUSIVE (X must be excluding others from possessing the property) 3. LASTING (The possession must last for the statutory period; CL is 20 yrs) 4. UNINTERRUPTED USE (continuous use that an ordinary owner would make) 5. VISIBLE (open + notorious) 6. ACTUAL [POSSESSION] (X must actually possess the land to obtain title. --The true owner DOES NOT have to know what's going on. --The adverse possessor (X) DOES NOT have to think he owns it (GF/bad faith is irrelevant).
COMMUNITY PROPERTY CP Presumption
Property acquired during marriage is presumptively CP. Think possession vs. acquisition.
Directors' Liability: DUTY TO MANAGE
Directors have a DUTY TO MANAGE the corporation. Directors may delegate management functions to a committee of one or more directors that recommends action to the board.
PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY Advertising
A lawyer is allowed to advertise their services through written, recorded, or electronic communication, subject to limitations: • Lawyer CANNOT make false or misleading communication about the lawyer or lawyer’s services. “False or misleading” = 1) If it contains a material misrepresentation of fact or law, OR 2) Omits a fact necessary to make the statement considered as a whole not materially misleading EVERY written, recorded, or electronic communication MUST include the words “Advertising Material” on the outside envelope (if any), AND at the beginning and ending of any recorded or electronic communication, UNLESS they fit either of the previous exceptions (lawyer, past relationship. Lawyer MAY advertise online IF lawyer is licensed to practice in the state where the ad is initially placed. MUST specify jurisdiction where lawyer can practice.
CIV PRO DIVERSITY OF CITIZENSHIP JXN
Section 1332: Diversity of Citizenship; Amount in Controversy: (a) The district courts shall have original jurisdiction of all civil actions where the matter in controversy exceeds the sum or value of $75,000, exclusive of interest and costs, and is between— (1) citizens of different States; (2) citizens of a State and citizens or subjects of a foreign state; (3) citizens of different States and in which citizens or subjects of a foreign state are additional parties; and (4) a foreign state, defined in section 1603 (a) of this title, as plaintiff and citizens of a State or of different States. [aliens are deemed to be a citizen of the state in which such alien is domiciled] (b) [...] (c) For the purposes of this section and section 1441 of this title— (1) a corporation shall be deemed to be a citizen of any State by which it has been incorporated and of the State where it has its principal place of business... [and] (2) the legal representative of the estate of a decedent shall be deemed to be a citizen only of the same State as the decedent, and the legal representative of an infant or incompetent shall be deemed to be a citizen only of the same State as the infant or incompetent. (d) [...] (e) The word “States”, as used in this section, includes the Territories, the District of Columbia, and the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico.
CRIMES 6th Am RIGHT TO COUNSEL
The 6th Am provides that in all criminal prosecutions, the D has a right to the assistance of counsel. It applies at all CRITICAL STAGES of a criminal prosecution after formal proceedings have begun. The right is violated when the police deliberately elicit an incriminating statement from a D without first obtaining a waiver of the D's right to have counsel present. The 6th Am right has been limited to cases where ADVERSARY JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS have begun (e.g., formal charges have been filed). Thus, the right DOES NOT APPLY TO PRE-CHARGE CUSTODIAL INTERROGATIONS.
PROPERTY PRESENT and FUTURE COVENANTS
PRESENT: 1. Covenant of Seisin 2. Covenant of Right to Convey 3. Covenant Against Encumbrances FUTURE: 1. Covenant of Quiet Enjoyment 2. Covenant of Warranty 3. Covenant of Further Assurances--The "Mop-Up" Covenant BREACH of a Covenant of Title: Where there is a breach of warranty, plaintiff's damages will be limited to the amount of purchase price received by the warrantor plus any incidental damages.
BUSINESS ASSOCIATIONS Directors' Liability: BUSINESS JUDGMENT RULE (BJR)
In managing the corporation, the directors are protected from liability by the BJR. The BJR is a presumption that the directors manage the corporation in good faith and int he best interests of the corporation and its shareholders. As such, directors will not be liable for INNOCENT MISTAKES of business judgment.
CRIMES ENTRAPMENT
Entrapment occurs if the intent to commit the crime originated not with the D, but rather with the creative activities of law enforcement officers. The defense of entrapment consists of 2 elements: 1) the CRIMINAL DESIGN must have ORIGINATED WITH LAW ENFORCEMENT officers; and 2) the D must NOT have been PREDISPOSED to commit the crime prior to the initial contact by the government. If D offers evidence to show these two elements, then the gov't must show predisposition beyond a reasonable doubt.
COMMUNITY PROPERTY Basic CP Essay INTRO Paragraph 1
"California is a community property state. All property acquired during the course of a marriage is presumed to be community property. All property acquired before marriage or after permanent separation is presumed to be separate property. In addition, any property acquired by gift, bequest, devise or descent is presumed to be separate property."
CRIMES BATTERY
Battery is an unlawful application of force to the person of another resulting in either bodily injury or an offensive touching. Need not be intentional; force need not be applied directly. Consent is a defense only to simple battery (e.g., medical operation).
CRIMES 5TH AM (MIRANDA)
The 5th Am provides that no person shall be compelled to be a witness against himself. Interpreted to mean that a person shall not be compelled to give self-incriminating testimony
BUSINESS ASSOCIATIONS Directors' Liability: FIDUCIARY DUTY
Despite protection presumed from the business judgment rule, directors are FIDUCIARIES who owe duties of CARE and LOYALTY.
CRIMES ASSAULT
An assault is either: (i) an ATTEMPT TO COMMIT A BATTERY; or (ii) the INTENTIONAL CREATION--other than by mere words--of a REASONABLE APPREHENSION in the mind of the victim of imminent bodily harm.
CRIMES MIRANDA: When Required
Anyone in police CUSTODY and accused of a crime, no matter how minor a crime, must be given Miranda warnings PRIOR TO INTERROGATION by the police.
CON LAW What is the 3 part test for determining whether something qualifies as OBSCENE?
MUST meet ALL of these requirements: (1) The material must appeal to the prurient interest (= shameful or morbid interest in sex) (2) Material must be patently offensive under the law prohibiting obscenity (ANY law must delineate which depictions would qualify as patently offensive) (3) Taken as a whole, the material must lack serious redeeming artistic, literary, political or scientific value (= value determined by a NATIONAL standard & NOT a local value)
BUSINESS ASSOCIATIONS Directors' Liability: DUTY OF CARE
RULE: A director owes the corporation a duty of care. She must act with the care that a PRUDENT person would use with regard to her own business, unless the Articles have limited director liability for a breach of the duty of care. EXAM ANSWER: Directors have a duty to manage. They are protected by the BJR, but they are fiduciaries who have duties of care and loyalty. Directors must act with prudence unless the articles have limited liability or a duty of care.
COMMUNITY PROPERTY Basic CP Essay INTRO Paragraph 2
"In order to determine the character of any asset, courts will trace back to the source of funds used to acquire the asset. A mere change in form of an asset does not change its characterization. With these basic principles in mind, we can now turn to the specific items of property involved in this instance."
CRIMES MURDER
Murder is the unlawful killing of another human being with malice aforethought. Malice aforethought may be express or implied.
BUSINESS ASSOCIATIONS Directors' Liability: DUTY OF LOYALTY
RULE: A director owes the corporation a duty of loyalty. A director may not receive an UNFAIR benefit to the detriment of the corporation or its shareholders, UNLESS there has been material DISCLOSURE and INDEPENDENT RATIFICATION. Types: A. SELF-DEALING B. USURPING CORPORATE OPPORTUNITIES C. RATIFICATION EXAM ANSWER: Directors have a duty to manage. They are protected by the BJR, but they are fiduciaries who have duties of care and loyalty. Directors may not receive an unfair benefit unless there has been disclosure, plus independent ratification.
EVIDENCE HEARSAY EXCEPTIONS -- Residual "Catch All" Exception
The FRE provides a general catch-all exception of hearsay statements not covered by specific exceptions. There are 3 requirements: 1) "TRUSTWORTHINESS" -- Statement must have "circumstantial guarantees of trustworthiness'" that are equivalent to those of statements admitted under other hearsay exceptions. 2) "NECESSITY" -- The statement must be offered on a MATERIAL FACT, and must be MORE PROBATIVE as to that fact than any other evidence which the proponent can reasonably produce so that the "INTERESTS OF JUSTICE" will be served by its admission. 3) NOTICE TO ADVERSARY -- the proponent must give notice in advance of trial to the adverse party as to the nature of the statement so that the adversary has an opportunity to prepare to meet it.
CRIMES MURDER: Malice Aforethought
In the absence of facts excusing the homicide or reducing it to VM, malice aforethought exists if the D has any of the following states of mind: (i) Intent to kill (express malice); (ii) Intent to inflict GBI; (iii) Reckless indifference to an unjustifiably high risk to human life ("abandoned and malignant heart"); or (iv) Intent to commit a felony (FMR) In the case of (i), (iii), or (iv), the malice is IMPLIED.
COMMUNITY PROPERTY Distribution of CP at DIVORCE
"The basic rule at divorce is to divide each community asset equally in kind. Thus, each spouse is given one-half of each community asset."
CRIMES VOLUNTARY MANSLAUGHTER (VM)
VM is an intentional killing distinguishable from murder by the existence of adequate provocation, i.e., a killing in the heat of passion. ELEMENTS: a) the provocation must have been one that would arouse SUDDEN AND INTENSE PASSION in the mind of an ORDINARY PERSON such as to cause him to lose his self-control; b) the D must have IN FACT BEEN PROVOKED; c) there MUST NOT HAVE BEEN A SUFFICIENT TIME to cool; and d) the defendant IN FACT did not cool off between the provocation and the killing.
COMMUNITY PROPERTY Distribution of CP at DEATH
If the spouse dies with a will, the spouse is entitled to dispose of all of his or her separate property and one-half of the community property. If the spouse dies withotu a will, the community property is awarded entirely to the surviving spouse. Between 1/3 and all of the decedent's separate property will be awarded to the surviving spouse depending on whether there are issue or parents surviving.
COMMUNITY PROPERTY QCP: At DEATH and DIVORCE
"At DEATH, the surviving spouse has a 1/2 interest in the QCP titled in the decedent's name. The decedent does not have an interest in the QCP titled in the survivor's name." "At DIVORCE, QCP is treated exactly like CP."
CRIMES INVOLUNTARY MANSLAUGHTER (IVM)
There are two types of IVM: 1) Criminal Negligence 2) "Unlawful Act" Manslaughter
CONTRACTS BREACH
When a party fails to perform materially by the terms of the K he is in breach. The nonbreaching party may seek damages.
CON LAW What are the boundaries of congressional action under the Commerce Clause after Lopez? (3 rules)
1. Congress may regulate the CHANNELS of interstate commerce 2. Congress may regulate the INSTRUMENTALITIES of interstate commerce, and persons or things in interstate commerce; OR 3. Congress may regulate ECONOMIC ACTIVITIES that have a SUBSTANTIAL EFFECT on interstate commerce In area of non-economic activity, a substantial effect cannot be based on cumulative impact – Morrison (VAWA) Wickard v. Filburn – cumulative impact of economic activity, even if it’s for individual use, falls under the Commerce Clause
CRIMES FALSE IMPRISONMENT (FI)
The CL misdemeanor of FI consisted of: (i) unlawful (ii) confinement of a person (iii) without his valid consent.
COMMUNITY PROPERTY Treatment of QCP at DEATH
For every asset of QCP, there is an acquiring spouse and a non-acquiring spouse, and QCP is treated like the acquiring spouse's SP during marriage. When one spouse dies, he does not have any rights to the surviving spouse's SP. Thus, when a non-acquiring spouse dies, he has no rights to the acquiring spouse's QCP.
PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY PR Essay Checklist Mnemonic
"Clients Love Fierce Counsel: Courts Feel Differently." DUTIES OWED TO CLIENTS: --Confidentiality --Loyalty --Financial Responsibility --Competence --(and other reasonable things) DUTIES TO ENTITIES OTHER THAN YOUR CLIENT: --Candor/Truthfulness --Fairness --Dignity/Decorum --(and other reasonable things)
CRIMES KIDNAPPING
At CL, the misdemeanor of kidnapping was the forcible abduction or stealing away of a person from his own country and sending him to another. Modern statutes and the MPC extends far beyond this definition. Kidnapping is defined as confinement of a person that involved either: (a) some movement (i.e., asportation) of the victim; or (b) concealment of the victim in a "secret" place.
PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY CONFIDENTIALITY: General Rule
You can't reveal anything RELATED TO THE REPRESENTATION of a client without her consent. The rationale is to maximize candor and trust, allowing the adversarial system to work.
CIV PRO ERIE DOCTRINE
A federal court, in the exercise of its diversity jxn, is required to apply the SUBSTANTIVE LAW OF THE STATE in which it is sitting, including that state's conflict of law rules. However, the federal courts apply FEDERAL PROCEDURAL LAW in diversity cases. First, ask if there is a federal law directive on point (if so, use that). If there is no federal directive on point, ask whether the issue is substantive or procedural. --Substantive --> fed judge must follow state law in a diversity case --Procedural --> fed judge may ignore state law.
CONTRACTS Article 2: WARRANTIES
Ks for the sale of goods automatically include a warranty of title (in most cases). They may also include certain implied warranties and express warranties. WARRANTY OF TITLE & WARRANTY AGAINST INFRINGEMENT: Any seller of goods warrants that the title transferred is good (free of liens or encumbrances). This arises automatically and need not be mentioned in the K. A merchant seller regularly dealing in goods of that kind automatically warrants that the goods are delivered free of any patent, trademark, copyright, or similar claims. But a buyer who furnishes specifications for the goods to the seller must hold the seller harmless against such claims. IMPLIED WARRANTY OF MERCHANTABILITY IMPLIED WARRANTY OF FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE EXPRESS WARRANTIES
CRIMES RAPE
Rape is the unlawful carnal knowledge of a woman by a man, not her husband, without her effective consent. Requires only penetration of the female sex organ by the male sex organ. Today, most states have abolished the marriage exception. Must be without the victim's effective consent.
CIV PRO FEDERAL QUESTION JXN (Section 1331)
The district courts shall have original jxn of all civil actions ARISING UNDER THE CONSTITUTION, LAWS OR TREATIES OF THE UNITED STATES... --fed Q must appear as part of the P's cause of action as set out in a well-pleaded complaint.
CIV PRO VENUE -- In General
Venue in civil actions in the federal courts is proper in: (i) a judicial district where ANY D RESIDES, if all Ds reside in the same state; (ii) a judicial district in which a substantial par to f the events or omissions giving rise to the claim occurred, or a substantial part of property that is the subject of the action is situated; or (iii) if there is no district anywhere in the US which satisfies (i) or (ii), (a) for actions based SOLELY ON DIVERSITY, a judicial district in which any D is subject to personal jxn at the time the action is commenced; or (b) for actions NOT BASED SOLELY ON DIVERSITY, a judicial district in which any D may be found.
CRIMES LARCENY
(Basic CL property offense) Larceny consists of: (i) A taking (caption); (ii) and carrying away (asportation); (iii) of tangible personal property; (iv) of another (v) by trespass; (vi) with intent to permanently (or for a reasonable time) deprive the person of his interest in the property. (e.g., intent to borrow not larceny).
PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY Duty of CANDOR to the court and FAIRNESS to your adversary
A lawyer is prohibited from engaging in conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceit, or misrepresentation. You must refuse to make a false statement of material fact, or offer evidence you know is false to a tribunal, or fail to correct a false statement of material fact or law that you previously made or presented to the tribunal.
CIV PRO CA Long-Arm Statute (§ 410.10)
“A court of this state may exercise jurisdiction on any basis not inconsistent with the Constitution of this state or of the United States.” o CA Statutory analysis: Easy to meet, because the statute reaches the constitutional limit.
CRIMES EMBEZZLEMENT
Embezzlement, variously defined in different jxns, generally requires: (i) the fraudulent; (ii) conversion; (iii) of property; (iv) of another; (v) by a person in lawful possession of that property. Embezzlement did not exist at CL; Modern statutes distinguish between grand embezzlement (a felony) and petit embezzlement (a misdemeanor).
CON LAW What is the Privileges & Immunities clause of Article IV?
No state may deprive citizens of other states of the Privileges & Immunities that it affords its own citizens. An anti-discrimination provision - limits ability of a state to discriminate against out-of-staters. Only FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS (those involving important commercial activities, like the pursuit of livelihood) and CIVIL LIBERTIES are protected.
PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY Duty to state the law truthfully
An attorney who knowingly makes a false statement of law to the court is subject to discipline. An attorney has an obligation to be candid about the law and to cite to adverse authority if it is from a controlling jurisdiction and directly on point.
CRIMES FALSE PRETENSES
False pretenses generally consists of: (i) obtaining title; (ii) to the property of another; (iii) by an intentional (or knowing) false statement of past or existing fact; (iv) with the intent to defraud the other. False pretenses did not exist at CL; Modern statutes distinguish between grand false pretenses (a felony) and petit false pretenses (a misdemeanor). Distinguishable from "Larceny by Trick" by WHAT is obtained. If only possession --> larceny by trick. If title is obtained --> false pretenses.
CIV PRO PERSONAL JXN: Foreseeability
It must be foreseeable that the ∆ could get sued in this forum. • Does the ∆ know or should know that its products could reach the forum state?
PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY PR Essay CHECKLIST
I. ATTORNEY'S DUTY TO THE CLIENT: a) The duty of LOYALTY b) The duty of CONFIDENTIALITY c) The duty of COMPETENCE d) The duty of FINANCIAL INTEGRITY (i.e., fees, client property) II. ATTORNEY'S DUTY TO 3RD PARTIES: a) The duty to OPPOSING PARTIES in litigation b) The duty to ACCEPT REPRESENTATION c) The special duty of PROSECUTORS III. ATTORNEY'S DUTY TO THE COURT: a) The duty of CANDOR b) The duty of HONESTY c) The duty to WITNESSES and JURORS IV. ATTORNEY'S DUTY TO THE PROFESSION: a) The duty to avoid UNAUTHORIZED PRACTICE OF LAW b) The duty to avoid false or misleading ADVERTISEMENTS c) The duty to not improperly SOLICIT clients
CRIMES ROBBERY
Robbery is a felony in all jxns and consists of: (i) a taking; (ii) of personal property of another; (iii) from the other's person or presence; (iv) by force or intimidation; (v) with the intent to permanently deprive him of it.
CON LAW When does a state law violate the DORMANT COMMERCE CLAUSE? Exceptions?
If a law burdens interstate commerce, it violates dormant commerce clause UNLESS that law is necessary to achieve an important government purpose. Helping in-staters at out-of-staters expense is NEVER an important government purpose State has to show the law is necessary: has to show there is no less discriminatory way to achieve the objective. EXCEPTION 1: Congressional approval EXCEPTION 2: the market participant exception. (A state or local government may prefer its own citizens in receiving benefits from government programs or in dealing w/ government-owned businesses)
PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY CONFLICT OF INTEREST: Actual Conflict
When two clients’ interests are in present and actual conflict, the attorney cannot continue to represent both parties.
CRIMES BURGLARY (CL)
CL burglary is: (i) a breaking; (ii) and entering; (iii) of the dwelling; (iv) of another; (v) at nighttime; (vi) with the intent of committing a felony therein.
PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY CONFLICT OF INTEREST: Potential Conflict
A lawyer may represent two clients in a civil litigation if their interests are only potentially in conflict, provided the lawyer reasonably believes that he can represent both clients effectively and obtains the consent of both clients after consultation.
CONTRACTS Ks Essay Checklist
"Armadillos From Texas Play Rap, Eating Tacos." A -- Applicable Law F -- Formation of Ks T -- Terms of the K P -- Performance R -- Remedies for Unexcused Nonperformance E -- Excuse of Nonperformance T -- Third-Party Problems
CIV PRO PERSONAL JXN: Relatedness
Relatedness between the contact and the π’s claim. Quality of D’s contact with the forum. Ask: Does the π’s claim arise from the ∆’s contact with the forum? --Where the claim is related to the ∆’s contact with the forum, it is called specific jurisdiction. --If the claim does not arise from the ∆’s contact with the forum, then jurisdiction is ONLY OK if the court has general personal jurisdiction. To have this, ∆ must have CONTINUOUS AND SYSTEMATIC TIES with the forum state. --Examples of systematic ties: domicile, incorporation, major facilities there, etc.
CRIMES ARSON
At CL, arson consists of: (i) the malicious; (ii) burning; (iii) of the dwelling; (iv) of another. Burning = blackening or charring of structure; mere blackening by smoke or discoloration by heat is not sufficient. Modernly, expanded to include things like exposions. Malice required.
CIV PRO PERSONAL JXN: Convenience
Convenience: ∆ may complain that the forum makes it tough to litigate because it is far from the ∆’s home and it may be tough to get ∆’s witnesses and evidence to the forum. Standard: the forum is OK unless it puts ∆ at a SEVERE DISADVANTAGE IN THE LITIGATION • Relative wealth of the parties is not relevant.
CIV PRO PERSONAL JXN: State's Interest
State's interest is often to provide a forum for its citizens. Ex: The forum state might have an interest in providing a courtroom for its people who are harmed by allegedly careless out-of-state manufacturers.
CRIMES FELONY MURDER RULE (FMR)
A killing during the course of a felony--even an accidental one--is murder. Malice is implied from the intent to commit the underlying felony. Under the CL, the felonies included are BARRK To convict a D of FM, the prosecution must prove that he committed the underlying felony. So, if he has a substantive defense to the underlying felony, he has a defense to FM. CAUSATION required. D's conduct must he the cause-in-fact of the result; i.e., the result would not have occurred BUT FOR the D's conduct. Year and a day rule (CL) Remember, Intervening acts break the chain of causation.
CON LAW What is the SUPREMACY CLAUSE?
Constitution, and laws and treaties made pursuant to it, are the supreme law of the land. (eg, Federal law WINS every time)
CIV PRO PERSONAL JXN: Summary of Constitutional Test
“My Parents Frequently Forgot to Read Children’s Stories” • Minimum Contacts o Purposeful Availment o Foreseeability • Fair Play & Substantial Justice o Relatedness of contact and claim o Convenience o State’s Interest
CIV PRO The CLASS ACTION
Representative(s) sues on behalf of class members. Must initially demonstrate ALL of these: (1) NUMEROSITY: too many class members for practicable joinder; (2) COMMONALITY: There are some question of law or fact in common to class; (3) TYPICALITY: Rep's claims/defenses typical of those of the class; and (4) REPRESENTATIVE IS ADEQUATE: Rep will fairly and adequately represent class.
CON LAW RATIONAL BASIS TEST
RATIONALLY RELATED to a LEGITIMATE government interest. (actual purpose need not be legitimate; must only be conceivable). Gov. usually wins. The law us usually valid unless it is ARBITRARY or IRRATIONAL. Challenger has the burden of proof.
CON LAW INTERMEDIATE SCRUTINY
SUBSTANTIALLY related to an IMPORTANT government interest. --Court looks to government's ACTUAL purpose. --Burden is on the government.
CON LAW STRICT SCRUTINY
Must be NECESSARY to achieve a COMPELLING government purpose. You must find that NO less restrictive alternative could be used to achieve the government purpose. --Court looks to government's ACTUAL purpose. --Burden is on the government.
CON LAW FREEDOM OF ASSOCIATION
Laws that prohibit or punish group membership must meet strict scrutiny. To punish membership in a group it must be proven that the person: (i) actively affiliated with the group; (ii) knowing of its illegal activities; and (iii) with the specific intent of furthering those illegal activities.
CON LAW EPC: Proving a Discriminatory Classification
For strict or intermediate scrutiny to be applied, there must be INTENT on the part of the government to discriminate. Intent may be shown by: (i) A law that is DISCRIMINATORY ON ITS FACE; (ii) A DISCRIMINATORY APPLICATION of a facially neutral law; or (iii) A DISCRIMINATORY MOTIVE behind the law. NOTE: The third is the most difficult to prove. A discriminatory EFFECT alone is not enough. The legislature's discriminatory motive must be shown (e.g., by evidence of a history of discrimination).
CON LAW Restrictions on Speech in Limited Public Forums and Non-Public Forums
Speech and assembly can be more broadly regulated in limited public forums (e.g., military bases and schools when classes are in session) and nonpublic forums. The Gov't can regulate speech in such a forum to reserve the forum for its intended use. Regulations are valid if they are: (i) VIEWPOINT NEUTRAL; and (ii) REASONABLY RELATED TO A LEGITIMATE government purpose (rational basis).
BUSINESS ASSOCIATIONS Rule 10b-5 Elements
1) FRAUDULENT CONDUCT: a) SCIENTER -- an intent to deceive; b) DECEPTION -- an intent to defraud by: (i) Lying (misrepresentation of a material fact or failure to disclose a material fact in breach of a fiduciary duty to disclose) or (ii) Insider Trading (misappropriator, tipper, or tippee) 3) In connection with the ACTUAL purchase or sale of securities; 4) the fraudulent conduct involved the use of some means of INTERSTATE COMMERCE (something as simple as the use of the telephone or mail will suffice); 5) with RELIANCE and 6) LOSS CAUSATION.
CON LAW Speech: Validity for Prior Restraints
To be valid, a system for prior restraint must provide the following procedural safeguards: (i) The standards must be NARROWLY DRAWN, REASONABLE, AND DEFINITE; (ii) Injunction must PROMPTLY be sought; and (iii) There must be PROMPT AND FINAL DETERMINATION of the validity of the restraint. Prior restraints are very rarely allowed. The government has the heavy burden of justifying the prior restraint by showing that some SPECIAL SOCIAL HARM will otherwise result.
BUSINESS ASSOCIATIONS RULE 16(b)
16(b) applies to BIG CORPORATIONS: Reporting corporation (1) listed on a national exchange or (2) with at least 500 shareholders AND $10m in assets); and Applies to BIG SHOT DEFENDANTS (Officer, director, or more than 10% shareholder. Provides that a ∆ (officer, directer, or more than 10% shareholder) may NEVER buy or sell stock within a single 6 month period (short-swing trading). Fraud is not required. All "profits" from such "short-swing trading" are recoverable by the corporation. If, within 6 months before or after any sale, there was a purchase at a lower price than the sale price, there is a profit.
CON LAW The ESTABLISHMENT CLAUSE: The "LEMON Test"
The Establishment Clause prohibits laws respecting the establishment of religion. If government action includes a preference for one religious sect over antother, it is INVALID unless it meets STRICT SCRUTINY. If government action does NOT involve sect preference, it is VALID under the Establishment Clause if: (SEX) 1) There must be a SECULAR purpose for the law; 2) The EFFECT must be neither to advance nor inhibit religion; and 3) There must not be EXCESSIVE entanglement with religion.
BUSINESS ASSOCIATIONS Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 (SOX)
SOX provides for the creation of the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board to register public accounting firms that prepare audit reports for companies registered under the 1934 Act. The Board establishes rules for auditing, quality control, ethics, and independence relating to preparation of audit reports. Covers reporting corporations either (1) listed on a national exchange or (2) with at least 500 shareholders AND $10m in assets). CEO and CFO must CERTIFY that based on the officer's KNOWLEDGE, reports filed with the SEC do not contain falsehoods. Gen. Rule: No knowingly false filings and no benefits during falsehoods or blackout periods. Can be punishable by up to 25 years imprisonment.