Zoos Vs Hutchins

Both of the articles that we read over the past few days had completely different opinions. The first article was about how most zoos lie about them being dedicated to wildlife conservation, public education, and animal welfare, and that zoos are only interested in personal financial gain. The second article, written by Hutchins, was about zoos improving the care that they give to the animals and that animals now have a much better life than that they would have had in the wild. Laidlaw’s article had many detailed facts and examples, and was very convincing. However, I side more with Hutchins’ article rather than Laidlaw’s. I find it hard to believe that zoos have not improved their ways over the past few decades. Hutchins article recognizes …show more content…
In the world there are many people that are selfish and only see themselves. However, there are also many individuals who are selfless and kind. In the article, Laidlaw greatly expresses how zoos are only interested in personal financial gain, and not about the animals. I find this hard to believe as people who go into the zoo industry likely have had some experience with animals, and they can’t be going in because they hate animals. Most people choose jobs which they love. If someone hates animals, then they shouldn’t go into the zoo business. Also, in this modern age, individuals are taught to be selfless and giving and not selfish or hateful. Furthermore, Laidlaw supports his argument that zoos are not educating the population properly with “In fact, viewing animals in cages may be counterproductive educationally by conveying the wrong kinds of messages...”. I agree with Laidlaw that viewing animals in cages may be send the wrong message, especially to young children who don’t know better. However, he also states that this is “[viewing animal in cages is] the primary vehicle of education in most zoos”, which I disagree with. I have not been to zoos often, but when I have I have never witnessed animals in cages, particularly not the generic metal bar cages that are often seen in movies. Animals are kept in natural exhibits, with glass or open areas for viewing. Laidlaw eventually concluded that zoos should either improve their bad habits, or face losing their jobs. I am in agreement with this statement, however, I feel that most zoos do not have to face this choice as they are doing fine as it