White Collar Criminal Case Study

Great Essays
Introduction
In this essay, I will be specifically discussing the disparities between “White-Collar Criminals” and “Street Criminals” within the United States Justice System. In the United States, “White Collar Criminals” are 33.4% less likely to be convicted of their crimes than “Street Criminals”. (Van Slyke and Bales 2012) In other words, “White Collar Criminals” have an unprecedented advantage in the Justice System. In a review of the U.S Sentencing Commission’s White-Collar Sentencing Guidelines and Loss Data, Mark Allenbaugh found that fraud sentences remain the second lowest average behind immigration charges. In comparison, the findings reveal that the average sentence for fraud charges fall at around 24 months, whereas the average
…show more content…
He claimed that the type of person who perpetrates this crime is a member of the upper class whose crimes were often disregarded by the Justice System. Sutherland described this person as being of high financial and political power and did not possess the traits commonly associated with deviant behaviour, such as a low socioeconomic level, sociopathic or psychopathic behaviour. (Reurink 2016) Since Sutherland’s classification more research has been conducted in “White-Collar Crime”. A study, headed by Stant Wheeler at Yale University concluded that most “White-Collar Crime” cases were perpetrated by members of the middle class who had abused their positions in their jobs. Therefore, the modern definition of “White-Collar Crime” is an illegal or unethical act in the financial sector that violate the public’s trust, committed by an individual or a cooperation, perpetrated by an individual(s) of a high social status for personal or corporate gain. (Reurink 2016) The definition for “Street Crime” has remained unchanged and is defined as an illegal activity usually involving theft, violence, illegal trade of prohibited items, etc. Commonly perpetrated by an individual(s) of lower socioeconomic …show more content…
While it is believed that many fear violent crimes, there is a growing desire to punish those who commit “White Collar Crime”. In a 2005 Telephone Survey, 60% of the sample responded that the government should dedicate more resources to enforcing and preventing these crimes. (Holdrege, et al.) In result, the public desires “White-Collar Criminals” to be convicted of their crimes at a higher rate. In order to do so, the United States Judicial System needs to conduct more research in unconscious bias on the courtroom and solve the issue of bias enabling individuals to rule in favour of White-Collar

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    According to Brian Payne’s, White Collar Crime, when the term white-collar offender is used, images of offenders from the economic or technological systems are often thought of (Payne, 2013). Crimes that are found in economic systems are those crimes committed by individuals such as stockbrokers or investors working in investment companies or other exchange markets that make investments, purchase materials and secure goods. Some examples include the Ponzi and pyramid schemes, insider trading or market manipulation. Crimes that are found in the technological systems are computer related actions that can sometimes be criminally illegal or harmful. These include software and internet crimes, virus introduction and unauthorized access to a variety…

    • 219 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    As we have learned, white collar crime can be difficult to precisely define and a wide variety of definitions have been looked at in the process. While there is no consensus on one definition, there is agreement among criminologists on the following being indicative of white collar crime including the occurrence of which is in a legitimate context, motivation that is derived from economic gain or occupational success, and a lack of direct, intentional violence (Friedrichs, pg 5). Trust and respectability are also very important terms in relation to white collar crimes that we do not see with conventional crime. An important sociologist, Edwin Sutherland pointed to the violation of trust as an important element of white collar crime and characterized…

    • 1582 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Decent Essays

    For example, robbery, burglary, murder, property, and violent behaviors are blue- collar crimes. Offenders of the blue-collar crimes usually have to come in contact with the victim in court. In a blue-collar crime, the offender is sentenced depending on the charge of the crime. On the other hand, white-collar crimes people with high paid occupations.…

    • 152 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Margolin Vs Novelty Now

    • 1389 Words
    • 6 Pages

    White-collar crime is “a variety of non-violent illegal act against society that most often occur in the business context.” (Kubasek, p.151) One of the white-collar crimes associated with Funny Face and Novelty Now is criminal fraud. Criminal fraud involves several ways in which an individual intentionally uses misrepresentation to gain an advantage over another. Fraud usually has “…the following three elements: (1) a material false representation made with intent to deceive (scienter), (2) a victim’s reasonable reliance on the false representation, and (3) damages.” (Kubasek, p.152) The three elements of fraud are clearly present in this…

    • 1389 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    All fraudulent individuals have three aspects in common: the opportunity to commit a crime, the financial pressure to ignite thoughts to commit a crime, and the rationalization to make a crime seem less ethically incorrect than it really is to commit (Will et al). Barry Minkow, after gaining high power and praise in the market by reporters and Oprah Winfrey herself, had all three of these aspects allowing him to commit his fraudulent white collar crime worth more than $200 million on paper (Ciulla). When Minkow was 16, he started his own carpet cleaning business in his parents’ garage under the name of ZZZZ Best (Ciulla). People viewed Minkow as a prosperous young entrepreneur, but they didn’t know that his carpet cleaning business was all…

    • 637 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Each of these categories listed, share the common factor of using crime to make money. The article The High Life of Crime, by Lynn Rossellini describes the career of criminal, Blane Nordahl. Rossellini gives numerous examples of how Nordahl used exceptional skill in breaking into houses and taking valuable items. Due to this description, Nordahl’s actions clearly fall under the classification of property crime. He used criminal activity for monetary gain.…

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Studies show that the United States of America has become the country with the highest crime rate throughout the world. In many instances in our country, wealthy criminals or those that commit crimes who belong to the upper class society tend to be overlooked or exempt from being punished for their crimes. However, this isn’t the case for the poorer end of the spectrum, when it comes to those less fortunate the criminal justice system tend to deem them as less adequate and their punishments usually end with jail or imprisonment. In Jeffrey Reiman’s The Rich get Richer and the Poor get Prison, he argues that the best way to understand the policies that are correlated with our criminal justice system, we must look at the Pyrrhic Defeat Model.…

    • 1028 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    “The Code of the Streets” written by Elijah Anderson draws a large focus to the differences of labels from a social theory and scientific point of view. It depicts the differences of what one would consider “street” or “decent” (Anderson, 82), “middle to upper class” vs “lower class”. The article considers the “street” class to be the younger generation; these would be the youth who oppose the views of those who live abiding by the law. The “street” often break the law, lack responsibility and have very little respect for authority and often distrust authority figures.…

    • 1425 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In today’s society there has been a focus on a special category of crime. These crimes consist of crime against women (crimes such as date rape, stalking, abuse and etc.), crime against elderly, hate crime (race, disabilities, sexual orientation, ethnicity, and religion), corporate or white-collar crime (crimes committed by respected business men/women in attempt to seek more money and they commit fraud), organized crime (mafia), gun crime, drug crime, cybercrime, and terrorism. These crimes have been a focus for the UCR and NCVS to help and understand what can be…

    • 661 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Prompt #2 The American criminal justice system is meant to be impartial, fair, and universal regardless of the defendant’s race or socioeconomic standing. As Professor Roy stated in his lectures, the foundational principles that the legal system is built upon are to be consistent and logical (Roy). These ideals should be utilized when implementing a consistent sentencing and conviction process.…

    • 928 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Historically, America has been predisposed towards racism against African-Americans. However, Americans, for the past century, have effectively ignored the issues with race that the American society still faces in the criminal justice system. In his TED Talk entitled “We need to talk about an injustice,” Bryan Stevenson addresses the issues with the American criminal justice system by detailing the problems and showing the important role the citizens of American can play. Although the topic is a serious one, Stevenson discusses the issues with elegance and carefulness and is able to effectively persuade his audience. Before delving into the information that Stevenson provides in his speech, it is essential to evaluate the setting that Stevenson…

    • 940 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    (Chen, 2008) As a final point of racial disparity, racial bias can be found in our language, conduct, and policies in our current criminal justice agencies. Prosecutors and even elected officials might feel some sort of connection with the offender, however it is extremely important to detect and correct bias behaviors in all realms of the judicial…

    • 734 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    prisons has received much attention in recent years, but the disproportionate representation of minorities is not limited to adult prisons. It is also found among youth confined in secure juvenile facilities. The crimes for which racial minorities and whites are imprisoned also differ; blacks and Hispanics were much more likely than whites to be imprisoned for drug offenses. This disparity is noteworthy since drug offenses constitute a larger share of the growth in the state prison system today. (Bonczar, 2003) states that there also are substantial racial and ethnic differences in the “lifetime likelihood of imprisonment.”…

    • 1792 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The main motive of white collar crime is money. The consequences of getting caught are heavily weighed by the offender to get the best benefits out of the crime. White collar crime is heavily based on the offender wanting to receive a certain status. This status may be used to be viewed as a person with money or a person with guts to commit this crime. An example of this is the Ponzi scheme.…

    • 2208 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    White Collar Crime is defined as a non violent crime which is committed by respectable individuals in the society. In general, an individual working in government associations such as banks or private sectors such as software companies carries out this type of crime. This is mostly committed by a person having high social status, such as doctors, engineers, and attorneys mainly for financial gain. Some of the White collar crimes include embezzlement, bribery, forgery, tax fraud, and infringement.…

    • 1877 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays