The Wisdom Of Repugnance By Leon R. Kass

Great Essays
What is Wisdom?
What is Wisdom? If one asks, the majority of people will answer vaguely that it is the knowledge gained during a lifetime. However, wisdom is much more than just the knowledge gained. It signifies the accumulation of knowledge, the application of learning, and the personification of God’s will in the creation of the universe. The abstract nature of the word wisdom allows for broad interpretation. For centuries man’s attempts to “Find” himself, posing the question “Who am I?” and “Who do I want to be?” People expressed themselves, physically, spiritually, psychologically and emotionally in order to promote their image, their sense of identity and individualism. Then, if we cloned someone, would not this strip the person of his
…show more content…
The word comes from the Latin root words, “re”, meaning back and “pugnare” to fight. When we use the word repugnance, we do not just mean the feeling of fighting back or resisting, but also a feeling of horror or sickness that causes you to resist in the first place. In the article “The Wisdom Of Repugnance” , Leon R. Kass illustrates that human beings should take a closer look at the greater implications of cloning and not just to do it because we can. Liberals, on the other hand, believe that, “cloning human beings will be an extension of existing techniques for assisting reproduction and determining the genetic makeup of children.” Kass implies, that each of us must find the meaning in why we should not interfere with the divine order that governed creation, by imposing or trying to create something or someone in the likeness of yourself or someone else. For example, “Dolly [the sheep] was, quite literally, made. She is the work not of nature or nature’s God, but of man … What is more, Dolly came into being not only asexually- ironically, just like he [who] calls himself a Lamb, but also as the genetically identical copy (and the perfect incarnation of the form or blueprint)” (Kass 17). We ought to do things the way God intends it. Cloning human beings disrupt the natural flow of God’s will for man, because it was not intended for man to make man in his image. “Know then thyself, presume not God to scan, the study …show more content…
In addition, I found the argument made was informative, intuitive and very convincing. He provides valid reasons why he believes that the cloning of human beings is repugnant, “cloning creates serious issues of identity and individuality. The cloned person may experience concern about his distinctive identity, not only because he will be in genotype and appearance identical to another human. But, in this case, because he may also be twin to the person who is his “father or mother.” It is very hard sometime figuring out who you are as a person, how does scientist expect cloned person to navigate that process. Furthermore, “because of what cloning is, one cannot presume a future cloned child’s consent to be a clone, even a healthy one. Thus, ethically speaking, we cannot even get to know whether or not human cloning is feasible.” Kass argues that there must be boundaries with what mankind can and cannot

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    In the article “Ethical Issues of Cloning” by Rita Putatunda explains about the problems of cloning. Copying the genes and making new reproductions of the human is equivalent to “playing God”. The successful cloning of Dolly (Sheep) in 1997 brings many tension upon society and furthers the possibility of human cloning. However, there is a high failure rate of cloning and it may alter the genes of the cloned animal/human. Putatunda questions that the cloning outcome might act as a unique individual or have to live like a genetic prisoner.…

    • 156 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I understand wisdom to be an achievement or result of getting out of your comfort zone and experiencing something foreign. The thought that wisdom is an achievement parallels with Siddhartha’s view of wisdom by which he left the thought of “teachers” behind and began a new experience. He wanted to be his own teacher and as a result or as an achievement, he found the world to be more beautiful than ever and found “…the secret that is Siddhartha”(Hesse, 36). Wisdom can simply not be taught; it is something that is gained as a result of various life…

    • 343 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Animal Cloning Satire

    • 691 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Cloning is a controversial topic which lies in the morals of the people, the decision to make a mini replica of a preexisting thing in a lab causes a range of reactions. Cloning is considered a type of asexual reproduction, which consists of reproducing DNA. My fascination with human cloning started in sixth grade because of a Novel by Nancy Farmer called The House of the Scorpion, the story is about a young boy who was isolated much of his younger life by a drug lord which is the original copy of the young boy. Matteo the original is over 200 years old because he discovered a way to keep producing clones of himself that provide him with organs and body parts to live forever. The series goes on with the original Matteo dying and by law the clone can inherit the empire of the original, but Matteo is still a copy of the original which means his life is built for destruction and pain.…

    • 691 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Summary/Response: “Human Reproductive Cloning: A Conflict of Liberties.” In this article “Human Reproductive Cloning: A Conflict of Liberties,” Joyce C. Havstad’s conflict is if cloning becomes safe and reliable, people should be able to have reproductive freedom. The author explained that promoters of human cloning know that it may lead to harmful characteristics. Instead of positively promoting human cloning they explain the causes and effects that could take place.…

    • 262 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Currently the creation of cloning remains a debatable and moral disruption issued as unethical to the human race. Cloning takes away the uniqueness of species in the way that two or more people now share the same of everything especially genes which are supposed to be different from person to person. As science becomes more and more advanced, it seems to be taking humanity into science’s control. The issue of…

    • 786 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    What´s Therapeutic Cloning?

    • 2603 Words
    • 11 Pages

    Therapeutic Cloning Although not a very popular topic, the issue of cloning human body parts is very relevant in today’s technological world. In 1996, Dr Ian Wilmut of the Roslin Institute was able to successfully clone a sheep named Dolly. Later, in 1998, Japanese scientists were able to clone mice.…

    • 2603 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There are many other arguments to be made here. Kass should have spent more time on the slippery slope argument or the fact that this is narcissistic and unnecessary. There are too many possibilities for abuse and far too many unknowns. Saying that cloning will result in identity and individuality issues or the dehumanizing of children is simply not a strong enough argument. There is no denying that there is something extremely narcissistic and arrogant about wanting to clone yourself.…

    • 1663 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Pros And Cons Of Human Cloning

    • 883 Words
    • 4 Pages
    • 3 Works Cited

    On the New York Times Gary Rosen wrote an article called what would clones say? In that article he said that “. Critics worry that clones will be grotesque puppets, the manufactured playthings of their creators, lacking all individuality. ”(Rosen, 1). The clones are more likely to be treated like puppets and lab…

    • 883 Words
    • 4 Pages
    • 3 Works Cited
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Or, the cloning of human life forms could be abused for eugenic purposes, for setting up stores for human extra parts, and for the propagation of a superman or a beast like that of Dr. Frankenstein. Along these lines, the cloning of human life form is ethically wrong, not for its own particular purpose, but rather because of conceivable abuses with deplorable results that damage the ethical guideline of non-maleficence and additionally the rule of…

    • 1729 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    If it is these things that make life worth living for an individual than this morality may demand the person give up their very reason of existing. [Ethics A Pluralistic Approach To Moral Theory, Lawrence M. Hinman, page 145] I would ask, how is that for the greater good? Only a number of people would benefit. The subject of cloning leaves me with some interesting questions when it comes to divine command.…

    • 1192 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “There really is no need for human cloning” (Oscategui 1). Scientists and philosophers often debate the issue of human cloning and whether clones possess traits that qualify them as human or not. First, clones display characteristics of humans in the emotional and personality sense, but the purpose of a clone’s life differs from humans. Next, clones lack a biological manner of production, but clones still possess the same body parts and physical characteristics of a human body. Lastly, the unstable process of cloning automatically guarantees the clones who are successfully produced to live a shortened life, although humans also live shortened lives due to illness and disease.…

    • 1106 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The science of human cloning is not the primary aspect of Never Let Me Go (Griffin, 2009), and Ishiguro brings artistic approach with some of the details of how humans are cloned in his novel (Carroll, 2010). Nevertheless, a large number of his questions about the ethics of human cloning are ones that have been raised and wrangled, all things considered, (Harrison, 2005). These ethical questions first came to the well-known consciousness in the 1960s and 1970s, when stem-cell research was first beginning to be conceived, and human cloning started to resemble a genuine possibility (Harrison, 2005). Ishiguro 's novel could apparently be perused as a rejection of the notion that cloning is dehumanizing; indeed, the motivation behind Hailsham…

    • 1209 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    From its first use the explanation of Wisdom has developed in accordance with the progression of the Bible. At first the meaning was vague described as Understanding. Through the commentary of Doubleday readers learn that Wisdom develops to an experience of understanding. This concept is supported by Sakenfeld who also adds that Wisdom is a mediator between humanity and God. It becomes apparent that Wisdom becomes easier to comprehend throughout the New Testament.…

    • 1273 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Cloning human beings is said to not be one hundred percent safe just yet. Over the years, this specific unimaginable creation has caused, for the most part, people to have nightmares about what the future would look like if this were to ever turn into a success. I am part of the multitude who agrees that cloning would possibly erase much of the uniqueness in a human being resulting in loss of individuality and freedom. Each and one of us has the treasure of coming up with genuine ideas without copying entirely from another person’s ideas. Cloning human beings would do the complete opposite taking away that creativity from the individuals mind.…

    • 1302 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ethics Of Cloning

    • 772 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Although cloning has and will accomplish more remarkable feats in the future one must keep in mind that in the wrong hands could result in a moral issue. An example of…

    • 772 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays