Indian Mutiny: The Conflict Between East And West

Improved Essays
The conflict between East and West is Exists throughout the ages , sometimes restless and sometimes intense, this essay is examine the main elements of the two clashes of culture and ideology and used for promote and justify the reasons of mythologies the Indian mutiny from different points of view. It's never been like other days, it was a special day in memory ,and it was not expected for a real historical event to turn into a myth remember for decades, Indian Mutiny has its results and impact on the Victorians in their own homes ,not only on the British community in India, or even on the Indians themselves ,as the first serious attempt for independence from the British presence or uprising in 1857, as a result of the cultural and intellectual …show more content…
This historical case constitutes an important part of the tale of ‘The Sign of Four’ to Arthur Conan Doyle , these events used the dissatisfaction about the wages, lake of opportunities for advancement between the Bengal crowds , the attempts of missionaries to convert the Indians ,and in addition to the case of paper cartridges for the army issue rifles ,which were coated with animal fat , especially pork lard (forbidden to Muslims) or beef tallow(forbidden to Hindus ),the Indian soldiers would have to bite these paper cartridges to open it before loading their guns ,this was against their religious beliefs, the spread of this incident promote the Indian belief that the British are working as missionaries to convert the local population to Christianity, and that what cause culture clash from the point of view of Doyle in his tale{ Nicola j.Watson and Shafquat Towheed ‘Romantics and Victorians ‘ …show more content…
M. Forster in his novel Commented on what he has seen in India about the impossibility of a particular composition of friendship between the various races and he saw this as a British colony during the British rule of India. https://books.google.jo/books?id=T7V4eGIck3IC&pg=PA27&lpg=PA27&dq=culture+clash+e.m+forster&source=bl&ots=C3dCuuuER_&sig=nbqD42tctDIW3iJtHW-ud8gGdcE&hl=ar&sa=X&ved=0CBwQ6AEwAGoVChMItoOJwNT4xgIViA3bCh3L0gPD#v=onepage&q=culture%20clash%20e.m%20forster&f=false

In conclusion it appears to us a clear divergence in opinions and views on the intellectual and cultural East-West conflict and how the ideological and cultural clashes had been utilized to convert historic event ,the Indian Mutiny ,and transmits it to the myth of the generations till the present days ,and its effect on the Victorians not only in India but also inside their own homes in Britain

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Bal Gangadhar Tilak publicly spoke out against their oppression with speeches calling for no more ¨fighting beyond the frontiers of India with Indian blood and money¨ (Document 6). The independence movement began peaceful but as Britain continually abused their resources and people the movement became violent. The Sepoy mutiny began after the British forced the Indians to use a weapon which required them to use a meat that was against their religion. When they refused Indians began to attack British soldiers to try and force them to leave. After the mutiny failed Mohandas K. Gandhi advocated for ¨passive resistance¨ or ¨securing rights by personal suffering,¨ to achieve Indian self-rule (Document 7).…

    • 857 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Church of Please and Thank You “One of the big moments in the spread of English took place in India in 1835. [British politician] Thomas Babington Macaulay proposed that English be used to create a class of Indian middlemen who would be sympathetic to British interests, without the necessity of large numbers of British citizens coming out and running the show” (Traves 102). As you can see, English has impacted different cultures over the years. As English continues to grow over time, English has become a way to communicate with foreigners to gain business. However, it can be a way to have less cultural differences.…

    • 1630 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Even though the British provided the Indians with advanced technology and education, Imperialism within India was mostly negative because of famine, the Sepoy Mutiny, and their bad regimen or bad treatment towards them. First and Foremost in India there was famine due to imperialism. The more cotton that was being grown, the more famine deaths there were. For example, in document 3 according to the chart it shows that between 1876-1879 there were between 6.1 million- 10 million famine deaths.…

    • 605 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Both Gandhi and Hitler were influential people. Although Gandhi was from India and Hitler was from Germany, they both had a sense of nationalism. Nationalism differed between Gandhi’s India and Hitler’s Germany. This is represented in a few different ways, Including Gandhi’s peace, Hitler’s violence, and their influence of future generations. They had long lasting effects for not only their nation, but the world.…

    • 685 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In the period of British Imperialism specifically during the latter half (1750 until 1857) there were many areas of disagreement between the Indians and the British due to religious and cultural differences. One major controversy caused by those differences was the practice of Sati/Suttee. As is the case in most cultures , religious views justify actions and morals. When one group of people interact with another group of people with a different cultures or religion, there is bound to be disagreement about where north on the moral compass lies.…

    • 1862 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Western Culture Dbq Essay

    • 541 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The people of India had many views on how to handle western culture ranging all way from assimilation to complete rejection. Many things such as religion, social class, and political ideology influenced an Indian’s position on whether to westernize and to what extent. For example, Mohandas Gandhi in a private letter following his experiences living with the peasants of India insisted that all western technologies and customs must leave with the British and all upper-class Indians must give up their wealth and status. The arguments presented in this letter are, like many of his, completely unrealistic and harmful since Gandhi was often overly idealistic and ignorant towards the benefits of British rule (Doc. 4). This view was not a popular one as virtually everyone benefited from these technologies and getting rid of them would send India fifty years backwards and drastically decrease quality of life.…

    • 541 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Andrew Roberts summarizes the British imperialism in India as a positive impact since it led to the technological development of the sub-continent. The European prejudices are deeply embedded in the quote stated by Andrew Roberts. He suggests that Britain was a benevolent colonial power since it led to the “modernization’’ and “development’’ of India. The author showcases strong support towards the British imperialist policies disapproving the Indian perspective. The exchange of goods and ideas(globalization) between the two countries certainly did result in the establishment of the railroad and improved sanitation in India.…

    • 362 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Western Front Mutiny

    • 204 Words
    • 1 Pages

    Introduction - The soldiers along the Western Front were surrounded by corpses, death and disease as well as lice, mud and tough landscapes with no escape from these harsh conditions. Constant trench raids, uninterrupted, continuous storm of bullets and infantry attacks only added to the already emotionally demanding nature of the First World War. These daily hardships pushed men beyond their breaking points, sparking the thought of mutiny in the French ranks. The British military knew that men would become ineffective if kept in the frontlines of the battle for too long so soldiers were rotated in and out of the trenches giving them opportunity to recover and reset themselves as well as a temporary release from numerous, draining conditions,…

    • 204 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The British actually started the chain of events, which led to the independence of India, when they decided to educate the Indians in western fashion with English as the common language. In 1885 the Indians founded the Indian National Congress to campaign for the independence of India. According to Auma Asaf Ali, one of the leaders of the group, "All the leadership had spent their early years in England. They were influenced by British thought, British ideas, that is why our leaders were always telling the British that Mahatma Ghandi is considered the greatest leader to emerge in the anti-colonial struggle and was also educated in Britain. He developed an approach to resistance based on the Hindu philosophy of non-violence.…

    • 1246 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Let’s take a step out of the country, across the Pacific Ocean, trudge against the waves of the Philippine Sea, sidestep through the gulf of Thailand and enter the Bay of Bengal and march north until you touch Indian soil. Now bolt through time to the Indian revolution when British colonial oppression mimicked the oppression in the colonies, when a man was beaten for refusing to give up his seat for a European. Step into that time, when thousands trekked 241 miles to the Arabian Sea, protesting British monopoly on salt, which squeezed the pockets of the poor. The salt march resulted in over 60,000 arrests including their leader Mohandas Gandhi. Gandhi had been a leader in civil disobedience and avid participant.…

    • 798 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    British women in the Raj reaped the benefits of Britain 's rule in India and also had some authority over how Indians would conduct themselves. In this paper I will discuss the role of the British woman in India and how they…

    • 2140 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    During the late 1800s, Western European nations like Great Britain began to use the term imperialism, to justify using their powers over weaker countries around the world. Two countries who were impacted by imperialism were Nigeria and India. Imperialism was very beneficial for the European and American powers, but had a negative impact on the countries who faced this which would lead to issues. One example that gives insight to how India was impacted by Britain’s imperialism, is Dadabhai Naoroji’s speech, “The Pros and Cons of British Rule.” Naoroji, a man born into a prosperous family, left his math career so he can fight for better conditions for India.…

    • 1588 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    India and the UK Two very powerful countries, but there was a time when the British empire used to rule over India (India, Pakistan and Bangladesh). In those decades the UK learnt somethings from India, and India learnt a few things from the UK, while somethings will never change. So in this text I will reflect, compare and share my opinions on the differences and similarities between India and the UK. One huge similarity is the language English. English is growing rapidly all around the world, with well over 900 English-speakers worldwide (as their first language).…

    • 794 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Decolonization of British India In the 20th century, technology was integrating the world web. Politics brought mainly disintegrations reflected in World War I and II. Moreover, the industrial powers involved in those wars lost their empires. A larger burst of decolonization came after 1943, when colonies started to fight for their dependency under the tensions of total war, the diffusion of information in general and the art of political mobilization.…

    • 899 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Thesis: The Indian Independence movement and the American revolution have their similarities and differences. Throughout world history there have been many different revolutions, some being successful and some being total failures, the two I am writing on were successful, and they changed the world as we know it forever. American Revolution: The American Revolution was much more than a revolt against British taxes and trade regulations. It marked the first time in history that a people fought for their independence in the name of certain universal principles such as rule of law, constitutional rights, and self rule.…

    • 1808 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays