Rock Art Essay

Improved Essays
Rock art can be viewed as part of everyone’s cultural heritage or as part of a specific groups’ cultural heritage. It is this difference of thought that can cause much debate on who should have access to and how to manage rock art sites. One way to ensure that the heritage is preserved regardless of what happens to the rock art itself is to record the stories that go along with the art. “Collecting and archiving [stories], with due respect for the traditional owners and in accordance with their wishes about what can or cannot be published, is as much a duty as preserving the art and its natural and archeological contexts” (Clottes, 2008:6). There is just some knowledge that is not meant to be learned or recorded. Indigenous people have the …show more content…
Additionally, Jean Clottes, an advocate for rock art preservation asserts that “it is always advisable, whenever possible, to incorporate local populations in the management and eventual commercial exploitation of the sites and in their conservation” (Clottes, 2008: …show more content…
It is timeless. The mere fact that rock art is still being created today and is still taken care of by indigenous groups all around the world asserts its importance in their everyday life. Not including them in discussions about access and management is not only disrespectful it is also foolish. Groups that consider rock art sites to be a part of their heritage want to ensure that the sites are managed correctly. They hold a stake in the site worth much more than any other party. The opportunity to learn from them, if allowed, would not only enrich the experience of engaging with the rock art, it would also provide valuable information about how the group defines management and access. In developing protocols together, cultural resource managers, governments, and indigenous groups can come up with a plan that is beneficial to everyone. It is essential for all parties to get a deeper understanding of each other’s views in order to not attack one another and produce a successful access and management

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    This job is to educate the students that come to the National Park and teach them about their Ancestors lifestyle and to talk briefly about the engravings. The information they provide is very effective and you would definitely learn about them, through stories that they tell, the engravings and the tools and weapons that they showed which are used to catch food. Overall, Kur Ring Gai National Park is a wonderful and educational place to learn about the Aboriginals way of life and what they did to protect their sacred land and their food. Hope to catch you next time on Clever Man on…

    • 494 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Suzan Shown Harjo’s article “We Are People, Not Property” argues for the respect of deceased Indians in museums, from the archaeologists finding them, and the language they used to house their ancestors. Harjo gives a list of laws that in which she helps fight for. However, there has been a rollback on how Indians are and now she is back to help the issue get resolve again due to archaeologists not wanting to classify Indians properly. The main purpose is to get people to understand the problems they are going through and help them fix it by advocating for the laws of the deceased Indians. Harjo uses pathos, logos, and ethos to ensure the meaning of her article gets across to the readers and help understand how much their ancestors mean to…

    • 1002 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This week’s theme is Ethnic and Tribal Museum. Amy Lonetree’s “Missed Opportunities: Reflection on the NMAI”, she mentions how colonization and museums for the Native Americans experience go hand in hand because it kept Native Americans frozen in a certain time period. “We do not want to make National Museum of the American Indian into an Indian Holocaust Museum… You have to go beyond the story of the tragedy and the travesty of the past 500 years.” (p.637) Their narrative within exhibits should include stories before colonization. The Native American culture has been able to survive assimilation and should be presented in a way that brings pride to their heritage.…

    • 316 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Jeremy Sabloff’s Archaeology Matters: Action Archaeology in the Modern World (2008) is an important text to consider in today’s world, and a text to help us understand how archaeology is not just understanding the past, but it expands on the possibility of helping humans understand our future. Archaeology has a role of not only studying the past, but providing information on how to deal with modern society’s problems. Crucial information can be supplied by archaeologist, who have spent the time researching past societies and we can apply their research to our current world. Sabloff provides ways we can implement archaeology in the 21st century, he acknowledges throughout his book that archaeology is linked with prehistoric and historic items…

    • 910 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Displays of Indigenous “artifacts” in Western museums have long been protested by activists. Critics argue that museums collect sacred and culturally important materials, fail to represent culture properly, and instead offer an unapologetic display of violent colonialism past (Pensley 37). In the poem “how to steal a canoe” by Leanne Simpson, the story of the repatriation of a canoe from a museum by two characters, kwe and akiwenzii, is explored. Simpson’s poem engages with the issue of reclaiming cultural objects and Simpson connect this activism to reestablishment and regeneration of Indigenous identity. This is done through the personification of the canoes and the transformation of the role of the canoe from object to a third character.…

    • 1301 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Heard Museum Analysis

    • 1765 Words
    • 8 Pages

    The Heard Museum The Heard museum was founded in 1929 by Dwight and Maie Heard, and has become internationally recognized for its collections, education programs, and festivals. The museum prides itself on portraying Native arts and culture in a sensitive and accurate way, while telling the story of American Indian people with art. I had no preconceived ideas about the museum, I knew a lot about Native Indians, First Nations peoples in certain tribes, but I also knew there is more to learn, therefore, like in any other new experience, I approached it with an open mind. As the tour began, it was explained that the Native Indians lands in Arizona once encompassed the entire state and more. However, their lands currently only cover a small percentage…

    • 1765 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Prehistoric cave paintings are exactly what the name says, paintings in caves from prehistoric times. They are from a really long time ago and they were the first known from of art by humans. People probably did this when they had some free time and nothing really better to do besides sit around and do nothing.” That is what I thought to myself before watching Werner Herzog’s film Cave of Forgotten Dreams. Many people do not understand the importance of these old pieces of art and what they can tell about past life.…

    • 803 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This period was from the late eighteenth to the mid-twentieth century and was the height of the prohibition of Native cultures. This prohibition consisted of the outlaw of cultural dances and potlatches for Native Americans. This time in history hindered cultural expression, though surprisingly, some did continue to flourish. Consequently, during the post reservation period, after World War II, an extraordinary change took place for the native cultures of North America.…

    • 355 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The interpretation and appropriation of culture within museums came under attack starting in the 1960’s. Native American groups raised questions about the biases and agendas of curators and museums and demanded that their voices be heard in the political arena. Many groups such as _______________ argued that White people were able to tell their cultural stories in museums with limited outside interference from other ethnic groups. However, in museums where Native American people and material culture was on display it was expected and accepted that Whites would interfere and construct their own narrative of Native American life. These groups explained that if Whites are interpreting and appropriating other cultures, then it is actually White…

    • 796 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Agency Theory in Archaeology Contemporary archaeological inquiry has situated itself under the umbrella of anthropology, an open marriage to many different ways of analyzing material culture; as it gives insight to both the physical world, as well as the social-cultural world. In this paper, I will discuss some of the beginnings to this union, and specifically the theory of agency as it relates to archaeological analysis. I enter into the debate among archaeology scholars by proposing that the theory of agency is a useful paradigm to the analysis of material culture, and adds a dimension beyond the artifacts of the past themselves - deepening the analysis and understanding. It is apparent after many years of the development of archeological…

    • 1367 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In my opinion, the purpose of the film "Curse of the Axe", appears to be an attempt to glorify the field of archaeological research. The filmmakers attempted to demonstrate that archaeologists can teach First Nations about their history. This film suggested that the Huron-Wendat had little, to no knowledge about their past. I feel that the filmmakers, even if they depicted an interesting portrayal of pre-colonial Aboriginal history, did so in a biased manner. In contrast to the last chapter of "Ontario Archaeology" which highlighted hostile relations between Aboriginals and archaeologists, the movie made it seem as if Aboriginal communities depend on archaeologists for knowledge of their ancestors.…

    • 766 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Graffiti Is Art Essay

    • 1251 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Graffiti is Art What do you consider art? Someone sitting in front of a canvas with a paint brush painting whatever they imagine. Why don’t you consider graffiti as art when it is the same thing, except that the streets are your canvas and a can of spray paint is your paint brush? Graffiti should definitely be art because there are graffiti museums that sell pieces of graffiti for substantial amounts of money.…

    • 1251 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Living With Art Essay

    • 1510 Words
    • 7 Pages

    According to the text Living with Art by Mark Getlein, there are six primary roles that artists fulfill in society: artists “create places for some human purpose” (i.e. monolithic art as Stonehenge, Gobeki Tepe, churches, etc..), artist “create extra-ordinary versions of ordinary objects” (for instance the World’s largest ball of yarn, or Tintoretto’s Last Supper), artists have been used to “record and commemorate” historical events (such as a wedding photographer or Pablo Picasso’s Guernica depicting the carnage of the civil war of Spain), artists give “tangible form to the unknown” (for instance the abstract and cubist movements of the 20th century, or the design of man-made objects), artists “give tangible form to feelings and ideas” ( works…

    • 1510 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Street Art Essay

    • 1586 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Graffiti was once labeled as street art which was frequently a prominent problem in urban cities; defacing or “tagging” public and private property was against the law. As time as evolved, so has the street art culture. Today, street art is one of most sought after and creative outlets for local artists. The culture around street art can be interesting in the fact that artists build their names and reputation with one piece of work at a time; sometimes when it starts to take over the city it gets the attention it has been wanting. Street art is now very innovative featuring many different art styles and often makes a commentary on a social issue and if it does not, then it was created to help change the city.…

    • 1586 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Throughout this course I have gained more of an appreciation for artwork and the artists that create them. I have also gained an appreciation for the people that try to define what art is in general or more specifically what makes good art. We have read great thinkers and their philosophies on this, and the fact that even people of such great intelligence can disagree on the subject proves how challenging it can be. By reading the opinions of these great thinkers, and by discussing their thought with our class, I feel I am in a much better place as to define what makes good art myself. I define art as anything created by someone that inspires another to appreciation.…

    • 2210 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays