The Help And The Butler Analysis

Improved Essays
Today’s racial films give us glimpses into the dark and dangerous lives of various slaves an activist. They allow us to see just how powerful the impact of segregation and slavery were on society and how dangerous it was to differ from the norm in those times. The Help and the butler are two gripping racial movies that depict the hard and dangerous the lives of black Americans in the 1950’s, both movies have various similarities, ranging from their production to their plot, but also carry various and extreme differences that make both movies very insightful and unique.
The help and the butler are both set in the 1950, a time where segregation still reigned and people of back descents were still treated as low class humans. Both movies follow
…show more content…
These movies both show us how fear can effect of our lives but in two very different ways. In The Help characters like Aibileen and Minny display how fear can control you into staying silent, both the maids are hesitant to really open up to Skeeter during their first few interviews and are scared of the outcome that contributing to Skeeters book can have but instead of allow this to stop them they sort out an alibi to cover themselves from harm if the book was ever discovered to be written by the towns maids. They understand that their society is unfair and want to make a difference but are just fearful of what that difference could lead to, they allow their fear to motivate them rather than stop them. This is a contrast to The butler where we see how fear can take control of individuals and cause them to turn a blind eye. Cecil’s unknowing allows his fear to control him to point where he develops a new view on the way the world works. With him witnessing his father’s murder, after stand up for his mother, Cecil develops a habit of allowing others to fight his battle rather than fighting them himself. He spends majority of the movie stuck in a world where he believes that all the presidents that come into office will with make it their mission to make the world an equal place for all races and discourages his son from openly fighting for the rights of …show more content…
Both Cecil and Aibileen, show us how with the right environment or help people can learn to respect themselves and get over their fears. They both place themselves in situations where the learn about the true meaning of their place in society and the power that they hold and through both positive and negative interactions these characters are able to overcome personal challenges the face and grow for the better. By the end of the movies Aibileen and Cecil are able to leave their jobs taking strength and comfort from the fear that once kept them trapped there. The theme of growth does not just stop with the main characters though; it also effects all the supporting character in the movies. For example, in The Help we see how Celia Foote changes Minny into more of an open and kind person, she grows past the hatred she has for white families and learns that no all families are the same. Even people like Charlotte Phelan grow past their need to fit into society and lean to fight for what they think is right. While in The Butler we see how different presidents grow after witnessing the effects of major civil rights rally’s. Almost all the characters in both movies are able to grow because of one another and become stronger and wiser then they were

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    However in the film, his ambition helps him fall away from deterioration and have an outcome of a successful career. The film characterizes Roy as a completely different person and depicted as a victim rather than a tragic hero. Despite all the discrepancies, the novel and the film both portray a common theme while still interpreting forceful messages to enhance the reader’s perspective of life. A major theme that was emphasized in different ways in the book and movie was inspiration.…

    • 1183 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    To Kill a Mockingbird and The Help compare and contrast The Jim Crow Laws were statutes enacted by Southern states, beginning in the 1880s, that legalized segregation between African Americans and whites. To Kill a Mockingbird is a book by Harper Lee that follows the life of a young girl named Jean Louise “Scout” Finch, Who lives in the segregated south and the obstacles she has to go through when her father Atticus Finch is chosen to represent an African American named Tom Robinson, who is convicted for rapeing a white woman. The Help, directed by Tate Taylor, is a movie that shows the obstacles African American maids have to go through in the segregated south, and how a young woman named Eugenia “Skeeter” Phelan stood up against the crowd and decided to write about the work experiences of…

    • 1115 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Juxtaposition In The Help

    • 1065 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Adapted from Kathryn Stocket’s novel of the same name, historic period drama film ‘The Help’ (2011) set within the infamously bigoted United States of America during the 1950’s and directed by Tate Taylor, presents the directorial perspective that the effects of racism within society can only be counteracted when someone with enough courage to do so, is able to accept that racial discrimination is an injustice. This particular stance on the issue of racism is constructed through use of juxtaposing the actions taken against racial discrimination by one of the main protagonists and her narrow minded and visibly racist peers, thus highlighting the courage required to take a stand for what is right. A generic convention, most prominent when communicating…

    • 1065 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In 2011 the movie The Help was made and based off the best selling book of the same name. The book portrays how white women treat their black maids in 1960’s Mississippi. The main character Skeeter, who grew up in a well to do white family in Mississippi, comes home from college and watches her now married and grown up friends treat their black help with no dignity. Throughout the movie Skeeter’s friends are very concerned with what others think and how it will affect their social status, even if that means showing extreme prejudice and selfishness to the black maids. The Help demonstrates how the idea of defined social classes is outdated and people should answer the call to help others who are not financially well off.…

    • 511 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Help was written by Kathryn Stockett in 2009. Stockett’s intention of The Help was to address racism in Jackson, Mississippi during the early 1960s. The relationship between a white person and their maid, or “help”, was appalling, in most situations. The maids in this time period were treated inadequately, no matter how laborous their work in the house consisted of. It was very rare for these maid to be treated with respect, even though they assisted in the care of their children.…

    • 690 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    These are questions that are left somewhat unresolved; from race to gender to humanity and intelligence. It seems that everything these two embody are contradictions. Their own embodiment, their own learned senses of self are completely throw out of the water, and replaced by a uniqueness and power that is frightening to their own kind. By giving us similar narration in both novels, as well as almost mirroring each other, Butler brings to light one major theme of this novel, the power of adaptability. She chooses to make her two characters what are considered today as repressed beings.…

    • 2366 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The film Get Out, directed by Jordan Peele, is the most biting movie on race that has had mainstream success in recent years. A film based around the premise of a black man visiting his white girlfriend’s parents for the weekend, explores many of the same topics discussed in Gender, Media, and Culture. Get Out is unwaveringly clear in its theme of denying the idea that America has progressed to the point of becoming a post-racial society. Peele employs numerous themes to support this idea, including those surrounding oppression, cultural appropriation, and very tongue-in-cheek allusions to white feminism throughout his debut film.…

    • 1580 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Given Circumstances 1. Geographical location, including climate: “The Help” is a drama film released in 2011 focusing on racism, discrimination, and inequality that the African American maids faced. The story of the movie focuses on the relationship between two black maids with a white woman journalist in Jackson, Mississippi. The warm, bright, and sunny days in the movie give the climate condition of Jackson, Mississippi. 2. Date; year, season, time of day:…

    • 1396 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Dominant attitudes in a society are revealed by the conflict between characters and people in texts. Both Skeeter and Hilly from the 2011 blockbuster, The Help, effectively construct the dominant attitudes held by the American Society in the early 1960’s with regards to the treatment and rights of African Americans in a currently white endorsed culture. The liberal push for increased Negro rights is accomplished by Skeeters challenge on the dominant attitudes, which are represented by Hilly and endorse attitudes for a White supremist society which is widely accepted in the American culture during the setting of the film. Through the careful construction of this film by Tate Taylor, the director, the audience is positioned to sympathise with the Skeeters representation of the African American population, and reject or challenge the dominant attitudes presented by Hillys portrayal of the Negro community.…

    • 856 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    “Racism is still with us. But it is up to us to prepare our children for what they have to meet, and, hopefully, we shall overcome.” ~Rosa Parks. The roots of racism have passed down through generations because parents force their children to follow racial traditions in order for them to continue those norms for future generations.…

    • 1529 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Society and culture continue to change as the world familiarizes itself with equality. A story called “The Help” was originally written into a novel by Kathryn Stockett and tells the story regarding a servant that helped her family in the 1960’s. In 2011, the book was created into a screenplay by Tate Taylor. “The Help” captures the oblivious reality of segregation and inequality between white and black people during the 60’s. In the movie, the main character Eugenia, or otherwise known as “Skeeter,” struggles to fit in with her long lost Mississippi friends that are clearly only focused on marriage and reproduction.…

    • 1433 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Student: Teresa Nguyen Class: English Communications Date: Grade: 12 Teacher: Mrs De Blasio What film techniques does Tate Taylor use to engage the viewer and present the ideas of injustice? Director Tate Taylor, in The Help, explores, through the lives of black maids, the injustice and imprudent judgments made towards the African American community in the 1960s. Camera work, dialogue, mise-en-scenè, and colours reveal the juxtaposing lifestyles of the racial classes, and the lack of development in society’s treatment of coloured people. Sounds expose the inferiority and challenges that African Americans experienced in attempting to display basic human behaviours, whilst historical context refers to the Jim Crow laws that…

    • 1064 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Introduction The ensuing paper discusses the family dynamics and interpersonal relationships present in the movie The Help. Most specifically, the relationship between a mother and daughter will be explored. We will begin by providing an overlay of the movie’s characters and basic story line. Following this overview, the writings will delve deeper into the environment, values, and roles that shape the Phelan family.…

    • 1497 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    One of the best American historical fiction film The Help centered around racial discrimination and gender roles in the Civil Rights era in 1960s. Throughout American history, racial segregation has always been an issue. The ideology of “separate but equal” was once a legal doctrine in the United States Constitution. It was until Supreme Court case Brown v. Board of Education statewide segregation laws have become illegal, and was approximately sixty years after the decision made in Plessy v. Ferguson (“Important Supreme Court Cases”). The Help while the film’s title suggests as “the help” provided from black maids in Jackson, Mississippi to middle class white families.…

    • 1277 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In the 2011 drama, The Help, the main and most important theme is that the ethnic and racial segregation between the whites and blacks. The director, Tate Taylor, developed this theme by demonstrating that the blacks live in a poverty-stricken and rundown part of Jackson, whereas the whites lived in more privileged suburban areas. This demonstration gives an effect to the audience of how society in the film and reality during that time period were actually overseen and this is also carried out through the film’s lighting and soundtrack. Overall, the lighting throughout the film is bright and lively, much like the surface of Jackson’s society, which contrasts to similar movies such as Malcolm X , which has a darker tone to it. In a blog for AMC movies, Nina Hämmerling Smith states: “The soundtrack for The Help tells the story in song, with choices that represent the disparate currents of the time.”…

    • 1214 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays