Susana Siegel Summary

Improved Essays
Susana Siegel made a convincing case how cognitive penetration (CP) may be problematic for dogmatism. Still, I feel that CP has some shortcomings. First, it is plausible that CP is out of our control – in Siegel’s terms, all cases of CP may be analogous with being “zapped”1. Second, it seems that one must be aware of CP in order for it to be problematic. If a subject has such awareness, however, CP becomes a sneaky defeater and fits the mold of dogmatism. Before proceeding, I will define dogmatism and explicate Siegel’s challenge. In the end I hope to highlight a few potential holes that, if expanded, could deflate the challenge of CP.
Dogmatism says that if a subject S has a perceptual experience with content P, then S has prima facie justification for believing P. Furthermore, S’s belief in P is immediate and does not depend on any further justified propositions. Cognitive penetration (CP) suggests that beliefs, desires, moods, expectations, etc. can influence the content of perceptual processes and/or experiences.
Siegel insists that CP threatens dogmatism. She uses a simple example to illustrate the problem2. Jill
…show more content…
Take the same case of Jack and Jill. Imagine you are Jill’s closest friend. In one situation you are aware that Jill has been cognitively penetrated and unjustifiably believes Jack is angry. In a second situation you are entirely unaware of Jill’s previous belief and how it affected her. Now suppose immediately after seeing Jack, Jill laments to you about him. During her lamentation she describes exactly how he seemed – facial expressions and all. In the first situation, you would certainly think that Jill’s belief is unjustified because you are aware of her predisposition and how it affected her. In the second situation, however, it seems you would have no reason to doubt Jill’s lamentation – both you and Jill would be justified believing that Jack is

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Study #1 Article Title: It’s Not Just About Salivating Dogs! Author: Ivan Pavlov Date of Study: 1927 Hypothesis: Ivan Pavlov believed that if a dog was exposed to a specific stimulus while being fed, the dog’s brain would associate the stimulus with the food; due to this association, the stimulus alone would prompt the dogs to salivate. Variables: The independent variables, or the variables being manipulated and tested, are the various stimuli that Pavlov used to ingrain a response in the dogs: the ticking of metronome, footsteps, the scent of vanilla, a rotating object. The dependent variable, or the variable measured and tested, is the presence of salivation in response to a neutral stimulus after the dogs have been conditioned to associate the stimulus with food.…

    • 1180 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Selena Quintanilla-Pérez (Spanish: [seˈlena kintaˈniʎa ˈpereθ] or [seˈlena kintaˈniʝa ˈperes]; April 16, 1971 – March 31, 1995), known by the mononym Selena, was an American singer, songwriter, spokesperson, actress, and fashion designer. Called the Queen of Tejano music, her contributions to music and fashion made her one of the most celebrated Mexican American entertainers of the late 20th century. Billboard magazine named her the "top Latin artist of the '90s", the "best selling Latin artist of the decade". She is often called the "Mexican American equivalent" of Madonna for her clothing choices, by media outlets.[a] She also ranks among the most influential Latin artists of all-time and is credited for catapulting a music genre into mainstream…

    • 203 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Known as the Queen of Tejano Music, Selena Quintanilla-Perez allowed music to lead her into becoming one of the most celebrated Mexican-American entertainers of the late 20th century. Starting out as a very young girl, she flourished rapidly in the music industry. With albums receiving gold record status, Tejano awards of all sorts, the Grammy, etc., her thrill-filled career was unfortunately cut short when the president of her own fan club killed her. Her physical absence is felt, but Selena Quintanilla’s music still lives today. Selena Quintanilla was born April 16th, 1971 to her parents, Abraham and Marcella Quintanilla.…

    • 1126 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Julia Alvarez Summary

    • 586 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Julia Alvarez grew up to age ten in the Dominican Republic. In this time period sugar cane was a booming industry, Catholicism was the top religion, and poverty was running rampant. Julia lived in a time when the government in the Dominican Republic was very corrupt. Anyone that disparaged the president was assassinated. Julia is associated with postmodernism (1996-present) and is still writing even today.…

    • 586 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Susan Smith Research Paper

    • 2578 Words
    • 11 Pages

    Susan Smith, you might have heard of her, she is the woman who drove her two sons Michael, 3, and Alex, 14 months into a lake while they were asleep (Cavazini).This event shocked America, the thought of a mother killing her two beloved children. In Susan’s childhood she was faced with abuse, depression and hatred. The events of her upbringing will cause her to loose relationships with people and also cause the death of her two sons. Susan smith was born September 26, 1971 in Union, South Carolina (“Susan Smith”) Today, Union County has a population of 30,300 (Pergament).…

    • 2578 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Celia Cruz Research Paper

    • 578 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Hispanic Heritage Month As a Hispanic Latino American, I feel very proud that in the United States exists a month to celebrate our Hispanic Heritage. Moreover, to recognize people who has had contributed with important things in this country. In the follow up paper, there is a summary of Celia Cruz’s life and a description about her and what represent for people who knows about her. Please keep reading and find why everybody knows when they hear the phrase “Azucar” (Celia C.).…

    • 578 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Elizabeth Kolbert's article, “Why Facts Don’t Change Our Minds,” in the New Yorkers February 2017 issue looks at some main ideas in three different psychological books about patterns in human reasoning and attempts to connect them to today’s politics. Her explanation of the studies and their outcomes were superb, though she could have done a better job at connecting these points to her political conclusion. It is difficult to distinguish what her main point is. She starts the article by describing a couple experiments done at Stanford on human reasoning.…

    • 794 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In “Varicella Vaccination Program Success” by Steven Novella, the author argues about the people who does not believe in vaccines and how are their arguments formulated. They ignore all the information and statitistics and focus on the smaller problems caused in the investigation, to assure that vaccines are not effective and riskful. However, besides all this, the author states at the end that we should follow more closely the vaccines programs and know that they are useful with the proper regulations. Moreover, Novella starts the article talking about the cognitive dissonance, which is “the state of mind that results when conflict arises between perceived reality and the cherished or learned facts, values, and beliefs regarding that reality.”,…

    • 398 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Peter Elbows Essay “The Believing Game” He discusses the vital information of the “Believing Game” and The Doubting Game to an instinct to which the audience understands to be important to our intellectual growth and differentiation of opinions/positions of ourselves and peers. In the beginning of Peter's essay, he discusses the way people deliberate in their minds over how people see things differently than others. He uses the example of inkblots to show that some people aren't willing to see things in a different perspective unless someone else is willing to see things in their perspective. Also the discussion of people wanting others to see their point of view, but wanting the others to give up their position and opinions about the topic or idea to…

    • 484 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Barbara Brody Summary

    • 666 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Barbara Brody, writer for WebMD, stated in an article reviewed by Joseph Goldberg, MD, that food providing our bodies with fuel is not the only reason for eating. Emotions can have a strong impact. Brody said you might eat due to being, “happy (birthday cake!), sad (who hasn't indulged in ice cream after a bad day?), or stressed (that 3 p.m. office chocolate break).” Of course, a once in a while treat in a healthy diet is no problem.…

    • 666 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Hysteria As Demonstrated In The Crucible And 1950’s America In 1950’s America the war on communism had reached a high point and anti-communist feelings were overwhelmingly common. In response to the anti-communist hysteria occurring around him, Arthur Miller, a well known playwright, wrote The Crucible to demonstrate the hysteria surrounding the American citizens and their government. By analyzing the usage of the causes of hysteria and individual rationalization of actions that are commonplace in The Crucible, a reader can see how hysteria starts in a society and what prevents and keeps hysteria from occurring.…

    • 1142 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Laura secord Many people know the story of Lara Secord but some of you may be a bit fuzzy on the details. Laura Secord was born Sep.t 13,1775 a Wednesday. When laura was 8 years old her mother died leaving Four little girls to her father. Her father remarried 3 times and had a large family, by his third wife. Laura was married at the age of 20 in 1797.…

    • 473 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Both Susan Rich, and Kazim Ali by the author talk a lot about their travels however their reasoning is very different but at the same time the similar. Kazim Ali was from the UK and was a writer, poet, and professor and flew often because of his dual Citizenship he had as well as how he consistently had to fly around for his job. Then there was, Susan Rich was a student given the Full Bright Scholarship and was able to go and travel to South Africa to live and experience life and live life to the fullest. Yet at the same time even with their initial motivations for traveling and going to these different places different places where not originally for the same reason, But they eventually their reason for their travel funneled in to the same…

    • 139 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Both the history and physical assessment have been thoroughly reviewed. Assignment: 1. Make a problem list. Her problem list is extensive,…

    • 2434 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Unit 2 – Approaches to learning theories Learning is the demonstration of knowledge of an action, which they did not know before” (Honey and Mumford. 1996) Understanding teaching and coaching it is important to have knowledge regarding the different approaches in learning styles and how they can be applied in a sporting scenario, which enables coaches and athletes to maximize their potential. The definition of learning can be contextualized by two paradigms, which are humanism and behaviorism Humanism…

    • 1591 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays