Summary: College Athletes Should NOT Be Paid

Great Essays
Twenty-two points, six rebounds, and three assists are the stats of Shabazz Napier, star point guard for the University of Connecticut's basketball team. Napier has just won the NCAA championship game and receives the Most Valuable Player (MVP) award. Because of this, Napier has become somewhat of a poster boy for the NCAA. Thus, the media will be rushing to hear his now valued opinion. When being interviewed about a week after the game, Napier says that there are "hungry nights where I'm not able to eat, but I still gotta play to my capabilities" (Sherman). Napier also comments on seeing his jersey being sold by saying, "to some credit, you feel like you want something in return" (Thomas). Many may think that scholarships cover all aspects …show more content…
The only ones not cashing in, it seems, are the player themselves." This does not seem fair that the ones who are making the money are not receiving any of the money. Greg Johnson, sports editor at The Daily Targum, and StudentNation, organization who give first-person accounts from student activists, organizers and journalists reporting on youth-oriented movements for social justice, economic equality and tolerance, says, "Coaches and athletic directors can negotiate million-dollar contracts, billions are available for installing state-of-the-art facilities, but the whole enterprise hinges on maintaining an arbitrary benefit to the student athletes." Supporters of the notion that college athletes should not be paid argue that there are problems with payment. Johnson, who spent sixteen years working in the School of Sport Sciences at Wingate University (NC), and Acquaviva, professor of sports science at Wingate University (NC) say that refuters ask the questions "how much should the athletes get paid and will payments be based on performance? What if the athlete gets hurt? What if the athlete is a bust and despite …show more content…
According to Sanderson and Siegfried, since they are considered students instead of employees, "they have not been covered by general labor laws." Because of this, "university athletic departments can dictate many aspects of a student-athlete's routine and engage these individuals in long hours of practices, something that might not be possible if general labor laws were in force." This also illustrates another reason how the college athletes are dominated, managed, and controlled. The NCAA does not have to pay the college athletes since they consider them to be students even though they treat them as if they are employees. Also, the athletes do not have a voice in NCAA regulations pertaining to them. The NCAA "maximizes its profits by steadily expanding regular season games," but "the players have no voice in these decisions to expand the schedule" (Sanderson and Siegfried). College athletes should be paid because the NCAA uses their power to stretch out as much money possible by using the athletes to their advantage without paying them for their services. However, arguers try to say that this is acceptable because they are students and are not employees and should not expect to get paid, but if this proposition turns out to be true, then the NCAA is treating the athletes as if they are

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    John R. Thelin, a professor at the University of Kentucky, wrote an article for Time.com titled “Here’s Why We Shouldn’t Pay College Athletes”. Throughout the article, Thelin refers to athletes strictly a part of college men’s football and basketball and explains why replacing a full-ride scholarship which amounts to 65,000 dollars with a 100,000-dollar salary does not make sense economically. Thelin also highlights the difference in state taxes which may make some colleges more appealing than others due to the benefits of keeping more of the theoretical 100,000-dollar salary. I believe that Thelin in his article is making a valid point that students should not be paid as employees of the university in which they attend, and that a 100,000-dollar scholarship should not replace a full-ride scholarship. However, in this article, Thelin is putting the readers under the impression that all college athletes are under full-ride scholarships.…

    • 471 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    An university can increase their profit by increasing concession prices, such as tickets and merchandise, or by lowering expenses. Two expenses Tubby Smith suggests that could be lowered are the investments of training facilities and coach’s contracts. He argues that coaches are overpaid to the point that they should not being the highest paid person in his/her respective state. Smith also suggests college sports programs invest an abundance of money in training facilities. Although he highlights valid points to lower the cost of funding an athletic program, these points would hinder the overall viability of the program.…

    • 924 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Due to NCAA rules, athletes have not been allowed compensation for their participation in college athletics. This rule has caused a great divide and debate within the collegiate sport world, especially with the recent exponential growth of college athletics. For instance, college sports critics Val Ackerman and Larry Scott argue “that college is ultimately about getting a degree and getting ready for life long after their playing days are over” supporting their claim that college athletes should not be paid (Ackerman and Scott). Opposing that view is the idea that college athletics offer exactly those benefits and more, which would be maximized with payment. As of right now, college athletes are being compensated through scholarships that average…

    • 319 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    And how can we as fans truly enjoy a football game knowing that one player's career-ending injury will leave him saddled with nothing more than a lifetime of pain and doctor's bills? This is why NCAA athletes should be paid because they risk their bodies every time they play a game for example when we watched a movie in class about NCAA athletes their was this guy which had injured himself very badly in the game of football and after the injuries he could not play football because he was paralyzed which caused him not to be able to play and that pretty much ruined his life. The college even told his parents that he would be very taken care…

    • 590 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    But is more evident that no time soon will colleges be paying student athletes, there are multiple reasons why it will not work. Although Reed Karaim makes some valid points the NCAA cannot pay all college athletes. It is clear that, in addition to their academic course loads, student-athletes’ physical conditioning, practice, travel and competition schedules make it difficult for many of them to take on part-time employment to supplement their institutional aid as do other students, but they took on that responsibility when they continued to compete; but student athlete’s should not be…

    • 818 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The NCAA and colleges can make money off the college athletes by having sponsors, making advertisements, and selling their jerseys. Many people believe that college athletes should not get paid since the NCAA and the colleges offer them scholarships and education while the opposite believe that NCAA and colleges owe them more than just a scholarship. College Athletes should not be paid because student athletes are not professional and it would ruin college sports. Student athletes should not get paid to play because they are considered amateur and not professional players. College is a place where students should learn and even if they want to be a…

    • 560 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Paid Student Athletes

    • 1489 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Pay for Play? Dave Anderson, Laura Freedman, Lee Goldman, and Peter Goplereus III have all written articles on whether or not the NCAA should pay their student athletes. Their articles, “Top 10 Reasons College Athletes Should be Paid”, “Pay or Play”, “Should College Athletes Be Paid”, and “No Control Over Their Rights” all provide many reasons as to why student athletes deserve payment. The NCAA is in the wrong for accepting “free labor” from these athletes. Although many student athletes are on scholarships, often times it is not enough, so they deserve fair compensation.…

    • 1489 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Over the past couple decades, college athletics have increased their popularity tremendously. The increase in popularity has led to a surplus of revenue brought to each of the Universities and the National Collegiate Athletics Association (NCAA). Last year Oregon had a revenue of $196,030,398 and not a single player was compensated for the work they did on those sports teams (Berkowitz para. 1).…

    • 1460 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Argumentative Research Paper Outline College athletes should not complain about not getting paid, they should be offered the option of a tuition or a salary. Not Both. People think that they should get paid because they are in college sports now. (Jones)…

    • 1236 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many people have recently raised controversy on the subject of whether college athletes should be paid or not. The student athletes feel they should be paid for their performance on the field due to the fact that they spend most of their free time on the field or court practicing the sport they love and they cannot afford to manage school, sports, and a healthy sleep life style on top of working to be able to afford things. College athletes should not be paid for their performance on the field. The student athletes should not be paid to play because they are in school for education, this could cause issues for colleges with auctioning, this can cause money problems for the student athletes, and sports are not a job they are a choice. Student…

    • 737 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Even though there are a majority of people with this movement, many argue that paying athletes is near impossible. There are opposing sides that claim colleges and smaller colleges could not afford to pay these athletes. It would be hard to imagine how these schools wouldn’t be able to pay these players. Karaim writes in his article about how the NCAA is a multibillion dollar industry. He claims that the NCAA should be able to afford and assist these colleges with the billions of dollars that they make every year (Karaim, 5).…

    • 1423 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    These players, however, do not get the appreciation they well deserve. Unlike any other business, the NCAA does not pay its employees; its employees being the student athletes. These same players invest up to 50 hours…

    • 1229 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The controversy of whether college athletes should be paid or not is a significant issue in the sports world, today. In this issue there are two different sides the NCAA and then their college athletes. The main reason the NCAA states they will not pay their college athletes is because they are ‘amateurs’. According to the NCAA, “Amateur competition is a bedrock principle of college athletics and the NCAA.…

    • 504 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Problem Of Paying Student Athletes

    • 2586 Words
    • 11 Pages
    • 5 Works Cited

    This results in many people trying to sue the NCAA because they believe this isn’t fair but that is another discussion. College athletes deserve to be paid based on all they do for their university. Works Cited Edwards, Harry. “Share the Wealth” 16 December 2011. Web.…

    • 2586 Words
    • 11 Pages
    • 5 Works Cited
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    While I personally respect the time and effort each and every athlete puts into his or her sport and have experienced…

    • 1302 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays