Staying Put By Scott Russell Sanders Analysis

Improved Essays
“Staying Put” is an article written by Scott Russell Sanders in which he attempts to convince the readers that people can thrive in their homeland instead of moving. Sanders begins his argument with an anecdote of the Miller family, then he states the social and philosophical benefits of staying put. As Sanders have suggested, a person becomes admirable when they devote themselves to their homeland regardless of hardships they will encounter. Moreover, he also claims that people must have a homeland of their own before having the ability to appreciate other cultures. Despite all the benefits that Sanders brings up for staying put; many people are better off moving due to of various social, ideological and environmental issues.
While Gracy
…show more content…
As a matter of fact, a person without strong nationalist beliefs will “wander the world like a sightseer”(Sanders 144). However, there are no downsides to be a ‘sightseer’; in fact“not all those who wander are lost” (Tolkien 50).In reality, a sightseer would be able to appreciate a culture and compare it against other cultures that have seen prior. Sander’s argument made it clear that he values groundedness over exploration and discovery. However, to many young people with their lives just starting, given up the chance to explore and ‘wander.’ and stay grounded, which can reduce their worldly knowledge and be shackled to the lifeless ground. There is no downside to being a sightseer. On the contrary, if a person was to stay in one geographical location their whole life only exposed to a single culture and see the rest of the world through the HD display on their television they would never truly be in touch with the rest of the …show more content…
According to Maslow's hierarchy, before any human being can achieve their maximum potential, they must first be physically safe. Thus, leaving an area of environmental disaster/environmental injustice will often bring more long-term benefit as opposed to staying put. Sanders starts his argument with an anecdote of the Miller family, who had experienced three tornadoes and rebuilt their house where it was destroyed. They are fortunate that, their insurance was able to provide them with the necessary funds to live, but not everyone as privileged as the Millers. Many groups, especially the economically disadvantaged suffer from the human-made environmental disaster. For instance, the water in 2014 the drinking water in Flint, Michigan was contaminated by lead, and consequently, many residents suffer from health issues. Unlike the Millers, not every family is able to afford insurance to aid their survival. While many people value environmental justice and want to fight for their community, a person must first be physically safe before having the ability to fight for their homes. In the face of environmental disaster, it is better to move safety rather than stay

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    In the article, “Immigrants Keep an Iowa Meatpacking Town Alive and Growing” written by Patricia Cohen, there is discussion regarding a small town in northwestern Iowa which experienced a large influx of migrants over a period of time. Cohen interviews a local resident on his thoughts about the migrants moving in and obtaining many of the local jobs. The resident believed it was one of the best thing to happen to their town, as it allowed their town the opportunity to grow. First, Cohen discusses factors as to why small towns are becoming scarce.…

    • 1201 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Disagreement on Staying Put Hunting and gathering was the basic life skills of early humankind. These skills were co-dependent on the aspect of mobility and nomadicity. Our ancestors, hunters and gathers, followed wherever the animals went. Soon they created civilization to make everything convenient and accessible. This investment and innovation lead society and human evolution.…

    • 819 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Pamela Puchalski is one author who believes that the government failed its people during the Flint Water Crisis, as she describes in her article “A Functioning Government Could Have Prevented the Flint Crisis” (2017). She attributes the poisoning of Flint residents to the incompetence of government officials at both the city and state level. Puchalski outlines the five different ways in which the government failed the people. First, she says, they made decisions based on what would be quick and cheap rather than what would be safe and beneficial to the well-being of citizens. The city manager decided to change the water supply to the Flint River from Lake Huron because it could be done quickly and would save money, but he did not consider the negative impact this would have on the cleanliness of the water.…

    • 990 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Out of this Furnace by Thomas Bell is a historical fiction novel that describes the life of immigrants coming to America. More specifically, this is a story of different generations of the Kracha family’s immigration to America. There are many setting; the central setting being Braddock, Pennsylvania- a steel town. Bell gives a realistic depiction on what the European immigrant’s personal and work life was like during the eighteenth century.…

    • 433 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “It is the unhealable rift forced between a human being and a native place, between self and its true home: its essential sadness can never be surmounted.” (Edward, 2002). To identify where is their home is a major problem for Islamic migrants, in particular for the second and third generation migrants. Unlike immigrants, migrants always are temporary works; they do not have passport and protection from the government that they are working. Most of them live in the country as an outsider.…

    • 778 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Palestinian American literary theorist and cultural critic Edward Said has written that “ Exile is strangely compelling to think about but terrible to experience. It is the unhealable rift forced between a human being and a native place, between the self and its true home: its essential sadness can never be surmounted.” In “The Poisonwood Bible” Nathan Price the father of the price family has exiled himself from his family which creates a rift in this family which eventually separates the whole family. Nathan is dedicated to his work but this ultimately leads to the destruction of their family. Nathan creates a rift through his stubbornness, his preaching, and how he feels about feed back.…

    • 1439 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Migration has occurred for many, many years. In the passage, Sanders uses a few different strategies while he responds to an essay written by a man that left his native country for a different one. Sanders uses the strategies to also state his perspective about moving. There are a lot of unique writing strategies; allusion, analogy, and anticipating objection are a few Sanders uses.…

    • 387 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Since the beginning of mankind, people have been moving. People were originally nomads and hunters and gathers. To Salman Rushdie, moving seems as a natural and beneficial thing. He is a writer who left India and moved to England, calls the “effect of mass migrations” as being “the creation of radically new types of human being: people who root themselves in ideas rather than places”. Scott Russell Sanders responded to Rushdie’s claim in Staying Put: Making a Home in a Restless World, in which he argues against Rushdie’s original claim that mass moving developes a good thing.…

    • 909 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Immigration can have several meanings to different people. For one immigrant, it was a representation of a new life. Natasha Johnson immigrated to the small town of Andover, Iowa from Kiev, Ukraine. Natasha traveled to Iowa with her daughter 12 years ago (Johnson, 2015). Since the day she first stepped foot in the United States, she has continually been adjusting, learning, and overcoming challenges.…

    • 1384 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Nevertheless, the main cause of lead poisoning is the pollution as it directly and disproportionately affected the Flint population. Due to a lack of political power, African-Americans living in Flint were disproportionately affected. Most environmental decisions are connected to government and the larger…

    • 1797 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Marquart intends for the audience to mentally take a step back and reflect, “Ohh, wait a minute… this place is actually… special”. Here are Russian immigrants, fleeing their home for a better life, feeling this never-before-felt “anticipation” as they arrived and anxiously waited to receive their government plots of land where they will live and re-make a home, a life. They sought peace and tranquility; the upper Midwest, North Dakota. Or in other words, their new home which is therefore special and not just boring and “a dreary plain” (L.39). Marquart achieves success in hopefully changing the perspective of her audience, making them see and recognize that the upper Midwest is a place people call…

    • 764 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Staying Put Analysis

    • 858 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Refusing to “Stay Put” In the passage, “Staying Put,” Scott Russell Sanders encourages people to “stay put”: commit to the given place and stay here during a long time. For this reason, the benefits of “staying put” in a place are that people can make a remarkable devotion to one place, learn more and go deeper about this ground, and “staying put” does not prevent people from recognizing and honoring the diversity of other places, cultures, and ways. However, from my point of view, staying in one place, especially the dangerous ground , is the unwise way to invest so much of lives, go deeper in the place, and recognize the diversity of other cultures and places. First of all, Sanders puts out the example of a farm family, the Millers,…

    • 858 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Question 1: Scott Russell Sanders uses the appeal of logos throughout the passage, Staying Put: Making a Home in a Restless World, by appealing to logic, persuading the audience based on sense and reason. In this direct example from the text, “From the beginning, our heroes have been sailors, explorers, cowboys, prospectors, speculators, backwoods ramblers, rainbow-chasers, vagabonds of every stripe,” logos is introduced through excessive detail, giving more than plenty of examples in which we create our heroes to be free-spirits. This detail creates a sense of reason in which it’s logical to assume Americans like to move around based off the list of heroes presented. “In our national mythology, the worst fate is to be trapped on a farm, in…

    • 1067 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As most of America is aware of by now, there is a grave injustice happening in Flint, Michigan. The city’s drinking water is heavily contaminated with lead and has been since 2014. The problem began when the city of Flint switched to using the Flint River as a source of drinking water. A month after the switch was made, residents began to “complain about the smell and color of the new water, which [was] 70 percent harder than its previous water source” (Kennedy, 2016). Despite the complaints, no action was taken.…

    • 1136 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Illegal Immigrants Should be Provided a Pathway to Citizenship The American dream can defined as the idea that all American citizens have a chance for great success and happiness in life. To many, America is viewed as a place where opportunity is around every corner. Not every country offers the same freedoms as the United States, so immigrants travel from their country to another in hopes of obtaining a better life for not only them, but their families as well. Not every person that comes over is legal, however.…

    • 1329 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays