Analysis Of Lisa See's Snow Flower And The Secret Fan

Improved Essays
Lisa See’s Snow Flower and the Secret Fan shows that women are forced to obey men and learn this at a young age. The men are focused into the outer realms and the women focus in the inner realm. The outer realm is focused on literature, accounts, and crop yields, while the inner realm focuses on children, daily chores, and emotions (See, 153). The women have control over the household, however, the women does not have a say. Women must be obedient to their husband and father and son. Though women’s power do lie within the men. In traditional China it was key to have separation between genders, social status within genders, and traditions.
In the story the male's primary focus was on his career and how they are doing financially. Though it was
…show more content…
Women expressed how they felt through the secret language of nu shu. Nu shu was a language created a long time ago to allow women to express how they felt to family, sworn sisters, and/or their laotong. During this time period women were not allowed to write because in men's opinion that was not necessary. Though men did know about nu shu. This was a key to the separation of men and women because it shows who was able to show their true emotions, men. The idea of nu shu was thought to be simple nonsense, so men never bothered with it. In the nu shu Lily and Snow flower expressed their feelings of their lives and talked about the separation between men and women. Lily writes to Snow Flower and tells her about how she never see’s her husband unless he is coming to look at the baby in the morning (see, 152). This gave them a chance to talk about inner realm issues. They talk about their chores and how their children are growing …show more content…
They are to live separate live and they come together, when it is dealing with bed time. The women are to spend most their time in upstairs chambers. The men never go in there because that is the women’s space. The men felt that the women’s only duty in life was to produce a son to that will take on the name and if the women could not do that then they were worthless. The women was in charge of taking care of the house. The men and women are held at different standards. As stated before the women were to follow the Three Obedience, they were to also follow the Four Virtues. This is being careful how you act, like not being too sexual; being careful what you say, like not to disrespect your husband; carriage, like not being a distraction; and occupation, which is your house work (See, 24). While the men were held to a different standard, which was the the Nine Consideration. The men would be clearheaded, listened, carefully, appeared affable, loyal, respectful, righteous, and level headed. (See,165). These show that the women’s standards were to please the men, while the men’s. In the book it seemed as if the women wasn’t needed in the household to begin with, unless it was for cleaning. They were seen as guest, in the chinese language wife means guest. This means that she would always be a guest in her husband's home (See,

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    These are rules that governed women on how they should have represented themselves, and how they should have done unto others. Furthermore, these “goody wives” were able to be pretty gentlewoman while having completed the tasks of…

    • 897 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Some women may find submitting to their husbands and staying at home as some sort of oppression. Still, there are women out there who take part in certain religions that practice having a humble wife and these women may seek for help and refuge in this piece…

    • 1082 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There is a drastic difference in the concepts of male and female equality during the time Lindo was a girl in China versus Waverly in America. In China, there was an invisible yet strong rule that men and women have different duties in life, as well as different privileges. Lindo, when she was a small child was betrothed to a boy whom she didn’t know. This is because back then, girls didn’t have any choice nor could have any opinion on which man they could and wanted to marry. A good portion of Lindo’s life was given to a man whom made her cry for fun.…

    • 257 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    KEY CONCEPT 2.2 An empire can be defined as a large collection of people across a large range of land that live under a common rule. Empires have long trade routes on land and coastline as well as taxes imposed on their people. Religion was also enforced and attacks from barbarians could be found. Governments included systems of central and local in order to maintain order along with armies in order to defend borders and keep peace. Classical empires encompassed a fewer number of people than the Ancient Era.…

    • 987 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Indian society was patriarchal; women had little influence and women were supposed to be dutiful. The Lawbook of Manu, said women must rely on the guidance of their husbands and sons, and a women’s job was to bear children and keep up with the house. In China, the mirror image to this sentiment is in Ban Zhou’s Lesson for Women saying women must be dutiful to their husbands, do womanly work, and put everyone before herself because women are lowly and weak. Women in both societies were treated as objects lower than men whose only job was to produce children.…

    • 932 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Women In Han China

    • 585 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Throughout history, the treatment of women in civilizations hasn't been the best. Although women weren't treated the best, they still played a crucial part in the development of civilizations. For they were responsible for raising the kids and maintaining the house while the men worked. The Han Dynasty and the Roman Empire, two of the biggest and most powerful empires of the ancient world had many similarities and differences in the way they treated their women. Such as their stance in the social hierarchy and their rules as members of societies.…

    • 585 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Before and after 1949, the gap between the possibilities and limits of Chinese women’s lives was large, where the limits on women far surpassed the possibilities for a prolonged amount of time. Societal views were placed upon women, creating a system in which women must conform to a specific type of person or they would be shunned upon by those around them. This system was what determined the future of a woman in China. In the following stories, “Sealed Off”, by Ailing Zhang, “A Woman Like Me”, by Xi Xi, and “Fin de Siecle Splendor” by Zhu Tianwen, we explore the status of women during these periods of times.…

    • 1295 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Yuan Cai’s, The Problems of Women, is a passage from a book written by Yuan Cai. The chinese elite and literate males are the sources’ audience. The book gives advice for other men that are like him and the head of a household. This passage is interesting to me because it pertains to gender and sex roles in the twelfth century. This passage tells me that the culture the author lived in had certain marital and sex standards for males and females.…

    • 1321 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The author uses strong words to speak to women; one specific phrase the father used that truly depicted a wife’s role was “sort of happy slave”. Comparing the role of a wife as a slave would definitely enlighten the reader on how women are perceived when taking on the position as wife and mother. They would often spend the entire day working at the home and with the children without complaint. If women did complain or rejected this role they were considered inadequate as a mother, wife, and as a woman. This was often the attitude towards women who chose not to accept her role as wife and mother.…

    • 807 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    By the author using this line, it shows that women were treated just like servants at this time because the author comes out as directly compares the wife of a marriage to a servant. During this time period, once a woman got married, she no longer had a mind of her own, so if a wife wanted to think about or say anything the husband's approval was…

    • 790 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In the 19th century the American view on women became clear. Many people began to write about the role of a woman and things the woman should be able to do. The cult of domesticity is one of the main outlines of the roles of a woman. It goes into the image of the ideal woman, a woman’s proper place in society, and lists some writings that will reinforce the cult of domesticity. It also goes into the four main principles that make up a true woman.…

    • 1102 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    During the time periods of the Han and Gupta dynasties, both dynasties made contributions to their country’s basic structure that previous dynasties had damaged. During the 400 year period of the Han dynasty, China’s basic political and intellectual structure had been well rounded out and during the time period of when the Guptas were in power, classical India carried out its greatest period of political stability and both economic and cultural life was able to advance. The political and economic institutions of Han China were primarily based on the expansion of bureaucracy within their centralized government and their development of extensive internal trade and merchants. Although Gupta India did share a similarity in their development of…

    • 1115 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    As a whole, ancient Chinese society was a patriarchy. Whilst patriarchal systems are particularly detrimental to women, they ensnare men and women alike. Thus, both men and women of ancient China developed methods of social advancement within the confines of their assigned gender roles to try to ensure a stable future. These methods of upward mobility were the exam system and footbinding respectively.…

    • 1615 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    “A woman had to obey her father as daughter, her husband as wife, and her son as aged mother” (Friedman, Seth). Women were told to look upon her husband as if she was looking at heaven itself. An example of how women were viewed in this society is shown in the Tale of Genji. Japan’s women escaped the cruel features of Chinese Confucian culture such as foot binding. Japanese women were able to inherit property at a time when they had more right (Strayer 383).…

    • 1099 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Socio-autobiography There is no society where gender is considered to be insignificant. China is one such society where gender roles and inequalities have developed over time and remain present today. As I have spent the majority of my life in New Zealand, I have been exposed to many Western perspectives on gender. However, being the first generation to grow up in New Zealand meant that many traditional Chinese views on gender norms were still incorporated into my upbringing. This socio-autobiography will explore sociological gender concepts across time and cultures, and how they have shaped my life.…

    • 1632 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays