Beauty, And The Tangled Knot Of A Guilty Pleasure: Article Analysis

Improved Essays
Craig, Maxine L. "Race, Beauty, and the Tangled Knot of a Guilty Pleasure." Feminist Theory 7.2 (2006): 159-77. Web. Maxine Craig in her article, “Race, beauty, and the tangled knot of a guilty pleasure” writes about the complications of beauty standards and the way in which it is perceived in our society. She argues that the discussion of beauty norms by feminist is often incomplete because race and class play important roles in the conversation, yet are frequently left out. Her contribution to the topic is appreciated because she makes it aware that there are both positive and negative attributes to beauty standards within our society. Furthermore, she suggests that beauty standards, if used at all, should be split into varying groups to …show more content…
The purpose of her writing is mainly to inform the public on the dangers and prevalence of beauty standards within our society while promoting the love for each individual’s own self. Furthermore, she argues that beauty ideals have been apart of our society for a long time and she reflects on the history of beauty standards within America to strengthen her argument. I agree with Cheryl in her many arguments within her article because she offers a fresh and new outlook on the topic. Her paper offers a new perspective of the issue by precisely tackling major problems such as the constant portrayal of Eurocentric beauty ideals as the generalizing perception of beauty within our society. I plan to use her article within my own writing to highlight the specific ways she illustrates how African American women were and are currently oppressed because of their …show more content…
This includes the form of beauty ideals African American women are expected to fulfill. She compares this standard to that of the Eurocentric exemplar and suggest that despite their differences, they are equally wrong. She, like many other authors, emphasize the importance of making room to be inclusive of a wider array of body images and shapes. I agree with Demetria in her argument that black body ideals sexualized and exaggerated by media can be just as damaging as the general beauty standards our society portrays. To add to her discussion, I feel as though she could have included how many black women are faced with a double standard of beauty in which they are expected to represent only the ‘good’ traits of themselves, and to mimic everything else. Demetria’s article is important to the discussion, however, because it brings attention to the physical and life threatening dangers that these beauty standards are inflicting on women. Within my own essay, I plan to use her article as an example of how African Americans are dirtily impacted by beauty standards and how specifically dangerous it can

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Lindsay Kite’s article titled “Beauty Whitewashed” is one that explains that women of color are changing how they look to fill in a standard of beauty that tries to bring down how they are shown to the world. To elaborate, women of color are forced to become “white washed” in order to make themselves feel beautiful rather than letting their natural beauty shine. Kite begins her article by stating that “one-third” of the population is of a colored background. With doing so, she explains that there is a large amount of the population that is “underrepresented” when it comes to the standard of beauty.…

    • 300 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Bluest Eye: Socratic Seminar further analyzed interesting parts of Morrison’s chapter, autumn. First, I thought it was an interesting that white standards of beauty today are not as prominent as it was in the past, but as society evolved these issues plaguing our society has also evolved into different forms. For example, in the modeling career there is diversity among campaigns like Aerie and as Emily experienced first-hand, beauty touches today are with physical makeup instead of edits for a perfect beauty image. However, the pressure for beauty is still a problem, as Jamie said, when you search Google the first images that show up are white women and as Christina said, actors like Beyonce, a confident black female, have edits making them lighter, showing that there is…

    • 684 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Beauty matters. Well, at least for some. From the clothes you choose to wear (and the ones you don’t) to the items you own, everything surrounding you changes how people perceive you, even things completely out of someone’s control. Pressures to adhere to societal norms can cause long-term harm for certain people, but others can take this concept in stride. Due to different upbringings, along with different environmental influences, it allows for a range of perspectives.…

    • 1601 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Though beautiful women of color [American popular culture icons]…have achieved renown in U.S. culture, media representations of these women have become increasingly “Anglicized” or “whitewashed” over time […] finding positive depictions of women with dark skin tones or natural hair is still nearly impossible in mainstream media. Further, when we do see women of color represented as beauty icons in the media, they almost always already fit white ideals – meaning they already have light skin tones, light-colored, straight hair, ideally “white” facial features, thin figures, etc. (Kite…

    • 1212 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    When the two talk about the ways race, class, and gender “inform preferences for lighter skin” (Kenway and Bullen 281), it is now understood to mean that they are meant to be smaller pieces of a bigger puzzle that affect how beauty and identity intermingle. Within the context of the beauty industry, this new understanding provides new insight as to how those who fall within similar communities—in terms of race, class, and gender—are differently targeted by companies. These communities can be singled out as separate and generalized entities, or can be combined and interwoven to create more complex and specific…

    • 898 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Anti-Beauty Myth” by Christine Rosen and “Taking Beauty’s Measure” by Rachel Shteir are articles from Commentary Magazine and Chronicle of Higher Education respectively. Both articles are resistant to the anti-beauty claims made by feminist writers. “Anti-beauty myth” discusses why people are still beauty conscious despite feminist efforts to punish over-emphasis on beauty while “Taking Beauty’s Measure” believes beauty should be desired rather than being ostracised. Even though both writers draw attention to the plausible flaws of the feminists’ claims, Christine Rosen, in “Anti-beauty myth”, provides an alternative perspective of beauty to supplement her arguments. Thus, it renders her argument stronger and more versatile.…

    • 729 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    [8] This makes more senses as to why African American women would look to other black women/media outlets to draw comparisons of what ideal beauty is. Yet, it’s harder for African American women to compare themselves to images within the media when they are both underrepresented and misrepresented. For a black woman with strong ethnic identity, social media images may not disturb her self image. “Ethnic identity refers to an individual 's knowledge of her/his membership in a socio-racial group and the level of attachment she/he has…

    • 1325 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Beauty is defined by the powerful members of a society. In the late 1800’s and early 1900’s, neo-colonialism’s image of beauty entailed westernized features such as thin lips, fine, straight hair, small features and white skin; the paler the skin, the more prestigious. Pale skin often symbolized wealth and status; even Caucasians powdered their skin to look whiter. High society folks did not work outside in the fields, as common laborers did. Their skin was not scourged by the sun.…

    • 1562 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Eckert Gender Roles

    • 927 Words
    • 4 Pages

    This is exclusively evident in women that deviate more between their figure and the ones depicted in the media. By contrast, thinner women are less affected by the media “because they perceive a smaller discrepancy between themselves and the media ideal” (S. Posac & H. Posavac, 2002, p.154). However these comparison only seem to relate to European American Women, since African American “groups tend to have a higher average BMI [body mass index] than comparison to EA groups… AA women have reported less dissatisfaction than EA women” (Jefferson & Stake, 2009, p. 397). Jefferson & Stake (2009) also concluded that “the mainstream media has less influence on [African American women’s] body image than it does on that of EA girls and women” (p. 398), since there are fewer African American women depicted in media, and the few that are depicted in the media tend to be more corpulent than European American depictions, African American women therefore believe that they are closer to their beauty ideal. Which explains why African American women are less affected by women’s portrayal in media.…

    • 927 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Consistently seeing memes or comments that criticize the way Black women look or act can produce depression, anxiety, and eating disorders. Trying to fit into this mold of beauty is dangerous; young Black women begin to skin bleach to appear lighter, and begin to hate their natural hair in order to have straight “proper” hair. Some might even begin to eat less, start using “waist trainers” to minimize their waists, or in extreme cases undergo plastic surgery to model after the praised figures social media adores. The beauty standards that society has for Black women is irrational. Black women are told to be “Slim-Thick” which means “A girl with big/toned thighs, plump booty, normal sized hips and a flat/toned stomach” (Defining Anything).…

    • 980 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Those women, although still slaves, were treated much better then those who had Negroid features such as darker skin, kinky hair, and a wide nose (Thompson, 2009). This discrimination had gone on so long that it created a legacy of women who passed down the way of thinking that if their skin wasn’t as light or hair wasn’t as straight or long then they weren’t as beautiful. This way of thinking, that black isn’t as beautiful and the only way that it can be is if black women alter themselves and their hair texture to become more beautiful, is very prominent in this new millennium without most of the girls knowing they are even a part of it (Thompson,…

    • 1717 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    In Criteria of Negro Art, Du Bois makes the argument that all art is propaganda and should serve the purpose of bettering and uplifting African Americans. Du Bois believed that black artists should use their work to advocate for their race and to help foster understanding between blacks and whites. Du Bois’ stance on black art being politicized is supported by the depiction of black life and female sexuality in Hurston’s novel; Their Eyes Were Watching God. In Du Bois’ essay, Criteria of Negro Art, the idea of beauty is discussed.…

    • 1353 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this modern era, everybody needs to be looking great and appealing. As, Kimmel and Holler (2011) utilize the idea of Naomi Wolf to portray the “beauty myth” the stigma in which woman being caught by the high premium models of fashion markets. Kimmel and Holler (2011) use Naomi Wolf’s definition that the “beauty myth” is an inaccessible female excellence that uses the pictures of female magnificence as a political weapon against women. It depicts that “the ladies itself get caught in an interminable cycle of beautifying agents, magnificence helps, weight control plans, and activity devotion” (Kimmel and Holler 2011, 324).…

    • 717 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    This essay will summarize Susan Sontag’s ideas concerning how beauty is seen in today’s modern culture and the consequences that these views have toward women, by using Susan Sontag’s vivid examples and definitions found in both “A Woman’s Beauty: Put-Down or Power Source” and “An Argument About Beauty”. Next, I will argue in support of most of her key points; however, I will also argue against some of the points presented in the essay. For example, I agree with her assertion that in todays modern culture women’s beauty is seen as parts and not as a whole and the effects of this distorted perspective. However, I disagree with her on how she believes that things will get better and how she blames Christianity for fostering one of the distorted perspectives of women’s beauty. Susan Sontag brings about a lot of key points that we as Christians should understand so as to bring about a better attitude and view towards women and beauty.…

    • 1295 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Aimilly Baez Human Communications Midterm Should Beauty Standards Be Banned in Social Media? For the past decade or so, sad to say; social media has become the biggest form of communication. It’s amazing how much of an impact social media has upon our generation, and our youth. Everyone you know has some type of social media handle, and if they don’t the person is looked at as an outsider. How many times has someone came up to you and told you “Did you see this person’s posts on Instagram?”…

    • 849 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Great Essays