Joanna Avila History 1302 T-TH, 5:30-6:50 Instructor: William Wooten October 18, 2015 A Fierce Review of A Fierce Discontent A Fierce Discontent, written by Michael McGerr, is a brilliant historical overview of the Progressive Era. Like it says on the cover, it talks about the rise and the fall, the good and the bad. McGerr states his argument in the book when he wrote “…That progressivism created much of our contemporary political predicament.…
The progressive era was a period of progressivists making an attempt to mend society by addressing the social and political difficulties caused by speedy industrial development and urban growth during the Gilded Age. The Gilded Age was a time of a corrupt government and abusive of workers including child labor. These aspects of the government continued long enough that the attempt to fix them lead to the Progressive Era. The Progressive Era was a time to fix the Gilded Age’s problems. The Gilded Age led to the Progressive reform due to the abuse of workers and also due to the corrupt government during the Gilded Age.…
According to author Michael McGerr, the argument of his work A Fierce Discontent: The Rise and Fall of the Progressive Movement in America, is “that progressivism created much of our contemporary political predicament” (xiv). While the author states that this is his purpose, his work seems to be more of a summary of the progressive era, devoting just a miniscule conclusion to connecting how progressive battles then led to the political situations of the twentieth and twenty-first centuries. If one takes McGerr’s work as merely an analysis over the progressives and their movement instead of a political commentary about today, the book makes much more sense. The author clearly defines who the progressives were, why they did what they did, and how they were related to the Victorians before them. From there he details the main battles of the progressives: “to change other people; to end class conflict; to control big business; and to segregate society” (xv).…
According to Rebecca Edward’s Politics, Social Movements, and the Periodization of U.S. History, the term “Gilded Age” to explain the period of 1870-1900 should be desisted due to its focus on the American elite and the lack of capturing the ordinary people. She explains that historians and textbooks describe the Gilded Age as a time of concentrated wealth and a corrupted government. This description ignores the Progressive parts that occurred before 1900, like the Hull House. Edwards also explains that the merging of the two eras marginalizes the non-progressive storylines, for example, Plessy vs. Ferguson, U.S. military interventions, and the exclusion of Asian immigrants.…
The Gilded Age was a breeding ground for corruption and social injustice. With all the monopolies and corrupted businessmen it made it hard for people to come up in the world. The Government had little power because all the power was with corrupted people. During this time the only people that were really happy were the business men, only because they were making good money. The Gilded age really lead to Progressive reforms because people grew tired of the social, financial, and governmental injustice.…
The Progressive Era was not unique and was simply built from the efforts of the Gilded Age reformers since many of the issues dealt with corrupt businesses; nevertheless, the efforts of the federal government…
The Gilded Age gave rise to new industries, created transportation and communication networks and provided infrastructure for further development of technology and science in the Progressive Era. Without the work done in the Gilded Age, the scientific and engineering breakthroughs of the Progressive Era would’ve been…
Throughout the structure of her explanation on the Progressive Era, Painter began the support with the prosperity of America. Painter’s reason to begin the Progressive Era with prosperity instead of the Progressive Era itself was to give knowledgeable background and analysis behind the Progressive Era. For example, Painter purposely included the growth of women and children workers in factories and mills in a span of 10 years. Not only general knowledge came to enhance readers’ understandings, but Painter focused on the prosperity in chapter 6 as well as the improvement of United States through new economic, political, and social reforms. While the structure contained the improvement of America as a whole, the prosperity chapter also revealed the corruption to readers so they would understand that changes needed to happen.…
The Gilded Age led to progressive reform because the people were tired of the problem taking place in the economy and in their social lives. The people began to find ways to make issues better. This brought the people closer to the progressive age. During the gilded age there was a lot of greedy and funny business going on in the economy.…
The Progressive Era was a century reform movement that required a return of control from government to the people. This resulted in restoring economic opportunities and the injustice in American life. Some of the Progressive reform goals were protecting social welfare, promoting moral improvement, creating economic reform and fostering efficiency. During the 1900-1920, the Progressive Era reforms included food acts, labor restrictions and civil rights of African Americans . The reformers who took part in these specific reforms were President Theodore Roosevelt and degraded African Americans.…
The progressive era is an era of improvement and social reforms set in place to make things in life more easier and more fair to the citizens in the United States. In the progressive era there were problems such as living conditions, woman suffrage, and working conditions were very apparent. First, one problem in the Progressive Era was living conditions. For example in a DBQ text it says “ Be a little careful, please. The hall is dark and you might stumble over the children pitching pennies back there.…
This wrong was corrected by some big name progressives and populists, but it is important to realize that the change was brought on by everyday americans who were all affected by the growth of business and saw it as their duty as whites, blacks, women, laborers, farmers, immigrants, and most importantly Americans to fix it. The GIlded Age found its beginnings comparable to the time before the war considering the amount of land and resources for corporations to use had not changed. What separates this time period from the rest however, is the increased connection of the continent through transportation and the amount of new laborers not seen before from immigrants and freed slaves (Shi and Tindall, p. 750). The country was now able to reach peak productivity with trains to bring in oil from the Ohio Valley, to steamboats bringing timber across canals from the Great Lakes region.…
The Gilded Age was a time of trusts in which they trusted the companies with too much power. Being very unreasonable with unfair treatment of workers they had a much uncontrolled business. It continued long enough that instead of fixing the problem it lead to the Progressive Time in history. The Progressive Era was the period of reform that lasted from the 1890’s through the 1920’s. During this era the Gilded Age was established and was led to a Progressive Era by giving women and children a voice.…
The Gilded Age, the period from the 1870s to around 1900, was named by Mark Twain, a famous author who thought the era was glittering on the surface but corrupt underneath (Mintz and McNeil). When most people picture the Gilded Age, they refer to Mark Twain's view of an imbalanced, corrupt society. Many think of the Gilded Age as an era full of social inequality, greed, careless wealthy businessmen, unhealthy and immoral lifestyles of the lower class, business scandals, and devious political tactics. Several critics and historians, who haven't set aside time to thoroughly study or take note of most of the beneficial effects of this period, may easily support and claim these beliefs. Although the Gilded Age is frequently viewed as an adverse era of social inequality and political corruption,…
From 1890 to 1920 the United States went through a difficult time when people started realizing that they need to be in charge of their own life. People realized that they were being over worked and were getting little to no pay. Also people realized that the government was rarely involved in big businesses, who were dominating the economy. Who are the Progressives? What social groups did the Progressives represent?…