That is because Kalmia is an allelopathic plant and the germinates reacted to the chemical compounds that were present in the extract. The same thing occurred with the organic matter for the same reason, the Kalmia likely leached allelopathic compounds in the soil which the seeds reacted to. (Inderjit 2002)
The seeds which germinated in the solution with a pH of 3.5 reacted in much of the same way as the seeds influenced by the allelopathic compounds in both the Kalmia extract as well as the Kalmia soil. This is likely because the pH of the solution was too acidic for proper root growth. (Attree 1990)
All this data is shown in figure 1. The box plots for treatments 2, 3 and 4 all contain lower root: shoot ratios compared to the box plot for treatment 1. Treatment 1 was the distilled water, treatment 2 was the organic matter, treatment 3 was the Kalmia extract and treatment 4 was the pH solution. P-values were calculated to show the difference between the four treatments and these values are shown in table 1. According to these values, treatments 1 and 3 are the least similar, while treatments 3 and 4 are the most