Phar Mor Case Study

Improved Essays
The Phar Mor situation is something that I feel happens a lot with companies and corporation, but on a much smaller scale. Therefore, I wasn’t surprised that the company was able to pull off such a scam for so long. I was more surprised at the fact that it involved the entire management group and that out of all of the people no one was honest or brave enough to put a stop it or expose it.
I feel that more people should have been punished in this case because so many people knew about the illegal cover up that was going on and decided not to tell anyone. So, they are just as guilty as the people that were actually involved in “cooking the books” to covering up loses and making them seem like profits. Coopers and Lybrant are as guilty in this
…show more content…
Unlike those people, I wouldn’t have stopped there. If I was rejected the board I would have tried sending letters to auditors and even investors. Because there were so many leaders of the company involved in the fraud I believe that one person wouldn’t be able to expose the fraud alone because they may come off as an angry employee that have other intentions. So, I would have tried to convince other employees in joining me in trying to expose the company for its’ wrong doings. Most likely no one would want to work with me and expose the company because of their loyalty to Monus.
No matter if I had someone to work with me or not I would have done all that I can to expose the company and I would have quit my job to protect my reputation and my future. Before leaving the job I would have gather all the information that I had access to that could prove my accusation. Hopefully, I would have been able to gather physical evidence but if not I would have recorded conversations like multiple people did. If all of the plans that I stated before failed to work out for me, my final straw would be to take the evidence that I gather to the FBI, present my case and leave it in their hands. I doubt that I would have to do that after bringing the information to investors and lenders, but it’s good to have a backup plan just in case things don’t work

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    In a case that all other parts the company, especially the higher managers, have ignored the truth more than once, an intelligent whistleblower should immediately inform the government about the issue. If the brave one is too stubborn and wants to handle the matter internally, then what happens to Eileen Foster will repeat itself, the wise way is to solve the problem as quickly as possible, whether by internal approach or outside enforcement. Without irritating the leaders, an outside intervention can help before the issue explodes on itself, costs BofA and Countrywide at least $915.5 million to settle all cases. If Eileen Foster had handed in the suspicious activity report to the U.S. Treasury secretly instead of accuse ER for not conforming to ethical conduct, she can save her job for obvious reasons, fines from the government can be lower than $915.5 million as well, underlying logic is that the fraud problem is probably not as bad during earlier times, therefore the leaders will have the chance to make a better deal with the…

    • 1666 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Rachel Varley Weston Smith Courtney Bouchez ACC 4313 9/4/15 W. R. Grace vs. SEC W. R. Grace trouble all started in the early 1990’s. W. R. Grace is a catalyst manufacturer, they specialize in petroleum refining and chemical processing catalysts. The relatively successful company had run into some unexpected spike in profits. The executives knew that they could not keep up this growth and eventually the profit would decrease again and investors would be concerned. So instead they decided to take the 30% growth and stash it in a secret fund, they participated in profit management.…

    • 1355 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Whistleblowing has been a topic of discussion in business for over a hundred years. While there are federally mandated regulations in place to protect whistleblowers, some still argue that whistleblowing is wrong. The main argument of these naysayers, like Norman Bowie and Sissela Bok, is that whistleblowing is an act of disloyalty to the company. In Ronald Duska’s article Whistleblowing II, he takes opposition to this stance. Throughout his article he makes three main points: employees have no obligation to remain loyal to a company, the primary function of business is profit, and the analogy between business and team is erroneous.…

    • 1165 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Barclays Scandal

    • 1122 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Spinoff traders, and successively, Barclays above all, might have benefited throughout the scandal itself, however when and through the investigation, all parties were command answerable for the manipulation of the rates. Barclays was ordered to pay fines and its name suffered, the traders were possible terminated from employment. In this state of affairs, no party edges long run. Question 2: Who was most responsible for the manipulation of LIBOR?…

    • 1122 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Aftermath of Incident: John Manville did admit that he knew about the dangers of Asbestos and that it could kill people and still kept it from all of his employees, except for his executive stakeholders. After 40 years of damages and lives lost, the cost to John Manville was 4.3 billion in settlements and over 800,000 in claims. John Manville still exists today making close to 2 million dollars in sales yearly. They are now forced to tell everyone who works for them the risks and how to prevent any exposure.…

    • 179 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    1. Identify accounting rules of revenue recognition and describe the inadequacies in accounting context of using bill-and-hold to recognize revenue at Halliburton. According to the accounting principle revenue recognition, it is the function when revenue is reported and recognized when a function has occurred. Under GAAP, revenue recognition should recognize a measurable amount of revenue once a certain transaction has been fully made.…

    • 908 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    He stated, “The fact that they didn 't catch the fraud leads me to believe that they blew it” (Stewart).The auditors of these funds should have somehow at least tested or dug deeper into the material provided to them to discover whether or not the underlying assets were…

    • 1325 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Peregrine Fraud Case Study

    • 1216 Words
    • 5 Pages

    1) At Peregrine, the risk factors, especially those aligned with control environment factors and the “tone at the top” are discussed. The risks included having a paper based confirmation system for the entire business; no segregation of duties, which meant that only one or very few people were working on the financial statements, and in this case Mr. Wasendorf was the only one and had altered all bank documents using only Photoshop, excel, scanners, and printers. Continuing on, time off was not required at Peregrine, which could have ultimately discovered this fraud much earlier, by allowing someone else to sit in the absentee’s seat and review all of their work. Additionally, Peregrine lacked internal auditors or an audit committee at the time. The presence of the internal auditors could have decreased odds of misstatement incentives to commit fraud by management, called fraudulent financial reporting, and overseen…

    • 1216 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Unfortunately in the corporate world there had been internal fraud committed by employees no matter what type organizations they are-nonprofit or profit-and this situation occurs more than anyone thinks it does. Embezzlement happens most frequently to not for profit organizations that have not taken active steps to prevent it. In addition, once any type of fraud or financial mismanagement is detected, many nonprofits do not handle the information properly or understand their responsibility; specifically, whether it is best to address the situation internally or report the fraud to the authorities. Periodically, the latest major fraud hits the headlines as other organizations sit back and watch, telling themselves that ‘it couldn’t happen here.’…

    • 332 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Essay Outline White-collar crimes, although not discussed very often, are on rise. When one hears the word crime, they are inclined to think violence or an unethical abuse of some sort. However, people rarely take corporate crimes such as fraud, theft, forgery, or embezzlement into a higher regard, as they do not highly affect the common citizen personally. Studying these executive crimes is important to raise awareness of deceit within society, and to protect and prevent unethical practices from occurring. The latent impact of these white-collar crimes is the emotional trauma, blackmail, and loss of finances.…

    • 1228 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    My analysis explains three reasons why good people remain obedient and may even succumb to immoral behavior: to feel recognized as part of a bigger whole, under influence of manipulative leaders, and through fear of an authority figure. Often times, it is difficult for an employee to be recognized as one with a positive impact on a company and to feel appreciated for the work he has done. In reality, the hierarchy of power implies that not everyone can become the “corn of the crop.” For a company like Deloitte which spans across the globe, it typically takes about twenty years to become a partner, and less than twenty percent of Deloitte employees actually become one. Despite this mediocre statistic, when faced with an unethical situation where…

    • 1053 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    White-collar crime often is conceived as a sort of residual category in criminology, that is, as a form of crime that is unlike traditional forms of street crime. Write an essay in which you accomplish the following tasks:  Identify and discuss the distinguishing features of white-collar type crimes and white-collar offenders. How do white-collar type crimes differ from traditional street crimes in regards to their characteristics and the techniques used by the offenders who engage in them? One of the most important things I learnt from this class, is to specify the definition of the “white-collar crime” first whenever I want to talk about it.…

    • 1120 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A company which took years to build, like approximately 16 years, where it grew from 10 billion dollar company to 65 billion dollar company, and it would collapse in mere 24 days was nothing short of a scandal. In fact this was to take the shape of a huge scandal. Certainly there was something being hidden from the view of public. For one, there indeed was a fatal flaw as there were several ethical issues. As per the video, there were the issues like arrogance, intolerance, greediness and cheating.…

    • 1057 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Stericycle is a renowned and a big company, they shouldnt have done any of such acts and now it has cost them their reputation and they will lose potential clients aswell If i was among the directors of Stericycle or lets say a manager, ı would consider the matters very carefully and find out who among the staff is responsible and fire hım or her and try as much as possible to not let the outside knows or any invetigators. But if it was already beyond my control i would report all those who are responsible and accept any punishment or fine that is given on the…

    • 997 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Incident at Morales is a short video that brings to attention ethical dilemmas that could be faced in the engineering work field. Phaust Chemical is a company that develops paint removers. They have thus far, dominated the paint remover market. Chemitoil, a competing company of Phaust, has recently plan to introduce a paint remover that competes with Phaust in the market. As a result, Phaust now has a high desire to quickly build a new plant and develop a paint remover in order to stay competitive.…

    • 2165 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays