Peoplemaking By Bryan Caplan And Victoria Satir

Improved Essays
Most people enter parenthood understanding that a lot of work goes into raising a baby. However, young parents put an enormous amount of extra pressure on themselves when they decided to start a family. When parents raise their children they often replicate or oppose the way their parents raised them. What if I told you, that when applied as solely one or the other, both nature and nurture play a very small role in building a responsible, ambitious child. In fact, a child’s behavior is a combination of more than just nature and nurture, but genetics and environmental stresses, the formula is Genetics x Environmental Influences. Both Bryan Caplan and Victoria Satir voiced their own opinions on the topic in their articles titled, “Good News and …show more content…
She calls a family a factory where people are made, and the parents are the people-makers. In addition, she also says that an individuals’ behavior depends on their relation to her four aspects of family life. The four aspects of family life are self worth; the ideas an individuals has of oneself, communication; A way to talk out or talk through problems, rules: the way a person should feel and act, and their link to society: the way in which an individual relates to different organizations and institutions in society. Additionally, when one or more of these aspects are negatively affected, the individual and the family …show more content…
A vivid example of this in my life is when my mom had a mental and physical reaction to her medications, she became very lethargic in her daily routine and had very irrational moods. For a span of four to five months, I managed to get up, feed myself and my mother, go to school, go to football practice, get home around six, make dinner, do chores around the house, finish homework around two or three in the morning, and get up around six in the morning for school the next day. I believe that as the research study says,“Stressful childhood events could modify children’s brain development” and behavior (Perroud, N., et. al. pg. 314-322). This traumatic experience during my childhood caused a behavior modification and is one of the main reasons that I act more mature than most of the people my age. Because I had this experience where I had no choice, but to act more like an adult, I grew up and matured faster than my

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Nature versus nurture has been a scientific debate that has constantly been argued and discussed for decades. Both “Outliers” by Malcom Gladwell and the article focusing on the academic success and economic status of children whose parents are immigrants argue on the nurture side of it all and the accountability of environmental factors that are out of one’s control and are not just purely genetic.…

    • 65 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Nature versus Nurture debate can be traced back to a few millenniums ago, and to this day it continues to rattle our brains with its complexity. William Golding an english novelist wrote the book Lord of the flies in 1954 under the preconceived notion that every human is born with the propensity to do evil; as opposed to Jean-Jacques Rousseau a philosopher and writer of the 18th century who swears it is our environment that shapes us to be good or evil. Genetic influence over traits may exist; however, the environmental factors are the real origins of our behavior. I agree with Rousseau on the nurture theory of this debate. Feral Children are a good example of Jean-Jacques theory.…

    • 929 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Despite the arguments favouring the ‘nature’ debate, it remains a deterministic approach that assumes that psychological traits are predetermined and programmed whilst virtually ignoring non-genetic factors involved in human development. Even when evolutionary psychologists acknowledge the influence of the environment, they reduce its role to that of a trigger of the predetermined developmental instructions supposed to be encoded in a person's genes. Furthermore this essentialist way of thinking creates naturalisms therefore ceasing to require social or political explanation, becoming a constant that can be relied upon and taken for granted. It also asks to question the role of stepfathers or people adopting children that are not their biological…

    • 140 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This experiment of studying adopted children is the ultimate test of “Nature versus Nurture.” Is the way people are and behave truly due to their environment or biology? The truth is that is is both, but this is a test to observe the extent of its severity.…

    • 584 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Nature versus nurture has been a debatable issue since as early as the 17th century in psychology. The issue consists on whether humans are how they are because of their nature or because how they are nurtured during child development. In a 2007 article, McLeod contributes that nature is what humans inherit while nurture is environmental influences. Researches and psychologists who are strong in their position of nature are called nativists. Meanwhile, the researchers and psychologists who agree on nurture are called empiricists (“Nature vs. Nurture, 2007, para.…

    • 1480 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Nurture Assumption

    • 457 Words
    • 2 Pages

    This article is a book review of the Nurture Assumption written by Judith Rich Harris. Harris’s main belief in the book is that parents must share credit with the child’s own nature, and most importantly with the child’s peers. Harris’s book focuses on the importance of peers and genes. Genetics explains only approximately half of the variation in people’s personalities and abilities. Everyone acknowledges peers is important, but instead of treating it as a nuisance in children’s socialization, Harris makes it a key player.…

    • 457 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Every teacher has their own philosophy on children and teaching within the early years. This philosophy is based around their beliefs and values, research and personal experience about children and the way they learn and the role of their educators. It is important that a teacher is clear on their philosophy, as they will draw on it for all that they do.(Arthur, Beecher, Death, Dockett& Farmer, 2012). This essay will explore one such philosophy that will be supported by research, varying theories as well as exploring what this would look like within a classroom.…

    • 2039 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Nature vs nurture is a big argument that still goes around a lot till this day and it is about whether it is true that children’s education is based on their parents actions and education on how they were when they were a child and a teenager. There are many remarks that will insult some people because they will say you are dumb just like how your mom was, or you are only smart because of your mom. This little argument can either be a good example or a bad thing that will affect people’s feelings, with me I look at it both ways. You have to realize that some students will hear either good or bad stories with their parents childhood and without realizing will follow their steps, but also children’s education and actions are sometimes based on their surroundings. I honestly think that certain kids are like their parents with by the way they talk because as their children are growing up…

    • 952 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A family does not work on an individual basis. It works together to produce one complete product, a functional family. Though all families are different, they share the characteristics of the family systems theory. And even though the theory clearly states in its’ title that it deals with families, the concepts and characteristics can not only be applied to families but also different groups thought out life.…

    • 732 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Nature vs Nurture There is always been a large controversy over whether our environment or genetic make-up effects our behavior, ability, personality and development. Nature vs. Nurture is known as most recognized controversy. Some people might believe it is our genes that effects our life, but others might believe it’s our environment we live in affects us and there are some people that believe both facts influence human behavior.…

    • 449 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In conclusion, both nature and nurture has different impacts on a child’s behavior. These factors can be from social and the environment or different genetics that a child can inherit. All of these factors have been tested through adoption studies where researchers have placed children in different environments and studied how the children react whether the environment being positive or…

    • 835 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A commonly held assumption is that children are bound to be very similar to their parents. While there is some truth in this, scientific research shows that genetic considerations do not entirely determine outcomes for individual development. From week 4 all the way to week 6 we have been reading different articles in regards to the different levels of contributions and influences that nature and nurturing have on individual development. Comprehensive clinical studies show that adverse conditions in early life can severely impact the developing brain and increase vulnerability to mood disorders later in life" (Murgatroyd, & Spengler, 2011).…

    • 1360 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Introduction The argument of nature vs. nurture has been one of the oldest and one of the largest controversies on whether our influences come from our genes (nature) or environmental factors (nurture), and how it could affect our behavioral, appearances, development, and our personality. These two play a big role in the human development. This argument will always exist on what is said about the human development. Scientists have not been able to sort this argument out and decide which one rules out the other.…

    • 778 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sociology – Unit 2 Assignment Unit 2 Assignment is worth 50 points Assignment - Chapters Three and Four Part I - Discuss the "nature versus nurture" argument and provide support for each aspect of the controversy. “Nature versus nurture” is a concept within psychology whereby the extend of which aspects of behavior is inherited or acquired. Human behavior is largely influenced bu both of these factors when it comes to behavior. There are characteristics that we inherit and others that we develop, depending on or environment and experiences.…

    • 637 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Nature versus Nurture "Nature versus Nurture" is one of the oldest argument of all time in history and it still continues until now. Beckett (2002) defined the nature as qualities and characteristics which are transmitted to humans directly from parents through genetics. While, nurture could be explained as "all external factors surrounding human beings from birth to death" (Beckett 2002). Wherefore, scientists confirm that the factors which influence human behavior are subdivided into three aspects.…

    • 733 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays