Nectar In A Sieve Imperialism Analysis

Superior Essays
TITLE HERE
Imperialism has taken over and replaced many cultures and countries; this concept could be seen as both positive and negative impacts upon the affected nation. The idea is based on perspective between the imperialist and the imperialized people. The colonizer has the pretense that they help the nation prosper and grow, however this concept comes to be neglected and ignored as imperialism changes and replaces the native people’s way of life and culture. Imperialism essentially dominates over the developing nation which does not enhance the country itself. This course is a direct reflection upon Kamala Markandaya’s novel Nectar in a Sieve in which Rukmani and her family grow into various hardships and complications as the construction
…show more content…
When the British introduce their modern technology to the Indian culture, it eventually, “became [Rukmani’s family’s] undoing”(Markandaya 131). With the tannery being the first modern advancement from the British, it puts Rukmani and her family through much stress as it increases poverty among her family and the rest of India. The success of the tannery “spread like weeds in an untended garden”(Markandaya 131). This is metaphoric of imperialism as Rukmani compares the modern technology the British bring as “weeds”, giving it a negative connotation. The tannery essentially swallows up the land of many including Rukmani’s family as it flourishes and prospers, forcing them to move away as their village continues to be modernized. Knowing that the British have modernized during the Industrial Revolution, they are able to bring many new products efficiently to the Indians. This pulls people towards the tannery as opposed to buying products from the village market, giving the British complete control of their land. The irony of how the British are motivated to “helping” the Indians modernize is crucial as it displays that the British end up controlling the India and its’ land, forcing them to grow cash crops instead of food crops. With the knowledge that India was located near the Red Sea, Britain became interested in using India for its potential, making it a huge market for …show more content…
The amount of rice Rukmani possesses symbolizes the progress of her family’s self-sufficiency. Before the construction of the tannery, Nathan has a good harvest in which Rukmani “had gunny sacks full of husked rice”(Markandaya 9). As the tannery flourishes, she loses rice and eventually “the granary [becomes] almost empty”(Markandaya 131). This is symbolic of what the British have done, for they have destroyed the Indians well-being and turns it into a land for their own benefit. The Indians are left with almost nothing and Rukmani’s family along with her village suffers through the result of this and hunger. Without their livelihood, Nathan demonstrates his insufficiency as he says, “cannot live by the land” and he has “no other knowledge or skill” to sustain himself with (Markandaya 133). After losing much of what they had left, they ultimately become helpless, resulting in the urgency to move away from their home. This is the effect of imperialism as it begins to displace the Indians with their own culture and people. Being under complete control of the British, the Indians become powerless and insufficient due to losing their livelihood. This is a direct reflection upon the development of famine in India as the British continue colonization. Imperialists essentially “spoil” the people with, “the brutal manner of [their] giving” instead of doing “the

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    In Nectar and a Sieve it was about Indian women who lived in a village where she went through some struggles with her family. In the novel you could find some important, powerful motifs and symbols. Struggle was a powerful motif in nectar in a sieve .rice being the perfect symbols I would say represented the fact that they weren’t accessed too much food due to the condition of their finances also tragic seasons of weather. This was huge struggle for them.…

    • 438 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Apush Empire Dbq Analysis

    • 537 Words
    • 3 Pages

    An empire is a group of countries controlled by one ruler or one government. Throughout history, empires transform its surrounding nations — changing the economics, politics, and societies during their rise and more notably their fall. Empires such as the Roman and British Empires faced a variety of problems that led to their decline. The fall of these empires influenced changes in nearby societies and regions.…

    • 537 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This shows that India created positive standards of living under British rule and it also highlights the key idea of ethnocentrism. The British judged India on their lifestyles, so they decided to improve it for the benefit of the people. In addition, in Document 6, the British made many improvements such as ending slavery, establishing a court system, educating officials how to administer their country, and also creating an education system (Document6). This also shows that the British positively influenced the Africans’ lives. However, they also did many negative and harsh things.…

    • 809 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    India Dbq

    • 923 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Although the english paid them to work they are paid 20x less by just being Indian so when they didn’t have people buying their products they were left with nothing hardly. Even though they were given jobs and a chance to make money it was in a way that was making nothing. The cost of cash crops was also that they ruined the land, it hurts the soil making it so that you can’t grow anything else other than that one thing that you plant the first time and even then it sucks the good and healthy from the dirt making even what you do plant not very good or not able to grow at all (Gandhi). Although the English saw it as a way to make more money they planted wrong and over planted indigo so when people didn’t want it they were stuck with all of this indigo and no need for it. And even though cash crops might could have been a good thing if they ended up planting the right thing they didn’t…

    • 923 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Imperialism is the domination of one country of the political, economic, or cultural life of another country or region. In the movie Anna and the King, we see many examples of imperialism in Southeast Asia. From the achieved freedom of a slave to the surprisingly difficult task of using cutlery, we see how the European culture has affected Siam. However, the most notable of these changes don’t occur during the time we spent with Anna, but after. Anna’s teaching and the revolution that occurred in Siam during the 19th century affected the siam region both positively and negatively.…

    • 383 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Western Culture Dbq Essay

    • 541 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The people of India had many views on how to handle western culture ranging all way from assimilation to complete rejection. Many things such as religion, social class, and political ideology influenced an Indian’s position on whether to westernize and to what extent. For example, Mohandas Gandhi in a private letter following his experiences living with the peasants of India insisted that all western technologies and customs must leave with the British and all upper-class Indians must give up their wealth and status. The arguments presented in this letter are, like many of his, completely unrealistic and harmful since Gandhi was often overly idealistic and ignorant towards the benefits of British rule (Doc. 4). This view was not a popular one as virtually everyone benefited from these technologies and getting rid of them would send India fifty years backwards and drastically decrease quality of life.…

    • 541 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the famines 58 million people died (Paragraph #7). During the famines, the British taxed the Indians, if they didn’t want them to buy something, they would add tax to it so they wouldn’t buy it. Although, the British have built universities and museums (Paragraph #11), only the wealthy went to school. The British had only educated 16 percent of the Indian population.…

    • 399 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The power of the British empire was able to put down rebellion with minimal struggle, overcome the expense, and reap the numerous benefits that dictating India brought. The chapter of Imperialism in British history was an important one, as it shaped British policy for over a century. Britain’s triumph over India benefitted Britain through gleaning them resources and an ally during the world wars. With minimal resources used during the conquest, the reward highly exceeded the cost.…

    • 1209 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Trade protocols and import-export duties were constructed to have a detrimental effect on India’s exports. The British would discard finished goods into India all while taking away raw resources contributing heavily to the downfall of India’s industry. With the downfall of India’s industry, the plunder of riches were used to help Britain’s economy prosper. Taxes that were obtained were used to finance Britain’s expansionism. Policies that were made had long term effects on India’s way of governing, education and social systems, culture, religion, and history.…

    • 463 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Imperialism has been a prominent force in the world for centuries and centuries, shaping the way the world looks today. Imperialism is a system of control where the minority completely dominants the majority through the extraction and exploitation of the land and its inhabitants. Through a corrupt system of control, MNU, the film District 9 reveals the prominent downfalls of imperialism highlighting the subjugation of the “inferior”, personal benefit, and national oppression. Subjugation of the inferior is a huge critique of imperialism, it supports the division of citizens and low qualities of life. The MNU uses multiple tactics to gain complete control over the aliens in district 9.…

    • 817 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Britain 's rule over India is often referred to as the Raj, where roughly about 20,000 or so British officials and troopers ruled over 300 million Indian people. The British almost had complete cooperation from the local Indian princes and Indian troops, making it extremely easy to control the country. Their control over India was solidified even more by the fact that India was not a unified country. The British made treaties with the independent states in India, which created a deeper divide in the country and ensured that India could never unite against them. The caste system only helped the Brits maintain their control.…

    • 2140 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The British built tanneries in India in order to take the needed land from the innocent people. As the “storm” occupies the village of Rukmani it “[leaves a] disaster and desolation” the people struggle more for food, protection and survival (Markandaya 41). The storm that demolishes the town symbolizes the British storming into India and decimating the native’s livelihood. Even though the massive storm of Great Britain attacks the town, it mentions how “the [British] tannery stood, its brick and cement had held it together” showing how British territories and land seek to remain and stay put (Markandaya 41). Britain 's industrialized invention of the tannery results in resources, and land to be taken away from the people; however, when the “storm” of the Britain hits, the powerful building stands.…

    • 1489 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    During the late 1800s, Western European nations like Great Britain began to use the term imperialism, to justify using their powers over weaker countries around the world. Two countries who were impacted by imperialism were Nigeria and India. Imperialism was very beneficial for the European and American powers, but had a negative impact on the countries who faced this which would lead to issues. One example that gives insight to how India was impacted by Britain’s imperialism, is Dadabhai Naoroji’s speech, “The Pros and Cons of British Rule.” Naoroji, a man born into a prosperous family, left his math career so he can fight for better conditions for India.…

    • 1588 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    European imperialism can be defined as Europe 's attempt to extend its power throughout the world through colonization. Salih and Conrad present the spread of European imperialism and the role it played in the lives of those it affected. Both novels present two major characters who present the ideology of the societies they represent. These characters embody represent the aspects of the cultures that molded them for both good and bad. Set in the dense heart of the Congo Joseph Conrad 's Heart of Darkness revolves around an essence of European imperialism masked by good intentions.…

    • 1474 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When Britain annexed and ruled India, they made great changes and created a vast impact. Britain invaded India knowing that India would offer many benefits and that there were many people to take from. When the British ruled, they had very forceful system and used many tactics to make sure they had full control over the Indians, therefor changing the ways the Indian thought. Lastly, the British made many adjustments in India’s culture as well. The British definitely changed the daily lives of many Indians.…

    • 729 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays