Menunier And Granger's Methods

Decent Essays
Case study
This paper follows the classification of Menunier and Granger's because they indicate that idiomatic and fixed expressions are phraseological unit. In addition, they subcategorize idioms into three subsets: semi-idioms, pure idioms and literal idioms. Concerning strategies, Baker's methods couples with Trosborg's techniques will be satisfactory. Moreover the research proposes the difficulties stated by Mona Baker. In this regard, it compares between idioms extracted from the Arabic novel by Radwa Ashour with its translation by William Granara clarifying which strategy is used to renders specific idiom. It is of importance to know that Ashour tries in her novel to mix between the colloquial and formal language. Therefore 11idioms
…show more content…
Likewise Abu Sa'ad (1987) argues that the majority of Arabic idioms are influenced by certain linguistic phenomena such as: synonymy, homonymy, and antonym (p. 47). Therefore Arabic idioms are clearer than English idioms, yet they cause confusion among translators. For instance, In the first chapter of Granada, Ashour describes the status of Arabs during surrendering Granada. They not only paid attention for every word, but they also interpreted any command had come from Al Hamra. She says,"الناس في غرناطة تسمع وتتقصي". In this part, the translator renders الناس تسمع وتتقصي into ''they kept their ears into the ground''. In oxford English dictionary "keep an ear to the ground" is defined as'' be well informed about events and trends''. This indicates that he uses idiom of almost similar meaning and dissimilar form as Baker …show more content…
For example, دون لف و دوران"" is a popular idiom means without nonsense. After the Castilians made everything under their control, they started to close anything related to Islam and Arabs even the Arabic bathhouses. At that time, they closed the bathhouse in which Saad was working so his friend Naeem tried to convince his patron with Saad's skills saying دون لف ودوران وأنت معلمي الذي أكرمني"". It is obvious that this idiom is free from any complications. Granara reflects Mona Baker method of using using an idiom of similar meaning but dissimilar form. He renders "دون لف ودوران" into "beat around the bush" which means "discuss a matter without coming to the point" In oxford English

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    VIC NAPPA and the Case of Oxymorons With the Peanuts ™ Gang! (Meet the Gang!) Pg. 1 Interjection: An abrupt remark, made especially as an aside or interruption. “Ring!…

    • 1260 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Context: During this passage, the lamp about to run out on oil and Suqqivaa is hurrying to fill up the lamp with oil, until her husband Irnginnak stands in the way and blocks her. Commentary: The Indigenous story “Oil’’ by Sean A. Tinsley and Rachel A. Qitsualik represents an abusive relationship between a wife and husband. An abusive relationship is a social issue that can happen to anyone.…

    • 1037 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Lost In Translation Essay

    • 1623 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Lost in Translation In her manuscript Trickster Travels, Natalie Zemon Davis was able to capture the life of a mysterious, elusive, and often times confusing man living in the Mediterranean area during the 16th century. In an attempt to understand al-Hasan ibn Muhammad ibn Ahmed al-Wazzan’s life as a traveler, diplomat, captive, writer, and translator, Davis analyzes primary and secondary sources alike in order to develop a comprehensive view of who al-Hasan al-Wazzan really was. Davis finished her manuscript in 2006, after doing thorough research into both the writings of al-Wazzan as well as the historical context in which the writings were composed.…

    • 1623 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Granger Movement Analysis

    • 557 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In the late 19th century famers were suffering due to the drastic challenges in the economy of the United States. After ending the Civil war, devastation came for the poor farmers worsening their economy, production in their lands, and future. They were trying to find an alley out of their nightmare that they were going through. One of the first issues that caused a struggle for the farmers was the high tariff on produce and imports. They were outraged with this injustice, this meant an increase on manufacture items, leading to more money to be spend ultimately more debt for the farmers.…

    • 557 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Language is a very powerful tool that can be expressed in different forms, each with a unique perspective. This is present in the stories “Two Words” by Isabel Allende and “I Am Writing Blindly” by Roger Rosenblatt. It is also visible in the collage titled “Always Together” by Philippe Beha and “Translations” a poem by Lake Sagaris. Three themes can be taken from the four interpretations on language. The theme that language is visible in every person, that the same words can have dual meanings depending on how they are used.…

    • 1044 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The ethnography of Meddle East by Elizabeth Warnock Fernea in the story of “Guests of the Sheik” remind me my own town in my home country. Being from Medial East most of the cultural norms and Islamic roles in the story looked quite familiar with the cultural norms and Islamic roles back in my country. Lived all the way down on the other side of the ocean, I personal experienced most of the life experience of Fernea, which she mentioned in her story “Guests of the Sheik”. Elizabeth Warnock Fernea tried to impartially share her eye witnesses experience from the Islamic Shiite village of El Nahra with her focus on the women life in town. After reading her great work about one of the Islamic village in Meddle East named El Nahra.…

    • 1459 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The main thesis of this article is focused on the rules for parents to raise teenagers. In this article Rittberg has chosen to study the teen behavior and provide expert opinion because it will help parents raise their teens and keep them safe from the serious damages to their behavior while they are in a developmental stage of life (Ellen Pober Rittberg N.p). This works particularly when teenagers want to adopt such behaviors that turn out to be dangerous for them and might pessimistically influence their upcoming educational, societal or occupational views. There lots of simple examples of author choice, i.e. what they need for reliability, responsibility for their role model. Their desires to debate need for house rules, i.e. no eating outside kitchen and spending time room (Ellen Pober Rittberg N.p).…

    • 503 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Jacques Roumain Analysis

    • 516 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Jocques Roumain is an excellent writer that shows audience the essence of the Haitians activism through his beautiful novel "The preface to the life of a bureaucrat. " The atavism which was a typical element that characterized the governmental authorities for decades. This novel was published in 1930 and in this period a lot of relevant events happened in Haiti. Eustache Antoine Francois Joseph Louis Borno was a lawyer who later became president of Haiti during the period of American occupation in Haiti. ( 1922- to-1930).…

    • 516 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Henna Vohra is a student from UIC that is majoring in English and minoring in Asian American Studies. By attending UIC, Vohra became influence to do more researches on the different usage of common languages and identities of each individual. In the essay, Finding the Right Words to Express Me, Vohra describes how she became aware of two distinctive dialects in English through her experiences. The different dialects of language used on a daily basis help identify an individual. Vohra realizes that she uses two distinctive dialects of English, which are “Black English Vernacular” and “Standard English.”…

    • 335 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As the author begins his interview with the tuna fisherman in Yemen, he asks the fisherman if he believes he is poor to which the fisherman replies, “Good. Not rich or poor, but I am happy” (Vollmann 29). Vollmann asks a similar question to a beggar lady whose name is Annah, and he gets nearly the same response to that of the fisherman “…For me it’s no problem. And I am happy” (Vollmann 30).…

    • 1808 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Undertaking Missions What drives people to undertake missions? The thing that drives people to undertake missions is to have a better life. In the three passages The Other Side Of The Sky, Call Of The Klondike, and Barrio boy there was Farah Ahmedi, Stanley Pearce, and Ernesto Galarza who undertook different missions but still managed to complete it.…

    • 465 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In the end, I ran.” (Khaled Hosseini 139). These are the words of Amir, a young Afghan living a privileged life in 1960’s Pakistan. This pivotal moment in Khaled Hosseini’s novel…

    • 987 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Grounded by Language In Mother Tongue, Amy Tan begins her short story by giving the audience prior knowledge that Tan is not a scholar of English and she is not able to give much more than her past knowledge on the English language. She then proceeds to give the readers an idea of how much she is fascinated by language itself and gives it a grading scale from complex english to simple English. Tan presents her short story by giving the readers a recent experience that made her rethink the past, present, and future.…

    • 1004 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    By selling or giving away his possessions, items that are not only considered Western by things bought for him by his father in preparation for becoming an accountant (119). In applying the definition of possessions and belongings to Ali’s situation, Kureishi illustrates the change in Ali and his feeling of no longer belonging to Western society and everything material that that entails. By removing Western belongings, bought for him by his father, from his life, Ali illustrates his view that he no longer belongs to Western society and by extension, his…

    • 1799 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Adaptation and translation It is a well-known fact that in order to obtain a perfect translation, one must go beyond the superficial meaning of the words. And is very important to extract what the words mean in a particular situation according to the cultural context. Considering the cultural element helps us understand that the translator is not only person involved in the translation process, he also gives us a new culture with another way of thinking, deep understanding the culture of another nations. For instance, in the book entitled Leaving the Atocha Station by Ben Lerner, the main character, Adam Gordon, is a young American poet who came to Madrid, Spain, for a fellowship, translates some poetry. Adam’s translation was a translation of converting words or text from one language into another; in other words, he was adapting poetry by using the exact equivalent or close by meaning…

    • 1079 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays