Analysis: The Meech Lake Accord

Improved Essays
Elijah Harper was the first Treaty Aboriginal to be a Member of The Legislative Assembly in Manitoba. He was in the Legislature between the years of 1981-1997. Elijah Harper’s career achievement was blocking the passing of The Meech Lake Accord. Elijah Harper was correct that the Meech Lake Accord deserved to be stopped. This is due to the fact that it was being voted on by people who had a conflict of interest. Secondly, it would have created an inequality of power between Quebec and the rest of the provinces. Lastly, the trade off for the Meech Lake Accord was almost purely symbolic. The Meech Lake Accord would have made a power disparity between Quebec and the other provinces. In the Meech Lake Accord, one of the conditions is that …show more content…
The Meech Lake Accord was voted on by Provincial Legislature. Unlike if Citizens of Canada voted for it, the votes needed to be unanimous in favour of the Meech Lake Accord. It would need to be unanimous in all Provincial Legislature. Quebec made deals with the Premier of each province to include conditions that would benefit them. These changes include changes in split cost programs and power over immigration to their province. These deals were made behind closed doors which angered many Canadians, sparking many protests. These protests could be largely attributed to Pierre Trudeau who became the figurehead of the opposition to the Meech Lake Accord. The deals that were made between the provinces greatly interfered with their bias. Since the Meech Lake Accord would give more power to the provinces which would be a conflict of interest. The Meech Lake Accord should have been voted on by the People of Canada, not by people who it would benefit. Luckily, the bill had to be passed in 3 years since its introduction. This is why Elijah Harper is a hero for delaying it till past the 3-year limit. This stopped the Meech Lake Accord from being passed in that iteration. This is one of the worst things to have come close to pass in Canada because it would have made a large change to Canada’s Government without allowing the average person to vote on

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    This closed door approach to the political process caused allowed for little input or negotiations from others and ultimately led to the decline and fall of the Meech Lake Accord, which resulted from a number of failures in the eyes of the public. However, two distinct oppositions can be found as the cause of the collapse of the Meech Lake Accord such as the Distinct Society clause and the absence of aboriginal…

    • 2008 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Then Manitoba had joined confederation in the year of 1870. Louis Riel had tried this idea again and failed because the federal government now owns Manitoba so the government said that he had committed treason which then lead him to having a…

    • 767 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Maple syrup influences Canada. Similarly, Quebec influences Canada as well. To sum up, many politicians will use method to win whatever they want, but sometimes they may forget what do they citizens want. Some politicians want to get right for their people, but actually they win the benefit for themselves.…

    • 669 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    According to the book’s publisher, McGill-Queen University Press, its authors include over “eighty elders from the five First Nations involved in Treaty 7 - the Bloods, Peigans, Siksika, Stoney, and Tsuu T'ina” . The first of these two articles, “A Treaty Right to Education” looks at the historical timeline regarding education in the treaties and how exactly they government of Canada has failed to provide education in reserves. This article argues that the Europeans failed to provide adequate education to the indigenous people as were promised in treaties one to seven which were negotiated between 1870 and 1877. The author goes into detail explaining the different ways in which the government failed to provide what it promised to survive which surprisingly is still occurring at the current time.…

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Nisga’a agreement was formed when the canadian government and the Nisga’a Nation agreed that Nisga’a had rights to control 2000km of land and to govern themselves. This group of First NAtions were lucky to gain land as well as independence. The Nisga'a national unity grew tremendously because of the agreement, they were finally able to express their culture and religion. This nation gained self determination, and because of this their unity grew. This helped Canada's national unity grow because a culture/nation is able to express their themselves.…

    • 258 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many francophones across Canada wanted to separate Quebec from Canada, and to make a separate country. Many people agreed with the idea, though many more did not. When it came to the proposition to the government, Trudeau said no because the idea was not precise enough. Later the idea started to really take flight across Canada which caught the attention of many French-Canadians. After a second attempt at requesting the idea, Trudeau once again was very confident in his rejection.…

    • 828 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Quebec has played a special role in French history of Canada. They spoke French in France, they feel that the way of living in France is still different from the North American mentality in Quebec. However, it doesn't mean that Quebec culture is exactly the different as the rest of Canada. I think it would be dangerous for them to do based on their history, traditionalism and their deep passion to do. Canada is at the reason why Quebec even existed.…

    • 369 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    The treaty was signed on Christmas Eve of 1814 and did not declare a victor, rather it was an agreement to peace and the agreement to suspend hostilities. However, this was a win for Canada in its own right as it was not devoured by the United States and remained mostly unscathed. As a result of this successful defense of Canada many ‘heroes’ emerged that played a crucial part in the conflict against the American…

    • 1399 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    1980 Quebec Referendums

    • 544 Words
    • 3 Pages

    All regions of Quebec voted against Quebec’s independence except the North Shore region and the Saguenay-Lac St. Jean (“1980…

    • 544 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Quebec has been viewed as an unique state compared to the rest of Canada for quite some time and by many individuals. Quebec 's separatist movement can be seen throughout Canadian history, from Justin Trudeau; the leader of the liberal party, saying ' ' Quebecers are better than the rest of Canada, because, you know, we’re Quebecers or whatever. ' ' during an interview, to the Quiet Revolution, Quebec views its self as its own country. It originally started with the Royal Proclamation of 1763, the first document that outlined how to govern the colony 's pre-Canada. It was unique wherein, the French lost New France to the English and yet, it protected the cultural integrity of what was to later become Quebec.…

    • 1360 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Canada feared of the United States taking over what was left of British North America. This was presented in the movie when John A. was talking to the then Governor General about the U.S threat and how the colony was so powerful. In 1854, the British North American colonies had signed a Reciprocity Treaty with the U.S for a ten-year period. In 1865, the American government decided to end the treaty. The British North American…

    • 1324 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The confederation was a good thing because they had the right to use French or English in Parliaments. But unfortunately the bilingual was not working together in Canada since the Regulation 17 enacted. That made Quebec aware that they…

    • 1243 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In 1978, the Canadian Government began to look to the North for economic expansion as a result of the vast resources of the North (Sinclair). The area is rich in gold and oil and the rest of the world also saw the economic potential in the North (Sinclair). In 1985, the United States of America began traveling through the Northwest Passage without the permission from Canada, lobbying the Northern waters to become international (Dickason and Newbigging 277). Canada saw the United States as a threat and acted swiftly to grant the Northerners their request for self-government. A political accord was signed by both parties in 1992 (Belanger, 222).…

    • 2048 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Aboriginal Struggles

    • 1283 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The United Aboriginal Struggle “Get over it!” A statement that has been repeated time and time again, with regards to Indigenous land. It’s a surprise that Aboriginals want their land back after centuries of not owning it. Is it not? Well, no, it is not.…

    • 1283 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Central to the separatist movement of the latter half of the twentieth century was the argument that Quebec needed to become an independent state in order to ensure the survival of the French language, uphold the integrity of Quebecois culture, and allow Quebec’s government to proficiently govern its own affairs. In the views of many, the fact that Quebec has managed to do these things in recent decades without sovereignty has diminished the need and legitimacy of calls for separation. In my opinion, these developments have indeed put to the lie the need for Quebec independence, for it is now apparent that independence is not a prerequisite of achieving these goals. That said, it does not necessarily put to the lie the legitimacy of independence, for the legitimacy of Quebec’s desire for independence is based on more than necessity alone. This essay will discuss how Quebec achieved each of the aforementioned feats without independence, in order…

    • 1725 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays