Mandatory Arrest Research

Great Essays
The law enforcement’s response to domestic violence remains a closely studied topic among researchers and policymakers. Beginning in the 1970s, domestic violence policy reforms swept the nation as a result of political pressure exerted by women advocate groups (Xie & Lynch, 2016). Within ten years, mandatory arrests policies were enacted in states across the U.S. with the purpose of reducing intimate partner violence. In light of the newly enacted mandatory arrest policies, a surge of research emerged with the aim of determining whether arrest policies were efficient in reducing and deterring acts of intimate partner violence (Novisky & Peralta, 2014).
The most influential study to propose arrest had a deterrent effect on subsequent intimate

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The UCR and NIBRS systems are the most utilized crime systems by agencies across the country. The UCR focuses on eight index crime, while NIBRS has twenty two Group A offenses. These two reporting system are very similar. NIBRS goes beyond the limits of what the UCR can accomplish. The UCR and NIBRS coincide with each other, if an agency cannot meet the full participation requirements, it may limit itself to reporting details of incidents involving the UCR’s eight index crimes rather than the NIBRS’s expanded list of twenty-two crimes.…

    • 632 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Victim safety is ensured with constant monitoring of the offenders. Offenders return to court frequently to ensure that there is no violation of bail conditions, orders of protection, and probation conditions (Kaye, 2004). Results have shown that domestic violence courts have allowed “complainants to have a greater trust…

    • 1424 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In The Social Dynamics of Family Violence by Angela Hattery and Earl Smith, they state that “intimate partner violence refers tot he physical, emotional, psychological, and sexual abuse that takes place between intimate partners…between two people who claim or claimed to love each other” (Hattery and Smith 205). Intimate partner violence in a heterosexual relationship can be summarized as a person’s desire to control the power in relationship and force women to be dependent on the man. “There are 2.5 to 4.5 million physical assaults inflicted on adult women by their intimate partner per year” (Hattery and Smith 203). This estimation is believed to be less than what may actually occur because domestic abuse is not sufficiently reported to authorities. A reason as to why women do not fully report these crimes could be that they do not see themselves as a victim, knowledge that an actual crime was committed against them, or simply because they believe that it was a one time incident that will not happen again and they want to forgive their partner.…

    • 1264 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Duluth Model

    • 589 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The Duluth model uses an interagency collaborative approach involving law enforcement, judicial and human services in response to making women safe (Dasgupta, 2010). According Pence and Shepard (1999), the model is understood as the “men’s [re-education] curriculum, the use of a mandatory arrest policy, the use of a tracking system to monitor the criminal justice system, or interagency coordination”(p.4). Ellen’s contributions to the Duluth program were successful thru facilitating trainings, talks, writing, and curriculum work to draw more supporters to the programming (Pence & Shepard, 1999). Through Ellen’s efforts to transform legal and social institutions, it led her to create the coordinated community response (CCR), an intervention strategy, which helped with domestic violent cases (Dasgupta, 2010). The primary goal of CCR is to protect victims of ongoing abuse and reeducate…

    • 589 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In “Perceptions of Domestic Violence Myths, Victim’s Relationship with her Abuser, and the Decision to Return to her Abuser,” Niwako Yamawaki highlights important information on why we as a nation should care more about domestic violence. With the countless victims of this tragedy, a majority experience difficulty when deciding to leave the forceful relationship. The average women will make five attempts to leave her abuser before ending the relationship; however, “50% to 60% of battered women return to live with their abuser after being discharged from a shelter” (Yamawaki, Ochoa-Shipp, Pulsipher, Harlos, & Swindler, 2012, p.2). Reasons for returning to their abusers include a lack of financial; resources, inadequate help from police or from other formal support systems. Women have a tough time dealing with this tragedy and the approach the NFL takes against this crisis is disappointing.…

    • 1584 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The ripple effect of violence against women spills over into the family, the children and can create a generation force for years to follow. Another issue with violence against women is that it is heavily unreported. There are a few major concerns about this particular type of crime going unreported. It hinders the ability for law enforcement to track the consistency of the crimes as it relates to victim and suspect profiles, patterns of behaviors as well as locations favored for this type of delinquency. Through research utilizing victimization surveys, it was found that about half of domestic violence victims interviewed reported their last violent incident to police.…

    • 340 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    While mandatory arrests do not allow for mediation between two parties in the domestic dispute, it does allow for uniformity, fairness, and possibly peace-of-mind for the victim. There was an experiment conducted in Minneapolis Minnesota that showed reduced repeat offenses with cases handled with an arrest versus cases that were handled by partner separation and mediation (10,Weisburd and Eck). uniformity especially important when an officer makes an arrest or deals with a situations because it’s widely known that people who felt like they were dealt with fairly are more likely to be cooperative.…

    • 547 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Some would agree that providing severe sentencing options would deter some offenders from engaging in crime. However, research is limited in regard to the direct impact that three strikes laws have on deterring crime. Proponents of these laws have cited empirical evidence that claims prisoners do acquire about their strike status, thus indicating a deterrent effect, however, this claim remains questionable due to a lack of statistical support. An analysis conducted by the RAND Corporation during the late 90’s, assumed that three strikes would not have a deterrent effect on potential offenders, but would have an incapacitate effect by reducing the number of felonies committed by adults in California between 22 and 34 percent (Dickey & Hollenhorst, 1995). In a follow-up assessment, RAND indicated that incarcerating people does prevent them from engaging in crime, but raised concern about the millions of dollars invested in prisons as the result of three strikes offenders, to prevent 60 crimes annually (Dickey & Hollenhorst,…

    • 1494 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Officer discretion is the ability of officers to use logic and common sense. And, for those seeking assistance from the criminal justice system (CJS), mandatory arrest subordinates their rights and needs to that of the CJS. Advocates claim, with effectiveness that the criminal justice system has factual ignored the context, circumstances and various desires and needs of victims. Majority of states have accepted arrest policies that require police to either arrest one or both parties at the scene, or to just write a report justifying why an arrest is not made. Mandatory arrest policies are normally safer for the victim because if the abuser isn’t arrested, he or she will make the attack worse against the victim as a beating for contacting the…

    • 602 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In particular, liberal feminism guided the creation of mandatory charge policies, which were supposed to ensure that regardless of the gender of the individual who was victimized, police would be required to take the incident seriously. Liberal feminism is widely criticized for focusing on the middle class, particularly white middle-class women (Comack, 2014, p. 37). This is particularly clear in examining some of the implications of the mandatory charge policy. Mandatory charge policies ignore the unique characteristics of domestic violence that do not typically exist in other sections of criminal law (Brown, 2000, p. iv).…

    • 1558 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Police perpetrated domestic violence is a growing epidemic that often goes unnoticed until it is too late. Domestic violence is defined as a pattern of intimidating actions in order to control the victim for the purpose of procuring and sustaining control. While all abusers exercise a similar method of abuse, officers use their advanced skills to escalate this behavior. Their professional training in force, intimidation and surveillance lead to a dangerous and often times lethal combination of domestic violence.…

    • 79 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Legislature desired reform and passed policies for a more direct approach to incidents of domestic violence and mandated law enforcement departments to take action. “In this atmosphere ripe for change, the pioneering and widely publicized Minneapolis Domestic violence Experiment provided some evidence that arrest was a better deterrent of repeat domestic violence than were traditional methods of separation and/or mediation” (Shearman & Berk, 1984). Public policies had an effect on law enforcement practices and impacted wide range of cases than intended. “Domestic violence cases were more likely than nondomestic violence cases to result in the arrest of an offender. While 49.9% of intimate partner cases and 44.5% of other domestic violence case resulted in arrest, only 35% of the cases in which the victim and offender were strangers, and 29.1% of the nondomestic cases in which the victim and offender knew each other ended up with an arrest.…

    • 1436 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Thesis: Laws and mandates alone are not effective in curtailing domestic violence I. . Laws and mandates are not pragmatic if they are void of comprehensive services and treatment for the victim, children, and perpetrator A. Arrest at incidents are not common B. Cases are often too complex to address in court C. TPOs are not effective as a deterrent to continued acts of domestic violence. II. Domestic Violence victims include more than just two individuals A. Children and other family members are often collateral damage in domestic violence B. Trauma and psychological effects on victims impacts their ability to contribute to society C. Laws and mandates do not include supportive services to victim III. Long term impact on the victim…

    • 295 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hypothesis: If domestic violence is continually seen as non-violent to law enforcement, then abusers will continually get away with the incorrect form of punishment. I support my hypothesis to an extent at this point, but I feel as though I should have rephrased it differently. After I did more research over domestic violence and over the laws regarding domestic violence, I am beginning to see that there are holes in my hypothesis. I do believe that abusers will continually get away with the incorrect form of punishment, but there are not exactly guidelines for what the punishment should be for the abusers. I realize that this is how all laws are, but domestic violence branches off into many different categories.…

    • 628 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Locally under Texas domestic laws the penalties range from a “class C misdemeanor, to a second degree felony, which could carry a penalty of two to twenty years in prison” ("Texas Domestic Violence Laws” 1). The conviction rate is very low in most states in fact FBI figures show that “70 percent of the time prosecutors do not file criminal cases”(“Investigating Domestic Violence: Raising Prosecution and Conviction Rates 1”). The study also suggested that with extra nonmandatory investigative work such as “taking photos, finding witnesses, obtaining protective orders, making arrests, listing multiple crime and submitting their reports in a timely fashion”would cause these figures would sharply decline (“Investigating Domestic Violence: Raising Prosecution and Conviction Rates 1”). A first…

    • 781 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays