Joanna Macay Organ Sales Will Save Lives Analysis

Improved Essays
“Every 14 minutes someone is added to the kidney transplant list”, the National Kidney Foundation is not playing around. Statistically speaking that is a lot of people in need of a vital organ. The author Joanna Macay talks about the need for organ donations in her Article “Organ Sales will Save Lives”. Macay disputes her case briefly when stating her thesis in the first paragraph. She goes on to give her opinion that the selling of organs should be built to become legal. More specifically the selling of kidneys. She presents a fact in order to grasp the audience 's attention. She conveys that most are dying to sell their kidneys. The quote sparked a curiosity in me and I started to search for the statististics. World Health Organization experts …show more content…
Macay turns down the idea of dialysis and talks about how dialysis is harsh and makes people tired. I found a problem with these claims. The effects of the treatment were not supported by evidence so I did some searching of my own. I found out dialysis does not put excessive stress on the body it is supposed to help the body function better. When we look at the effects of not having enough dialysis however, you start seeing the negative side effects of the renal failure. I discovered this when I took a glance at “How will I feel on Dialysis?”. This article warns , “Some signs that you may not be getting enough dialysis include: feeling weak and tired all the time.” The site even goes on to say that after the patents get accustomed to the dialysis they feel like they don 't even require the treatment anymore. Dialysis shouldn’t physically restrict you from participating in normal activities while in treatment. The author, although wrong with the effects of the treatment is correct in saying that the process is in fact time consuming. She shows neglect in shedding light on at-home treatments and dialysis you can have while you sleep. this segment shows the generalization of this treatment when leaving these few key facts out about different types of …show more content…
All of this is true but it is not so easy to afford all the medicine for the new kidney to survive. Most insurance plans do not cover the anti rejection drugs. Patents who receive a kidney transplant would have to pay hundreds or even thousands of dollars to cover their medicine alone. I find the writer wrong in excluding the true cost of a kidney transplant. She doubts dialysis to be expensive but forgets to mention how costly a new organ can be. If that patent misses one ani resistant pill intake they are at high risk for the organ to be rejected. Unless you have an identical twin a kidney transplant is a serious thing. It is very costly just like

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    If there was a statistic that backed up organ legalization as far as how many lives would be saved per year, would it be immoral for a person to be in approval of legalization? Miriam Schulman, the director of Markkula for Applied Ethics at Santa Clara University, who wrote Kidneys for Sale: A Reconsideration, believes it goes far beyond saving lives. Anthony Gregory, a research fellow and student programs director at the Independent Institute, and the author of Why Legalizing Organ Sales Would Help Save Lives, End Violence, has similar beliefs as Schulman. Both authors explain how legalizing does not only benefit the rich, but can also benefit the poor as well in other ways; what the need is to what is actually available, such as how many kidneys are available to how many are actually donated; and explains what the people who…

    • 821 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In “Organ Sales Will Save Lives”, Joanna MacKay argues that the sale of humans organs, such as kidneys, should be legalized. She claims, “There are thousands of people dying to buy a kidney and thousands of people dying to sell a kidney.” She provides critical background information on the problem before delving into her main ideas. MacKay claims that donors need and deserve the money, and that buyers are unable to access the necessary organs any other way. Unfortunately, people living in poverty in third world countries would thrive if given the money buyers are willing to provide in exchange for a vital organ.…

    • 268 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Some people scrape by barely enough to eat, living in a run-down shack, and sleeping on its dirt floor. These are the type of people willing to line up at hospitals to have organs removed just to pay off a little debt, buy food and clothing, or even pay for another family member’s operations. They are so willing to sell their kidney for around $1,000, but there’s a risk in donating in this procedure. More people than what you would think risk their health every day just for a little cash. Several studies show that a human can live a healthy, happy life with only one kidney.…

    • 615 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sally Satel Organ Selling

    • 617 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Should organs be legal to sell around the world? Sally Satel, a practicing psychiatrist and kidney receiver, believes so. Satel states that there is a global organ shortage, and that has to do with kidney selling being illegal. In order to make organ selling legal, one would have to price a kidney at $50,000, and implement rigorous health screening. However, what Satel argues in “Why We Need a Market for Human Organs,” reprinted from The Wall Street Journal, is a high risk, high reward deal task in that if everything goes according to plan, everyone is has a new kidney (in theory).…

    • 617 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    She states how dialysis is a way of treating kidneys, but, it is not permanent and there are side effects such as: feeling tired and faint. A live kidney has more benefits than a cadaverous one. Mackay points out how 2,583 Americans died while…

    • 996 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Truth Behind Purchasing Illegal Organs for Transplant The US Department of Health and Human Services reports that an average of 22 people die every day waiting for a donated organ (HRSA). As a result, desperate and wealthy people are willing to pay thousands for black market organs. An illegally purchased kidney alone sells for between 30,000 and 100,000 in America (Interlandi, 2009). However, the donor is likely given less than a tenth of that money.…

    • 1744 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    "Are Ban on Kidney Sales Unjustifiably Paternalistic" by Erik Malmquist corresponds to the main article because they both share that a kidney transplant is the best treatment for the end stage renal disease. The articles both explain the problem on how this disease affects people and…

    • 1198 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Kidneys for Sale Miriam Schulman is the assistant director of Markkula Center for Applied Ethics (hereinafter referred to as “Center”). In 1988, the Center posted the article titled “Kidneys for Sale’’ on its website, highlighting the ethics and morality issues surrounding the continued sale of human kidneys for personal profit, which also led to emails from destitute people who wanted specifics on how they could sell their kidneys, which compelled The Center’s Issues group to discuss the pro- ideology and the ethical issues concerning the issues of organ sales. Overall, the article discusses three main considerations about the sales of organs: the morality and ethics of such exchanges; the true shortage of human organs available…

    • 790 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Anyone who gets a kidney by contract is removed from the waiting list, and everyone behind him benefits by moving up”(Satel). This would actually leave poor people better off than they are now. If most people selling kidneys are random and anonymous then poor people would not be deprived because anonymous people wouldn't give them a kidney for free anyways. In 2005, “only 88 donors last year made such anonymous gifts”(Satel). If someone were having trouble getting a kidney and they needed financial help they could get that from the government.…

    • 1129 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “There are thousands of people dying to buy a kidney and thousands of people dying to sell a kidney.” [Mackay] Mackay instantly grabs on to the readers heart strings with the beginning of her essay. MacKay’s introduction is full of emotionally- charged words and pain. “In third world countries, there are people willing to do anything for money.” [Mackay] “Eager to pay off debts, they line up at hospitals, willing to sell a kidney for about $1,000.…

    • 769 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Ethical Organ Donation

    • 1514 Words
    • 7 Pages

    According to the World Health Organization, the illegal trade in kidneys has risen to such a level that an estimated ten thousand black market operations involving purchased human tissue and organs now take place annually. Organ donations can create a brewing ground for murky crimes! Everything from body snatching, transplantation tourism, involuntary donation, and, the black market organ trade. It is unfortunate that these crimes are on the rise. However, if government legislation were to gain control over organ donation and make ethical organ donation possible, then everyone can benefit.…

    • 1514 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The phrase “drop in a bucket,” is a phrase to say a person can have $100, but there is a million dollar goal, the money now may seem big, but the goal later in life is bigger than what was expected (“A drop”). This little idiomatic phrase is essential to this problem of having some money before organ transplants; that little drop (money before) needs to multiply extravagantly to fill the bucket (cost after bills). To really go into the topic, a main matter for attention related to organ trade and sales is the cost to receive an organ and plus the hospital bill right after. A proposal to make about this is to find a way to lower that high price of the ending bill and make sure families do not have to suffer after all of the turmoil. It would…

    • 1454 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Organ Donation Beneficial

    • 1311 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Organ donation is the act of surgically removing an organ from one individual and transplanting that organ into another individual. This process is necessary because the receiving individual's particular organ has failed and in order to survive they must accept a functioning organ. Therefore, organ donation is necessary to save lives. Although, in order to have the organs available, the community must be willing to donate their organs. Overall, to greatly increase the amount of organs available, an opt-out system would be most beneficial.…

    • 1311 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Kidney Research Paper

    • 817 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The Kidney is are two bean-shaped organs which filter about 120-150 quarts of blood daily to produce about 1 to 2 quarts of urine, composed of waste materials and toxic fluids. There are two main types of methods to treat kidney disfunction namely Kidney transplantation and Kidney dialysis. This essay will discuss the positive and negative impacts of these two solutions on a patient with kidney failure. Kidney transplant is the transfer of a healthy kidney from one person into the body of a person with relatively poor kidney function, intended to filter out toxic waste products in the blood to effectively make up the composition of urine.…

    • 817 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Donation Compensation There is no shortage of people who are in need of lifesaving organs. There is a waiting list of over 650,000 people just waiting to receive lifesaving organs. This list is accumulated data from across the United States. Of this amount, almost sixty percent of this number are people waiting for kidney transplants.…

    • 1129 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays