Is Fat Stigma Making Us Miserable Analysis

Improved Essays
In a NY Times article, “Is Fat Stigma Making Us Miserable?”, Emilie Lucchesi talks about the causes of psychological health problems arising not necessarily from the physical characteristic but from the overbearing stigmatization of being overweight in our society. Contrary to popular belief, there exists almost no direct relationship between how much a person weighs and their psychological health welfare; the problem lies, instead, within how people are being treated. She explains that it’s rather “the teasing, judgment and unsolicited advice directed at overweight people that can cause the greatest psychological harm.”
The article goes on to introduce Courtney Bailey, a media scholar in popular culture, as she explains that the fat stigma
…show more content…
He compared everyday, face-to-face interactions to that of a ‘staged act.’ Individuals, he believed, acted as not only social actors, who have specific roles or parts on various stages, but also as audience members, who constantly responds to someone else’s role performance. He notes that an individual’s “performance will tend to incorporate and exemplify the officially accredited values of the society [and] acknowledges that performers can disrupt social roles by not playing the part their audience expects” (Dillon, 2014, p. 283). What is important to note here, is that there already exists a pre-determined social role of a ‘normal’ person in general, whether we like it or not. The “expected behavior” of people at its most basic foundation, exist free of any physical or mental dysfunction or defect; This is why those who deviate from the norm, like the overweight people in the abovementioned article or those infected with herpes in the, “Protecting Oneself from a Stigmatized Disease,” article, are prone to garner more cruel and judgmental attention from those who are ‘normal,’ and not stigmatized or …show more content…
It comes natural to us to always want to put on a “good” performance. This engagement in impression management can be split up into two different regions—the front and back stages. The front stage is where the performance is given and the back stage is where actors can prep for their performance. In this way, they can ensure a successful ‘presentation.’ The overweight people, being the target of weight discrimination, refused to go to the gym and doctor’s offices to avoid further stigmatization. In this way, they are able to manage their audiences to just those in their immediate surroundings, like their family members who already know what they look like, in order to minimize the possible damage. This is an example of something called passing, a technique used by those wanting to present “an uncontaminated or ‘unspoiled’ identity when in the co-presence of others from whom they must hide their stigma [from]” (Dillon, 2014, p. 292).

People can say we advanced as a society with our increases in social tolerance and legal equality, but that doesn’t stop the audience from “staring,” embarrassing or ostracizing stigmatized people in a public setting. Staring has been associated with the “mechanisms of social control; we stare in disapproval, and when someone else stares at us, we tend to alter or cover up our behavior, and

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    And once that’s been squared away, then comes the decision to display that nonconforming, abnormal self to the collectively-minded, decidedly normal society. Not an easy task to do. That is why when we see a brave human being who is willing to show this unique side of themselves to us, we are shocked. We don’t know how…

    • 1056 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Newson’s Argument Claim: In the film, “Miss Representation,” film producer, Jennifer Siebel Newson claims that women in today society are being miss represented by social media because women are expected to live up to social media expectation such as women need to be beautiful, sexy, and skinny in order to be successful. Reasoning: Social media portray women to be beautiful, sexy, and thin frame which often seen on T.V over and over. This is what social media intend for women to see and encourage to look like.…

    • 1407 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This stigma surrounding food and fatness is simply just another source of income for America 's capitalistic market, not an actual threat to one 's general well-being. Despite agreeing with the majority of her argument, there is one point that I cannot get behind one hundred percent, that point being her assertion that obesity is not a real dilemma with real consequences. No matter the size, our bodies are absolutely beautiful, fighting everyday to keep us alive and kicking. Albeit, just like motor vehicles, our bodies can only handle so much wear and tear before they begin to break down.…

    • 784 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Changing Outlook on Body Appearance Throughout the article, Mary Worley expresses her feelings toward body acceptance by not only revealing many of her real-world experiences,(including a trip to a NAAFA convention, an outlook change in accords to dieting, and discovering the most beneficial way to becoming a healthier human being), but also by providing seemingly factual information to support her opinions about the way in which others view overweight people in our society(Worley, 163-167). Unfortunately, she fails to provide credibility in accords to many of her numerous accusations; therefore, Worley sometimes comes across a mite pretentious. However, some of her more opinionated claims retain value considering Worley, a woman who…

    • 881 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    She claims most people are reluctant to seek medical care because health specialists are some of the most prejudiced people there are (Worley 165). She believes physicians will treat a person’s weight before treating what is actually wrong with the patient and attribute many complaints or ailments to that person’s weight, and believes that these types of pressures can lead to the quick end of a fat person’s life (Worley 165). What Worley seems to be ignoring is the fact that being fat that can lead to many diseases, which have been previously stated, that will lead to the shortening of a fat person’s life, not being told they are fat by someone whose job is to keep people healthy. Even so, in recent surveys it was found that thirty-one percent of nurses and one in three doctors said that obesity was a condition to which they responded negatively (Ansfield). This survey of four hundred doctors supports Worley’s claims of prejudice fat people face from health professionals.…

    • 1058 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    But, this is often not the case. A person’s weight is not always an indicator of one’s health. Just because a person is thin, does not mean they are healthy physically or mentally. Larsen’s openness and honesty about her life struggles allows the reader to connect to her writings. The pressure of society affected her, and many others who are vulnerable to the media’s…

    • 706 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    However, it’s not only an individual’s personal problems that play a role in developing this distorted obsession of body image which leads to eating disorders but also public problems like social media. Tiggerman (2002) claimed that “the media puts severe pressure on women of all ages to be a certain size. Repeated exposure to such images may lead a woman to internalize the thin ideal such that it becomes accepted by them as the reference point against which to judge themselves” (92). Even though, it’s hard not to be influenced by media, it’s not only to be blamed for setting the standards of beauty because it constantly portrayed in every outlet possible. An article from Brown University explains that, “People with negative body image tend to feel that their size or shape is a sign of personal failure too and that it is a very important indicator of worth”.…

    • 1846 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Obesity In Canada

    • 1161 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Obese Canadians face adversity in everyday life. They can be perceived as lazy, unhealthy and uneducated. Also, they can be viewed negatively because of their appearance. They may experience hatred, prejudice and unfairness at their workplace, from their health care providers and in social settings. These experiences along with their current health condition may directly affect one’s self-image and may result in other psychological conditions such as depression and anxiety.…

    • 1161 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Chapter Three Part One 2. How does anti-fat bias impact the workplace? Overweight people are experience “stereotypical attitudes from employers and disadvantages in hiring, wages, promotions, and job termination because of their weight.”…

    • 1442 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Basing my argument on the findings of scientists, stigmatizing those affected with obesity is not a healthy way of adopting public health measures. Trying to stigmatize these individuals is a threat to those individuals and it is meant to cause health disparities, making it harder to assist those individuals in this sector. When these individuals are criticized, this can be said to be an act of social injustice which should be a priority when it comes to public health…

    • 1398 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Obesity is often portrayed as a medical disorder condition that can be overcome by simply changing your diet and physical lifestyles; however, it is much more complex than that. People often stereotype those who are obese as being lazy, less intelligent, and unattractive. Observers may overlook tend to generalize those who are obese as lazy, the narrow minded thought that being obese is the own person’s fault and nothing else. However, not one diagnosis fits all. Negative prejudices against those who are obese influences the way we understand our increasing weight as a problem…

    • 1608 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Individuals suffering from obesity in most cases are always discriminated by the rest of the people that they associate with in their daily lives, this is because many people do not take time or do not completely understand the reason some people may suffer from obesity. While it is true in some cases that obesity is caused by just overeating and a lack of exercise there are also several metabolic disease and conditions that lead to obesity due to their bodies inability to regulate hormones in the body correctly. Since there is no way to distinguish between those obese individuals who have made personal life decisions and those who are effected by disease they all inevitably get lumped into the same category. In many instances, some people take advantage of these situations to mock them while referring to their huge sizes or deformed body figures (Wang, et al, 2014).…

    • 1816 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The public acts as an audience, watching closely at our every movement and gesture. Should we misact or perform out of our pre-determined boundaries, we face the risk of losing our gender status and might potentially be confronted with our inadequacy as a person. Depending on the context and setting,…

    • 1188 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    If you are a certain amount of heavy, you are not considered beautiful and that’s disgusting. You rarely see heavy models, from music videos to company ads, you never see a woman that's not “thin.” There have been many studies that evaluate whether social media and social comparison plays a big part in eating disorders, depression and other psychological disorders that cause women to take unhealthy precautions to change their appearance. Though many of these social media images are “digitally modified in order to look flawless” (Arendt, F., Peter, C., & Beck, J. (2017) many women still feel a huge amount of dissatisfaction when they see a woman who is thinner than them. They begin to compare themselves to the subject who is being idolized on social media.…

    • 849 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    While watching tv most of the character are thin, and the one character who is overweight is seen as unattractive. The outsider on television is always seen as ugly instead of using it as representative of beauty and uniqueness. ”When girls begin to view fashion models and celebrities as icons, it is called media internalization. This internalization refers to the extent to which an individual invests in societal ideals of size and appearance (thin ideal for girls and muscular for boys) to the point that they become rigid guiding principles”. [Thompson et al., 2004].…

    • 1033 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays