French Third Estate Analysis

Improved Essays
The first source represents the injustice and inequity the Third Estate experienced during the Old Regime in French society. The Third Estate is naked and at the bottom, strenuously supporting the priviledged classes. On the other hand, the privileged classes are wearing extravagant attire and are standing with pride and happiness. They show no mercy towards the Third Estate that is continuously supporting them, despite the Third Estate’s low income and unfortunate living conditions. The First and Second estate are also the more dominant figures in this cartoon. This illustrates that they are in control of the country and have the most power. The barrier between the privileged class and Third estates divides society into two completely different …show more content…
It has done everything it has been asked to do, yet, receive no rights or freedoms. Even though they have one that is shackled, the other arm still shows their desire to be treated more equally and create a fairer constitution in which all men are born free. The Third Estate did not back down from the monarchy with their other one arm and continued to fight for their own freedoms and rights. Without the Third Estate, the monarchy would be in severe debt and not succeed. The Third Estate is what connects all the other estates together and allows the formation of the French nation. If there were no privileged orders during the French Regime, The Third Estate would receive more equitable treatment and not be suppressed by other people from their own country. This source demonstrates French nationalism since it implies that without the Third Estate, there would be no unity within France nor would there have been a fairer, more equitable constitution. The Third Estate is everything that the Old Regime was about; despite the fact that they received no priviledges, they wanted to be something different- a group that was well respected by their authorities and had equal rights as the upper

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In order to have democracy foundation, there has to be political, economic and social forces to overthrow the king and develop a new form of government. Therefore, democracy would change the social status and built equality between the three estates. Since France created the new democracy, it also originated nationalism. The revolution changed the economy by having financial difficulties and caused the influence of the American Revolution. From the beginning of world history, the french revolution was one of the most significants events: since it developed a democracy for the world to follow.…

    • 772 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    1. This picture draws attention the social conflicts that were happening during the Estate General, by depicting the third estate, middle-class lawyers or officials representing the people, being brought down. The picture shows those in the first two estates, the clergy of the Catholic Church, and the nobles, standing looking freighted by the man on the ground, who is part of the third estate, by the looks of his outfit. During this time the king refused to mandate voting by head or person rather than by order, because of this the third estate fought back, for if they did vote by head the third estate would have the advantage over the other two estates. They held meetings and elected deputies to write down their grievances, by doing this they thought the king would solve all their problems, but then France experienced a food shortage.…

    • 481 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Haiti 1805 Constitution

    • 636 Words
    • 3 Pages

    I found the 1805 Constitution of Haiti printed in The New York Evening Post on July 15, 1805 to be similar to the previous primary source we read on the Third Estate of Dourdan. Both of the primary sources presented a list of statements that the people proposed to the king, or to the Emperor in this case. One statement that I found similar was, “Property is sacred, its violation shall be severely prosecuted” (H. Christophe). This made me think of the Third Estate grievances because I remember that primary source stating that the property of citizens should not be infringed upon. I also noticed they shared the same ideology about equality.…

    • 636 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This means that the National Assembly, which was mostly made up of members of the Third Estate, wanted an end to the practice of giving people rights based on their social class. Based on this, one can infer that the practice of giving people rights based on their social class was seen as unfair by members of the Third Estate, who, because of their status, had fewer rights than members of the First and Second Estates as well as the King of France. In short, the unfairness of France’s social system led to unhappiness among members of the Third Estate and was a major contributing factor to the French Revolution. The last cause of the French revolution was the heavy taxes the people had to pay. In the diagram titled “The Three Estates in Pre-Revolutionary France,” there are three pie graphs that show the population of France, the land ownership, and the taxes paid according to the three Estates.…

    • 489 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In Document 3, pre-revolutionary French cartoonist illustrates these plights. The king, the clergy, and the nobles are relying on the labor and taxes of the Third Estate. The suffering of the peasant farmer showed in the drawing proves that the cartoonist, and others of the Third Estate, resented this. The French initially tried to solve this problem, as evidenced in the “Cahier of the Third Estate of the City of Paris” document where educated members of the Third Estate…

    • 1144 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The French Revolution was divided into three social classes the clergy (first estate), the nobles (second estate) and the peasants (third estate). The upper class (the clergy and the nobles) raised the tax prices on the third estate but they didn’t have to pay taxes. They also raised the price of bread which made most of the peasants starve and they would fight over the loaves of bread. But later the third estate creates something known as the National Assembly and they created the Declaration of the Rights of Man which changed many things. There were many things that caused the French Revolution but the main reasons are the inequalities between the social classes, The Enlightenment, and the American example.…

    • 958 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    rred during the radical period of the French Revolution as a response to the conflict between the Girondins and The Mountains. During this time, the Committee of Public Safety executed thousands of internal “enemies of the revolution” (“Report in the Name,” 47). Although many argue otherwise, The Terror was not a perversion of the original ideals of the revolution because the ideals of the revolution were to gain more equality for the people of France, and the punishments that occurred were necessary and the cultural changes, in fact, benefited the citizens. As seen through the voices of the Third Estate and its supporters, one of the fundamental goals of the French Revolution was to gain equality and freedom for citizens. In the Town of…

    • 1589 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    French Revolution Dbq

    • 720 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Louis XVI was king during the time of the French Revolution and prevented anyone from the third estate to speak out against him. This law was more directed towards the third estate since the first estate and the Catholic Church were crucial to the country during the time, and the second estate had power in the countrysides. In essence, Louis XVI had the first and second estate on his side by providing them more rights and privileges than the third estate who were currently living in the state of…

    • 720 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A revolution is when citizens of a country rebel against their government seeking major change. This occurred in France shortly after the Declaration Of Independence was signed which pronounced the American Colonies free from the British’s taxes and unfair treatment as well as marked the end of the American Revolution. Unlike the Americans, the French were fighting amongst social classes or estates in their own government. It started with the rebellion of the Third Estate, which consisted of extremely poor commoners who made up the majority of France at the time. The most important causes of the French Revolution were the heavy taxes on the third estate, the unfair amount of land and power the 1st and 2nd Estate held, and the American Revolution.…

    • 616 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is an intermediary body established between the subjects and the sovereign to keep them in touch with each other…the only will dominating the government… should be the general will or the law. The governments only power is the people’s power vested in it.” The concept of the King no longer dictating the law of the land motivated turmoil among the people. The people of the Third Estate were once subjects of the king; however, due to the Enlightenment influence it led to their individuality as citizens by birth-given rights protected under the law. A revolutionary idea in this period, especially considering the government rule was an absolute monarchy.…

    • 928 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Beccaria’s idea, was that the French were trying to make a system of law where everyone would be innocent until proven guilty, which is what we use today. Beccaria tried making the lifestyle ‘terror free,’ where there would be no torture, although the death penalty was still used against some beliefs. Along with Beccaria’s ideals, (Beccaria – Essay on Crimes & Punishments) Emmanuel Joseph Sieyes wrote about “The Third Estate,” which embraces all that which belong to the nation. Even though it may be referred to as a ‘nation,’ the nobles received more freedom than peasants, which was common all around France. This is continued with Beccaria’s ideas, because even though nobles may be treated differently, the punishments are always the same, and so is the theory that everyone is innocent until proven guilty.…

    • 725 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the third estate in France, the people were not treated as equal as the people in the estates above them. Document #5 describes this situation when it says: “Every citizen has the right to participate personally or through his representative in its formation. ... All citizens, being equal in the eyes of the law … no person shall be accused, arrested, or imprisoned except in the cases and according to the forms prescribed by law. No one shall be disquieted on account of his opinions, including his religious views. ...…

    • 871 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The third estate was finally granted a say in the decisions that were made in France, why would they adjust their power to fit the needs of people they saw as incapable? Not to mention that the first and second estate already saw themselves as superior to others. Gouge was asking for more than just equality. She was asking for property share, a general will, freedom of speech as long as it did not disturb public order, women to be able to assert that a child is a man’s without being punished, security, resistance to oppression, separation of powers, and an equal share of public administration and in the determination of taxes (The Declaration of the Rights of Women, Gouge). These were all rights that men simply would not want to give up.…

    • 1255 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    I am living in the French Revolution. I am not related to the king and are not a member of the clergy so for that I am part of the third estate. Being in the third estate can be a good and a bad thing. Being in the third estate means that we are paying all of the taxes. Also I am equal to a serf.…

    • 162 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    His analysis is as follows: Property (wealth), power (influence), and prestige (status) divide people into social classes, where the people with the most of the three are on top, while the people with the least are on the bottom (“What Divides Us: Stratification”). Prestige in particular is important in the novel, because it is not reliant on social class. “Although property and power are objective, prestige is subjective, for it depends on other people’s perceptions and attitudes”(“What Divides Us: Stratification”). This is illustrated by the tributes from the districts.…

    • 1492 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays