Identity Issues In Vladek's Life

Superior Essays
moment, Art recalls that he hated helping his father around the house, as Vladek would believe that whatever Art did was wrong: “He made me completely neurotic about fixing stuff (Spiegelman 97). Further, he says that he became an artist, as his father could not compete with him in that area (97). For these reasons, Art not only resents Vladek’s attitude, but he also suffers from depression due to the responsibility he feels towards Vladek.
In Lost, Treichel deals with identity issues, as a result of his dysfunctional family life. As indicated earlier, when the narrator’s mother embraces him, he feels resentment towards her. There is a resemblance here to Art’s relationship with Anja. Both mothers, in Lost and Maus I and II, look up to their
…show more content…
Likewise, in another scene, the narrator stresses that he was becoming more like Arnold. He says, “…I wanted to stay who I was” (Treichel 45). The narrator stresses, he did not want to be like Arnold; he did not want to share his food or room with him (Treichel 45). Further, the threat of Arnold engulfing the narrator’s identity and replacing it with his own is so traumatic, that he suffers from physical symptoms. He is diagnosed with trigeminal neuralgia, which he relates back to his resemblance to Arnold. He explains the pain to be like a stomach cramp which reached his face, shot up his cheek, and ended at his forehead. Simultaneously, he compares it to the feeling he would get if Arnold was literally being carved out of his face (Treichel 40). Moreover, the narrator’s resemblance to foundling 2307 causes him to doubt his existence to such an extent, that he contemplates whether he is related to his parents in the first place (Treichel 117). For the reasons above, Arnolds influence in the narrator’s life, shatters his sense of self. He struggles to form an identity for himself and constantly question his existence throughout the …show more content…
The fact that Art is attempting to heal himself along with depicting Vladek’s story, is evident in his biography. Author Elmwood believes that by intertwining himself into the narrative of his father, Art is able to overcome his insecurities and become a part of the family’s history (701). Besides, when Art discovers that Vladek read his comic strip about Anja and asks Vladek if he is angry, Vladek responds that he is glad that Art got it outside his system (104). Thus, in Maus I and II, there is a sense that Vladek and Art are aware that Art is a victim of intergenerational trauma and he needs healing, but in Lost, the narrator seems oblivious, at times. “The narrator whose suffering is to live with traumatised parents and the consequent loss of an identity is more detached from the distress that his parents experience,” explains author Van der Merwe (4). This is justified to a certain degree, due to the age difference between Art and the narrator in Lost. The narrator recognizes his emotions of anger, guilt and shame, but does not effectively work through them. Both Treichel and Art experience the burden of their parents post-war trauma; yet, Art frees himself from this “weight,” whereas Treichel remains buried beneath it. Throughout the memoir, Treichel’s emotions are

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Vladek known as Art Spiegelman’s father. Vladek describes himself as “young and a really, handsome boy”. He also compared himself to “Rudolph Valentino”. Vladek in the book is drawn as a strong handsome mouse whilst he was young and the older version of him is just as put, he looks older (glasses, sweater-vests) The way Vladek speaks is unique, such as when he says “It was nothing to find so they searched over the neighbors.”…

    • 195 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Significant personal events in one’s life can act to influence an individual’s artmaking practice. This is evident through Frida Kahlo’s artwork ‘The Broken Column’ 1944, Jenny Sages ‘After Jack’ 2012 and Christian Thompson ‘King Billy’ 2010. Frida Kahlo, is the first example of such an individual as she experienced a horrible accident causing permanent damage to her spine. As a result of the accident, Kahlo became influenced to paint through using her emotion as a driving force to paint where Kahlo states “I am broken, but I am happy as long as I can paint”. This is depicted in Kahlo’s artwork ‘The Broken Column’ in plate 4 which depicts a figure namely Kahlo herself being pricked by nails with the presence of a broken pillar.…

    • 395 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Maus II, Artie struggles with feelings of vulnerability and isolation. This is particularly notable in the scene above where he visits his psychiatrist. Drawn as a small mouse sitting in a chair that is far too big for him, Artie is barely able to make his outstretched legs reach the edge of the seat.1 This inability to rest his feet on the floor could suggest that he does not feel grounded in himself. Artie’s parents are now both dead, and grief may have caused him to feel severed from the world around him.…

    • 291 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Letting the reader know how he was saying the kids name to Connie. This also us the type of guy Arnold is, the outspoken cocky type guy. Arnold could have been a guy who is shy but this summarizing dialogue…

    • 692 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    While they are the same person, they are also different in their respective ways. Similarly, we begin to see how Alexie views marginalization, and the unity that is satisfied or not by belonging to a tribe. Arnold reveals himself to be a loner and a nomad within the first few pages of the story. While he is many things that contradict the depression that may be inflicted on such an individual in his position, he is also a walking contradiction in himself, as he is a boy from many different tribes, and also a loner. He decides on his own he is not simply an Indian, and not only white.…

    • 978 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    ... it 's spooky having sibling rivalry with a snapshot!” (Spiegelman,1991, p. 15). Here one can infer that when Art was a child, he was troubled by the fact that his parents idolize his dead brother. When comparing Art and father relationship to other Holocaust survivor’s father and son relationship one can see that they don’t have a normal father and son relationship. The traumatic experiences that they went through in the concentration camps has compromises the way normal parents act toward their offspring.…

    • 1003 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    He’s been in a constant battle to please his parents since he was a child. “His own troubled existence as an inheritor of their trauma.” (Berger 1) Alan Berger states that Art Spiegelman’s life is difficult being the second child of two Holocaust survivors. Richieu,his dead older brother, left a permanent scar on his parents after he died. Anja could never fully recover from the loss of her first child and as a result, she tried to smother Artie with maternal affection until he was completely sick of her overbearing nature.…

    • 1673 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the novel The New Sufferings of Young W. by Ulrich Plenzdorf the reader is presented with a complex character by the name of Edgar Wibeau. Edgar is a very abstract individual who has decided that the strict life he was thrust into by both his mother, and having to live in a boring town in East Germany has placed upon him were not in his future plans. After coming to this realization due to a work related incident, he packs up the belongings he finds most important to him and moves to Berlin. During his time in Berlin is where the reader is presented with the many personas that make up the character that is Edgar. Plenzdorf uses these many personas that he has written into Edgar’s character along with various interests as a way to speak out…

    • 976 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Denial is a familiar concept because it is how we shut out the unwanted in our lives. It appears to allow us the freedom to choose what our worlds are made of. However, once we begin to apply it to the shaping influences in our lives, it becomes a danger to our capacity for personal growth. In A Bird in the House, Margaret Laurence explores the necessity of willfully accepting and embracing the legacies of the dead in our lives. Through the use of tone and symbolism, we are able to observe the resultant growth that accompanies this acceptance.…

    • 775 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    As readers of Maus, it’s clear that there are at least three speculations for Art’s guilty conscience. We can see this thorough out the story with the though-provoking material provided to us…

    • 1180 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In Art Spiegelman’s Maus, he uses metafiction to establish things he would not have been able to communicate otherwise. Spiegelman created a character to represent himself in the outer story of the novel. This made the book more credible and created trust between Art and the audience. Using himself as a character helped him portray his emotions toward his father’s story. The utilization of metafiction let us closely see Art and Vladek’s relationship, like Art’s rebellious nature.…

    • 1015 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Art on the other hand “survives” the holocaust, but feels guilty about not being there with his father and using his stories as a means to make himself popular. Even though both characters survive in the sense of living (Art’s father lives after the holocaust as seen), neither is a true “survivor.” Both feel abhorrent towards each other, but, neither says it. Vladek only cares about “surviving” from the holocaust and Art only about his stories. However, Spiegelman’s “Maus” is both Vladek and Art’s story.…

    • 764 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Theme Of Guilt In Maus

    • 1029 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The narrative consists of three main forms of guilt, Art’s emotional state of guilt on not being a good son to his parents, his feelings of guilt over his mother’s suicide, and his feelings of guilt in the publication of his books. All these feelings build into the theme of survivor’s guilt. In Maus one of the most basic forms of guilt is Art feeling that he has…

    • 1029 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Conflict In Maus

    • 1363 Words
    • 6 Pages

    As Vladek continues to tell his stories he realizes that he does not want parts of his life and stories, which he is telling his son in the book. Artie lies to his father and incorporates all of it anyways. This really shows how much Vladek means to Artie, compared to how much telling the full story of the Holocaust means to him. Therefore, without the tension and poor relationship between father and son, there might now be such an over-powering Maus. Conflicts arise in many parts of Maus and in many relationships; however, Vladek, especially, has a lot of tension because of the trauma he faced during the Holocaust.…

    • 1363 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Female Characters In Maus

    • 506 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In Maus women are not depicted as being capable as men, this occurs in Vladek’s relationships where the women are dependent on Vladek. The main female characters also have less depth compared to the main male characters, and can be more easily reduced down to “wife” or “mother”. In this book we get to see through the perspective of Art and his father, but never a female character. The female characters’ main purpose is to offer insight into the perception of a male character or a situation. This occurs with Françoise, we do not see much of her in the story, but when we do she is used to tell the reader how Art feels about his relationship with his father.…

    • 506 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays