Separation Of The Mind From The Body By Raymond Smulyan

Superior Essays
Raymond Smulyan proposes a very interesting concept regarding a drug that would separate, the soul or mind from the body. In his hypothetical drug, he states that drug would annihilate the soul completely but that the body would function exactly the same before. Meaning, that the person would act like if they sill had a soul. People would not be able to tell that the mind was separated from the body, only if they were told about it. This, to various philosophers of the mind would bring to many opinions and arguments about whether this could be possible or not. In, fact, there have been various papers and literature out there that bring this concept into depth about whether the mind is something that is attached to the body or something that …show more content…
The mind is such complex concept that for some to believe that they could pin point the location of the soul, in my opinion is rather obscured. The soul is who someone is, and separating the two would be the separation of who the individual would be. There would be no opinions thought and possible any sense of what is going on in the world. That would also bring to question if these people could function as human beings and have empathy for others just as much as people with a “soul” would have. Also, what would be the purpose of this drug? Why would someone want to disconnect themselves of who they are and what, in my opinion makes them who they are. If there would be such possibility then the person would be an aimless body, or in other words a robot. The whole purpose of someone to be alive is for them to be able to live human experiences: either it being sadness, love, romance, amongst others things that we have experienced and are yet to experience. If some one is deprived from this then they ultimately bring to question what is there purpose in life. It also brings to question that would participate in this types of experimental drug? What happens when the soul is retrieved from the body and for some reason in the future, the person wants their soul back? Could they grant the person the wish of giving them back their soul or is it gone forever once they choose to take the drug and separate themselves from it? The soul is an intangible object, that ultimately makes us who we are, the though that there is a possible drug that can separate the soul from the body, is something that is not likely to happen and that untimely, in a broader aspect, would be

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Kierstin Flint Mrs. Atnip English 2 Period 2 2 November 2015 Friendship A Relationship in One During a lifetime friendships are the most important bond that people can form. These friendships are alive throughout all generations and we use the skills we learn to continue making new relationships. Throughout the novel, A Separate Peace, the author, John Knowles, displays the good things about close friendships but also the hardships that often occur. Gene and Finny, two boys that attend Devon school, grow emotionally and physically despite their opposite personalities.…

    • 951 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He can do so by attending support groups, or some kind of group therapy. After interacting with a terminal drug…

    • 707 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Book Review for Death Cure Death Cure, by James Dashner, is the third book in the series Maze Runner. Death Cure is full of action as the protagonist, Thomas, works to put an end to the Flare. The book begins with Thomas put in solitary confinement as another variable in the trials. Eventually, he was let out by A.D. Janson, know as Rat Man to Thomas and his friends. When they were all finally reunited, Janson told them that they will be receiving their memories, that they lost due to the swipe for previous trials ran by WICKED to find a cure to the Flare.…

    • 554 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The body, while seemingly clearly definable and understandable, is a concept that humans have struggled to define and understand for much of history. Social conceptions of the mind of spirit shaped philosophers’ understandings of the relationship between the mind and body, as well as attitudes toward the body. In his essay “The Concept of the Body,” Eliot Deutsch presents readers with four popular modes of conceiving of the body. These models, popularized at different points throughout history, are the prison, the temple, the machine, and the instrument. Through reading Plato’s dialogue Phaedo, one gains perspective on Socrates’ conception of the body, as a prison.…

    • 812 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Divided Minds Book Report

    • 701 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Subsequently after reading Divided Minds, one can be positively sure that schizophrenia is not only a day-to-day battle for its vulnerable victims, but also for the loved ones and their families. This memoir is written by a pair of identical twins, one with an incorrigible mental illness who is also an award-winning poet and the other a doctor of psychiatry. Although the sisters alternate in the telling, it is clearly Pamela's story that captivates you. As identical twins, Carolyn and Pamela were raised in a nearly identical environment.…

    • 701 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Memories act as the gateway between the past and the present, whether a gateway to pain or a gateway to happiness. Yusef Komunyakaa’s confrontation of the Vietnam Memorial opens a gateway of misery and confusion for him. In his poem, “Facing It,” the poet relives his painful memories from the past, coming from early experiences in racism and later on in his life in the scarring events of the Vietnam War and Komunyakaa must learn to cope with these heavy memories without letting it destroy him. In his poem, “Facing It,” the dark slab of granite wall reflects the narrator’s attitude and memories towards the Vietnam War and all of its attached memories.…

    • 781 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In today’s society, most schools, both elementary and secondary, don’t discuss Asian or even Asian American History. African American, Native American and even European histories are all extensively covered in history classes. Many students have at least some knowledge of African American slavery, forced cultural assimilation of Native Americans, and the civil rights movement. From an early age, children are taught that the U.S. is a country created by immigrants; however, American history classes have shown a trend of teaching that excludes Asian Americans from the history of this country. At most, the topic of Asian American history is lightly touched, only introducing San Francisco Chinatowns or the large influx of Asian immigrants looking…

    • 1254 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    According to Laurence Shames, “Americans have always been optimists, and optimists have always liked to speculate” (90). Shames starts to talk about how Texans would purchase some land, put a main street on it, building some structures and call it a town all hoping for the railroad to come through their town. Every single person who tried to do this we're optimists. In the article “The More Factor” they did this for two reasons: to make money and for America to keep booming like it was. I think that this was the one way that America was really going to take off and turn into the power house country they could be.…

    • 709 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Bealer, L. Tracy. "The Kiss of the Memory: The Problem of Love in Hurston’s Their Eyes Were Watching God. " African American Review: Summer 2009, 311-327.…

    • 1450 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Freedom of Speech It was in 1791 that the United States transcribed the ten amendments within the Constitution. The first amendment, Freedom of Speech, is one of the most controversial laws in today’s society. It states that Congress shall make no law that reduces ones freedom of speech or freedom of press. Although there is a law in place stating such freedoms, it is not as clear and simplistic as it states.…

    • 824 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Amelia Anthony Period 1 AP Biology 8/16/17 Survival of the Sickest The title of Survival of the Sickest by Dr. Sharon Moalem suggests a notion opposite to both common knowledge and common sense. The basis of evolution-- “survival of the fittest”--means that weak genes, like ones that cause harmful iron buildup, or misshaped and nonfunctional red blood cells, should have been eliminated long ago. Evolutionarily, Moalem sets up, hereditary diseases do not make sense. However, he proves passing down certain seemingly negative traits, in the long run, comes with some sort of benefit and reason.…

    • 722 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Prior to delving in and analyzing the various responses of Huxley, Ryle, and Armstrong, a synopsis highlighting the key points of “An Unfortunate Dualist” is essential. Ultimately, Smullyan paints a picture of a protagonist who is extremely unhappy due to his philosophical inclinations. He reasons he cannot commit suicide for it will not be a rational act given the various associations he believes suicide holds. This dualist, comes across a miraculous drug which will annihilate the soul, yet leaving the physical body- his perfect solution. During the night, a friend who is aware of his sufferings sneaks in and injects the drug.…

    • 1625 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Analysis of “Head, Heart” Lydia Davis’s poem “Head, Heart” chronicles a short, yet meaningful interaction between the entities Head and Heart. Head and Heart have recently suffered an immense loss and feel great distress. In this time of great sorrow, it is Head’s duty to act as consoler to Heart, to comfort Heart in its moment of despair.…

    • 839 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Introduction to Beyond the Natural Body” written by Nelly Oudshoorn and “The egg and the Sperm” written by Emily both emphasize the idea of a woman’s body being examined through a social construct instead of a science classification. In the 1970’s, the female body was explained in terms of how the male body was perceived, for example: in texts written by the Ancient Greeks would refer the female genitals, the ovaries as the “female testicle”, as it used the male organs to lead every description. The illustrations that were shown of the female genitalia very closely resembled the male penis and someone could believe that there really is no difference between the two genders, as they were trying to make it the “one-sex model” (Laquer 1990).…

    • 1156 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article, “The Obligation To Endure” by Rachel Carson the author focused on explaining the consequences of human behavior. She explains how much harm we have done to our environment by the use of pesticides specifically referring to DDT, a pesticide that is not only poisonous to insects but to our Ecosystem as a whole. These pesticides instead of helping humanity they are having the opposite effect and are altering our nature. She could not be more accurate, pesticides tend to settle into our soil, from there they are transferred to our water supply creating a chain reaction, therefore contaminating wild life, plant life, and our water, etc. Therefore, regardless of some of the benefits that DDT can have, such as the ability to prevent…

    • 1014 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays