The provision prevents over 19.3 million American citizens (Zong and Batalova), 700 Medal of Honor winners (Haddock), and 62 former U.S senators from enjoying the same opportunities as their natural born counterparts (senate.gov). By the same token, a citizen who is born abroad to foreign parents but nurtured in the U.S. from infancy will never be eligible for President, while a natural born citizen who is raised overseas will still maintain the opportunity to run for the position. The requirement unreasonably assumes that an individual’s citizenship status at birth is a proxy for loyalty and even jeopardizes the prosperity of the nation by excluding potentially more qualified candidates. As a democracy built upon the grounds that “all men are created equal,” the future prospects of any U.S. citizen should not be predetermined by the uncontrollable circumstances of his
The provision prevents over 19.3 million American citizens (Zong and Batalova), 700 Medal of Honor winners (Haddock), and 62 former U.S senators from enjoying the same opportunities as their natural born counterparts (senate.gov). By the same token, a citizen who is born abroad to foreign parents but nurtured in the U.S. from infancy will never be eligible for President, while a natural born citizen who is raised overseas will still maintain the opportunity to run for the position. The requirement unreasonably assumes that an individual’s citizenship status at birth is a proxy for loyalty and even jeopardizes the prosperity of the nation by excluding potentially more qualified candidates. As a democracy built upon the grounds that “all men are created equal,” the future prospects of any U.S. citizen should not be predetermined by the uncontrollable circumstances of his