Esquivel's Argumentative Essay

Great Essays
Esquivel argues that individuals will assume a state of hopelessness when their dignity is disrespected because throughout life, one desires to obtain a sense of belonging.
When Pedro becomes injured, he asks for Tita to stay by his side through his pain. While watching the two together, Rosaura comes to the realization that since Pedro did not ask to be with her in a time of need, his preference is Tita.

“Tita, don’t go....Tita took Pedro’s hand again. For a moment Rosaura and Tita looked at each other challengingly. Then Rosaura understood that there was nothing for her to do her, and she went back to her room and locked the door behind her. She didn’t come back out for a week.” (Esquivel 201)

In past situations, Rosaura tries to prevent Pedro and Tita’s relationship, where now, for the first time, she comes to terms with the fact that there is nothing she can do
…show more content…
however long the ride took, we eventually reached our destination. I peered out the window to recognize a sign with sizeable letters reading “Welcome to Osrui.”
After our bags were comfortably packed away, it was time to begin. The retreat started with a welcome activity, followed by dinner, Aruchat Erev. Then, a program in Port Hall, followed by T’fillot, and after the end of the long day, the time came to return back to our cabin.
The nights were dim and dark, but the cabin was lit up like a sky full of stars, with each star serving as a flashlight. Hesitantly, I lifted my blanket off of me as my eyes motioned across the glowing room. I trudged over to my backpack, grabbed my flashlight, and slowly dissolved myself into my pillow as I read the words “assignment for May 6th.”
Saturday, the most important day, began to unfold. The whole retreat was dedicated to planning the main event that took place that night; The Havdalah service. After painting the murals and writing the poems and rehearsing the music, it was finally time to see the meaningful moment all come

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In the book Like Water for Chocolate, the author, Laura Esquivel, uses the literary element of magical realism to suggest that love cannot be oppressed. Tita and Pedro were destined for each other, but Tita had to uphold the tradition of the De la Garza family, which prohibited the youngest daughter from getting married. As a result, Pedro is forced to marry Rosaura, Tita’s sister, to remain close with Tita. Throughout the book, Rosaura and Mama Elena, Tita’s mom, try to suppress the love Tita and Pedro has for each other, but their efforts are unfruitful as Tita’s feelings for Pedro still prevail. Esquivel utilizes magical realism to show how uncontainable Tita’s love is by showing the magical effects Tita’s food has on her audience.…

    • 197 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Laura Esquivel in the novel, “Like water for chocolate” claims that emotion and imagery was used to explain how Tita is falling in love with John. Esquivel supports her explanation by illustrating the tone and mood in the words she uses in the sentences. The authors purpose is to inform the reader that Tita is hopeful to start a new life at John’s side, in order so that Tita can move on from Pedro. The author writes in a positive tone for the readers and in Titas view. Esquivel writes in a positive tone so she could illustrate how Tita is optimistic about a new beginning.…

    • 392 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Laura Esquivel’s film adaptation of Like Water for Chocolate and Kate Chopin’s stories, A Pair of Silk Stockings and The Storm, share a similar theme. They all focus on the complexity of women’s struggles to discover their freedom and individuality against social norms and traditions. At first they all place their desires aside because they feel a sense of duty whether they are forced or self imposed. Eventually, each woman takes a step to fulfill their desires if only for one brief time. In the film Like Water for Chocolate Tita is struggling with the desire to be with her true love and find her independence and individuality.…

    • 1110 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Period 6 Like Water for Chocolate Part 1: Background 325 words Like Water for Chocolate is set in the country of Mexico during the Mexican revolution. While on the ranch, actions from the war aren’t so present but the author makes it known that the revolution is going on. Woman were consumed in family life, marriage and their land.…

    • 1617 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    79). In this quote Rafaela gets locked up because she is too “beautiful”, but really her husband wants to keep her to himself so she would not want to leave him. In this quote Rafaela is stripped of her freedom because her husband keeps her locked up in her house. He does this because he has the power over her to do so. This makes her more vulnerable because she is unknowledgable about the world and only has her husband’s words about it.…

    • 1615 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    While events in these three books echo the history of their respective countries, their main characters do as well. In One Hundred Years of Solitude, the Buendía family represents different parts of Colombia as the family cycles through life and death. All members of the Buendía family are solitary in some way, which represents the isolated of Latin America. According to Laura Turgeon in World Literature and its Times, their seclusion is “symbolic of . . . their culture, their continent . .…

    • 806 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Liliana Hecker’s short story The Stolen Party, the maid's daughter, Rosaura, gets into an argument with her mother because she believes she is invited as a guest to Luciana’s elegant birthday party. After discovering the shocking truth which proves her mother’s belief, that she is only there to work the party as a server, she learns that sometimes advice from people who are older than us can be useful because they have more experience. Before the party even begins, Rosaura argues with her mother to let her go to the party. Rosaura and her mother disagree about whether or not she can go to the party and Rosaura wants to go because she feels “‘[she] [has] been invited’” while her mother fears that she will only be seen as “‘the maid's daughter’” (Hecker 1).…

    • 530 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    At Luciana’s house, the kitchen not only represents a form of murky secrecy but also secluded forms of work. Rosaura’s misunderstanding is reinforced because on a regular basis, Rosaura would go to Luciana’s house and they would both finish their “homework” (107) and would tell each other “secrets” (107). Though Rosaura claims her and Luciana are friends, they are not performing actions that real friends would do; the ‘homework” that they complete is related to a form of work and while this is occurring, the mother is also working and cleaning the house. Additionally, the secrecy in the kitchen is not only told towards Rosaura but also against her. During the party, Luciana’s cousin claims that she knows all of Luciana’s friends, but that she…

    • 216 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The novel Like Water for Chocolate takes place on a ranch in Mexico during the Mexican Revolution during 1910-1917. The book contains many characters with many characteristics. Tita, the main character, is a young eighteen year old female that lives with her mother, Mama Elena, on their ranch. Tita is the youngest daughter in her family. She has two sisters, Rosaura and Gertrudis.…

    • 2090 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    According to the FDA love is not an ingredient however, emotion still plays a large role in cooking. In the novel Like Water for Chocolate by Esquivel the main protagonist Tita faces many challenges in life. A narration by Esperanza, Tita’s granddaughter starts every chapter with a recipe. The recipes may seem like just a tradition being recorded but, they actually correlate with the emotions and challenges Tita faces in the chapter.…

    • 785 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    These are the first steps to mend their relationship. Once Tita’s anger simmers down, Gertrudis talks to Tita saying, “Pedro and you have both made the mistake of trying to keep the truth a secret” (190). The passion between Pedro and Tita had been kept a secret throughout their whole lives, and Gertrudis’ advice causes Tita to question her relationship with John, and even “he knew that something had changed inside of Tita” (203). Esquivel presents Pedro as “a monster of selfishness and suspicion” that everyone experiences at some point in their lives (212). When two people are fighting for the love of one person, one often becomes jealous and selfish.…

    • 1900 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    A Cup of Water Under My Bed: A Memoir by Daisy Hernandez Daisy Hernandez, a Cuban-Colombian, depicts her life challenges in the memoir “A Cup of Water Under My Bed.” Her mother grew up in poverty in Colombia, her father in Cuba. She was born in the United States, where she lives in Northern New Jersey with her parents, sister, and aunts. As a young child, Hernandez blamed her Hispanic culture for the injustices she faced including how she was looked at differently by her Caucasian teachers, her limited English vocabulary, and the long hours her mom had to work at a factory. She wants to convince herself that she is like her Caucasian teachers— with “no history, no past, and no culture.”…

    • 1197 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Equality is something that is perpetually strived for, but seldom achieved. In the novella The House On Mango Street by Sandra Cisneros, the protagonist, Esperanza, does not want to continue the cycle of inequality. Throughout the story, Esperanza continually sees women in her life treated like objects in a society that values women for their looks, and not for what is on the inside. In the thread of gender roles, a theme that is developed is that men do not treat women as their equals, but instead as something that can be possessed and dominated. This theme is developed throughout the stories Esperanza tells about her great-grandmother’s resentment of being a married woman, Rafaela’s lack of freedom in her marriage, and the troubles Minerva…

    • 1155 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Family Information Miguel and Rosa Del Sol have been married for four years and are the parents of three children. The family reports that they are of Hispanic origin and English is their primary language. Christopher who is nine years old is Rosa’s son from a previous relationship. Christopher’s biological father, Jim, has not been involved in his life since age two. Jim is 36-years old and according to Rosa, struggled with alcohol addiction that resulted in physical abuse during her pregnancy.…

    • 2049 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Story “The Stolen Party” by Liliana Hecker demonstrates the dominant conflict of Person vs. Person by showcasing the various problems/people Rosaura had to go through. Rosaura goes through numerous conflicts during the story which deal with Person vs. Person the first conflict is Rosaura and Herminia, Rosaura’s mother, arguing over the party Rosaura desperately wanted to go to, second conflict is the discussion between Rosaura and Luciana’s Cousin and lastly Rosaura and Senora Ines when Rosaura is leaving the party. Rosaura wanted to go to Luciana’s party but her mother was not allowing Rosaura to go because Luciana was the daughter of Rosaura’s mother’s boss and Rosaura’s mother refused the fact that Rosaura was Luciana’s friend but instead…

    • 448 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics